Comparison Between The Taste Of Ashes And Post Communist Nostalgia

2040 words - 8 pages

This essay will discuss two books, Marci Shore’s The Taste of Ashes and Maria Todorova and Zsuzsa Gille Post-Communist Nostalgia. Both books deal with post-communist Europe and use memory as a tool for their research. While Shore writes in a more personal narrative she gives us the realization that even when we rid countries of tyranny and coercion this does not in any way make these places better. In fact, things get far more complicated. It becomes evident that research has shown how you cannot throw people from a former communist regime into something democratic and expect it to automatically gain smooth running or for these people to know how to carry on as normal, while having the burden of being expected to block out their communist past and start afresh. We cannot assume that nothing could have been worse than dictatorship, so believing that whatever follows is evidently going to be something far better. This is the point Shore makes in her ‘Taste of Ashes’. This is different to post-communist nostalgia as it delivers a more personal tale from the author herself, writing about her own encounters with these countries. Shore explains that her book is a deeply subjective one, writing in the first person, owning the perspective of a young American women who wanders into a completely different world. Attempting to untangle the dark mysteries of Polish-Jewish relations, speaking primarily to those who experienced it all first hand, these people have been named and not named. Shore separates this book into a lengthily 27 chapters, which may immediately strike the reader as daunting. However, each chapter is arguably the perfect length, giving the book a great layout. This book moves forward in time from the early 1990’s through to the second post communist decade while also moving back in time, from the 1980’s to the years immediately following the first world war. The pivot of the revolutions in 1989, which ended communism with the fall of the Berlin Wall and brought Shore to Europe.

This book tells the story of the darker side of the fall of communism, about the lingering presence of the past through the memories of Eastern Europeans who still hold onto the guilt and those who served in communism with loyalty and no regrets. However, we are not here to judge, only to read and as Shore pointed out in her preface, hopefully understand. As her landlord explained in chapter 13 ‘The Locomotive of History’ how were any of us to know which side of communism we would have been on had we lived through the experience. ‘It’s easy for me to talk, how can I know how I would have behaved in such circumstances? I, too, have no confidence that I would have behaved well. On the contrary, I suspect I would have been a coward’. Out of all the chapters written in this book, the chapter on ‘The Locomotive of History’ (mentioned above) stands out the most. Arguably, this is due to its explanation of how Warsaw was, even after the collapse of communism. On a...

Find Another Essay On Comparison between The Taste of Ashes and Post Communist Nostalgia

Comparison between the Art of War and the Time Machine

1395 words - 6 pages Novels of the past century have talked about the works of fiction and how they help people’s lives. They offer morals as well as lessons learned after reading. The novels The Time Machine by H.G. Wells talks about the future of the human race as well as the theory of time travel and The Art of War by Sun Tzu provides readers with a manual type of reading explaining how to fight or avoid wars. Although they may have many differences between

Comparison between "The Iliad" and "The Women of Troy"

1001 words - 4 pages The Iliad by Homer and the Women of Troy by Euripides are both Greek works of literature that look at the Trojan War from different perspectives. Book 6 of the Iliad illustrates that the ultimate glory is to fight for the city with no regard to the impact on the family. The Women of Troy focuses on the negatives that war causes, especially towards the soldier’s wives and children. Whereas the Iliad focuses on the battle itself and centers on

Management Report of the Comparison between Coca-Cola and PepsiCo

2464 words - 10 pages regulations of creating a healthier sweetener and reduce the amount of corn syrup in products that may diminish taste and quality of its products. Current Events in Managerial and Financial Decisions The Soft Drink Industry The soft drink industry experienced a loss in total sales by 3% in 2013. This has been the lowest since 1995 according to Beverage Digest. Adding to the threats consumers tastes

Comparison Between Merchant of Venice and The Bible

2041 words - 8 pages Egyptian, after Abram had dwelled ten years in the land of Canaan, and gave her to her husband Abram for his wife. 4 And he went in unto Hagar, and she conceived. and when she saw that she had conceived, her dame was despised in her eyes. 5 Then Sarai said to Abram, Thou doest me wrong. I have given my maid into thy bosom, and she seeth that she hath conceived, and I am despised in her eyes: the Lord judge between me and thee. 6 Then Abram said

A comparison between the writings of Hughes, Hill, and Harrison

935 words - 4 pages Theology, September song, and National Trust are works of Hughes, Hill and Harrison, which all speak of situations in the past that have affected society to the present day. As for other works of these poets such as Examination at the Womb Dorr, In Memory of Jane Fraiser, and Book Ends, each deals with the struggle of death. These poems recite different aspects of how the consequence of death reaches us all.Hughes' point in writing Theology

Comparison Between The Stranger And Myth Of Sisyphus

1090 words - 4 pages Getting used to punishment The book, The Stranger, was written by Albert Camus and was based on the Myth of Sisyphus, and thus these two books share many similarities and also contain many differences. In the Myth of Sisyphus, Sisyphus was eternally condemned by the gods to push a rock up a hill, only to have it fall down on him again. Meursault however, is a person who is accused of murder, sent to jail for over a year, and is then executed

The Role of Nostalgia in The English Patient

3141 words - 13 pages approaches to history ignore, as he further indicates. His conception prefigured two dominant tendencies of research into nostalgia in film studies. While the first examines the use of intertextual devices and flashbacks to evoke nostalgia (Lurry 2000, Wollen 1991), the second aims to evaluate the relationship between nostalgic film and history (Boym 2001, Dika 2003, Grainger 2002, Hutcheon 1989, Jameson 1985). Although the former identifies

Comparison of Post-classical societies

885 words - 4 pages (Lecture 16). During the post-classical era, the Chola Dynasty rose in Southern India between 9th-13th c. C.E. and came to be rich and powerful through sea trade, and started to exert their influence over most parts of southern India (Lecture 16). Economies During the post-classical era, there was a lot of trade in the Indian Ocean basin, and this served to create stronger links between the Indian society and the Islamic world. In the Indian society

David Hume's Of the Standard of Taste

646 words - 3 pages detrimental to the artist, or may never be publicised, which is unfortunate for the public. On the topic of aesthetic judgment, there are two main paths one could take: that of the subjectivists, who claim the importance of the role of the viewer or audience, and assert that art can only be judged by the preference and aesthetic taste of individuals, as well that anything that creates an aesthetic response can be considered art; then there is

The Effect of Age on Taste

1936 words - 8 pages . This problem of taste loss due to aging needs to be studied more because it can effect both the physical and mental health of many elderly people. When elderly individuals try to live life with a weakened ability to recognize certain food flavors or any other consumable item, their dietary needs can be greatly affected. A certain number of foods are not going to taste good enough to satisfy the appetites of the elderly, so they might resort

The Relationship Between the Communist/Socialist Movements and the Liberation Movements

1254 words - 5 pages Communist/socialist movements played a vital role in the development of liberation movements. Throughout most of Asia and Africa the communist/socialist sphere of influence grew to amass approximately a third of the worlds population. Engulfing many nations on the cusp of their independence. The relationship between the communist/socialist movements and liberation movements was based on an acting factor that enabled the movement to succeed

Similar Essays

The True Relationship Between Taste And Smell

1279 words - 5 pages Introduction It has been alleged that the perception of flavor and aroma are “derived from the senses of chemical irritation, taste and smell” (Rawson, 2003). Collectively, these senses constitute what has been termed chemosensation, even though these sensory systems are supposedly very different in their physiology and anatomy. Nevertheless, they do have the ability to “regenerate, and their noted susceptibility to aging and age associated

Book Comparison Of The Rise Of Communist Parties, Soviet Union, And China

1496 words - 6 pages , Stalin, and Mussolini first, and China in Transformation second. Not only will one be able to make a cross comparison between the Soviet Union and China, one will be able to compare and contrast the rise of the fascist totalitarian regimes (Germany and Italy) as well. Also, since the Communist takeover happened later in China, one might be able to see certain aspects of Soviet Communism in Chinese Communism. One would think that China would

The Taste Of Death Essay

1257 words - 5 pages The Taste of Death Lying halfway between San Diego and Los Angeles makes the Temecula Valley an easy escape for city dwellers hungry for the serenity of a day in the country. Temecula's wine country is located a mere five miles off of the I-15 Freeway among citrus groves and vineyards. In the clear early mornings, colorful hot air balloons seem suspended in the skies overlooking this bucolic valley. Growing up I felt privileged to live

A Comparison Of Impressionism And Post Impressionism

2184 words - 9 pages A Comparison of Impressionism and Post-Impressionism In this essay, I will contrast and compare the two art movements, Impressionism, and Post-Impressionism. I will be concentrating on the works of the two leading artists of these styles Claude Monet and Vincent van Gogh. The impressionist movement is often considered to mark the beginning of the modern period of art. It was developed in France during the late 19th century. The