Comparison Of Hamlet And Machiavellis The Prince Baruch College Eng 2150 Essat

1600 words - 7 pages

Joseph Escoto
Professor Swanton
ENG 2800
October 12, 2016
Hamlet: Machiavellian or Meager?
In examining Fortinbras’ claim at the end of the play where he said had Hamlet lived, that he would have made a good ruler, we will consider Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince as a guideline to how a ruler should act and present himself in nearly all situations such as his faith, leadership abilities and disguising one’s faults. Through this examination it will be found that under Machiavellian standards, Hamlet would not have made a good king because he lacks many of the qualities and traits deemed necessary to be a fit by Machiavelli. Machiavelli’s The Prince was essentially a hand book; in which he creates a guideline to how he would want the perfect fictional prince to act in many different aspects of life. For Hamlet, due to his inaction and other blunders, rather than becoming a strong Machiavellian leader, like Fortinbras, who claimed Hamlet would be a good king, Hamlet along with his step-father and mother are killed, which leads to Fortinbras taking over Denmark without resistance.
One of the biggest mistakes made by Hamlet and the biggest reason why he would not have made a good king despite Fortinbras’ claim is because of his indecision and constant internal struggle with both faith and unnecessary meticulous overthinking. Machiavelli believed that when making decisions it is better to act quickly rather than wait, this is the exact opposite of what Hamlet does as we is constantly plotting but never acting. In his guidelines to being a good prince Machiavelli states in regards to acting fast “Yet I am of the opinion that it is better to be rash than over-cautious, because Fortune is a woman and, if you wish to keep her down you must beat her and pound her” (188). In regards to Hamlets actions, or rather inaction, he constantly planned on killing Claudius, by first setting up the play to depict his fathers murder, then just over-internalizing, but not acting until it was too late as his mother had died and he was moments away from death too. To further prove the point of Hamlets indecisiveness and cautious approach rather than taking action, Machiavelli states that “But if times and circumstances change, he is ruined, because he does not change his course of action” (188). In addition, his belief in faith which according to Machiavelli “A prudent ruler… cannot and should not observe faith when such observance is to his disadvantage and the causes that made him gives his promised have vanished” (182). Hamlet lets his belief in faith keep him from avenging is father by not killing Claudius when he sees him praying because to Hamlet “Now might I do it pat, now he is praying and I’ll do’t: and he goes to heaven. A villain kills my father; and for that, I, his sole son, do this same villain send to heaven” (3.3.74-9).
Another trait in which Machiavelli writes about is generosity. He states “Commencing then with the first of the characteristics...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Hamlet and Machiavellis the Prince - Baruch College Eng 2150 - Essat

Hamlet: The Irrational Prince Essay

1285 words - 5 pages the loss of his father and if he is just simply acting mad, could that be to confuse his enemies? And hide is intensions? One thing is for certain and that is Hamlet cannot act on his words. He is excellent at expressing himself verbally either to others or to himself but cannot act on them which makes us wonder, is the Prince of Denmark a coward? There are many times Hamlet was able to execute his vengeance for his father. In Act 3 Scene 3

Comparison of Oedipus and Hamlet Essay

1368 words - 5 pages his actions?" Disgruntled Reader (1999) offered these comparison-contrast questions: ? How can the ending of the two plays be considered positive ones? ? To what degrees are Oedipus and Hamlet victims of fate? Of hamarita (fatal character flaw)?

The Genius of Hamlet, the Very Sane Prince of Denmark

2537 words - 10 pages The Genius of Hamlet, the Very Sane Prince of Denmark Hamlet in Shakepeare's The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark is often seen as a lunatic. Lucid and ingenious, Prince Hamlet falls into a state of emotional turmoil, but he is never insane. Hamlet feigns madness to reveal his anguish concerning the two women he used to love - his mother Gertrude and his lover Ophelia. To escape estrangement from his countrymen, Hamlet

Contrast and comparison of Hamlet

955 words - 4 pages Dr. Wu1) Would you hire Dr. Wu? Provide several reasons for your answer.Making this decision is pretty touch considering that Nathaniel Wu has all the qualities for this job and can really help establish the company. The one thing that really makes things hard is the disease he has been diagnosed with. Since we don't know what the certain age a person can actually see the effects, I would consider hiring him and signing a deal of just a few year

Timeless Aspects of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and Trifles

2012 words - 8 pages Timeless Aspects of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and Trifles William Shakespeare is considered the greatest playwright, if not the greatest writer in the history of literature. His criticisms of society in his works have passed the “test of time,” and still are as significant today as they were when they were first written. There are many similarities in Hamlet, Prince of Denmark by William Shakespeare, and Trifles by Susan Glaspell

Aspects of Life in Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and Trifles

2400 words - 10 pages Aspects of Life in Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and Trifles In William Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, the protagonist, Hamlet, has arrived “from his university studies to find Claudius, his uncle, ruling Denmark and married to his mother, Gertrude. Her remarriage within two months of his father’s death has left Hamlet disillusioned, confused, and suspicious about Claudius” (DiYanni 1394). These types of crimes do not only

The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark by William Shakespeare

1200 words - 5 pages is introduced Hamlet, he is clothed in all black—portrayed as a morose, dejected prince. The audience’s initial impression of Hamlet sets the attitude for the entire play. Even without Shakespeare delivering an intricate sketch of Hamlet's features, readers can visualize his pallid face, disheveled hair, and severe, ominous eyes. Clothed completely in black, Hamlet exhibits all the forms, moods and shapes of distress. Throughout the progression


1608 words - 6 pages 3. Reality and appearances, or if you prefer, being and acting, are important themes for both Machiavelli and Shakespeare. Why? How do their perspectives on this subject agree or differ?APPEARANCE vs. REALITY IN "THE PRINCE" AND "HAMLET"One of the most fundamental questions in philosophy is the appearance vs. reality. We find ourselves asking the question of what is genuinely "real," and what is viewed merely as just an "appearance," and not

Hamlet Video Comparison. This review compares the Branagh and Jacobi versions of Hamlet

852 words - 3 pages Hamlet Video Comparison Essay"To be or not to be, that is the question" (3,1,56) that the different directors must ask themselves when choosing the design of their play. The tragic play, Hamlet by William Shakespeare, has had many interpretations from the single script. Directors Derek Jacobi and Franco Zeffirelli have both directed the same play, Hamlet, yet the differences in the renditions of the play emphasize different aspects. In the

The Promise of Mediation, written by Baruch Bush and Joe Folger

1331 words - 5 pages The book The Promise of Mediation, written by Baruch Bush and Joe Folger, outlines two different approaches to mediation: problem-solving and transformative. A problem-solving mediator uses a highly controlled process that directs the “substance of the discussion” (Burgess, 1997). Problem-solving mediators highlight the areas that the parties agree on, while avoid areas of disagreement. This approach means that problem-solving mediators play a

A comparison of Hamlet and Claudius

1025 words - 4 pages things such as madness, suicide and depression. This is the case in Hamlet. A comparison of the love relationship between Ophelia and Hamlet and Gertrude and Claudius, will illustrate that betrayal, selfishness and lack of love cause the downfall of these relationships.There are many examples of betrayal in the play Hamlet. In these examples betrayal leads to the destruction of relationships. Claudius is the king of Denmark and he will do

Similar Essays

A Character Comparison Of Ophelia In Hamlet, Gerturde, And The Prince Of Denmark

1869 words - 8 pages essay will analyse how the figure of Ophelia evolves in Shakespeare's Hamlet, in John Updike’s Gertrude and Claudius and in Graham Holderness’s The Prince of Denmark. In particular, it will examine how these texts convey some of the main differences regarding her character, always connected to a deep symbolism: her physical description, her personality and her madness and death. First of all, in these three masterpieces, Ophelia's physical

The Life And Death Of Prince Hamlet

1233 words - 5 pages The Life and Death of Prince Hamlet Plagued by the philosophical aspects of life and death, Prince Hamlet repeatedly failed to act upon avenging his father's wrongful murder. Though he knew what he must do, Hamlet's inaction is caused by his constantly changing persona and theories on the inevitability of death and the afterlife. Hamlet's attitude towards death changes from fearing death and the afterlife to accepting it as inevitable

The Language Of The Flowers And Hamlet: Prince Of Denmark

944 words - 4 pages occurring without really stating “this is what is going on.” These bouquets have a variety of ways of being translated. This may be the only translation that we have of these flowers, but they can be read in different ways. I have included all to show the possible entire meaning of these small passages from Hamlet, Prince of Denmark. It is up to the reader to interpret the flowers as they will and perhaps one day there will be a true translation

Hamlet Prince Of Denmark Essay

2220 words - 9 pages . The goals of a Marxist literary critic include assessing the social tendencies of the literary work, and comparing them to the social tendencies of today, and the specific time period in which it was written. The analyst must also recognize to what social class the author belongs and how that might affect the portrayals of certain characters. When analyzing Shakespeare’s most notable play Hamlet Prince of Denmark, the reader will being to