Comparing The Simpsons And Aristophanes' Clouds

1937 words - 8 pages

Tomorrow on the Simpsons, Homer will discover that Bart has stolen his credit card and charged $10,000 worth of "Itchy and Scratchy" merchandise. Having no hope for paying off this debt, Homer decides to go to law school because he cannot afford to hire a bankruptcy lawyer. The famous lawyer, who teaches classes, sends a crestfallen Homer home to retrieve his son, for Homer is much too thick-headed to possibly learn the ways of the courts. As Bart graduates from law school, he uses his newfound skills of argument to convince the courts that his parents are insane, his sister Lisa deserves to be in a boarding school, and he should be able to put his youngest sister up for adoption. Unable to see another way, Homer tears down the walls of the Springfield Law School, attacking the famous lawyer for ruining his life. On many levels, this is a typical episode of The Simpsons, one I am sure any Simpson's fan would enjoy. The only problem is this is not an episode of The Simpsons, and it will not be airing tomorrow. This synopsis did not come from the TV Guide, rather it is an updated version of Aristophanes' famous comedy, Clouds. Though it may come as a surprise, many of the elements of America's favorite cartoon are actually the same elements used by Aristophanes many centuries ago in his comedic drama, Clouds.

There are many similarities between the main characters of Aristophanes' Clouds and the modern television favorite The Simpsons. The first comparison to be made is between the father figures Strepsiades and Homer Simpson. Though separated by centuries of changes, Strepsiades and Homer share a surprising number of basic character traits. First, they share a lack of intellectual strength; put simply, both characters are incredibly stupid. Strepsiades demonstrates this through his inability to learn as seen in his visits to the Pondertorium: "SOCRATES: This is preposterous![…]You'll get no more instruction from me" (Clouds 783). Homer Simpson certainly presents similar stupidity, so frequently that it has been a running gag for 12 years now. An example from the third Season follows: "HOMER: Fine! I'll never, ever, ever do another stupid thing! Good night! [angrily turns to leave and walks face first into the side of a truck]" (Vitti). Any modern Simpson's fan can easily see in their mind's eye Homer Simpson cast in the role of Strepsiades.

Homer Simpson and Strepsiades also have in common grand schemes, which nearly always backfire. Strepsiades' plan to have his son learn the inferior argument clearly backfires as his son uses the argument against his father. Homer's plans backfire as well. An example of this is the episode entitled "Lisa's Rival" from the sixth season, in which Homer plans to sell stolen sugar door to door. After quitting his job, he soon discovers that the open space of the backyard is not a good place for storage, as a combination of bees and rain destroy his surplus (Scully). And so the parallels continue.


Find Another Essay On Comparing The Simpsons and Aristophanes' Clouds

Postmodernism and The Simpsons Essay

8511 words - 34 pages HugvísindadeildHugvísindadeildHugvísindadeildHugvísindadeild Postmodernism and The Simpsons Intertextuality, Hyperreality and Critique of Metanarratives Ritgerð til B.A.-prófs Björn Erlingur Flóki Björnsson Kt. 110982-5779 Maí 2006 Abstract This essay offers a postmodernist reading of the popular television program The Simpsons, with special regard to the postmodern theories of

“Homer Simpsons and his Attitude to Alcohol in The Simpsons: Duffless (1993) and Homer vs the Eighteenth Amendment (1997)”

1987 words - 8 pages situation yet. For example, when he is in the driving school, he laughs at a documentary in which car accidents are depicted (“It´s funny cause I don´t know them”- "The Simpsons" Duffless 1993). Besides, Homer is obliged to go to Alcoholics Anonyms. This organisation is considered non-lucrative and apolitical which try to help people who have alcohol-related problems. Nonetheless, Homer sees that these people try to eliminate alcohol in his life

Lust in Homer's The Odyssey and Aristophanes’ Lysistrata

1380 words - 6 pages Lust in Homer's The Odyssey and Aristophanes’ Lysistrata Lust is defined as an intense longing or a sexual desire. It is a common theme in literature; particularly in classic Greek literature. The reason it is so prevalent in literature is that is prevalent in our daily lives. Everyone lusts after something or someone. It is an interesting topic to examine closely, and classic literature is an excellent medium for such an investigation

Compare and Contrast: The Man to Send Rain Clouds and Old Man at the Temple

746 words - 3 pages The Man to Send Rain Clouds and Old Man at the Temple their settings due to the place, time, and culture are similar and different in many ways. Both of these stories were very interesting. It was neat seeing how different two cultures can be. Comparing the stories was a little difficult because they did have a lot of differences. At first these stories seemed completely opposite. When studying them closer, many similarities were discovered. It would be interesting to do this with other stories of all kinds.

The Notion of War in the Eyes of Thucydides, Homer and Aristophanes

1875 words - 8 pages Greek classical literature is considered to be the canon of literary writing that pertains to the ancient history of Greece. Greek literature displays the classic lifestyle, culture and beliefs of the Greek race during the early portions of mainstream ancient and classical European history. Prominent Greek writers such as Thucydides, Homer, and Aristophanes produced pieces that are regarded, up to this day, as af conveyer of Greek life in the

Comparing the Federalists and Republicans

928 words - 4 pages Practice 3.3.2 Comparing the Federalists and Republicans To what extent were the policies of Presidents Jefferson and Madison a departure from those of Federalist Presidents Washington and Adams? The policies of Presidents Jefferson and Madison differed dramatically from those of Presidents Washington and Adams in that they advocated civil and states' rights instead of favoring a strong central government and preferred an agricultural rather

Comparing and Contrasting The Outsiders

802 words - 4 pages group of friends, you will find that he is a gold-hearted person. Although the movie and the book, both entitled The Outsiders, contain several similarities, they have many differences as well. To begin with, when comparing the book and the movie, you will find they both tell the story of fourteen-year-old Ponyboy Curtis who is the youngest brother in the Curtis family. He earns good grades, loves sunsets, and grows up in Tulsa, Oklahoma, in a

Comparing the Unconscious and Consciousness

2057 words - 8 pages Comparing the Unconscious and Consciousness Consciousness and unconscious are two psychological terms that are commonly used in this field of study. Their importances mainly appear when psychologists deal with their patients because they will surely think about these two terms. To understand these two terms we must know their definitions. This step can enable us to recognize the difference between them. Consciousness is a

Conpare/contract paper about the role of religion in The Jilting of Granny Weatherall and The Man to Send Rain Clouds

841 words - 3 pages Joe Van LanenMay 6, 2004EN 135J.K. RayThe Jilting of Granny Weatherall and The Man to SendRain Clouds both deal with people's attitudes towardsreligion and the role of in people's lives. Write a paperdiscussing the role of religion in these two stories.ReligionIn both stories The Man to Send Rain Clouds and TheJiltingof Granny Weatherall religion plays a large part inthe lives of the characters, but in death it takes an evenmore central role.In

Hansel and Gretel Vs. The Simpsons

1788 words - 7 pages At one time or another almost every child has read a story about mystical beings, dashing heroes, and evil villains, all acting out a story in a mysterious place, in a time long, long ago. Fairy Tales, while almost purely of a fictional content, offer us a glimpse into the culture and social staples of a certain society. The classic fairy tale Hansel and Gretel, by the Brother's Grimm, depicts two young siblings abandoned in the forest by

Comparing and Contrasting Digging and The Follower

1914 words - 8 pages Comparing and Contrasting Digging and The Follower In this essay I will be giving quotes and explaining about two pieces of poetry, written by Seamus Heaney. The two poems I will be writing on will contrast and his memories on his rural childhood. The poems will be "the follower" which takes us back to Heaney as a child wanting to follow in his father's footsteps. I will also be writing on "digging", which takes us

Similar Essays

Euripides’ Electra And Aristophanes' Clouds Essay

1452 words - 6 pages Euripides’ Electra is a tragedy that encourages readers to consider the problematic nature of humanity’s response to injustice: its quest to make fair that which is unfair, to correct unjust actions, and to mark the fragile border between what is ethically correct and morally wrong. Aristophanes’ Clouds is a tragedy disguised as a comedy that illuminates Strepsiades’s profound disregard for justice, conduct, and the establishment of civilization

Just And Unjust Speech In Aristophanes' "Clouds"

578 words - 2 pages Throughout Aristophanes’ “Clouds” there is a constant battle between old and new. It makes itself apparent in the Just and Unjust speech as well as between father and son. Ultimately, Pheidippides, whom would be considered ‘new’, triumphs over the old Strepsiades, his father. This is analogous to the Just and Unjust speech. In this debate, Just speech represents the old traditions and mores of Greece while the contrasting Unjust speech is

Comparing Satire In Babbitt By Sinclair Lewis And The Simpsons

2275 words - 9 pages The Power of Satire in Babbitt and The Simpsons      Sinclair Lewis used his writing to promote the enrichment of American society by attacking the weaknesses he perceived in his era.  His most notable work, Babbitt, is a satire on the middle class lifestyle and attitude of the 1920s.  Lewis' satirical style and voice is comparable to the modern television series The Simpsons, written by Matt Groening.  Babbitt and The Simpsons

Who Is An Educator ? A Comparison Between Aristophanes' "Clouds" And Plato's "Apology" To Find An Answer To The Question

1101 words - 4 pages . At 19 c, he says, he does not try to educate people and charge a fee. Unlike, in Aristophanes' Clouds, Socrates charges Strepsiades to educate his son. As we see, In Plato's Socrates, Socrates claims, he does not teach and charge a fee whereas in Aristophanes' Socrates, in Clouds, he teaches by charging a fee. In addition, In Apology, at passage 20 c Socrates emphasize on being master in the subject you teach to charge your students for a fee