Comparison Of Main Character's Isolation In Jamaica Kincaid's "Girl" And Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill"

567 words - 2 pages

In Jamaica Kincaid's "Girl" and Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill", the protagonists experience different yet similar degrees of isolation. In "Girl", the isolation is subtle while in "Miss Brill" the isolated status of the character is extremely obvious. Both types of isolation involve the character's social life/role and stem from those around them; Miss Brill becomes isolated and excluded from surrounding strangers in the park, while a young girl's mother ignores her. With "Girl", Kincaid presents the reader with a long list of social instructions and warnings from a mother to her daughter. The advice involves everything from the very traditional, such as how to sew on a button, to the dark, unspoken aspects such as how to "throw away a child before it even becomes a child" (440). All of the advice pertains to social roles and duties of women. The protagonist, whose name is never given, presents the reader with small clues that she questions her mother's teachings. She only makes the attempt to question her mother twice: "but I don't sing benna on Sundays at all and never in Sunday school" (440) and "but what if the baker won't let me feel the bread" (441) give indications into the young girl's mindset. She seems to somewhat disagree with her overbearing mother but not enough to pursue any type of argument and seems to be rather disconnected from her mother's long tirade. Giving the indication of isolation is her mother's response to her weak protests. She barely notices her daughter's comments, showing virtually no reaction, except to refute her latter...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Main Character's Isolation in Jamaica Kincaid's "Girl" and Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill"

Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill Essay

877 words - 4 pages Illusion vs. Reality in Miss Brill "Miss Brill" by Katherine Mansfield is set the Jardins Publiques in France. Every Sunday Miss Brill looks forward to getting dressed up and visiting the park, where she enjoys people watching. Her weekly visits to the park are undoubtedly the highlight of her week, bringing her great joy and satisfaction. There are many illusions in this story, in this essay I intend to show three different illusions Miss

Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill Essay

612 words - 2 pages Miss Brill is a story about an old woman that lacks companionship and self-awareness. She lives by herself and goes through life in a repetitive manner. Each Sunday, Miss Brill ventures down to the park to watch and listen to the band play. She finds herself listening not only to the band, but also to strangers who walk together and converse before her. Her interest in the lives of those around her shows the reader that Miss Brill lacks

Self Realization in Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill

904 words - 4 pages In the short story entitled "Miss Brill," written by Katherine Mansfield, the reader spends a routine Sunday with Miss Brill, whose character is revealed through her thoughts about others as she observes a crowd of strangers and soaks up the atmosphere while sitting at a bench in the park. Miss Brill seems to enjoy her routine of sitting in the park and listening to the band play, but most of all she savors the ability to eavesdrop into other

Review and Character Analysis of Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill

1041 words - 4 pages reminisce about her younger days. On one Sunday afternoon, while Miss Brill was sitting in her usual spot in the park, a boy and a girl sat down at the other end of the bench: "They were beautifully dressed; they were in love. The hero and Heroin, of course, just arrived from his father's yacht" (273). Miss Brill immediately began to judge the young couple as they sat on the bench, as well as work them into her fantasy play in the park. When

The Aging Process in Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill

600 words - 2 pages Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill" perfectly captures the phases one's mind goes through when faced with becoming old. Elderly people tend to be nostalgic, even sentimental about their youth. In later years, the nostalgia can develop into senility or fantasy. The ermine fur in "Miss Brill" is the catalyst of her nostalgia and symbolizes the passing of time in three stages: an expectant youth, a vital adulthood, and finally, a development into

The Insignificant Soul in Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill

924 words - 4 pages something. “But why? Because of that stupid old thing at the end there?’ asked the boy. ‘Why does she come her at all—who wants her? Why doesn’t she keep her silly old mug at home?” All this time, Miss Brill had accepted the idea that she was adopted in this small community at the park and important. But her fateful ear had betrayed her. The comments of the boy and girl weren’t about each other. They had included the old woman, Miss Brill into their

The Characterization of Miss Brill in Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield

836 words - 3 pages as many others. The short story "Miss Brill" by Katherine Mansfield is no exception to this and displays the main character of Miss Brill as the protagonist, who is confronted with the reality of her existence. In order to bring us closer to Miss Brill, Mansfield uses the technique of showing, by which she lets the reader infer what sort of character Miss Brill is simply by the descriptions and dialogue of the environment around her. This is

Point of View in Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield

823 words - 3 pages The point of view that Katherine Mansfield has chosen to use in "Miss Brill" serves two purposes. First, it illustrates how Miss Brill herself views the world and, second, it helps the reader take the same journey of burgeoning awareness as Miss Brill. The story is written in a third person omniscient (although limited) point of view. Miss Brill also interprets the world around her in a similar fashion. She is her own narrator, watching

"Miss Brill" by Katherine Mansfield

523 words - 2 pages Miss Brill: Point of View and SettingThe story "Miss Brill" by Katherine Mansfield is told to us in the third person; by someone watching. We are given a poetic description of a beautiful afternoon at the park. We can see and also feel the crispness in the air. Our narrator also allows us to see into Miss Brill's perceptions, thoughts, feelings, and into her world as a whole. We see the world through her eyes. We feel her emotions.This beautiful

Short creative essay on Katherine Mansfield's short story, Bliss. The main character's hysteric happiness with life is questioned when it is revealed that her husband has a lover.

513 words - 2 pages Bliss by Katherine MansfieldDo all female writers write in this tone? Their short stories, rather. The woman, mostly alone with her thoughts and deeds eventually comes to the realization that every preconceived notion she had about her life is in direct conflict with the truth and everything she held dear is worthless? Okay, so it's probably unfair to assume all women writers do this based on one short story, especially one from the age where

Narrative Women in Context in Jamaica Kincaid's The Autobiography of My Mother and Virginia Woolf's The Voyage Out.

2643 words - 11 pages Narrative Women in Context in Jamaica Kincaid's The Autobiography of My Mother and Virginia Woolf's The Voyage Out.         When looking at literature as a symbolic representation of life, the absence of a mother figure within the narrative may have a direct correlation with the portrayal of society as strictly patriarchal. In Jamaica Kincaid's The Autobiography of My Mother, the loss of Xuela's mother and alienation from her father is

Similar Essays

Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill Essay

1139 words - 5 pages reality from her routine events. In the short story, "Miss Brill," Katherine Mansfield effectively uses various literary techniques to characterize Miss Brill's complex and interesting character. Mansfield illustrates Miss Brill as an elderly woman in denial from old age and her lack of human interactions. Through the effective use of diction, imagery, and symbolism, Mansfield expresses qualities of Miss Brill as lonely, critical, and fragile

Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill" Essay

1194 words - 5 pages referred to as characterization. Four of the most easily recognized literary techniques used in Mansfield's "Miss Brill" are her use of symbolism, setting, allusion, and points of view used by different characters in her story.Symbolism plays a very large part in understanding Miss Brill the character. This can easily be seen by the relationship between Miss Brill and her "alter-ego", the fur. A symbol is "a person, object or event that suggests more

Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill Essay 793 Words

793 words - 3 pages "Miss Brill" The Third Person-Point of View as used by Katherine Mansfield in “Miss Brill” Katherine Mansfield’s use of the third person, limited omniscient point of view in “Miss Brill” has the effect of letting the reader see the contrast between Miss Brill’s idea of her role in life and the reality of the small part she truly plays in world around her. In one short Sunday afternoon, the main character’s view of herself changes

Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill Essay 1211 Words

1211 words - 5 pages As humans, much of our lives are based around social interaction. We are taught to live through various means of socialization from the time of our birth . Without this socialization and interaction among each other we can become very disillusioned and confused about how to function as a part of society. One would tend to isolate ourselves, exiled in this place we call the world. In Katherine Mansfield’s short story “Miss Brill,” one such person