This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison Of Ophelia In Mel Gibson And Brannagh's Film Depiction Of Hamlet

761 words - 3 pages

When given the challenge to depict a character of one of the most studied literary works of all time, one faces a difficult task. Kate Winslet and Helena Bonham Carter are given such tasks in William Shakespeare's Hamlet. They each portray Ophelia in Brangah's Hamlet and Zeffirelli's Hamlet, respectively. The character of Ophelia, as written in Shakespeare's original work, is a kind girl who is quick to obey her father and brother. As the play goes on, she falls into madness because of her father's death and her failure to cope. Because of her madness, she ends it all by drowning herself in a river. Winslet and Carter each depict the character of Ophelia differently. Two scenes that illustrate such differences in Hamlet are shown when Ophelia is talking to her father and when she finally tumbles into insanity.As Polonius is talking to his daughter, Ophelia, he pushes her and speaks with a horribly frightening voice in Branagh's Hamlet. Fear is easily found in the eyes of Winslet as her father pushes her around with forceful hands. Despite her father's lecture on staying away from Hamlet, she continues throughout the conversation to have flashbacks of her and Hamlet making love. Kate plays her character faintly weaker here as she seems terrified at what her father might do next. The flashbacks hint that the single thing that can calm her is remembering her times with Hamlet.Helena plays the character a little bit stronger than Kate. When Polonius is talking to her she seems to reject what they are saying. Nonetheless, she still listens. However, it seems like she is just agreeing to be obedient, but not at all honest. In the scene she does not seem afraid, as with Kate, but more open to her father's concerns and wishes. Confusion is found in her eyes as she copes with her father's harsh opinion of Hamlet and how she must stay away from him. Both scenes end the same with each Ophelia agreeing to obey Polonius' wish.Kate's Ophelia is first shown in her madness when she starts singing in the presence of the King and Queen. She is wearing a straight jacket, unlike Helena, and is dancing all over the place. At one point, she ends up on the ground and...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Ophelia in Mel Gibson and Brannagh's film depiction of Hamlet

A Comparison of Two Film Adaptations of Hamlet

1021 words - 4 pages " engraved in stone, which adds to the foreboding feel the music has already given the film. The first scene gives a little comic relief when the guards become confused after seeing the ghost. When the camera enters the looming castle a celebration is being had and is abruptly interrupted by the mysterious Hamlet. The real life of the play starts to be seen upon Hamlet's entrance; Hamlet's costume and character are very bold and start to add to the

Contrast of Hamlet – Gibson and Branagh

558 words - 2 pages An example of two different movies that have the same title, contain a scene that is essentially getting the same message across, but differ so much in the depiction of two scenes, would be hamlet. In 1990, Mel Gibson and Paul Scofield played the role of prince hamlet, and the ghost of king hamlet. 6 years later, in 1996, another version of hamlet was released, starring Kenneth Branagh as prince hamlet, and Brian Blessed as the Ghost of hamlet

Essay on the Manipulation of Polonius and Ophelia in Hamlet

1009 words - 4 pages The Manipulation of Polonius and Ophelia in Hamlet        The main plot of Shakespeare's Hamlet centers around Prince Hamlet's desire to repay King Claudius for his evil deeds. Around this central action revolve the stories concerning the minor characters of Polonius and Ophelia. Though they do not motivate Hamlet's actions towards the King, these characters act as forces upon Hamlet himself, trying to spur him to do things he does not

Character Analysis of Ophelia and Gertude in Shakespeare´s Hamlet

1347 words - 5 pages become very well known. One of William Shakespeare's most famous plays is, Hamlet. In Hamlet, the women, Ophelia and Gertrude were portrayed as property, non- controlling, inferior, and solely dependent on men throughout the play. Ophelia is an obedient daughter who is dependent on her father, Polonius for guidance. Ophelia and Hamlet were deeply in love, until his mother, Gertrude married his uncle, Claudius, the day of his father's funeral. After

Gaden of Ophelia: Hamlet

2251 words - 10 pages song: “Quoth she, "Before you tumbled me, you promis'd me to wed”. Hamlet then replies, "So would I ha'done, by yonder sun, an thou hadst not come to my bed" (Shakespeare). From her songs to her conversations it hold her words true, that Ophelia has, indeed, committed the act of abortion. Although it appears to be just a weed, the meaning of rue, holds it value to the fullest, and Ophelia does a magnificent job in covering up her open confession

The Character of Ophelia in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1197 words - 5 pages The Character of Ophelia in Hamlet      In Shakespeare's play, Hamlet, the character Ophelia plays an important role in the elaboration of the plot.  In the beginning, she is in a healthy state of mind, in love with Hamlet, yet controlled by her father.  During the play she has several troubling experiences involving Hamlet - causing her to become distressed.  The death of Ophelia's father leaves her mentally unstable and in a state of

Depiction Of A Tragic Hero In Hamlet

1786 words - 7 pages heroes. Hamlet suffers dramatically from his inability to decide what is wrong and what is right. Ophelia is in anguish over the death of her father, and the loss of affections by the man she loved deeply. Claudius suffers unbelievably from greed, while Gertrude is a woman who suffers from greed of title. All in all, the depiction the ?tragic hero? in Hamlet is one of many layers. It shows that the tragic hero is one who overcomes conflicts that

The Tragic Tale of Ophelia and Hamlet

1409 words - 6 pages . For Hamlet, his bond with Ophelia pales in comparison to the weight of the les talionis obligation thrust upon his soul. Ophelia faces trouble of a different nature. Having been raised to be very obedient to her father and to let him think for her, she is coerced into pushing Hamlet away and not giving into her love. It is the very lack of communication of these personal dilemmas between Ophelia and Hamlet that ultimately leads to Ophelia’s

Hamlet´s Treatment of Ophelia and Gertrude

2087 words - 8 pages . Gertrude is viewed as an incenstous person to Hamlet since he tells her God will judge her based upon her acts of incest and murder. Gertrude's involvement with the murder of King Hamlet has cost her the mother-son connection with Hamlet which leads to him having an unstable relationship with Gertrude. Hamlet discovers elements of false love in Ophelia as he relates her flaws with Gertrudes'. Ophelia is part of a plan to set up Hamlet which will

The Romance of Hamlet and Ophelia

874 words - 4 pages The most wonderful and intriguing topic for discussion is one of Shakespeare’s play has to be the relationship of Hamlet and Ophelia. Some people have doubted the love that is there, while others believed that there was love. Today in our current generation we still read and analyze this bond that they have. Everyone at least has experienced love in some kind of way to know how love should and should not feel, and even how love looks. So how

Depiction of Latinos in 20th Century Film

2534 words - 10 pages Depiction of Latinos in 20th Century Film Graphs Not Included Over the course of this past century, the depictions of assimilated Latino characters has improved a great deal. Early portrayals of Latino assimilation generally proved to be a montage of unrealistic caricatures which seemed to convey the filmmaker's creativity more so than true representations. This formed the manner in which the American people at large viewed not just

Similar Essays

Hamlet And Ophelia Comparison Essay

672 words - 3 pages about writing and acting, andeven goes so far as to put a little vignette in the play of Hecuba, andtells the actors how to do their job. Is Hamlet an actor telling otheractors how to act, or is he a crazy fool presuming too much?Whilst Hamlet is off trying to make the world think he is crazy, Opheliahas a real breakdown of her own. Ophelia goes mad for two reasonsmostly- she is forced to deny Hamlet her affection (and he thereforedenies her), and

Mel Gibson Vs. Kenneth Branaugh As Hamlet

1041 words - 4 pages Mel Gibson vs. Kenneth Branaugh as HamletFirst in an installment looking at the modern film versions of Shakespeare's playsby Lynn Davison Jr., Contributing WriterThe recent "box office rebirth" of England's favorite bard has left Hollywood with much to do about interpreting Shakespeare's classic dramas. The characters of Ophelia, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, the gravedigger, and of course Hamlet himself take new life, as the greatest actors of

Hamlet: Mel Gibson Vs Kenneth Branagh

1388 words - 6 pages enters the castle clearly insane, she sings about the pain she is facing “How should I your true love know from another one? By his cockle hat and staff, and his sandal shoon” (4.5. 22-25). This scene was crucial to Ophelia character because it foreshadows her madness over her love with Prince Hamlet. Although the film version of Hamlet played by Mel Gibson was not perfect in many ways, the role of Ophelia played was most convincing portrayals of

A Character Comparison Of Ophelia In Hamlet, Gerturde, And The Prince Of Denmark

1869 words - 8 pages essay will analyse how the figure of Ophelia evolves in Shakespeare's Hamlet, in John Updike’s Gertrude and Claudius and in Graham Holderness’s The Prince of Denmark. In particular, it will examine how these texts convey some of the main differences regarding her character, always connected to a deep symbolism: her physical description, her personality and her madness and death. First of all, in these three masterpieces, Ophelia's physical