This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Ursula K. Le Guin’s Forgiveness Day And Nicola Griffith’s Ammonite

1870 words - 7 pages

Comparing Ursula K. LeGuin’s Forgiveness Day and Nicola Griffith’s Ammonite

    In Ammonite, Nicola Griffith tells the story of one woman’s encounter with and assimilation into the culture of an alien world.  Ursula K. LeGuin’s “Forgiveness Day” similarly recounts one woman’s experiences as she confronts an alien culture.  In both cases, these women, Solly in “Forgiveness Day” and Marghe in Ammonite, learn about themselves as their position shifts away from that of an outsider and they find their place in society.  Although there are similarities in the characters’ backgrounds, their journeys, and their quest for belonging, there are fundamental differences in the process the characters go through in order to find a place where they belong.  Specifically,  LeGuin and Griffith mirror one another in describing the causal relationship between accepting oneself and participating in a romantic partner relationship.  This difference is telling as it reflects the differing attitudes towards the role of romantic partnerships in one’s growth process as well as in society as a whole.

    As these stories begin, both Marghe and Solly are striking in their lack of attachments to the outside world.  Moreover, they confident in their professional abilities and proud of their independence.  In their freedom, both are spiritual orphans.  Marghe’s mother is dead and she is not in contact with her father.  In addition, she has no real friends and is distrustful of her colleagues on Jeep.  Solly is also an orphan in a very real sense; she has spent most of her life in space, and the technical restrictions of travel mean that as she traveled she would skip “another half millennium in the process” (LeGuin 47).  Her parents, as well as anyone she left behind, would therefore be long dead or so far away as to be unreachable.  She has been assigned alone to act as “the first and only Envoy of the Ekumen to the Divine Kingdom of Gatay” on the planet Werel (LeGuin 47-48).  Just as Marghe finds herself alone as the only SEC representative on Jeep, Solly finds herself a lone diplomat to an alien culture.  Although they both lack personal attachments, there are differences in the state of Solly and Marghe’s personalities when they arrive.  While Marghe has an upsetting past that she would prefer to forget, Solly appears to be without a past; she is a ‘space brat,’ completely without roots.  Solly is free of bonds tying her to another time or place, but Marghe is tied to Earth by her mother’s death.  Solly craves human contact, feeling that “she needed to talk to a woman” (LeGuin 53), while Marghe refuses friendly invitations to socialize with the Mirrors, claiming that she is “not interested” (Griffith 26).

    Solly carries her ideological beliefs with her, and imposes them on Werelian society.  She treats the asset (slave) she is given as an equal because “she believed no human being had a right to dominate, much less own, another . . . and that she hoped they...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Ursula K. LeGuin’s Forgiveness Day and Nicola Griffith’s Ammonite

This Essay Is The Effects And Function Of Fear In The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas. The Essay Is About Ursula K Le Guin's Story The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas

1346 words - 6 pages Fear and its Effects and Functions in "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas"Fear plays a very important role in Ursula K. Le Guin's short story "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" as it pertains to the story's main theme of the collective's needs and wants being more important than that of an individual. Fear helps to develop the plot as well in that it functions as hidden ripple in the perfection of Omelas because how can a person or group of

Comparing The Media Techniques Used to Present the D-Day Landings in the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan

2062 words - 8 pages Comparing The Media Techniques Used to Present the D-Day Landings in the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan The heroism and bravery of those who took part in the D-Day has been brought to the big screen from several perspectives. 1939-1945 were some of the most horrific times in the broad spectrum of human conflict ever seen by mankind with unmatched weapons of devastation and the senseless slaughter of millions of lives

Comparing The Longest Day Directed by Andrew Martin and Saving Private Ryan Directed by Steven Spielberg

1138 words - 5 pages Comparing The Longest Day Directed by Andrew Martin and Saving Private Ryan Directed by Steven Spielberg These two directors were trying to achieve different goals, 'The Longest Day' was made post-war in 1962 and when the war may still of been in peoples thoughts and where many of the people who fought in the war would still be alive. However 'Saving Private Ryan' was made much later on in 1999, by then the world has gladly

Comparing The Daffodils by William Wordsworth and Miracle on St. David's Day by Gillian Clarke

1425 words - 6 pages Comparing The Daffodils by William Wordsworth and Miracle on St. David's Day by Gillian Clarke In this essay I will attempt to compare two very contrasting poems, William Wordsworth’s `The Daffodils' which was written in pre 1900s and Gillian Clarke’s ‘Miracle on St David's Day’, written in the 20th century. Strangely enough Gillian Clarke’s ‘Miracle on St David's day’ was actually inspired by ‘The Daffodils’. In 1804

Human Subconcious. Analysis of the two books "Sphere" and "The left hand of darkness" by Ursula K. Le Guin, and the movie "Enemy mine"

1196 words - 5 pages In the past two millenniums, humans' situation has evolved a lot. We have come a long waysince the Roman empire. Many new types of technologies have been discovered anddeveloped. Today, our knowledge and understanding of different types of phenomenons haveincreased tremendously. Among other things, we have been able to understand how natureworks and how we have been created. We even considered the fact that we might not be theonly civilization

Comparing Forgiveness and Marriage in Much Ado, All's Well, and Measure for Measure

2651 words - 11 pages Forgiveness and Marriage in Much Ado about Nothing, All's Well That Ends Well, and Measure for Measure      Shakespeare never does manage to make the journey to the end of his comic plays an easy one for his characters or his audience, and as his comedies evolve, the journey becomes even more difficult. Tragic elements and more psychologically complex characters increase the intensity of the ending and often make a reader or viewer

Gillian Clarke Comparing attitudes to old age in 'Miracle on St. David's day (Gillian Clarke)' and 'Old man, old man (U.A.Fanthorpes)'

572 words - 2 pages Comparing attitudes to old age in 'Miracle on St. David's day' and 'Old man, old man'In both poems old age is shown to cause disconnection from the people with their surroundings. Parts of the poem 'miracle on St David's day' shows the people do have connections with their surroundings. For example 'he rocks gently to the rhythms of the poems' shows that the man can hear the poem and connects with it. When the man in the poem starts to recite

Comparing the Female Protagonists in Groundhog Day and A & P

1372 words - 5 pages Role of the Female Protagonists in Groundhog Day and A & P      Groundhog Day, starring Bill Murray, is a film about a television weatherman named Phil who relives the same day, 2 March, over and over again. A & P is a short story by John Updike in which a cashier, Sammy, has his routine day disrupted when three girls wearing swimming suits stroll into the grocery store where he works and are confronted by the manager. Though their

Comparing Tension and Conflict in Things Fall Apart and Clear Light of Day

1049 words - 4 pages Tension and Conflict in Things Fall Apart and Clear Light of Day       How does the tension between traditional and modern views of the world play itself out in Achebe's "Things Fall Apart", and Desai's "Clear Light of Day"?           In both Achebe's and Desai's novels, tension and conflict between the new and the old, traditional and modern are the strong undercurrents that move the story and the reader into an

Comparing two documentaries,One day in September and Nanook of the north (modern and old)

878 words - 4 pages These documentaries were produced in different decades, firstly One day in September was released on the 4th September 2000, and this was a documentary on the tragic events of the Munich Olympics.The second documentary I watched was Nanook of the north, a story of an Inuit and his family's life. This documentary is said to be the first feature length documentary ever, it was released in the USA in 1922. The documentary looks at real life

Comparing and Contrasting Ancient Greek Drinking Vessels and the Present Day Starbucks Cup

1038 words - 4 pages There are a handful of differences and similarities from an Ancient Greek drinking vessel and a Starbucks cup some people may not take into consideration. While comparing and contrasting a Starbucks coffee cup and Ancient Greek drinking vessels I will take careful notation into the differences and similarities of their form, function and decoration of the artifacts. I will go into careful detail of what the ancient Greeks used to create their

Similar Essays

Journey Into Self In Nicola Griffith’s Ammonite And Nancy Springer’s Larque On The Wing

2624 words - 10 pages Journey into Self in Nicola Griffith’s Ammonite and Nancy Springer’s Larque on the Wing     Let your soul roam free. Discover your true self.  Play with your inner child.  Share the memories of your ancestors.  Understand your parents.   Have total self control. Open yourself up and peer inside.  These are accomplishments most humans will never achieve, but Nicola Griffith’s Marghe from her novel Ammonite and Nancy Springer’s Larque from

Ursula K. Le Guin's The Lathe Of Heaven And Science Fiction And The Future

1229 words - 5 pages Ursula K. LeGuin's The Lathe of Heaven and Science Fiction and the Future What will happen in a couple of days? a month ? a year? or twenty years from now? The answer is not known. Author Ursula K. LeGuin gives us the answers about the future from her point of view which can be seen through her article Science Fiction and the Future and her novel, The Lathe of Heaven. Ursula K. LeGuin believes people try to control the future they may have

Ursula K. Le Guin’s A Wizard Of Earthsea And L. Frank Baum’s The Dummy That Lived

948 words - 4 pages beginning of the story. At that point, the protagonist realizes that he or she possesses a unique ability. In high fantasy, that ability generally involves magic. Ursula K. Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea serves as a prime example of this notion. The protagonist, Ged, goes on a journey to quench his thirst for better understanding of wizardry. Another example of fantasy would be L. Frank Baum’s “The Dummy that Lived,” in which a fairy’s mischievous acts

Comparing Ridley Scott's Blade Runner And Philip K. Dick's Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep?

1584 words - 6 pages Comparing Ridley Scott's "Blade Runner" and Philip K. Dick's Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? How do we know that we are human and, if we are human, what does it mean to be human? These two philosophical inquiries are explored in great depth in Ridley Scott's film "Blade Runner", and of course the text of Philip K. Dick's wonderful novel Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? on which the film is based. Most would agree that these themes