Comparison Between Edna Ponteiller In The Awakening And The Caged Bird In Maya Angelou's Poem Aga Khan Ib1 Essay

1047 words - 5 pages

Compare Maya Angelou’s poem “Caged Bird” with ways in which Edna is described as a caged bird in the Créole community. Does she differ in any way from the bird?
In my essay, I will explore the ways in which Edna Ponteiller is presented as an imprisoned woman by the Creole community just like the caged bird presented in Maya Angelou’s poem Caged bird. I will also examine whether Edna differs in any way from the bird.
Maya Angelou and Kate Chopin are well known writers and feminists. They both have played an impactful role in the feminist movement during the 1900s. These robust and powerful women had expressed the hardships a woman had to go through in patriarchal and racist societies. Whether it is The awakening or Caged bird there is portrayal of an unfair system where one has the freedom and liberty and other doesn’t. Edna being the prisoner of the Creole is nothing less than the Caged bird portrayed in the poem.
The caged bird presented in Maya Angelou’s poem is a sheer reflection of Edna who serves to be a microcosm of all the entrapped Victorian women in general. “But a bird that stalks down his narrow cage”. A caged bird who is constrained and denied freedom is depicted in this line which is very parallel to the Creole culture of narrowing women’s lives to their homes and families with nothing beyond that. “Creole women were expected to worship their husbands and idolize their children.” In such a society where women are only considered to be fit for the role as a mother and a wife makes the Kentucky born Edna nothing more than the caged bird with clipped wings.
“…his bars of rage, his wings are clipped and his feet are tied”, the bars of the cage symbolize the barrier for the bird identical to how the Creole culture acts a barricade to Edna. “…it a holy privilege to efface themselves as individuals and grow wings as ministering angels”. Like the bird, Edna’s movement is limited by the social norms of the Creole culture such as being expected to stay home as idle decorative symbols of their husband’s wealth. Though Edna is presented as an angel with wings she can only use them to protect and shield but not to fly.
The theme of injustice and unfairness is injected by the vast comparison between the “free bird” and the” caged bird”. “A free bird leaps on the back of the wind and flows downstream…” whereas “…a caged bird stands on the grave of dreams” emphasizing that a free bird is unstoppable and a caged bird is always halted. This discrimination is alike to the contrast in the privileges of Mr. Ponteiller vs Edna’s. The Creole women have to follow their husband and must obey all of the rules that do not give them much opportunity to be independent. For instance, the creole culture states that a man can do any job of preference whereas women could only get a job as factory workers that too with a lower wage. Such heavy discrimination of women makes Edna nothing but a...

Find Another Essay On Comparison between Edna Ponteiller in the Awakening and the caged bird in Maya Angelou's poem - Aga Khan Ib1 - Essay

Analysis of Maya Angelou's "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings"

1049 words - 4 pages Maya Angelou's I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings chronicles the early years of the author's life - up to age seventeen. In the book, Angelou poetically describes the phenomenon that is growing up black, in the south, in the time before and during World War II. I believe that you are expected to interpret this as a memoir of overcoming the odds. I believe that you are expected to regard the happenings of this book with feelings of empathy and/or

Focuses on the literary elements of Maya Angelou's "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings". Entitled: "The Melody of Maya"

1219 words - 5 pages Just as a sweetly sung melody dances through the wind, Maya Angelou's style flows fluently throughout her writing in her autobiographical piece, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. As the silent listener lets the tune seep into his ears, he begins to notice each individual note. The consistent style of personification and lively imagery exemplifies and enhances the intention of Angelou. The whimsical array of harmony and notes strike a chord inside

Loss of Freedom in Sedaris' This Old House and Angelou's Caged Bird

1543 words - 6 pages misinterpretation and confusion, where as a narrative essay is straightforward and to the point. The loss of freedom was expressed quite literally for the caged bird, but in my opinion was also expressed for the young boy. Sedaris reminisces of his childhood, and reflects on the disapproval from his father to express himself freely through something simple, such as clothing. “The way I saw it, the problem wasn’t my outfit but my context. Sure I looked

With close reference to the text, explain how Maya Angelou contrasts captivity and freedom in caged bird

613 words - 2 pages The poem “Caged Bird”, written by Maya Angelou shows two main themes; social injustice and lack of freedom. The poem is based on the point of view of the poet brought up in Arkansas, U.S.A. in 1920s’ when the racism towards black people was still around. With the real-life experiences, she expresses the distress and the sorrow of the caged bird representing black people. Maya Angelou use variety of language techniques, such as

Race Relations in I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou

781 words - 3 pages Race Relations in I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou The reasons listed by the censors for banning I Know Why the Cage Bird Sings do not explain the widespread controversy around the novel. There is reason to believe that the question of the novel is in its poignant portrayal of race relations. This explains why the novel has been most controversial in the South, where racial tension is historically worst, and where the novel

I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou

707 words - 3 pages As a black woman in the 1930's and the 1940's, little power or ever respect was given. There had been no civil rights movement and Jim Crow laws and segregation were still in effect. Blacks, in general, especially women, were not given a felicitous education because it was illegal to acquire or obtain books during that time period. Maya Angelou's autobiography, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, was deeply shaped of her coming of age during the

I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings Influences On Maya

1095 words - 4 pages A Lifetime of Influence Marguerite Johnson had a harsh childhood growing up in the South during the days of cotton picking and slavery. All of the adversity she encountered when she was young inspired her to write the book I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. In it, she depicts what life was like growing up in the small town of Stamps, Arkansas, and illustrates the daily hardships that were roadblocks throughout her life. Many people help her

I know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou

1594 words - 6 pages these hardships, Maya Angelou was awarded over fifty honorary degrees for her novel, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings (Women Memoirist 43). Dealing with the dilemma to learn to read and write, one may wonder how one of the best African-American authors of all time could prosper during such manifold, impeding hardships. Her novel takes place in the Deep South in the midst of a cultural and political reformation. Written in 1969, the novel, I Know

"Caged bird" by Maya Angelou Compare and contrast the lives of both birds. In what ways does the author manage to transmit her message?

647 words - 3 pages “Caged Bird” analysisIn the poem “Caged Bird” by Maya Angelou, we can see that the themes are the lack of freedom, but also the hope for it. This emotion filled poem compares and contrasts the life of two birds. One symbolizing freedom, someone who has got it all but still wants more; and another one representing imprisonment, the desire of something unknown. The poem is structured by six stanzas, each one talking about the

"Caged Bird" by Maya Angelou

587 words - 2 pages Question:Explore the ways in which Maya Angelou uses the 'Caged Bird' metaphor to present her ideas.Consider the range of poetic devices, language, poet's message, technique, etc.The poem ’Caged Bird’ composed by Maya Angelou depicts the contrast between good and evil, black and white, freedom and imprisonment. It also displays deeper meanings and connections to how the blacks were and are treated by the white. The caged bird can be

Comparison of the Main Characters in To Kill a Mockingbird and I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings

816 words - 4 pages Jim. Her mother die when Scout was just a baby girl. For this reason she lives in a single parent home. In the other hand, Maya the main character from the story “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” lives with her relatives after her parents’ divorce at the begging of the story. Maya and her brother Bailey were sent to live with her grandmother at a remote town named Maycomb, Alabama. Maya treats her grandmother as her actual mother since during the

Similar Essays

Language Representing The Bird In Angelou's Poem Caged Bird

653 words - 3 pages In the thought provoking masterpiece "Caged bird "the poet, Maya Angelou, through the contrast of the birds, illustrates oppression and fear of freedom of these who cannot be free. This is supported by the bright descriptions of the carefree bird. Angelou uses powerful verbs to reflect the difference between the two birds. The free creature "leaps", "floats" "dips", "claims" and "dares". The active tense of these words helps to show the full

Racism In Maya Angelou's I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings

2035 words - 8 pages Racism in Maya Angelou's I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings Maya Angelou, the current poet laureate of the United States, has become for many people an exemplary role model. She read an original poem at the inauguration of President Clinton; she has also appeared on the television show "Touched by an Angel," and there read another poem of her own composition; she lectures widely, inspiring young people to aim high in life. Yet this is an

Analysis On Maya Angelou's 'caged Bird'

764 words - 3 pages How has the poet conveyed the idea of inequality in her poem ‘Caged Bird’? How has she made this contrast vivid for the reader?The poet, during the whole poem contrasts two very different realities; the caged bird’s and the free bird’s. By alternating the stanzas in the poem, she makes it easier for the reader to compare both birds. The birds throughout the poem are actually an extended metaphor to the conditions of men, some

Analysis On Chapters 14 And 15 Of "I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings" By Maya Angelou's

804 words - 3 pages Maya Angelou's I Know Why Caged Bird Sings illustrates how an innocent and naive girl growing up in the midst of the Great Depression overcomes life's many obstacles and becomes the powerful and influential woman she is today. Maya is a world renowned author, teacher, speaker, actress, and mother. Through this autobiographical piece, Maya's use of figurative language and allusion compounds her thoughts, as she depicts how one can supersede the