Comparing Views On Life In Thoreau’s Walden And Voltaire's Candide

1119 words - 4 pages

Comparing Views on Life in Thoreau’s Walden and Voltaire's Candide

Is the glass half full or half empty? This clichéd measure of optimism versus pessimism describes our society's base understanding of possible outlooks on life. In Candide by Voltaire, ultimately Candide rejects both blind optimism and absolute pessimism. He goes on a quest to discover how to live well, which is the same thing Thoreau prescribes in Walden and Other Writings. For this paper, in accordance with Voltaire and Thoreau, "living well" means aligning one's actions with one's ideals in order to achieve satisfaction. Despite a distance in time of a century and in location of an ocean, Thoreau and Voltaire had incredibly similar views on life. A staunch individualism provided the framework for both men's thoughts. While they chose different lifestyles, the ultimate conclusion for the two men can be encompassed in the phrase that completes Voltaire's Candide, "we must cultivate our garden" (120).

Do not try to cultivate a garden with excessive surplus in order to barter for unnecessary goods or to store up for the future. "Simplicity, simplicity, simplicity," Thoreau orders (173). Voltaire would agree that this is the essential key to living well. After traveling around the world and questioning every sort of person, Candide finally finds peace after seeing the simple life of the Turk on his modest farm with his children. "That good old man seems to have made himself a much better life than the six kings we had the honor of eating supper with," Candide remarks (119). At the end of his quest, Candide finally realizes that power, prestige, and all the other things most people seek indeed are not the answer to happiness. Thoreau wholeheartedly supports this view, demanding that "our lives must be stripped" (133). He encourages us to downsize our lives and our possessions. In order to really live we must narrow our scope, focus on what is literally right before our eyes, particularly nature. Such a focus proves quite difficult today with technology that allows connection across the globe in only seconds. Thoreau illustrates the beauty and divinity of the now by saying, "God himself culminates in the present moment" (177). Many of us spend our lives regretting the past and worrying about the future, and fail to realize our life is happening right now. Candide makes the mistake of placing his happiness on the future reunion with Cunegonde, yet when he finally finds her "she had become ugly" (115). His search for her, which had been his motivation and drive, bears unsatisfactory fruit. The lesson from Candide's journey and Thoreau's words of wisdom is to enjoy each moment of cultivating a small but sufficient garden.

Do not let anyone legislate about how you should cultivate your garden, but follow the guidance you know inside of yourself to be true. Thoreau's essay Civil Disobedience has influenced many people, including Gandhi and Martin Luther King, to work...

Find Another Essay On Comparing Views on Life in Thoreau’s Walden and Voltaire's Candide

Back to Nature in Henry David Thoreau’s Walden

2029 words - 8 pages spring of springs... they would rise to a higher, more ethereal life. (38-39) Thoreau explains the slumbering metaphor even further by including the snake. He grounds his argument in the cyclic rotations of the seasons and nature's reaction to it. Comparing humans to the snake shows how we too have the ability to rise from our slumbering state if we listen to the calls of nature. Without the natural lure, we pacify ourselves with meaningless

Essay on Voltaire's Candide - Voltaire's Opposition to Optimism

1178 words - 5 pages Voltaire’s Opposition to Optimism in Candide Philosophy is a means by which humans search for a general understanding of the world and its concepts. Through experience, thought, and observation, one can arrive at a conclusion that forms the basis of his ideas. However, if one simply thinks and does not act, this conclusion does not make any significant difference on his life. This is a major point that Voltaire tries to make in

Voltaire's "Candide" is a satire on optimism.

998 words - 4 pages characters base optimism on theoretical philosophical arguments rather than real-world evidence. These philosophies prevent them from taking action and preventing adverse situations. Jacques drowns in Lisbon harbor and Pangloss stops Candide from saving the good Anabaptist by arguing "Lisbon harbor had been created expressly so that the Anabaptist would be drowned in it" (Voltaire, 12). If Candide had not listened to Pangloss, he could have saved the life

Analysis of Voltaire's philosophy in Candide

1213 words - 5 pages life experience to have reason to think otherwise. This supports Voltaire's opinion thatJohnson 2knowledge is not based on stories or philosophies, but rather on actions and experience.Voltaire exhibits his belief that life experiences help to gain knowledge through the old woman and her story. In chapters 11 and 12, the old woman explains to Candide and Cunègonde the horrors that she has experienced in her life. Her story helps to shape

The Search for Truth in Voltaire's "Candide"

1467 words - 6 pages Voltaire's "Candide" is a novel which contains conceptual ideas and at the same time is also exaggerated. Voltaire offers sad themes disguised by jokes and witticism, and the story itself presents a distinctive outlook on life. The crucial contrast in the story deals with irrational ideas as taught to Candide about being optimistic, versus reality as viewed by the rest of the world.The main theme which is presented throughout the novel is

Use of Satire in Voltaire's Candide

1578 words - 6 pages Successful Use of Satire in Voltaire's Candide Voltaire's Candide is the story of how one man's adventures affect his philosophy on life. Candide begins his journey full of optimism that he lives in "the best of all possible worlds," but he learns that it is naïve to say that good will eventually come of any evil.  Voltaire successfully uses satire as a means of conveying his opinions about many aspects of European society in the

Satire of Philosophy In Voltaire's Candide

1160 words - 5 pages "best of all worlds" (Voltaire 10). He is also somewhat naive and believes that he could make the world a better place by spreading his theories on optimism. When Candide had met up with Pangloss after a long period of time, Pangloss said that he was almost hanged, then dissected, then beaten, but he still thought that everything was for the better. No matter how little Pangloss believed in the fact that somehow everything would turn out well, he

Movie Essay - A Comparison of Satire in Voltaire's Candide and the Film Lexx

1176 words - 5 pages Satire in Candide and Lexx Voltaire's Candide is a story about a young man learning about the realities of the world; realities he never could have believed to happen in life because his education heavily involves the idea that this is the "best of all worlds." Salter Street Films' Lexx is a story about a group of misfit adventurers and the calamity that befalls them after they steal the Lexx, a Manhattan-sized insect with the ability

Voltaire’s Views of Religion and State Expressed In Candide

801 words - 3 pages Voltaire’s Views of Religion and State Expressed In Candide      Throughout Candide, Voltaire uses satire as a tool to reveal his controversial views regarding religion and State. He reveals the corruption, hypocrisy and immorality present in the way in which government and religion operated during his lifetime. Most particularly, he criticizes violent government behaviour (ie; war) and the behaviour of members of the aristocracy, who

Essay on Voltaire's Candide - Fallacy of Optimism Exposed

793 words - 3 pages noble ancestry. Though greatly disappointed with their outcome all but Candide insist on claiming that all is for the best. The complete absurdity that one could go through as much and end up in the place where they end up and still claim that all was for the best furthers Voltaire's belief in the fallacy of systematic optimism.   Works Cited and Consulted: Frautschi, R.L. Barron's Simplified Approach to Voltaire: Candide. New York: Barron's Educational Series, Inc., 1998. Lowers, James K, ed. "Cliff Notes on Voltaire's Candide". Lincoln: Cliff Notes, Inc. 1995. Voltaire. Candide. New York: Viking Publishers, 1996.

Rising Above a Corrupt World in Voltaire's Candide

1606 words - 6 pages ignorance of the nobility's pride, corruption seen in religion, corruption of the government, corruption of morals, and the flaw in complacent optimism. Voltaire takes Candide through all of these forms of corruption to make him realize his ideals and his own personal philosophy on life.   Illustrations concerning the ignorance of nobility's pride are evident particularly in the Baron, the six dethroned kings, and Don Fernando. The fact that

Similar Essays

Essay On Satire In Voltaire's Candide

638 words - 3 pages Use of Satire in Voltaire’s Candide            Voltaire successfully uses satire as a means of conveying his opinions about life.  In his novel, Candide, Voltaire satirizes the philosopher Liebnitz's philosophy that this is the best of all possible worlds.  In the novel, the perpetually optimistic and naive character, Candide, travels around the world, having various experiences that prove, at least to the reader, that evil does exist

Religious Satire In Voltaire's Candide Essay

961 words - 4 pages finished talking about the importance of charity to an assembly. After Candide tells the orator that he isn't sure whether the Pope is the Antichrist, but that he needs bread, the minister angrily refuses and tells him to "never show your face here again." In the meantime, his wife drops ---- on Candide's head (Candide, Chapter 3, pg. 46-47). Voltaire clearly structured the passage to be especially ironic. The orator represented the Christian

A Comparison Of Satire In Voltaire's Candide And Gulliver's Travels

2248 words - 9 pages to satirize the tendency of corrupt people to take advantage of overly trusting individuals. Both Gulliver and Candide fit the description of the overly trusting, impartial character. Van Doren chronicles this situation as demonstrated in Gulliver's Travels: Grateful for the kindness shown on him, Gulliver aided the Lilliput in this war by capturing the Blefuscudian fleet and bringing it as a gift to his royal host. But the Lilliputians were

Voltaire's Candide As An Attack On Optimism

1325 words - 5 pages whether the mice on board are comfortable or not?" To Voltaire, men were the mice, and "his highness" was not concerned in the least with their day to day existence.   How are Voltaire's views manifest in Candide??   Pangloss is meant not to attack Leibnitz, but rather optimism as a philosophy. Thus the reader cannot forget that all of Pangloss's ramblings are not Voltaire's personal attacks on Leibnitz, but in some way represent an