Comparing The Ways Michael Herr In Dispatches And Pat Barker In Regeneration Show The Effects Of War

4183 words - 17 pages

Comparing the Ways Michael Herr in Dispatches and Pat Barker in Regeneration Show the Effects of War

When comparing Michael Herr's 'Dispatches' and 'Regeneration' by Pat
Barker the differences in format, style and setting are clear from the
outset. However both books explore the horrifying effect of war on
those directly and indirectly involved. The two authors attempt to
take the reader away from objective, statistical impressions of war
and closer to the real experiences of those affected. The various
mental and physical effects of war are explored in the books but the
underlining effect that is highlighted is the fact that the men
involved will forever be separate from the rest of society because
they have been irrevocably altered by experiences that can only be
understood by those who were there.

As an autobiography centered around Herr's experience of Vietnam
'Dispatches' provides a different reading experience to Barker's
novel, which is loosely based on the real life meeting between
Siegfried Sassoon, Wilfred Owen and Dr. W.H.R Rivers at Craiglockhart
War Hospital during The First World War. Due to the different
approaches the structure of the books is different and that affects
how the effect of war is shown. 'Dispatches' is a tapestry of
experience with no real linear structure except for the Khe Sanh
section where a siege develops through the section. Herr moves from
his own thoughts and experiences to stories that have been passed on
from soldiers or other correspondents. For instance, Herr's opinion of
a detached soldier is immediately followed by the soldier's own third
person story. This means that a great range of experience and
perspective is relayed. Barker also uses multiple viewpoints, but
these exist in a linear structure. Each character's view is slightly
different and is revealed at different stages in the novel. I am
surprised that one reviewer believes 'The novel has no obvious plot'*.
While not traditional, the plot fairly simply charts the mental and
emotional development of the characters over time. Generally, the
character of Rivers is followed as his views change and his

* Ms. Tallulah:

patients attempt to remove the mental consequences of the war.
Importantly, 'Regeneration' begins with Sassoon's actual ant-war
declaration from 1917, which gives the novel immediate legitimacy. The
plot of Dispatches is not clear-cut as many different events, themes
and ideas are explored. The book seems to have no clear direction as
Herr explores his time in Vietnam almost like a stream of
consciousness. Because of these structural differences 'Regeneration'
leaves a specific, personal impression of the effect of war whilst
'Dispatches' is an overwhelming bombardment of experience that brings
you closer to the true experience.


Find Another Essay On Comparing the Ways Michael Herr in Dispatches and Pat Barker in Regeneration Show the Effects of War

Compare and contrast the ways "Regeneration" by Pat Barker and "The Rights of Desire" by Andre Brink deal with the theme of Love

1173 words - 5 pages Love is the least understandable human feeling. Love appears in all kinds of forms during most novels studied in class. However love is very difficult to categorize, some correlations can be made between 'types' of love and between the characters of different novels. In "The Rights of Desire" and "Regeneration", this is the case. Admiration, sexual attraction, respect and love in the family are seen and dealt with in different ways. In "The

An analysis/review of the book Dispatches, by Michal Herr

1004 words - 4 pages Dispatches PaperAs I read Dispatches by Michael Herr, there is an overwhelming sense of fear and horror. His dispatches are populated by soldiers called 'grunts', whose enemy was everywhere and nowhere. Their maps were blank; their names for the enemy, 'Charlie' or 'VC', told them nothing. How do you recognize them? They all wear black pajamas; they are all alien to us. They are everywhere. That's where the paranoia began. Herr's dispatches are

Comparing Irony of War in Dulce et Decorum, Regeneration, and Quiet on the Western Front

1185 words - 5 pages superficial ideals. The soldiers were simply the victims of a meaningless war. In conclusion, Remarque's firsthand encounters with trench warfare, Owen's vivid descriptions of the soldiers' experiences and Baker's touching accounts of the lives of historical figures, all state that there were no victors in war, only losers in a hopeless battle for territorial supremacy. Works Cited Barker, Pat. Regeneration. Toronto: Plume, 1993. Owen, Wilfred. "Dulce et Decorum Est." The Faber Book of War Poetry. Ed. Kenneth Baker. London: Faber, 1997. 3-4. Remarque, Erich Maria. All Quiet on the Western Front. Trans. A. W. Wheen. New York: Ballantine, 1982.

Compairing the two books, "Dispatches" by Herr and "Batman: The Dark Knight Returns by" Miller. Focuses on an indepth look at the main characters and how they are seen in the eye's of the reader.

1348 words - 5 pages and intelligence, shouldn't the fact that a life is a life have any relevance? Regardless of how you might value the human race it is possible that any other species could have become the Alfa-species thousands of years ago. Throughout the books Dispatches and Batman: The Dark Night Returns, the characters are constantly placed in classifications of varying value, putting one being above the other. We will look at how and why these characters

“To what extent does language develop the theme of gender roles in Pat Barkers “Regeneration”?”

1308 words - 6 pages Pat Barker uses language effectively in the novel “Regeneration” to present gender roles and other themes within the novel. Her presentation of women, emasculation and men taking on more feminine roles are important for the theme of gender roles within the novel. She also uses language effectively to present themes of duty and father figures. There is a very small but important female presence in “Regeneration”. The first mention of women in


2473 words - 10 pages michael crichton's next: The Horror show of capitalism in biotechnologyBy Satrio Pangarso Wisanggeni 120222415477We've reached the point where we can stick it to Big Pharma-and we will. Those massive, bloated companies need us and they know it. They need genes, they need technology. They're the past. We're the future. We're where the money is! (Crichton, 2006:12)That sentence is uttered by John B. Watson. He is a fictional character from Michael

The Horrors of War in Regeneration and All quiet on the Western Front

1739 words - 7 pages families, and the effects the war had on them. The effects of war are prominent throughtout the Novels “Regeneration” and “All quiet on the Western Front” and is also explored deeply in Wilfred Owen’s “Selected War Poetry”. Throughout these works we discover that war was inescapable for these men

Aborted Aspirations in Pat Barker's Regeneration

1886 words - 8 pages repercussions. Regeneration poignantly points out that not all is fair in war, or life. Works Cited "Abortion: In Law, History & Religion." Childbirth By Choice Trust. May 1995. 26 April 2004. <> Barker, Pat. Regeneration. New York: Plume, 2003. Horden, Anthony. Legal Abortion: The English Experience. New York: Pergamon Press, 1971. "Marie Stopes." Spartacus. 7 December 2001. 26 April 2004. <http://www.spartacus> Raffel, Brian, Monica Borgone, Michael D'Ambrosio and Rebecca Heydon. "Abortion Around the World." 1999. 30 April 2004. <>

A Comparison of the Techniques Employed in Portraying the Horror of War in Regeneration and Journey's End

2585 words - 10 pages A Comparison of the Techniques Employed in Portraying the Horror of War in Regeneration and Journey's End "I chose the First World War because it's come to stand in for other wars… It's come to stand for the pain of all wars." Pat Barker wrote "Regeneration" in the 1990's and R.C. Sherriff "Journey's End" in 1927, the quote is from Barker and illustrates the magnitude of the effect of the First World War, and

The Regeneration of Limbs in Class Asteroids

1622 words - 6 pages The ability to regrow missing limbs is an incredible power that a few animals have mastered. The mystery behind how they do it is still not known very well. But hopeful soon we will be able to solve yet again another one of Mother Nature’s many mystery’s and puzzles. One of the best models of this incredible process is starfish. My goal in this paper is to find out about regeneration in starfish. Regeneration is the ability of an organism

Comparing Ralph and Jack to Show How the Characters Change in Lord of the Flies

978 words - 4 pages Comparing Ralph and Jack to Show How the Characters Change in Lord of the Flies Golding uses many techniques to change his characters as they progress throughout the novel. The main character Ralph is a prime example of this developing character. Both of the boys arrive on the island with a certain manner. They are sensible and being from well brought up families and homes, soon start to work together in harmony on the island. The

Similar Essays

Examine And Compare The Ways In Which Pat Barker In Regeneration And

1199 words - 5 pages Examine and compare the ways in which Pat Barker in Regeneration and Wilfred Owen in his poetry explore the nature of life in the trenches. Pat Barker and Wilfred Owen are both successful writers in delivering an insight into trench life from the perspective of a soldier, although in different ways. Owen, being a soldier himself, has had first hand experience of trench life and describes the pity of war, in that war is a waste of young

Comparing The Documentary Hearts And Minds By Peter Davis With The Book, Dispatches By Michael Herr.

755 words - 3 pages cruelty and callousness of both Americans and Viet Cong- but is far more politically against our involvement. Dispatches is an objective, but just as frightening series of reports from Esquire's war correspondent, Michael Herr.It is interesting to compare the documentary Hearts and Minds with the book, Dispatches. It is one thing to read about events by a correspondent, and quite something else to actually witness the horrors of war, and the

Regeneration By Pat Barker Essay

2081 words - 8 pages crises experiences of the individual soldiers in particular those who had a mental break down. In the ghastly condition of war in which it is almost normal to have nightmares and vomit regularly, only severe symptoms of breakdown where considered as needing treatment or for that matter 'regeneration'. These devastated soldiers were transferred to a mental hospital where they received counseling by a professional psychiatrist and a safe environment

Regeneration, By Pat Barker Essay

1037 words - 4 pages the war which explained by Sassoon’s moral reasons in opposing to fight. Rivers realized that it is not up to him whether or not to stop the war, but what it is important is, a person has to be willing to do something rather than to be forced. In the case of Sassoon, although he disguised the fact that he fought for a war that it not justified, he still wanted to go back so that he can be with his fellow soldiers, even if it meant death. Works Cited Barker, Pat, Regeneration. New York: Penguin Books, 1991. Print.