Comparison Of Edith Wharton's House Of Mirth And Toni Morrison's Jazz In Identity Formation Of The Characters Through Dependence On Others For Money And Love

2012 words - 8 pages

Discovering One's Identity: Love and Money in New York City "With some people, solitariness is an escape not from others, but from themselves. For they see in the eyes of others only a reflection of themselves." The quote by Eric Hoffer reminds me of Toni Morrison's Jazz and Edith Wharton's House of Mirth in that the main characters of the novels encountered pivotal crises where their sense of identity was thwarted by money, love, or their relationship with another character. The House of Mirth centers on Lily Bart's attempt to acquire wealth and a haughty social status, which, in turn, leads her to achieving a sense of self, but only at the highest of cost. Her relationships with Selden and other male characters, such as Percy and Trenor, lead her to a full realization of her true place in society and teach great moral lessons to the reader on wealth and love. In Jazz, Toni Morrison portrays the difficulty of African-American's in New York City in their ability to gain a sense of self understanding through the obstacles of money and the emotion of love through the characters of Dorcas, Violet, Joe, and Golden Gray. Although race and societal status of the primary characters offers a certain degree of variation between Jazz and The House of Mirth, both novels give inspiring dimensions to characters that alert and instruct the reader to a higher level of understanding themselves in a society whose high values are placed on achieving wealth, prominent status, and profitable personal relationships, extraneous to love or personal satisfaction. The theme of love is introduced in both novels from the very beginning, both leading us down paths in which identity and money play equally important roles. When Violet sets the parrot squawking, "I love you," free and when Selden's eyes become "refreshed" at the sight of "Miss Lily Bart," the reader does not yet know, but will soon learn to find out, that each relationship will lead to different paths of either self-destruction or self-fulfillment. "She was so evidently the victim of civilization which had produced her, that the links of her bracelet seemed like manacles chaining her to her fate," (Wharton, 5). For starters, the character of Lily in The House of Mirth is obviously the epitome of a lower-middle class woman, striving to gain status in upper-class elitist New York City society via marriage to a man who has already gained that status. She continues on the topic of Selden's cousin Gerty, "But we're so different, you know: she likes being good, and I like being happy. And besides, she is free and I am not" (Wharton, 6). From the very beginning, the reader knows he/she is dealing with a very narrow-minded, money driven woman who represents every stereotype of a woman as a being dependant on her husband for money and societal respect. When Selden asks, "Isn't marriage in your vocation? Isn't it what you're all brought up for?" the reader is not at all surprised by her reply, "...What...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Edith Wharton's House of Mirth and Toni Morrison's Jazz in Identity Formation of the Characters Through Dependence on Others for Money and Love

The House of Mirth by Edith Wharton

1325 words - 6 pages failure in a society that unquestioningly accepts the manipulations of its people. Edith Wharton creates Lily as a character that is unable to lower herself to society’s manipulations in The House of Mirth through her characteristics and flaws. Her mother’s teaching and her father’s role in her life make Lily believes that money was everything, and a husband only serves as an economic stability; therefore, love is not important. Lily’s inability to control her feeling for Selden and blackmail Bertha Dorset lead to her social descend at the end of the novel, and a death that she could not escape from.

The House of Mirth, by Edith Wharton

1412 words - 6 pages tragedy but there is always the cause and effect. Realism and its irony give the novels meaning and reasons for events that occurred to the characters. It does not have chaos, but order and imparts life as it is through the storyline. There is also this essence of the expression that everything in the novel happens for a reason. Realism in The House of Mirth by Edith Wharton revealed the fate of Lily Bart, her death. Irony showed the truth about her

The Contrasting Nature Of Love Explored In Toni Morrison's Beloved

1381 words - 6 pages Sethe. In page 322 Paul D remarks "(…) we got more yesterday than anybody. We need some kind of tomorrow." He conveys the meaning that their mutual past, what they have been through and their dealing with the past has brought them up to this moment and love has been allowed to grow between them. His desire for a tomorrow is based on his feelings towards her. At this point Paul D has stopped trying to block his emotions and allows himself to love

The Omniscient Narrator in Toni Morrison's Jazz

2347 words - 9 pages " identity, those clues, which are not easily discernible, become clear in the last section of the novel.  The voice of jazz becomes audible in the first paragraph:               Pain.  I seem to have an affection, a kind of sweettooth for it.  Bolts of lightning, little rivulets of thunder.  And I the eye of the storm.  Mourning the split trees, hens starving on rooftops.  Figuring out what can be done to save them since they cannot

Destructive Love in Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon

1766 words - 7 pages not for this very reason, this confusion, that suicide bombings and other acts of violence and devastation are committed…in the name of love? In Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon, the reader experiences this tenuity that is the line separating love and hate in many different forms and on many different levels—to the extent that the line between the two begins to blur and become indistinguishable. Seen through Ruth's incestuous love, Milkman and

Social Injustice for African Americans in Toni Morrison's Novel, Jazz

679 words - 3 pages Social Injustice for African Americans in Toni Morrison's Novel, Jazz Jazz, a novel by Toni Morrison, explores many different aspects of African American life in the early part of the twentieth century. This novel tells a story of the difficulties faced by black families living in the United States. Toni Morrison describes in detail a few of the upsetting situations they had to face. She also subtly throughout the book places one or two

Comparing Love in the Film, Secrets and Lies and Toni Morrison's Beloved

2171 words - 9 pages .  The film never does reveal Cynthia’s past, but it is evident that she was deprived of love or traumatized in some way.   She is so dependent on everyone, especially Roxanne and her brother Morris, because she has lost herself for whatever reason and survives only through the attention of others.  Without their love and support, she is filled with nothing but jealousy and loneliness.  Cynthia’s deprivation of love results in her loss of self

The House of Mirth

1734 words - 7 pages Lily Bart lived in the upper part of New York society. She loves nice things and extravagance. However, throughout the House of Mirth Lily plays a game. She wants to be virtuous, stay in the social circle, and have the money to keep up with the demands of her so called friends. She involves herself so much into the social life she loses all chance of gaining her riches virtuously or through true love. She misses her chances inevitably: from

The short story "The Word Love" has made this essay a comparison to the main characters mother and a average mother in the states.

1078 words - 4 pages whatever nurturing she had craved, but when disciplined was needed the mercy of a loving mother seemed to be lacking. Instead of a loved one rebuking and correcting a child who had disobeyed, a judge would come forth and dispence the sentence on the guilty. Culture, parenting, and the love between mother and daughter seem to collide when observing the mothering of the child, and retribution for wrongdoings.Motherly love is a driving force in the

Naturalism in The House of Mirth

1521 words - 6 pages and circumstance if one possesses a certain strength of will or a simple faith in human possibility.   Because of Wharton's slight deviation from naturalistic conventions, a literary debate exists among critics as to the validity of viewing The House of Mirth as a novel which embodies naturalism. Some arguments contend that naturalism does not play a vital role in the novel because of the fact that such a significant internal conflict

Lily's Choice in The House of Mirth

2514 words - 10 pages Lily's Choice in The House of Mirth         Near the beginning of The House of Mirth, Wharton establishes that Lily would not indeed have cared to marry a man who was merely rich: "she was secretly ashamed of her mothers crude passion for money" (38). Lily, like the affluent world she loves, has a strange relationship with money. She needs money to buy the type of life she has been raised to live, and her relative poverty makes her

Similar Essays

Edith Wharton's The House Of Mirth

1959 words - 8 pages Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth serves as a strict model of etiquette for high society in the Gilded Age. It teaches one the intricate art of keeping up appearances and assimilating into the fickle leisure class. At the same time, the novel’s underlying purpose is to subtly critique this social order. Lily Bart’s perpetual, although often reluctant quest for financial stability and mass approval is a

Subjectivity In Edith Wharton's The House Of Mirth

1869 words - 7 pages Subjectivity in Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth      Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth presents an interesting study of the social construction of subjectivity. The Victorian society which Wharton's characters inhabit is defined by a rigid structure of morals and manners in which one's identity is determined by apparent conformity with or transgression of social norms. What is conspicuous about this brand of social identification

Edith Wharton's The House Of Mirth As Satirical Commentary On Society

2123 words - 8 pages        Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth creates a subtle, ironic, and superbly crafted picture of the social operation of turn-of-the-century New York. In her harsh expression of community, she succeeds in portraying a world of calculation operating under the pretenses of politeness. The characters become competitors in the highly complex game of social positioning with an amorphous body of socially formed laws. Through her presentation of

A Lacanian Analysis Of Edith Wharton's "House Of Mirth"

3168 words - 13 pages Law and Desire in "The House of Mirth"In Edith Wharton's novel, The House of Mirth, the main protagonist, Lily Bart oscillates between dreams of marriage and equally strong desires for independence and freedom. Despite her training on the social codes of conduct and etiquette, which was ingrained into her daily existence by her mother, Lily exhibits frequent moments of recklessness that threaten her opportunities in the marriage market. Why does