Comparing Therapy And Medication Essay

1927 words - 8 pages

Introduction
Major depressive disorder affects nearly 15 million of American adults in a given year. (Kessler, Chiu, Demler & Walters, 2005). With the impact it has on the society as well as the well-being of the individual, it must be in the interest of the healthcare to be able to provide patients with the most effective treatment method. Extensive research has been conducted on the efficacy of antidepressant medication and cognitive therapy, the two main treatment methods used for depression today. The discussion has, however, been characterized by conflicting claims, resulting in a debate over what should be used rather than us having a definite conclusion of how patients are best ...view middle of the document...

There is, however, discrepancy between the results, and in this review a closer look will be taken at more recent research and what the results suggest.

Method
Five randomized trials conducted from the year 2000 and onwards were selected. The primary database used for searching was PsycINFO. Keywords used include “psychotherapy”, “antidepressants”, “medication”, “psychopharmaca”, “depression treatment” and “depressive disorder”. This was later narrowed down to closely fit the research question. Specific concepts in the search then included “cognitive therapy” as well as “Relapse”, “Combination Treatment”, and the name specific commonly used medications.
Results
In research conducted by Hollon et al (2005), it was stated that while there was evidence for the enduring effects of cognitive therapy, there was a lack of extensive research comparing the effects to the use of antidepressant medication after terminating the treatment.
In the study, 180 patients meeting the criteria for severe and major depression were assigned to either one of the treatment methods. Of these, 104 met the response criteria and were included in a 12 month continuation phase and constitute the main focus of the study. Patients who had responded to the therapy were withdrawn and followed up during a 12-month period. Those who had responded to the medication treatment (Paroxetine) were either assigned to a placebo group or a continuation medication group, with both being followed up for 12 months. The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) was used during the entire study, and during the continuation phase relapse was defined as a return of symptoms lasting for at least 2 weeks.
The results display that patients who had been withdrawn from cognitive therapy treatment were less likely to relapse (30.8%) than those who had been withdrawn from medications (76.2%). No significant difference was found between patients withdrawn from therapy and those who were kept on medication.
The findings of the study suggest that cognitive therapy has better enduring effects than medication, and is just as effective as keeping the patients on medication.
The perhaps most highlighted study in recent years is the one of DeRubeis et al (2005), a straightforward placebo controlled trial comparing the efficacy of antidepressant medication and cognitive therapy in the treatment of moderate to severe depression. The background of the study consisted in a lack of research evaluating the effects of cognitive therapy in this specitic group.
In the study, which took place at the research clinics of the University of Pennsylvania and Vanderbilt University, 240 adult patients were assigned to either one of the two treatment groups or the placebo group. The medication used was Paroxetine. Just like in the previous study, the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale was used.
At 8 weeks, the results were measured in the treatment groups. The response rates for antidepressants (50%) and cognitive therapy...

Find Another Essay On Comparing therapy and medication

Depression: The Best Course of Action

2424 words - 10 pages various treatments of depression. Many studies were done exclusively comparing therapy to medication. Robert J. DeRubeis, Greg J. Siegle and Steven D. Hollon did a study that compared a mixture of behavioral and cognitive therapy, and medications for depression. They took an interesting approach to this controversial topic by showing how each of these popular treatments affects brain and neural mechanisms in each patient (DeRubeis, Siegle and Hollon

A Speedy Recovery of Anorexia Nervosa by Family Therapy

761 words - 4 pages . Recent researches have shown a generalized trend of family therapy being more suitable for adolescence AN patients than individual therapy. My question for the research is how is family therapy more helpful than individual therapy for adolescence AN patients? My three data include Medication Adaptation Headache by Miriam Solomon, Stephanie J. Nahas, Judy Z Seagal and William B Young, Randomized Clinical Trial Comparing Family-Based Treatment With

Feminist Therapy And Anorexia Nervosa

1697 words - 7 pages anorexia is cognitive-behavioral therapy coupled with medication (Protinsky & Marek, 1997). However the emergence of feminist therapy in mainstream practices and hospital settings seems to be a much more promising treatment for this disorder. According to Arkinstall (1995), a feminist therapist does not view or treat her client as a woman with a personal defect or dysfunctional thinking, but as an equal who has unhealthy methods of coping. This

Obesity and asthma

894 words - 4 pages studied the relationship between BMI and asthma severity. 3.095 adults with self-reported asthma who make the percentage of 32% and 33%, respectively, were overweight and obese. Comparing with non-overweight individuals, obese individuals with asthma were more likely to use the reliever medication, controller medication, and to be classified as patients with severe asthma. From this study, it is clear that obesity is associated with severe asthma

What is Involved in Treating Schizophrenia?

656 words - 3 pages , relaxation therapy, crisis handling and so on, research has shown significant reductions in symptoms and enhanced quality of life. Group Therapy removes the schizophrenic from a clinical setting and provides a safe place where one can finally exhale, with the realization they are not alone. Comparing drug side-effects, along with discussions about life skills, job and relationship challenges may lead to practical solutions. Sharing goals and dreams can

The Hopelessness Theory of Depression

1896 words - 8 pages therapy for depression, and that Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is better than using psychiatric medication. This evidence has made Cognitive Behavioral Therapy the most common first treatment for depression. The article said that negative thinking and unhealthy ways of coping with these negative thoughts and emotions often cause depression. This way of thinking ends up in low self-esteem, feelings of being unworthy, of being a failure, and seeing

Therapy vs. Medication: Why Medication is Vital to Treating Anxiety

891 words - 4 pages , Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (“Anxiety”). The different treatments vary based on the different type of anxiety. But all treatment falls into two categories: Medication and Therapy. While both of the treatments are useful, and it is most effective when medication is combined, some people feel uncomfortable talking to a stranger about their problems. If someone does not want to talk to a therapist, it is vital that

What is the Current Status of Occupational Therapy Practice for Adult Drivers with Dementia

1852 words - 7 pages /Daily-News-Watch/New-Research-Links-Mild-Cognitive-Impairment-MCI-To-Increased-Isolation-And-Risk-Of-Death.aspx Kay, L. G., Bundy, A. C., & Clemson, L. (2009). Awareness of driving ability in senior drivers with neurological conditions. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 63(2), 146-150. Kukull W. A., Higdon R., Bowen J. D., McCormick W. C., Teri L., Schellenberg G. D., Lococo, K.H., Staplin, L., Siegler, J.N. (2007, March 5). Medication and

The effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy

2549 words - 10 pages can benefit from cognitive behavioral therapy. Cognitive behavioral therapy is at least as effective as medication, i.e. antidepressants in these forms of depression. The duration however differs. For a mild depression the duration of the CBT is shorter than for the moderate form of depression. The combination of cognitive behavioral therapy and antidepressants is very effective in the treatment of a major depression. The combined effect is higher

Major Forms of Therapy

1066 words - 4 pages of therapy would be someone with ADHA. Strategies to achieve a successful treatment would be medication, behavioral modifications and counseling. Cognitive therapy method utilizes the thought of re-teaching a person the way they thinks and feel about things. Rational-emotive behavior therapy is a good example of cognitive therapy. This method makes use of the individual learning to reorganize their feelings to ones that

Music Therapy

1655 words - 7 pages favorite music need lower doses of pain medication than patients who did not listen to music (Syed, 2006). Developmentally disabled individuals and individuals with mental health needs are also receptive and benefit from music therapy. Music therapy for autistic individuals has helped to teach social interacting, encouraging the desire to communicate, and minimizing non-communicative speech. “As far as autism is concerned, studies have shown

Similar Essays

Comparing The Efficacy Of Cognitive Therapy And Antidepressant Medication In The Treatment Of Depression

1746 words - 7 pages ”, “antidepressants”, “medication”, “psychopharmaca”, “depression treatment” and “depressive disorder”. Results In research conducted by Hollon et al (2005), it was stated that while there was evidence for the enduring effects of cognitive therapy, there was a lack of extensive research comparing the effects to the use of antidepressant medication after terminating the treatment. In the study, 180 patients meeting the criterias for severe and major depression

How Medication And Therapy Combats Depression

1692 words - 7 pages methods to treating depression, medication and therapy. Medication and therapy both easily rival each other in effectiveness, but I am out to discover which is one more effective. Depression: Depression is a mood disorder that causes a constant feeling of sadness and loss of interest. Depression can affect how you feel, think, and behave. When suffering from depression normal day-to-day activities become troubling, and you feel as if life isn’t worth

How Medication And Therapy Combats Depression

1912 words - 8 pages main methods of treating depression, medication and therapy. Medication and therapy both easily rival each other in terms of effectiveness, but which one is more effective? Depression: Depression is a mood disorder that causes a constant feeling of sadness and loss of interest. Depression can affect how you feel, think, and behave. When suffering from depression normal day-to-day activities become troubling, and you feel as if life isn’t worth

Comparing Adlerian Therapy, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, And Solution Focused Brief Therapy

3634 words - 15 pages use to guide me daily as a school counselor. Modern day counseling is equipped with a wide variety of therapies, techniques and approaches. The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast three approaches of therapy. Also in this essay the views of the person and the Therapeutic process will be discussed. The three models that are going to be compared are Adlerian, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), and Solution Focused Brief therapy (SFBT