This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The Concepts Of Seeming And Being In Relation To Political Power And Leadership In The Prince And The Republic

3114 words - 12 pages

Comparing the Concepts of Seeming and Being in Relation to Political Power and Leadership in The Prince and The Republic

9. Machiavelli says the prince only has to seem good, not be good. Socrates insists that seeming is bad, being is good. Is it better to remain in the cave with Machiavelli, or see the light with Socrates? Write three pages for Machiavelli and against Socrates, write another three pages against Machiavelli and for Socrates.

Both Niccolò Machiavelli and Plato, in their works The Prince and The Republic (respectively), address the concepts of seeming and being in relation to political power and leadership, however they do so in two distinct manners. In the Republic, Socrates insists that seeming is bad, and being is good. Using a parable of people in a cave, he states that the only way to know the difference between what seems and what actually is reality is to experience it in its purest form, instead of through images. Machiavelli, on the other hand outlines the different ways that a prince could rise to power, and justifies any and all means that a prince could take. He states that a prince only has to seem good when it fits his purposes, not actually be good. He encourages an aspiring prince to be deceitful and conniving in order to gain and maintain power. Before concluding which political theorist is correct, it is interesting to examine whether it would be better to remain in the cave with Machiavelli or see the light with Socrates.
The citizens of Socrates’ Republic are divided into three classes. Those who are deemed fit to rule, the philosopher/rulers, are those who have been chosen to pass through several stages of training and preparation. They are the most fit to rule, because they are the only ones who (at the end of their training) know the difference between what seems to be reality and what reality actually is. They have gained this knowledge because they have spent the majority of their lifetimes preparing to rule. The other two classes of people in the Republic, the warriors and the moneymakers, can really only see what seems to be, and occasionally what really is. They simply rely on the philosopher/rulers to be knowledgeable and always act in the best interests of the community as a whole. The parable of the cave is evident here.
Socrates tells Glaucon a tale of men in a cave. These men have been “chained foot and neck since childhood” (Plato 514a). The chains prevent them from turning around; they can face only forward towards a wall. Directly behind them is a low wall, behind that a road, and behind that a burning fire. People pass by on the road between the backs of the men and the fire, casting shadows onto the wall directly in front of the men. Sometimes these people carry things, and on occasion they speak. Since the men cannot turn their heads, and never have been able to, they must assume that the shadows they see on the wall are real images. Likewise, they assume...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Concepts of Seeming and Being in Relation to Political Power and Leadership in The Prince and The Republic

The Dimensions of Morality in The Prince and The Republic of Plato

1291 words - 5 pages . The Prince (1513) essentially lays out a how-to guide of how to obtain power and how to keep it; The Qualities of the Prince contains a list of qualities that one should appear to have while in power; this work will be used to represent the case against moral responsibility for others. The Republic (approximately 380 BCE) is detailed description of the ideal society; The Allegory of the Cave is an explanation of how we should choose the servants

Examine the relationship between the concepts of Fortuna and virtù in Machiavelli's "The Prince"

2286 words - 9 pages personal qualities that the prince will find it necessary to acquire in order to "maintain his state" and to "achieve great things," the two standard markers of power for him. By contrast, fortuna exists as the enemy of the political order, the ultimate threat to the security and stability of the state. Machiavelli revives in his work the pagan notion of Fortune as an essentially uncontrollable goddess, who may nevertheless grant her favours to a man

Representation of power in relation to gender and religion in the scarlet letter

2027 words - 8 pages power in relation to gender can again be seen. Hibbins throughout the novel, is compared to and indeed accused of being a witch. Her nocturnal activities are spoken of and her strange ways are mentioned several times. It is also related how her relationship with the 'Blackman' is an issue of concern to the townspeople. Whatever power she does hold brings suspicion and often fear from those around her. But this power must be examined. The source

The Prince and The Discourses: a Study in Sovereign Power

1601 words - 6 pages theory. In any event, when looking at these two books it becomes evident that the Prince was meant for an audience who wouldn’t take it completely seriously but would look to it as a satirical reminder of what could be; and then with the Discourses, of how it should be done. Machiavelli's political treatise, The Prince, has previously been seen as a departure from traditional thinking of the time. Machiavelli wanted a new theory that was free

Political Propaganda and Religion in the Late Roman Republic

2928 words - 12 pages being on an extremely prominent street, the Via Argentarius (Stamper 92). While already having established his godliness, he further stepped over the boundaries of Roman conservatism by placing the temple in an important street facing yet another building he constructed. The late Republic was a period of controversy, unrest and change. Generals like Pompey and Caesar not only contributed to this, but expanded on it for their own purposes through

Comparing the Role of the Noble Lie in the Iliad and the Republic

1293 words - 5 pages comparing the the role of a noble lie in the Iliad and the Republic, the ends of the lie remains the same. Plato introduces the lie by writing: “Could we,” I said, “somehow contrive one of those lies that come into being in case of need, of which we were just now speaking, some one noble lie to persuade, in the best case, even the rulers, but if not them, the rest of the city?” His goal is to persuade, in the best case, the rulers, and if

A comparism of " Animal Farm" and the events of "Tiananmen" in relation to the issue of 'education and learning' and the power this brings to societies

1456 words - 6 pages glue factory, but to a vet who just happened to be using an old glue factory cart. Because of the other animals intelligence levels they were unable to see the absurdity of this notion.The animals were so unquestioning, so uneducated they were unable to ever see these unfair and unjust ways of the pigs and how much the pigs were abusing their power and exploiting them!The importance of education and learning was also evident in the ways in which

The Nature of Power and Rule in A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur’s Court and The Prince

1087 words - 5 pages and non-fiction novel The Prince by Niccolò Machiavelli. These two writings intertwine authoritative concepts including new leaders taking up residence in the new state, defending the weak, rising to supremacy through fear, and never avoiding war to delay controversy. One principal for becoming a successful leader is how one comes into power. In Machiavelli’s The Prince, it reads, “there are still two ways of becoming prince…[one of] these are

This essay is about child abuse, in relation to the different concepts of violence found in the book "Violence and its Alternatives", by Manfred B. Steger

1111 words - 4 pages begin with kissing or fondling and progress to more intrusive sexual acts, such as oral sex and vaginal or anal penetration. Emotional abuse destroys a child's self-esteem. Such abuse commonly includes repeated verbal abuse of a child in the form of shouting, threats, and degrading or humiliating criticism. Other types of emotional abuse are confinement, such as shutting a child in a dark closet, and social isolation, such as denying a child

Comparing Orwell's "1984" and Machiavelli's "The Prince"

1932 words - 8 pages When examining the totalitarian government of 1984 by George Orwell, a direct connection can be drawn to the motives and ideals associated with Niccoló Machiavelli’s The Prince. Machiavelli’s support of the political necessity as a means to remain in power resonate with the government whose aim is to “extinguish once and for all the possibility of independent thought” as a way to ensure complete political orthodoxy within the country (193

Themes in The Prince and the Pauper

543 words - 2 pages adapt to the situation. Edward Tudor always refers to his father in times of danger. He is very pompous.Both of the boys are described as being mad. But Tom Canty, who is mistaken as the prince is taken great care of just because he is a prince and wears splendid clothes. Edward Tudor, who is in rags, is considered completely mad and no one takes care of except Miles Hendon, but he still believes that Edward is insane. Edward on the other hand

Similar Essays

Obtaining And Maintaining Political Power In Machiavelli's The Prince

841 words - 4 pages In 1513, Niccoló Machiavelli wrote a political treatise supplying various method of ways a prince can obtain and maintain his political power. This work of literary art caused tons of controversy and was later forbidden by Pope Clement VIII due to it going against the normal traditional ethics at the time According to Machiavelli, a prince should only be concerned about power and ways leading to the success of their political actions. Modern

Comparing Leadership In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar And Machiavelli’s The Prince

1467 words - 6 pages John Maxwell once said, “People buy into the leader before they buy into the vision.” A leader must have a solid foundation as a human being before he can try to pursue the public about his visions. He will be examined from every angle about his leadership traits, style, characteristic, and so forth. All of these areas of leadership comes together in what we know as integrity. Integrity is doing what is right morally; it requires honesty, making

Comparing Machiavelli's The Prince And Plato's The Republic

1796 words - 7 pages Comparing Machiavelli's The Prince and Plato's The Republic       Many people in history have written about ideal rulers and states and how to maintain them.  Perhaps the most talked about and compared are Machiavelli's, The Prince and Plato's, The Republic.  Machiavelli lived at a time when Italy was suffering from its political destruction.  The Prince, was written to describe the ways by which a leader may gain and maintain power. In

The Relation Between Media Content And Political Power

1226 words - 5 pages It is interesting to comprehend the relation between media content and political power. What biases do the media experience in producing news in relation to government interests? Media, according to Herman and Chomsky, has a tendency toward elites’ political interests; media tend to follow official’s agendas. Herman and Chomsky proved this generalization through the use of terminologies and the way they place such kind of news (a foreign