This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison Between "Lord Of The Flies" And "Catcher In The Rye".

1014 words - 4 pages

Comparison EssayThe two books that I am comparing are The Catcher in the Rye, and Lord of the Flies. The two books are very interesting and are very opposite yet the same in many ways. In The Catcher in the Rye, Holden is an idealistic character who becomes more of a realist as the novel progresses, while in the Lord of the Flies, many characters assume different roles. But the main argument between the two novels is that Holden has a dream job of being the catcher in the rye. The catcher in the rye symbolizes that Holden is on an imaginary cliff, trying to keep the children from falling off. The rye symbolizes childhood and innocence, but falling off would mean falling into the "phony" world of adult-hood. Holden wants to keep the kids on the rye preserving their innocence. In the Lord of the Flies, the boys are stuck on an island without adult supervision and quickly lose their innocence, becoming savages. Jack is the leader of the savages, and he is always acting very wild and crazy on the island. Jack yelled this quote a number of times, " Kill the pig! Cut his throat! Kill the pig! Bash him in!" ( Golding 126). The theme I am trying to connect, is it possible to stay innocent your whole life, or will everyone eventually lose their innocence?In the Lord of the Flies, Ralph and Piggy are the two main characters trying to keep innocence on the island by trying to restore a democratic island. Piggy tries to use his wisdom, while Ralph tries to use the little power he has left. But in order to restore democracy and innocence on the island they must compete with Jack, who is controlling the island by making everyone believe that eating meat is more important than being rescued. He even lets down his guard at the signal fire and loses their chances of being rescued; but even though Jack is not the right guy to be leader on the island, because he doesn't think for the long run, the boys like Jack because he fills their stomachs with meat. Ralph and Piggy can be compared to Holden's dream job of being the catcher in the rye. Both things are unrealistic, as it is impossible to keep kids from falling into adulthood and losing their innocence, because it is a normal, healthy part of life, and Holden eventually learns that, and Ralph and Piggy realize that it is unrealistic to compete with Jack's group of savages, and that everyone will eventually lose their innocence.Holden Caulfield believes that all kids are innocent, and when they go into the adult world, they all become phonies. Holden feels that all adults in the book are phonies, except for the nuns. Holden thinks that all adults ruin children and take away their innocence. If Holden's thoughts were true, then Holden would think that the island in Lord of the...

Find Another Essay On Comparison between "Lord of the flies" and "Catcher in the rye".

A Comparison of Attitudes Towards Life in "The Catcher in the Rye"and "Dead Poet's Society"

1491 words - 6 pages In this world, there are many attitudes towards life that one can possess. This attitude can range from nihilism to ignorant idealism depending on the human being. The works entitled "Dead Poets' Society" and "The Catcher in the Rye" hold a variety of stances on life. However, the novel, "The Catcher in the Rye" mainly paints the mind-set of idealism because it is about an adolescent named Holden Caulfield who is highly idealistic. The novel

This essay is a comparison between the books Animal FArm and Lord of the Flies

599 words - 2 pages Book Essay: Animal Farm and Lord of the FliesIn 1887 Lord Acton wrote in a letter to Bishop Mandell Creighton, "Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely." It has often been noted that this is the primary theme in both Animal Farm and Lord of the Flies. In addition, these books share two sub-themes related to this primary theme. One sub-theme is that people will often abuse power when it's not earned. The other is that when

A Comparison of Holden of Catcher in the Rye and Equality 7-251 of Anthem

697 words - 3 pages Catcher in the Rye and Anthem - A Comparison of Holden and Equality 7-251     Is it possible that two completely different authors could create two identical characters?  It seems so; J.D. Salinger's Holden, from Catcher in the Rye, and Ayn Rand's Equality 7-2521, in Anthem, appear to be one in the same person.   To end the oppression they received for the span of their entire lives, both Holden and

"Good people...are good because they come to wisdom through failure." analysis of the quote using two novels: The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger and The Lord of the Flies by William Golding

1177 words - 5 pages "Good people...are good because they come to wisdom through failure." According to William Saroyan, this means that a person can learn from mistakes and become a better person. This statement is confirmed in J.D. Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye and William Golding's The Lord of the Flies. J.D. Salinger's Holden is constantly trying to preserve the innocence in children throughout the novel. In addition Holden also attempts to keep his brother

A Comparison of The Destructors and Lord of the Flies

2384 words - 10 pages A Comparison of The Destructors and Lord of the Flies        In Graham Greene's "The Destructors," the author presents the Wormsley Common car-park gang, a group of adolescent delinquents who commit petty crimes for fun. William Golding, in his novel Lord of the Flies, presents a slightly younger group of boys who are wrecked on an uninhabited island and develop a primitive society that eventually collapses and gives

Comparison of "The Color Purple" and "Lord of the Flies"

1453 words - 6 pages in her self esteem.In contrast, Ralph in the story "Lord of the Flies" is the chief of his tribe on the island. He expresses himself and tells his tribe what to do, where as in Celie's case, she has to listen to her husband. She cannot express herself, where as he wants to express more of himself to the tribe. He is full of confidence of what he does and all the decisions he makes, whereas Celie will go with anything her husband says. Ralph is a

Lord Of The Flies Comparison t

1342 words - 5 pages , if you look closer, his character acts as a contrast to the title of the novel, Lord Of The Flies. This translates to the Greek word, "Beelzebub" also meaning the devil, or Satan. Simon can be compared to a character in another famous story; the bible. Just like Jesus Christ, Simon cares for the small and vulnerable. He loves nature and life. He is the only member of the group who is never scared. He even volunteers to venture through the forest

"Lord of the Flies": Film and Book Comparison

723 words - 3 pages the novel, "Lord of the Flies". The main theme of the story is, "the dark side of human nature". The book is able to express the main theme better with some vivid scenes while the film version fails to do that.To begin with, the film failed to show some important elements of the novel due to the deleted scenes of violence and bloody graphic. For instance, in the film version, when Roger pushed the boulder and killed Piggy they did not show the

Comparison of "Catcher In The Rye" by Salinger And "The Adventures of Huck Finn" by Mark Twain

1361 words - 5 pages adventure' that one receives to begin the cycle. There are many ways that this is found in literature including going by desire, by chance, by abduction, and by being lured by an outside force. In The Adventures of Huck Finn, Huck is forced with the dilemma of whether to stay with his father and continue to be abused or to leave. Huck goes because he desires to begin his journey. In The Catcher In The Rye, Holden mentally is torn between experience

Comparrison Between Holden Caufield And Louie Banks In Running Loose And The Catcher In The Rye

896 words - 4 pages Louie Banks and Holden Caufield both have a certain someone who they do not get along with in each of the books we read. Louie has problems with Boomer, while Holden's problems are with Stradlater. Both boys have similarities with how their problems with the other character occurs and they both have differences. They approach each situation differently also in the regard to how the situation develops with their opposing character. Louie

conflict between the character Jack and Ralph in Goldings " Lord of the Flies"

705 words - 3 pages Throughout William Goldings novel Lord of The Flies there is an ever presentconflict between two characters. Ralph's character combines common sense with a strongdesire for civilized life. Jack, however, is an antagonist with savage instincts which hecannot control. Ralph's goals to achieve a team unit with organization are destroyed byJack's actions and words that are openly displayed to the boys. The two leaders try toconvince the boys that

Similar Essays

Comparison Between "Tom Sawyer" And "The Catcher In The Rye"

608 words - 2 pages In this essay I’m going to compare and contrast two interesting books: “The Catcher in the Rye” by J.D. Salinger, and “The Adventures of Tom Sawyer” by Mark Twain. I will analyze the aspects of the lives of the main characters Holden and Tom, and their points of view.” The Catcher in the Rye” is a story about a teenager called Holden. The story takes place in a modern school in the United States. The other

Comparison Between The Law In Golding's "Lord Or The Flies" And Aquinas's Concept Of Law

719 words - 3 pages society were for his own benefit and not for the benefit of the society. The use of violence was his way of keeping everyone in his own society scared, therefore subservient. He also uses violence to take Piggy's glasses, which gave him the power to make fire. This type of behavior causes the children in his tribe to act like cruel, wild and barbaric animals.The theme of "The Lord of the Flies" is the conflict between two opposing impulses that

Comparison Between "Catcher In The Rye" And "Rebel Without A Cause"

668 words - 3 pages When one both reads Catcher in the Rye and sees Rebel Without a Cause, he or she can't help but wonder if the writers, Nicholas Ray and J.D. Salinger, somehow knew each other, or if one writer copied the ideas of the other. Jim Stark and Holden Caulfield, the two main characters of the stories, have so much in common that if they ever met one another, they would immediately become friends. The main theme that applies to both works is teenage

Compare And Contrast Between Juno And Catcher In The Rye

910 words - 4 pages The main protagonists Juno and Holden of movie Juno and the book Catcher in the Rye, have main thing in common, they have not yet accepted the fact they play a role in society, communicating with the people around them, and with their families. Where they differ is in the problems they face. Juno's main problem is that she becomes pregnant at a young age which is considered to be a life changing event by societal standards. The main source of