This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The Resource Based View, Porter's Five Forces And Dynamic Capabilities In Strategy.

2415 words - 10 pages

In the last two decades, one of the most fundamental questions emerging in strategic management is how firms achieve and sustain competitive advantage. In a simplified world, understanding how firms achieve and maintain superior or abnormal returns means comprehending how firms position themselves in a certain market, what they produce and how they use resources at their disposal to do so. In this sense we may distinguish between the positional perspective, developed by Michael Porter, according to which achieving competitive advantage is the result of exploitation of imperfections in the market, the resource based perspective, which states that competitive advantage lies in the ownership of valuable resources, and the dynamic capabilities view, which follows the resource based view but also adds the dimension of time in the equation. In this essay, I will compare and contrast these three views after having described them, and will end by illustrating how they can all be brought together.According to Michael Porter, operational efficiency (OE) as measured for example by financial management tools is necessary but not sufficient for firms to sustain viable superior returns. Firms that compete on OE can quickly imitate new technologies and management techniques of rivals, and feasibly reorient themselves when competition shifts the productivity frontier outwards. As Porter notes: "Although such competition produces absolute improvement in OE, it leads to relative improvement for no one." (Porter 1996, HBR, p.63) The dominant idea emerging from Porter's competitive forces approach developed in the 1980's is that superior returns are achieved when a company positions itself within its environment in way that creates a quasi-monopoly. By "environment" we refer to the industry in which the firm chooses to compete and by "position" we mean how the firm decides to compete in this industry. This framework provides a systematic way of thinking about how competitive forces determine the profitability of different industry segments. In the pursuit of a viable competitive advantage, a firm is confronted with a two dimensional consideration: it must identify an attractive industry and additionally it has to make a trade-off between alternative generic strategies in order to assume a clear position in the market. (Porter, 1980)Industry attractiveness is determined by Porter's five industry-level competitive forces, namely the power of suppliers and buyers, the rivalry amongst existing firms, the entrance of new competitors and the development of substitute products. The way value is appropriated among suppliers, existing rivals and buyers is determined by their bargaining power. Other constraints on profitability include the threat posed by new entrants, which partly depends on the expected retaliation by existing firms, and the threat of substitute products. When many firms compete in the industry core, there is little product differentiation and no dominant...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the resource based view, Porter's five forces and dynamic capabilities in strategy.

Porter's Five Forces Model and The Movie Rental Business

916 words - 4 pages or partners better by supplying quality products and virtual service to promote brand lifting, customer feedback, great customer experience, and offering the right product to the targeted market. Porter's Five Forces Model is one of the frameworks that help businesses develop their market strategy and analysis. This paper will focus on the Porter Model to evaluate a prospective market entrance for a potential movie rental business. Therefore, the

Airline industry and Porter's five forces

567 words - 2 pages 1.Use Porter's five forces of competition' framework to show how the structure of the airline industry has caused low profitability during the past twenty years.Below are Porter's five forces of competition. In them you will understand what has caused low profitability.The bargaining power of suppliers: Labor is the airline industry's largest single expense. Most airline workers belong to one of a dozen unions, which give the airline workers

Porter's Five Forces of competition

293 words - 2 pages 1.Threat of new entrants- Barriers of entry consist of the following: economies of scale, product differentiation, capital requirements, switching costs, access to distribution channels, government policy and cost disadvantages independent of scales.2.Bargaining power of buyers- Buyer purchases large volumes relative to the seller sales and is a significant portion of the buyer's total costs. In addition, there are few switching costs, and the

Porter's Five Forces, online marketing advantages, and marketing ethics

1447 words - 6 pages Essay QuestionsA.Choose a specific industry (e.g., grocery retailing, the airline industry, etc.), and apply Porter's Five Forces Model to discuss that industry's competitive forces and their relative influence.B.Discuss how online marketing could provide competitive advantages in the industry you analyzed in question A.C.Do you think firms that market products for children have any special ethical responsibilities when they advertise? Why or

Using SWOT, Value Chain, Porter's Five Forces and other variables in Panera Bread Company, USA

2543 words - 10 pages has to be used to reposition the operations of PBC, analysis of both the micro and macro environmental points of view of the organization - where demographic, socio-cultural, political/legal, technological and global considerations of the organization in question. It also dwells on strength, weaknesses, opportunities and threats including studying trend analysis of the organization.Porter's five forces model, concept of strategy groupings, resource

Lowes’ Porter's Five Forces Competitive Analysis

1272 words - 5 pages by discounting, differentiating and adding extra value on the product or services. High level, intense rivalry may result with profit lost for the company. In most cases, new entrant barriers are high due to the intensity of rivalry (Porter, 2008). Lowes’ Porter's Five Forces Competitive Analysis As relevant to these competitive forces, the common and mutual goal of companies can be explained as better profitability with a greater market share

Use Michael Porter's five forces model to analyse the business environment in which your organization operates: Victor Chids

1691 words - 7 pages to be at play in an industry and affecting how that industry works and providing an indication of its attractiveness. The five forces are:Rivalry among competing sellers in the industryBargaining power of suppliersBargaining power of customersThreat of substitutesBarriers to entryThe following is an analysis on the business environment in which my organization, Intermarket Banking Corporation Limited is operating in.Intensity of rivalryRivalry is

Adidas Case Study: SWOT analysis and Michael Porter's Five Forces Model, including strategic recommendations

2515 words - 10 pages like soccer, which require the cleated/studded type shoe. The cleated shoe gave Adidas its initial foundation and leadership position, but the cleated shoe is not the key to being competitive in Adidas's current environment. A trend of wearing sports apparel, both footwear and textiles, for everyday leisure types of activities was emerging in the early 1990s. This trend was primarily seen in the 25 and under age group.Adidas is a German based

Reflective piece on usefulness of Porter's Five Forces model

893 words - 4 pages In the first seminar of the term, I was observing how Porter's 5 Forces model (5F) can be used to analyse the strategic business dynamics of the European Forestry/Paper sector in the post 2004 European Union.5F is an analytical framework, which allows competitive dynamics to be systematically appraised in assessing existing and future profitability of markets/industries by analyzing the influence of particular characteristics of each of the five

Ryan Air: Analysis using SWOT & Porter's Five Forces

2073 words - 8 pages of substantial growth -annual traffic grew by over three million passengers to 11.1million.The year 2003 saw the opening of a new base in Italy at Milan-Bergamo. The company opened its Skavsta base in Sweden, with six new routes to Aarhus(Denmark),Oslo, Tampere (Finland),Glasgow, Hamburg and Paris. Ryanair demonstrated its expansion strategy with an agreement to purchase Buzz, the UK based no-frills subsidiary of Dutch airline KLM. Ryanair

Using Porter's five forces to analyse Telstra Australia

808 words - 3 pages has gained a strong reputation in the telecommunication industry for its new technology and R&D projects. Therefore in order to compete with the Telstra, new entrant will have to suffer large set-up cost in. On the other hand, since Telstra consists of many highly specialized assets, it may be impossible to sell when facing overcapacity, hence extremely difficult to exit the industry.Competitive Strategy Of TelstraApparently, Telstra's

Similar Essays

Comparing The Resource Based View, Porter's Five Forces

8332 words - 33 pages exploratory study is an attempt to present the present status of Internet banking in India and the extent of Internet banking services offered by Internet banks. In addition, it seeks to examine the factors affecting the extent of Internet banking services. Design/methodology/approach - The data for this study are based on a survey of bank websites explored during July 2008. The sample consists of 82 banks operating in India at 31 March 2007. Multiple

Porter's Five Forces Essay

803 words - 4 pages competition was often too narrowly defined, and that managers almost always neglected other competitive forces such as customers, suppliers, other marketplace entrants, and the potential for substitutes products. Consequently, in 1979, Porter published an article in the Harvard Business Review titled How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy, officially introducing the world to Porter's five competitive forces that shape strategy (Porter, 2008

Porter's Five Forces Essay

2326 words - 9 pages three generic strategies: cost leadership, differentiation and focus.The following table illustrates Porter's generic strategies :Target ScopeAdvantageLow CostProduct UniquenessBroad(Industry Wide)Cost LeadershipStrategyDifferentiationStrategyNarrow(Market Segment)FocusStrategy(low cost)FocusStrategy(differentiation)Cost leadership.This generic strategy is based in following a cost strategy; that is to say, it tries to produce the lowest cost but

Porter's Five Forces Essay

2255 words - 9 pages technique of Porter’s Five Forces Model is discussed in this essay and in applied in the model for shaping strategy of a new and small-size firm in the stockbroker industry. The weakest point in the industry may be local adviser-based brokers and the needed-based positioning may be the suitable strategy for the firm to survive in the fierce competitive market. Even though a myriad of tools and techniques learnt in the Strategic Cost Management