This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing The Voice Of Frost In Mending Wall, After Apple Picking, And The Wood Pile

1377 words - 6 pages

The Voice of Frost in Mending Wall, After Apple-Picking, and The Wood-Pile

The "persona" narratives from the book - "Mending Wall," "After Apple-Picking," and "The Wood-Pile" - also strive for inclusiveness although they are spoken throughout by a voice we are tempted to call "Frost." This voice has no particular back-country identity, nor is it obsessed or limited in its point of view; it seems rather to be exploring nature, other people, ideas, ways of saying things, for the sheer entertainment they can provide. Unlike poems such as "Home Burial" and "A Servant to Servants," which are inclined toward the tragic or the pathetic, nothing "terrible" happens in the personal narratives, nor does some ominous secret lie behind them. In "The Wood-Pile," for example, almost nothing happens at all; its story, its achieved idea or wisdom, the whole air with which it carries itself, is quite unmemorable. A man out walking in a frozen swamp decides to turn back, then decides instead to go farther and see what will happen. He notes a bird in front of him and spends some time musing on what the bird must be thinking, then sees it settle behind a pile of wood. The pile is described so as to bring out the fact that it has been around for some time. With a reflection about whoever it was who left it there, "far from a useful fireplace," the poem concludes. And the reader looks up from the text, wonders if he has missed something, perhaps goes back and reads it again to see if he can catch some meaning which has eluded him. But "The Wood-Pile" remains stubbornly unyielding to any attempt at ransacking it for a meaning not evidently on the surface.

This surface is a busy one, as when the speaker meets the bird:

A small bird flew before me. He was careful

To put a tree between us when he lighted,

And say no word to tell me who he was

Who was so foolish as to think what he thought.

He thought that I was after him for a feather --

The white one in his tail; like one who takes

Everything said as personal to himself.

One flight out sideways would have undeceived him.

The bird is teased for its egoism in thinking that the world revolves around his subjective hopes and fears, and his nervousness is amusing because never was there a less predatory or even purposeful figure than the walker in this poem, who early along - in deciding to continue rather than turn back - put it this way: "No, I will go on farther - and we shall see." See what? See things like a bird lighting in a tree, and be free to make up a story about why it doesn't speak, or how jealously protective it is of the white feather in its tail? Being free to "see" means indulging in such harmless playful fantasies the freedom of whose play is a measure of its solitary creation, far from any human or social situation. Perhaps the point of maximum play occurs in the lines about the bird's caution as he lights in the tree and determines to look only: "And say no...

Find Another Essay On Comparing the Voice of Frost in Mending Wall, After Apple-Picking, and The Wood-Pile

Comparing After Apple-picking to Apples Essay

1097 words - 4 pages produce varying effects. By comparing "After Apple-picking," by Robert Frost and "Apples," by Laurie Lee one can see how the poets coincidentally use similar subjects to discuss a broader, more meaningful issue. Both Frost and Lee use the apples in their poems to illustrate the relationship between man and nature, and to emphasize the importance of allowing natural processes to occur without interference. In addition to the use of simplified symbols

Analysis of Mending Wall by Robert Frost

2952 words - 12 pages Analysis of Mending Wall by Robert Frost Robert Frost was inspired to write Mending Wall after talking with one of his farming friend Napoleon Guay. He learned from talking with his neighbor that writing in the tones of real life is an important factor in his poetic form (Liu,Tam). Henry David Thoreau once stated that, “A true account of the actual is the purest poetry.” Another factor that might have played a role in inspiring Frost to

After Apple-Picking

1186 words - 5 pages In After Apple-Picking, Robert Frost uses various metaphors as a way of comparing things in life to apple picking, by enabling the reader to view his work from numerous perspectives. Frost’s metaphors are used in the themes of comparisons, senses, and tired. Frost uses analogies throughout the poem to enable the reader to view the apple picker and his job farther than just apple picking. His use of imagery actually take the reader on the journey

Values of Nature In Frost's "After Apple Picking"

1301 words - 5 pages Robert Frost once said "There are many other things I have found myself saying about poetry, but the chiefest of these is that it is a metaphor, saying one thing and meaning another, saying one thing in terms of another, the pleasure of ulteriority" (The Atlantic Monthly, 1946). In "After Apple Picking", Robert Frost does as he said, he uses a simple story about a man, who, after a hard day of picking apples, is tired and wishes to rest, to

Mending Wall, by Robert Frost

1230 words - 5 pages Many works of literature contain an aspect of writing in which the author relays a story to the reader directly in order to conceal a deeper hidden meaning or concept that the reader will later discover. Authors veil the messages they wish readers to uncover using literary devices such as metaphor. In “Mending Wall” Robert Frost uses the metaphor of the wall to reveal the literal and figurative distance between the speaker and his neighbor to

"Mending Wall" by Robert Frost

2404 words - 10 pages cones under his pines, I tell him.It means the persona is growing apple orchard while the neighbor is growing pine trees. Since they are only trees and not animals, they would not be able to get across to the other side to disturb each other. Frost mentioned this to reinforce his feeling of mending the wall is foolish.If imagination is applied in interpreting this part of the poem, I think these lines could also mean that the persona was comparing

Mending Wall by Robert Frost

965 words - 4 pages Mending Wall by Robert Frost "Mending Wall" is vintage Robert Frost. Vintage to the degree that Frost has often referred to the work as his second favorite poem. Within its lines are the simplicity of language and subject, realism and imagery, humor and cynicism that combine to reveal the meditative insight that marks the poetry of Robert Frost. An annual ritual of mending a stone wall that divides the adjoining property of two New

Robert Frost-The Road Not Taken And After Apple Pi

485 words - 2 pages Robert Frost, born in 1874, can be considered one of America's leading 20th century poets. Throughout his life he wrote many poems that are well known today. Most of Robert Frost's poems are deceptively simple on the surface, but actually have tremendous depth and meaning. Two of these poems are "The Road Not Taken", written in 1915, and "After Apple Picking", written in 1914. They both have many similarities, and both are about the choices

"The Explication of a Universal Thought" The following essay pertains to the "The Mending Wall" by renowned poet Robert Frost

565 words - 2 pages . Though the objects differ in every aspect, they are essentially immobile and unthreatening. The speaker even notes that his apple trees "will never get across" (l. 25) and cause harm to his neighbor's pine trees. He realizes that he and his neighbor "do not need the wall" (l. 24); yet, the edifice of "loaves and ...balls" (l. 17) prevails.Another poetic device that Frost employs to communicate the theme is repetition. Though it is used in moderation

Robert Frost's "After Apple-Picking"

363 words - 2 pages Frost leaves the reader with two main questions in this poem: What sort of sleep is he referring to? What is it that troubles him so? The typical form of sleep, most often associated in poetry, is death. The poem speaks of a rest from picking apples which could be a reference to the Garden of Eden. After the apple was picked (and, of course, eaten) man was cast into a world of sin, death, and trouble. The narrator explicitly states that he

Human Imperfection Illustrated in Frost's Poem, After Apple Picking

515 words - 2 pages The poem “After Apple Picking” by Robert Frost expresses the feelings of the narrator during and after the process of harvesting apples by showing the sustainability and ambition of human spirit. Frost’s poem is an accurate reflection of life and of human imperfection through the use of repetition, literal and figurative language and various symbols. The repeated use of the word “sleep” resonates throughout the poem and suggests that the

Similar Essays

Robert Frost And Masculinity: Comparing The Poems "Home Burial" And "Mending Wall"

2543 words - 11 pages stereotype, and make the reader question not only society's unchanging assignment of specific gender roles, but Frost's own view of rugged masculinity, and bring out Frost's own anxieties with being a masculine poetic figurehead.The most lighthearted Frost poem that directly addresses society's expectations of masculinity would be "Mending Wall", which not only questions the idea of barriers created in nature to be unnatural, but also barriers

The Use Of Metaphors In Frost's, “After Apple Picking”, “Birches”, And “The Silken Tent”

1110 words - 4 pages meaning of thinking, they must understand that it is merely being able to say one thing in terms of something else “… To tell them that is to set their feet on the first rung of a ladder the top of which sticks through the sky.” This quote is ideal as we look further into three poems by Frost in which orientational metaphors are used and also connect with the symbol of toward heaven and then coming back to earth. In particular, “After Apple Picking

After Apple Picking By Robert Frost

998 words - 4 pages day picking apples. As he lies down to sleep, he can still smell the apples he has picked all day "The scent of apples: I am drowsing off". Even after a nights sleep he still feels tired and hazy. He calls the ice that frozen over the water "a pane of glass." Frost wonders if he is still dreaming or not. He has been looking forward to the harvest yet at the same time it is such a large task it made him tired of picking apples "of apple-picking: I

After Apple Picking, By Robert Frost

1413 words - 6 pages “After Apple Picking” is reminiscent of uncertainty and restlessness. Paton wrote a whole article on how Frost went about writing his poems and one of her key observations was that Frost liked to dwell in the unknown or unsaid. “His poems often depend on the drift of colloquial language toward aphorism and vagueness. Daily speech and experience are loaded with allusiveness and metaphor.” (Paton 44). One such example is the ending of “After Apple