This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison And Contrast: The Cask Of Amontillado And A Rose For Emily

866 words - 3 pages

What makes a story interesting to you? Is it mystery, intrigue, irony, horror, humor, or even murder? If you answered murder stories then you are in luck.
"The Cask of Amontillado" by Edgar Allan Poe's and William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily" are compelling murder stories, full of dynamic characters, vivid detail, and compelling points of view. These two stories encompass the elements of plot, character, setting and point of view among others. Although the elements of the central theme of murder are different, these stories share other elements that make these stories unique.
In the short story “The cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allan Poe, the basic plot structure is classified as flashback. In the text, this strategy of plot structure is defined by “informing the reader of events that happened before the opening scene of a work.” This is identified in “The cask of Amontillado” during the opening when Poe illustrates the anger and malice Montresor has for Fortunato.
The overall effect this story has on the reader is one of suspense. Brick by Brick the story is developed making you wonder if Fortunato was considering the possibility that this was some sort of joke. Poe’s use of flashback is effective due to the questions the reader is forced to consider while the story is read. As the story concludes, we learn that this event took place a “half century” prior. The fact that Montresor is recounting this event 50 years later reiterates how Montresor is feeling, and how effective the use of flashback in this story is. It’s been 50 years, and the only person who had to pay was the victim, Fortunato.
A symbol is a person, character or an object in a story used to represent an idea. In the short story, A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner, the symbols reinforce the themes of tradition vs. progress, decay and the passage of time, and love that is not returned. This is apparent in Faulkner’s comparison of the death of Miss Emily to that of a fallen monument. This comparison sets the scene for the reader view and imagine how the new and old collide in the south. In this story the new being Emily and the old, her restrictive father.
Emily was so restricted by her father, that she became so desperate for love that she would even resort to murder. Emily murders Homer Barron because she must at any cost get a man. Even in her death the force of his presence is felt. This is another prime example of how the father’s influence dominated Emily’s life. Even in her death her father is still present above her corpse overshadowing her.

Find Another Essay On Comparison and Contrast: The Cask of Amontillado and A Rose for Emily

Comparison of Tobias Wolf's Hunter in the Snow and William Failkner's A Rose for Emily

803 words - 4 pages Tobias Wolff’s “Hunters in the Snow” is a suspense type of story, with an unexpected turn in the end, while William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” could far into the horror genre, because of the baffling atmosphere. These two short stories have similar focuses on symbolism, foreshadowing, settings, atmosphere, and themes; with this in mind they also have many differences such as the writer’s style. The two stories start out with describing the

A Rose For Emily And Feather Pillow Comparison

274 words - 2 pages Rose for Emily and Feather Pillow Essay The stories Rose for Emily and Feather Pillow have a lot of things in common but also have some differences. Rose for Emily starts off early in Emily's life and all through her life she runs through trouble with men. Her first and only relationship was with a guy, that was not the marrying type. She didn't want to lose him so she poisoned him so they would never part. In the story Feather Pillow a husbin

compare and contrast a rose for Emily and the yellow wallpaper

882 words - 4 pages drifts into a timeless realm.2. Did you feel prepared for the story's ending? Why or why not? No, because from the beginning till the end of the story Bierce created this illusion and reality. We the reader was not mindful of any division between them Farquhar's illusion is, for us as the audience, reality. He creates his imaginary world out of despair just like he was about to die, and assuming his escape is a way of reclaiming control over the

A summary, analysis and evaluation of "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner and comparison between "A Rose for Emily" and "Barn Burning" by William Faulkner

721 words - 3 pages "A Rose for Emily""A Rose for Emily" is a tragic story about a woman named Emily Grierson who, for all her life has been controlled by her father. Once her father dies, Emily does not know, nor understand how to live her own life. At first she denies that her father dies; then after 3 days, with much pressuring from the locals and the doctors, she admits her fathers death and lets the townspeople bury him. Much of the town is wondering what to

Comparison Between “The Cask of Amontillado” and “The Tell-Tale Heart”

2127 words - 9 pages Edgar Allan Poe is known for some of the most horrifying stories ever written through out time. He worked with the natural world, animals, and weather to create chilling literature. Two most notable thrillers are “The Cask of Amontillado” and “The Tell-Tale Heart”. Poe was infatuated with death, disfigurement, and dark characteristics of the world. He could mix characters, setting, theme,and mood in a way that readers are automatically drawn

Compare and Contrast: "The Masque of the Red Death [by Edgar Allen Poe]" vs. "A Rose for Emily [by William Faulkner]"

542 words - 2 pages Most notably recognized for their strange and bizarre stories, both Edgar Allen Poe and William Faulkner wrote several disturbing narratives. As such, it is not surprising to find that Poe's story, "The Masque of the Red Death," and Faulkner's tale, "A Rose for Emily," have much in common. Among their numerous similarities, the most apparent comparison is the theme of death in both plots.Foremost, in "the Masque of the Red Death," the country

Camparison of “A rose for Emily” and “The Yellow Wallpaper”

1098 words - 5 pages The two short stories “ A Rose for Emily” and “The Yellow Wallpaper” are two very similar but at the same time very different. The main characters Emily Grierson, from William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily", and the narrator, from Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wall-Paper," are both in the same boat that many women were placed in the late 1800’s and the early 1900’s. Both of these two stories were written in a generation that women were

The Mystery of the Rose and the Narrator in A Rose for Emily by Faulkner

1187 words - 5 pages While one of the most traditional interpretations of “A Rose for Emily” is the variety of meanings for the “rose” presented in the title and how the “rose” fits in with the story. Laura Getty states in her article many varied perspectives that many could ponder when identifying what the “rose” stands for. She states many possible theories that depict what the “rose” means, including theories of other writers that help support her own theory and

The Cycle of Justice and Revenge: The Cask of Amontillado

1215 words - 5 pages pride. As such, Montresor, in his need to avenge his family, crosses over justice’s fine line into the vast territory of revenge. This is furthered by Elena V. Baraban’s “The Motive for Murder in ‘The Cask of Amontillado’ by Edgar Allan Poe” as she comments on Montresor’s need to right the wrongs done to his family. Through their works, Baraban and Poe reveal justice and revenge to be a never-ending cycle, especially when the integrity of one’s

Examples of Irony and Symbolism in The Cask of Amontillado

1852 words - 7 pages .”(Lorcher) The Garcia7 nitre was perfect for montresor it was a way to trap fortunate into his death without him realizing it. “Nemo me impunelacessit.”(Poe 22) is Montresors family motto. In the article titled “Symbolism and Irony in ‘The Cask of Amontillado’.” It tells us the meaning “nobody harms me without being punished.” This is symbolic to what happened to Fortunato he offended Montresor so his punishment was death. The

Comparing The Cask of Amontillado and The Interlopers

674 words - 3 pages Comparing The Cask of Amontillado and The Interlopers   Literary devices are tools used by the author to help the reader understand a given literary work. Writers use different literary devices depending on their style and what they wish their reader to get out of their work. One important literary device that is essential for a successful literary work is theme. Theme is the general insight into life that the author shares with the

Similar Essays

The Gothic Tales Of: The Cask Of Amontillado And A Rose For Emily

1133 words - 5 pages There are many literary devices used in writing a short story. Some important literary devices are irony, symbolism, and imagery. This not only gives insight to the author's style but it also allows the reader to understand the short story they are reading. In "The Cask Of Amontillado," by Edgar Allan Poe and "A Rose For Emily," by William Faulkner the use of irony, symbolism, and imagery are used to show readers what pride, revenge, and power

Comparison Of A Rose For Emily And The Yellow Wallpaper

1162 words - 5 pages A Rose for Emily and The Yellow Wallpaper Comparison William Faulkner's “A Rose for Emily” and Charlotte Perkins Gilman's “The Yellow Wallpaper” are two short stories which incorporate many similarities, both stories are about the emotional and psychological experiences of two women living in a reclusive environment. The women presented in both of the stories experience moments of insanity, loneliness, feelings of being controlled by others

Comparison Of The Swimmer And A Rose For Emily

619 words - 2 pages “The swimmer” and “A Rose for Emily” both show the same theme in the way that they both show that the characters cannot face the past. Emily will not face the truth, the fact that her father died. Neddy drinks because he cannot face the past. The act of drinking takes his mind off of the pains he dealt with in the past. The main ideas that are expressed in John Cheever's The Swimmer, is how Neddy lives through a variety of stages of alcoholism

Comparison Between The Yellow Wallpaper And A Rose For Emily

1154 words - 5 pages Barbara Angelis stated “Women need real moments of solitude and self-reflection to balance out how much of ourselves we give away” (Angelis, BrainyQuote). This statement reflects the theme of isolation and how one can truly understand themselves through self-reflection and time spent in loneliness. In the short stories, “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner, both female protagonists