This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison Of Two Pieces Of Media

2556 words - 10 pages

Comparison of Two Pieces of Media


Dr Harold Shipman, a previously trusted family doctor, was found
guilty of murdering 15 of his patients, in February 2000. 'The
Guardian' newspaper and the 'Panorama' television show both made
in-depth reports of these atrocities. Both contained the same
information and had the same purpose, but they are presented in
completely different ways, and are intended for different audiences.

In this essay I am going to compare the different presentational
devices used and describe their effectiveness.

Paragraph 1

The two different reports on Dr Harold Shipman contain roughly the
same information, but they have presented the information that would
apply to their target audience. They have also gone into more detail
about parts of the case that they feel are important. The way that
their reports were presented depended on the type of media they used.
The newspaper, because it had limited space, had to make their report
short and to the point, only including the most important information.

The 'Panorama' documentary included interviews with the families of
the victims, friends of Shipman and even a patient who escaped his
wrath. The newspaper contained a few interviews, but because it was
written, it couldn't have the same effect as the interviews in the
documentary. The interviews in 'Panorama' were much more convincing
than the ones in the newspaper. The interviews take up less space in a
television show than in a newspaper, so most of the time, the
newspaper will only include the most important parts of the interview,
or maybe even sometimes miss out parts of the interview to influence
the readers mind.

Harold Shipman's final victim was Cathleen Grundy. Shipman killed her,
the forged her will, and inherited her £386,000 estate. 'The Guardian'
writes only a small sentence on this case:

"…and forging the £386,000

will of his final victim."

Yet the documentary had a whole piece on the Cathleen Grundy case. It
shows a re-construction of the murder, it shows the £386,000 estate
that was in her will, and it also shows interviews with Cathleen
Grundy's family. This is significant because this case was the one
that finally brought Shipman to justice.

'Panorama' was a special show, broadcasted after the watershed (9pm).
This means that the show was deemed unsuitable for younger viewers. I
agree with the makers of the show, the things that Shipman did were
horrifying, and not for the ears or eyes of children. The grotesque
details that were in the documentary were left out of the newspaper
report, this is because they can't control who reads their newspaper.
They can't go into too much detail as the information may offend some

The content of the newspaper article is mainly about Harold Shipman's

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Two Pieces of Media

Analyzing Two Pieces of Work About Homelessness

2633 words - 11 pages Analyzing Two Pieces of Work About Homelessness I am writing an assignment which is on media. The two sources I have been given to analyse is a leaflet from ' The Salvation Army' and a newspaper article from ' The Guardian.' Both are based on the subject of homelessness. The problem of homelessness is a very unsettled issue. It is evident in many countries but in the UK it is concentrated in London. The two items are

Comparison of two paintings Essay

609 words - 2 pages lines and angles of perspective meet at one point. Aerial perspective I used in Golconda. There is a disillusion of distance and space. Smaller images and mistier colors are used to introduce the sense of depth in space.To sum up, eventhough there are lots of differences in these two paintings by two different backgrounds of artists at two different periods, they both give a very conceptual drawing to the viewers to interpret what makes the drawings excellent pieces.

Comparison of two paintings

830 words - 3 pages Comparison of two paintings Paintings have been used to represent people since the beginning of the human race. Through time due to advancements in material and painting techniques combined with the ever-increasing talent of the artists, paintings representing people have become very lifelike and are extremely realistic. Some painted portraits have as much detail as modern photographs. However, there are also paintings of people that

Comparison of two Religions

978 words - 4 pages Comparison of two Religions Religion has been a practice of many cultures from the beginning of time. Research two different religions, and determine what the origins of the religions are. Find out what is similar, and what is different about the two religions, that you choose. Analyze the two different religions and discuss. Origin of Hinduism The origin of Hinduism is a mystery, because there is no founder for this religion. This religion

Comparison of Two Authors

1139 words - 5 pages confinement that alienates Eveline from the outside world becomes the one of the main focus of the story; rather than being confined in her room, Eveline is confined in her life. She is alienated from the outside world because of the events in her life. She goes to work every day “to keep the house together and to see that the two young children … got their meals regularly” (Joyce 380) – that is her main focus. She goes to her work and returns home; she

SOAPSTONE pieces of me

1653 words - 7 pages Character: The main character in Pieces of Me is Maddie. Maddie is a teenager who ran away from home, because she didn’t get along very well with her mom’s boyfriend. Maddie is a confident, independent girl. She got around by herself and didn’t interact with others very much. After a few months of living on her own she met a guy named Q. Her and Q got along very well, but at first she wasn’t very open with him. The farther the book went on

Pieces Of Hell

846 words - 4 pages Pieces of hell I never imagine the hell can send to us some pieces in our world, I was thinking of if I go to the hell I will see everything there, but not in our world. The destiny decided to show me a piece from hell when I was young, when I decided to build a family. Like any simple man in this world dream of getting a nice and quiet family, I was a rich man, and I had my own flat in the family’s building, also I had one factory and 2 shops

A Comparison of Two Newspapers

1300 words - 5 pages A Comparison of Two Newspapers When we first look at these two newspapers, the first thing that comes to our attention is the different differences of the front pages of the two. “The times” has a more sophisticated feel to it, while the “Daily Mirror” seems trendier with its pictures and stylish typeface. While both papers share the same headline (about David Blunkett and the visa of his former lover’s nanny), they

A Comparison of Two Advertisements

3161 words - 13 pages A Comparison of Two Advertisements I am going to compare two advertisements which I took from the magazine 'Marie Claire.' 'Marie Claire's target audience is young, sophisticated women, aged 18-30s. In the magazine, there is lots about fashion, beauty, relationships and general women's issues. I have chosen two different advertisements to compare. Both advertisements have very different, effective persuasive techniques

Comparison of Two Newspaper Articles

1999 words - 8 pages Comparison of Two Newspaper Articles These two articles are about asylum seekers. Both articles agree that there are too many asylum seekers, but are presented in a very different way to each other. Article one is a shorter more aggressive tract, not intended to make the reader think about the article but just to instantly agree with it. Article two however stands back and looks at the problem, why it has arisen and

A Comparison of Two Newspapers

827 words - 3 pages A Comparison of Two Newspapers There are many tabloid and broadsheet newspapers but now however there are online versions of these popular papers. Two examples, one tabloid and one broadsheet, are The Mirror and The Guardian. When newspapers first came out there were no online versions as the Internet was not invented yet, and therefore was a very basic but effective form of communication. Times move on and therefore

Similar Essays

Comparison Of Two Social Media Campaigns

2278 words - 9 pages Social media campaigns by two different alcohol companies will be analyzed in this report. A comparison would follow after a detailed analysis of the companies’ uses of social media. “Transform Today” is a campaign launched by Absolut Vodka in August 2013. The alcohol company teamed up with artists from all over the world and interacted with consumers via social media. One of the main strategies used in the campaign was ‘#NextFrame”, a

Gcse Media Studies Coursework: A Comparison Of Two Local Newspaper Articles. This Essay Compares Two Newspaper Articles Taken From Two Different Local Newspapers In England

1264 words - 5 pages In this essay I will be comparing two articles taken from local newspapers in different areas. I will be looking at the techniques used in each article and their effectiveness. I will use this comparison to eventually decide which article is the more effective of the two.The two headlines from the articles are quite different. 'Inches from tragedy' is a large, bold headline written in a way that makes you want to see what the headline is talking

Comparison: Pieces Of Flannery O'connor Essay

1783 words - 8 pages Flannery O’Connor was an extremely revered author for his writing techniques that may be examined throughout almost all of his pieces, especially in: “Everything That Rises Must Converge” and “Greenleaf”. Both of these short stories hone in on the two most controversial topics in societal history: religion and race. And with that, “Everything That Rises Must Converge”, a short story in the collection Everything That Rises Must Converge, is a

Comparing And Contrasting Two Pieces Of Music

592 words - 2 pages In the essay I will compare and contrast "Gavotte" from the Classical Symphony by Prokofiev and the "Fantasy on Japanese Woodblocks" by Alan Hovhannes. I felt different about both pieces, but I did see a couple similarities. And that's what I'm going to explain about in this essay: both the differences and the similarities of the two pieces.I'll start by explaining how I felt about both pieces. The "Gavotte" had a very calming affect on me. For