This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison Of 1984 And The Dispossessed

1188 words - 5 pages

In all of human history, the notion of a perfect society has been considered and attempted, but never truly attained. A positive perfect world, were every member is blissful, is a utopia. Alternatively, a negative perfect, world full of disdain and melancholy, is a dystopia. 1984 is a dystopia because its society is decadent and miserable. The Dispossessed is a world full of tranquility and freedom; therefore its society is a utopia. Both novels can be considered complete opposites for their contradicting societies-one with restriction, the other with liberty. Both societies differ because the 1984 society lacks basic rights, while The Dispossessed society does not; in 1984, the government has absolute control of the people, while the society of The Dispossessed has autonomy.Every now and then, complete opposites have some things in common. For instance, one way or another all societies in the world have similarities. In the case of 1984, a dystopia, and The Dispossessed, a utopia, similarities do exist. Both of their societies, thought structured differently, are concepts of perfect worlds under different point of views. In 1984, the inner party does everything in its power to have their vision of a perfect world, even if it means killing, lying to the public, and rewriting history- all for the purpose of benefiting themselves. The inhabitants of The Dispossessed live their own idealistic lives on the principles of Odo, which are peace, love, freedom and other positive values. Both of these societies are isolated from other societies. Oceania does not involve itself with other societies because of the war being fought. The Odonian society separated itself from the mother-planet Urras by migrating to a moon, thereafter keeping communication with Urras to an absolute minimum. The few similarities between these two societies cannot compare with the significant differences these seemingly contradictory worlds posses.Basic human rights are often taken for granted in places such as the United States., were liberty is experienced since birth. Several countries under totalitarian control give its citizens almost no decision in paving their own lives. In 1984, the citizens do not have privileges that a positive or just society would have. Basic rights, a crucial part of freedom, are not present in Oceania because a specific order in rank is followed in order for this suppressing society to avoid positive changes for the community. Two of the three classes, the proletarians and the outer party are denied of their basic rights by the government, the inner party.. All three of these classes have different rights. The proles, the working class, have no say in the way the government runs the country. They are considered animals by other classes and are left to live in squalor. Following the proles is the outer party, who have more important jobs; however, like the proles they have no control of their lives. The highest class, the inner party, has complete...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of 1984 and The Dispossessed

Comparison of A Brave New World and 1984

866 words - 3 pages Comparison of A Brave New World and 1984 A Brave New World is a story about Bernard Marx, who rejects his society because he finds that he is not satisfied with living a controlled life. 1984 is a story about Winston who finds forbidden love within the restrictions of his society. These books are both in the same genre, so they can be easily compared and contrasted. The main similarities in the two pieces are the topics of the

Compare the descriptions of the society of '1984' and 'Brave New World' in the first three chapters of each book. Huxley and Orwell comparison

1625 words - 7 pages different, only the world of which they were created by, "Nothing like a oxygen shortage...keeping an embryo below par."The past in both of the novels is a topic of great controversy within the raging totalitarian societies. History and the past are avoided in each to prevent any means of comparison between the old and new ways of governing. This is most evident in '1984' where history is not just destroyed and forgotten it is actually rewritten

"1984" in Comparison to "The Giver"

1821 words - 7 pages War, torture, and constant fear, all of these are key elements in the distopia George Orwell creates in the novel, 1984. In this book, Orwell creates a society which is based solely on hate and controlled by those who seek only power. Orwell, however, is not the only author to ponder the possibility of an extreme, futuristic society. In particular, The Giver, by Louis Lowry relates a great deal to the themes found in 1984. Unlike 1984, Lowry's

A Comparison Contrast of 1984 and A Brave New World, no comments, just an "awkward" comment in the transition between the 4th and 5th paragraph

2277 words - 9 pages A Comparison Contrast of A Brave New World and 1984 Although many similarities exist between Aldous Huxley's A Brave New World and George Orwell's 1984, the works books though they deal with similar topics, are more dissimilar than alike. A Brave New World is a novel about the struggle of Bernard Marx, who rejects the tenants of his society when he discovers that he is not truly happy. 1984 is the story of Winston who finds forbidden love within

Comparison Of "Brave New World" By Aldous Huxley And "1984" By George Orwell

1414 words - 6 pages David Lilienthal, a writer, once said, "The idea of utopia is mischievous as well as unrealistic" ( A dream for a utopian society always exists, but it remains a dream. In the novels Brave New World and 1984, the manipulations and recreations of society cause perfection. Winston Smith, the protagonist of 1984, is a low-ranking member of the ruling Party in Oceania. Part of the Ministry of Truth, he alters historical

Utopia: the naive dream. a book comparison between "Lord of the Flies" by William Golding, "1984" by George Orwell and "Brave New World" by Aldous Huxley

7520 words - 30 pages never even think of rebelling. If this closed society, however, were to be infiltrated by an outside force, then the Party may not be have been able to control the perception of reality, and therefore would make itself vulnerable to a rebellion. All the same, in the year 1984, Oceania was a closed society, and the Party, accordingly, remained an indestructible force. The Party had complete control over what the people perceived as reality, so

"1984" and "The Crucible"

889 words - 4 pages at all of his options.These articles from The New York Times relate to Thomas Pynchon's quote, "There is always some agency like the Ministry of Truth to deny the memories of others, to rewrite the past, (1984 xxi)" because in both of the stories the U.S. is trying to put more troops into Iraq, but now for different reasons. We have been over in Iraq for four years and there have been no improvements, just more American soldiers are being killed

Ponder the Meaning of Life With 1984 and The Matrix

1900 words - 8 pages The film The Matrix, directed by Andy and Lana Wachowski, may seem to be a unique, original storyline to the untrained viewer, but the story of a totalitarian government and a hero who attempts to save the people is far from this. In reality, there are so many similarities that can be seen in other texts that were written and filmed before that it cannot be ignored. In particular, George Orwell’s 1984 has a similar government that controls its

Fahrenheit 451 And 1984 - The Fear Of Utopia

1248 words - 5 pages Several conflicting frames of mind have played defining roles in shaping humanity throughout the twentieth century. Philosophical optimism of a bright future held by humanity in general was taken advantage of by the promise of a better life through sacrifice of individuality to the state. In the books Brave New World, 1984, and Fahrenheit 451 clear opposition to these subtle entrapments was voiced in similarly convincing ways. They first all

Hitler’s Reich and 1984: The Repercussions of Totalitarianism

2868 words - 11 pages source of inspiration for countless authors. Reactions are evident in the period of postmodern literature that emerged as a response to Hitler’s Reich. Because of the political messages within these, they greatly influenced society, and therefore have a place in the historical analysis of WWII. George Orwell, a political essayist and novelist, was a prominent luminary of these writings, and in his novel 1984, he attempts to explain the disastrous

Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984

2192 words - 9 pages To a man with a hammer everything looks like a nail. I would submit this is the case in regards to Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. The courts have been granted a tool and since its introduction have been wantonly applying it case after case. I will endeavour to argue that s.78 has been developed into the tool the courts sought as oppose to the tool they have been granted and the wording of the statute ignored. The point

Similar Essays

Tva And The Dispossessed Essay

1525 words - 6 pages TVA and the Dispossessed The Norris Bassin was the Tennessee Valley Authority's first and most significant experimental laboratory in regional planning. TVA had been created in the post-World War I era in 1918 in an effort to end dependency on Chilean nitrates for war production. Years later, in 1933 during the Great Depression, the Authority began to acquire land in the upper Tennessee region. Its main purpose was to create a storage

The Voice Of The Dispossessed Essay

1683 words - 7 pages THE VOICE OF THE DISPOSSESSED The four main speeches seem to be the catalyst that propels Invisible Man from one situation to another. The speeches open up many opportunities for him and, at the same time force him to confront the world around him.Words are how IM expresses himself and how he finds satisfaction in being. He loves nothing more than speaking to a crowd, to hold them with his every word and make them feel something through him that

Comparison Of 1984 By George Orwell To The Actual 1984

1346 words - 5 pages Comparison Of 1984 By George Orwell To The Actual 1984 Since the onset of the United States, Americans have always viewed the future in two ways; one, as the perfect society with a perfect government, or two, as a communistic hell where free will no longer exists and no one is happy. The novel 1984 by George Orwell is a combination of both theories. On the "bad" side, a communist state exists which is enforced with surveillance technology

Comparison Of The Books "1984" By George Orwell And "Shadow Men" By Jonathan King

606 words - 2 pages thing when trying to tell a story. The books 1984 by George Orwell and Shadow Men by Jonathan King are very different in the way the story is described and presented.The novel 1984 was the better written of the two because of many reasons. First of all, Orwell did a better job in creating the main character, Winston. Winston is a meek person on the outside, but a very strong willed and curious on the inside. Inside, he feels that there might be