Comparison Of "Thistles" By Ted Hughes And "Mountain Lion" By D.H Lawrence

1446 words - 6 pages

Q: Poets are often concerned with the connections between man and the natural world. Choose two poems and explain how the poets' attitudes are conveyed through the choice of language."Thistles" effectively shows how Ted Hughes is able to use an extended and sustained metaphor of a negative facet of nature in order to portray the destructive, repetitious nature of man. The choice of subject for this metaphor, representing mans' brutality is also successful in showing how man is linked to, and a part of, nature. The tone of "Thistles" is more reflective and a statement of 'what is', "Mountain Lion", by D.H Lawrence, however, has a distinctive negative mood as the poet shows the link of man to nature as domineering and destructive to the latter party. Although the simplistic and often negative diction of "Mountain lion" plays an effective part in conveying the theme of the piece, in contrast to "Thistles" the language of this poem is not the main technique used it is rather the events of the poem that more deliberately and clearly convey the poet, D.H. Lawrence's views on mans' connections to the natural world.The first stanza of "Thistles" is devoted to the introduction of the main metaphorical subject of the poem, conveying the "thistle's" setting in the present, and thus not immediately portraying their representation of mankind; this deduction is caused by the contrast of the "summer air" in this first stanza compared to the winter of the second. Although the link between nature and man is not evident here the poet already grants the "thistles" similar attributes to the violence of men - the "blue black pressure" can be analogous to a corpse; possibly a foreshadowing effect for the connection that is made between the "thistles" and the "Vikings" who represent the widespread violence of man. In contrast to this Lawrence uses only the first three lines of his piece in order to introduce the crisp setting of "Mountain Lion" - the "January snow", "dark" "spruce trees", "blue" "balsam" and "still unfrozen" "water sounds." Lawrence's description is effective in evoking the tranquillity of the setting, obviously meant to indicate nature's harmony with existence before the arrival of men. In order to fully understand the reason behind this largely positive introductory stanza the second and third stanza must be taken into account as here it is evident that the first three stanzas define each other. Lawrence immediately introduces the main theme of his poem in this second stanza as he clearly states "Men! The only animal in the world to fear!" with the further statement "They have a gun. We have no gun;" the far more basic syntax of repeated exclamation marks as well as the shortened sentence structure is further effective in conveying this view. This clearly depicts to the reader Lawrence's negative view of the aggression of man; the contrast between the second two blatant stanza's and the first stanza's more delicate evocation of the mood and feel of...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of "Thistles" by Ted Hughes and "Mountain Lion" by D.H Lawrence

"Thistles" by Ted Hughs Essay

988 words - 4 pages In the poem "Thistles" by Ted Hughes there are a number of different themes and ideas that are put across. George Macbeth, the acclaimed literary critic, has made some very powerful and in-depth comments about the poem. He states that the poem is"praise to the unkillable virtue of heroism" I personally am not sure whether to disagree or agree with this analogy. However I do agree with later comments about Hughes "presenting this quality through

Review of Snake by D.H. Lawrence

2342 words - 9 pages Review of Snake by D.H. Lawrence Vocabualry: *Carob-tree: a red flowered tree originally in the Mediterranean area. * pitcher : tall, round container with an open top and large handle. * flickered: moved * mused : think about * bowel: bottom of earth * perversity: offensive * log: tree trunk * clatter: v. loud sound of hard things hitting * convulsed : violent movement * writhed

Analysis of "the piano" by D.H. Lawrence

702 words - 3 pages Analysis of "Piano"The speaker in "Piano" by D. H. Lawrence is proud to be a full grown man, yet he loves remembering his happy childhood; his nostalgic attitude causes him to feel guilty as if he had betrayed his present state of being. Through effective imagery, Lawrence is able (to describe an image) to help the reader understand the speaker's nostalgic attitude. The diction and tone used in this poem reveal the speaker's struggle as his

The Jaguar By Ted Hughes

790 words - 3 pages This poem 'The Jaguar' was written by Ted Hughes, he tries to capture the mood of a post war, 1950's zoo. He depicts the animals as hot, lazy and lethargic. This is because they have been captive for a long stretch of time. The animals are not lively but are dull and lifeless. He uses the expression 'stinks of sleepers from the breathing straw' to show this. He then unveils the jaguar as being live and vivid. 'At a jaguar hurrying enraged.' 'The

Explication of an excerpt from Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence - College Eglish - Explication Essay

787 words - 4 pages 1 Williams Taylor Williams Roy Cartlidge, prof. Twentieth-Century Novel Monday October 16 Explication of an excerpt from Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence Sons and Lovers, a twentieth-century novel by D.H. Lawrence is a novel which explores the theme of Oedipus complex. This excerpt take place in part two of the novel just after Baxter Dawes' court case with Thomas Jordan, who he had pushed down a flight of stairs during a drunken attempt at

Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence -- Brief analysis of family relationships

516 words - 2 pages When William leaves the house to take a high-paying job in London, he is excited, but Mrs. Morel is grief-stricken over his parting. Being his mother, she should be proud of him, but she is not. Rather, she fears losing him and holds even more tightly onto her other son, Paul. This shows her inability to mother her sons correctly beyond their childhood. Instead of showing her love for William by letting him go proudly, she shows her insecurity

"The Rocking Horse Winner" by D.H,Lawrence

585 words - 2 pages Summary: An analysis on D.H. Lawrence's "Rocking Horse Winner." Specifically, discusses how through the characterization, symbolism, and language of the short story, Lawrence successfully creates a materialistic image.________________________________________I. Written in 1933, D.H. Lawrence's short story "The Rocking Horse Winner" illustrates the consumptive nature of materialism. Through the use of characterization and symbolism, the author

The Rocking Horse Winner by D.H. Lawrence

1130 words - 5 pages The Rocking Horse Winner by D.H. Lawrence Written in 1933, D.H. Lawrence's short story "The Rocking Horse Winner" illustrates the consumptive nature of materialism. Through author's use of characterization, symbolism, and language in The Rocking Horse Winner, Lawrence successfully portrays a greedy and cold hearted mother, Hester, who attempts to fulfill the dissatisfaction in her life using wealth and material comfort. Lawrence uses

False Picture of Marriage in The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence

1207 words - 5 pages impression of the other. Modern literature demonstrates that a marriage built upon illusion will falter when exposed to reality. In order to understand the effects of illusion on marriages in modern literature, we will explore two pieces: The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence. Both stories have central characters who have created, and lived with, a false picture of their spouse and their marriage. Firstly, I will

The Blind Man by D.H. Lawrence

884 words - 4 pages The Blind Man – And the Blind Shall "see" The story "The Blind Man" by D.H. Lawrence can be read at many levels.  On the surface, the story is about the struggles of Maurice Pervin as he learns to cope with the loss of his sight. On a much deeper level, it can be seen that Maurice is closed in by his blindness and it is through another man's weakness that he begins to “see” again. To understand the meaning of "The Blind Man", one must

Exposition To The Lottery By D.H. Lawrence

592 words - 2 pages Churchill in southern California in 2434 A.D. or year two hundred fifty nine of survival. It was left almost unaffected by the radiation, but rain poisoned the land and the cities were all blown down by very strong winds. Some people died in the buildings, some were lifted up 300 meters and then they fell down. Some basements and bomb shelter, where people were hiding were covered by meters of the cement and steel, but some survived.There were only

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast 'thistles' By Ted Hughes And 'tall Nettles' By Edward Thomas Cambridge English Literature Coursework

810 words - 3 pages of the poem to the reader.In the two poems "Tall Nettles" by Edward Thomas and "Thistles" by Ted Hughes, the poets show views on the struggle between nature and mankind from different perspectives. While Edward Thomas portrays this as a gentle yet slowly overpowering process, Hughes conveys his ideas on a more violent and fierce note, therefore there is a large contrast between their poems. Both poets do this through the structure of the poem in some way or another, enforcing their unique thoughts on nature's ways and conveying to the reader such thoughts.

Critical Appreciation Of Ted Hughes' "Thistles" And His Intentions On Writing The Poem

710 words - 3 pages Ted Hughes is a renowned, restrained poet for his ability to be intricate, and his concealment of emotion in insignificant forms of life. In the poem, Thistles, Hughes personalizes Thistles; such trivial plant, to successfully evoke the lives of human beings, while emphasizing nature's dominance over men. The poem also deals with the idea of history being repeated in a cycle, the dead being "resurrected". Such complex ideas are effectively

The Power Of Nature In Ted Hughes´ Poems Wind And Thistles

657 words - 3 pages Both Ted Hughes' poems, Wind and Thistles, show a theme of the power of nature. In Wind, Hughes shows the effects that a violent storm has upon a house and the landscape around it. In contrast, in Thistles Hughes presents a poem about people who are constantly oppressed by their enemy and, like the thistle, never give up. While both poems are about different things, they both explore the power that nature possesses. However, in Wind, Hughes

Comparison And Contrast "You Touched Me" D.H. Lawrence And "The Boarding House" From James Joyce

1153 words - 5 pages gradually alters, most people comply with it either for self mentality pursuit or public reputation. In the early twentieth century, public took the ethicality and morality very seriously, and this arose contradictions with human's free will and instinct for self benefit. "You Touched Me" from D.H. Lawrence and "The Boarding House" from James Joyce each tells a story that ends with one controversial marriage in the conservative Europe. By comparing