This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparisons Of The Glasser And Dreikus Models

1423 words - 6 pages

Comparisons of the Glasser and Dreikurs Models
There are many similarities to the behavioral models of William Glasser and Rudolf Dreikurs. Both psychiatrists worked closely with young people, and both developed ways to encourage proper behavioral management of disgruntled youth. The methods that each man established are often utilized in clinical sessions and in proper classrooms management.
Dreikurs Model
Dreikurs’ model relies on the idea that “a misbehaving child is only a discouraged child trying to find his place” (Jones & Jones, 2013, p. 33). When a student is feeling inadequate, they will filter through some or all of the four attention-getting behaviors. These disruptive behaviors are: attention getting, power, revenge, and displays of inadequacy. Dreikurs believed that when a child fails to feel as though he or she belongs, they will “act out” in various ways in order to gain acceptable. Sometimes these behaviors work, and other times, students are left feeling more frustrated. For example, a student who may fall behind in class may use inappropriate jokes or commentary to solicit respect from classmates. The student may then try exhibiting power over the administrator in the classroom further trying to increase their status in the social climate. If the student does not receive the attention they seek, they may try to seek revenge on the teacher or even other students in the classroom. In many cases, the disgruntled student gives up entirely and will revert to using phrases such as, “I don’t care anyway,” or “I meant to do that.” Instead of being instructed on how to cope effectively with their emotions, students default into primitive fight or flight strategies. Because of a student’s inability to feel socially equal, they either lash out or become unresponsive. This why Dreikurs believed that there are “Two key dynamic social-congnitive factors, of valuing oneself and others as equal and of contributing to the community on the basis of respect for self and others, in their conjunction provide the most enduring processes for well-being” (Ferguson, 2001, p.326).
Glasser Model
Glasser also understood how important self-efficacy is to student achievement and behavior. Glasser believed that five “powerful forces” were at work in everyone’s “genetic structure” (34). The five basic needs are: to survive and reproduce, to belong and love, to gain power, to be free, and to have fun (34). Students deprived of one or more necessities would find themselves lacking when it came to success in school. Environments that were more student-center were conducive to student achievement, and offer students choice is one way to empower failing students. For example, clinical studies that use the Glasser approach are concerned with moving clients from the “past to present”; the desire is to take the individual “from the problem (the ‘‘don’t want’’) to the desired outcome—what the client does want (W). The client is then asked what he or she has been...

Find Another Essay On Comparisons of the Glasser and Dreikus Models

“Birches”; the comparisons to imagination and reality.

1338 words - 6 pages Often times we may see ourselves wondering through a photo album from our youth or a neighborhood park and reflect on our experiences as a child, the innocence that went along with our almost singular view of the world around us and the joy created in even the most trivial of activities. Robert Frost touches these thoughts in his poem “Birches” as he recounts childhood, and it’s memories, through the observation of Birch trees having been bent

Fiela's Child- Dalene Matthee Comparisons and contrasts of the Long Kloof and the Forest

658 words - 3 pages Throughout this thought-provoking novel, Matthee shows us how the environment where people are brought up, plays a strong part in who they become. She compares and contrasts the bright, open expanse of the Long Kloof with the darkness of the Forest, as well as the inhabitants of these areas.The novel tells us the story of a boy who struggles to understand who he is and where he belongs. This boy is Benjamin Komoetie.Despite spending his younger

The Comparisons between the Brook Ellison Story and the Book of Job

2093 words - 9 pages In this short reflection paper I will be comparing the movie, “The Brook Ellison Story” and the book, “The Book of Job.” Both of these magnificent stories are highly respected by the public and they both give wonderful example of M.R. DeHann book, The Broken thing: Why we suffer. Some of the things that will be disgusting in this paper is a summary of both of these wonderful stories, how four out of the seven main questions for my search for

Willam Goldings Lord of the Flies and its Comparisons to World War II

1701 words - 7 pages Axis Power and the Allis Power; both of these potencies can be seen in Lord of the Flies. Jack in the Lord of the Flies, who is the main antagonist, can conspicuously be seen as the Axis Power, moreover, as Adolf Hitler. Throughout Hitler's time, his mind started to become warped, and his execration for Jews began to increase. This can be visually perceived by Jack’s mind gradual becomes warped, and he becomes more primitive; along with his

Comparing and Contrasting Two of the Four Models of Stress

1430 words - 6 pages This essay aims to compare and contrast two of the four models of stress; Hans Selye’s (1907-1982) general adaptation syndrome (GAS) and Mowrer (1939) avoidance model. Firstly, the author will give published definitions of the term stress; the author will then briefly discuss the term stress. This essay will look at the Selye (1956) general adaptation syndrome and Mowrer (1939) avoidance model of stress and then compare and contrast both models

Integrating Change Models and the Theology of Leadership

1615 words - 7 pages Integrating Change Models and the Theology of Leadership A sentiment common to almost any organization is that the one fact that remains constant is change. As society changes, and human understanding grows, any organization that maintains a static posture, assures its demise. Churches and Christian organizations are no exception. The gospel may remain the same, but the method for communicating it must speak to the audience to assure

Examining the Social and Cultural Models of Disability

1532 words - 7 pages In this paper, the determination is to examine the social and cultural models of disability that have been critiqued in recent disability studies scholarship because the social model omits disabled people and the cultural model disabled people do not need their own identity and they need to be included like the rest of us. By understanding why and how the social model and cultural model is being offer, why do people critique it and what are the

The Power of Baseball and Role Models in Latin America

1983 words - 8 pages The Power of Baseball and Role Models in Latin America In many countries around the world, the socioeconomic problem is so bad that they are granted the title of a Third World country. Countries that are not quite as bad, such as most Latin American countries like Cuba, the Dominican Republic and Puerto Rico, often have trouble, on a smaller level, of creating jobs and job security for its people to inspire work ethic and incentive to raise


2088 words - 9 pages that the four models which will be mentioned, are based on pure scientific results which came out from the aforementioned European Projects on governance. Therefore, the roots of these models may have been based on earlier governance projects undertaken in various cities, but nevertheless, the later models were studied and logically analysed. Back in 1989, David Harvey wrote " In recent years, urban governance has become increasingly preoccupied

The Importance of Program Evaluation and Three Evaluation Models

1779 words - 7 pages and applicable for today’s global market. This paper will discuss the importance of program evaluation and three evaluation models, Tyler’s Goal Attainment Model, Stufflebeam’s CIPP Model and Scriven’s Goal Free Model. CURRICULUM EVALUATION Curriculum evaluation is an important aspect of any national education system. It provides the basis for curriculum policy decisions, feedback on continuous curriculum adjustments and processes of

Happiness in the Hierarchy of Needs and Biopsychosocial Models

3113 words - 12 pages quality of our social relationships impacts our cardiovascular, immune, and hormonal systems. Loving, abusive, or neglectful environments impact affect-regulation and attachments models. Negative experiences are associated with a different set of stress responses (Gilbert, 2002). Also, it is important to consider that many illnesses or disorders, such as depression, are the end results of interacting processes and that the physiological symptoms

Similar Essays

The Biological And Psychodynamic Models Of Abnormality

595 words - 2 pages Though at one point in time clinical scientists believed in only one model of abnormality, we now have six very different models. The original model of abnormality was, unfortunately, the product of cultural beliefs. But because no one model can be deemed complete on its own, competing models have since developed to strive for the comprehensive means for treatment. For example, the biological model and the psychodynamic model take very different

The Power Of Models And Modeling

3412 words - 14 pages The Power of Models and Modeling Models have evolved since the turn of the century. There are models for most any item or system that exists. Developments in mathematics have enabled the world of models to explode. Now most everything can be modeled using some sort of mathematics. Agriculture is field that must rely on predictions. The Farmers Almanac is a source of information that allows one to predict upcoming events. The data in the

Greek And Christian Models Of The Truth

2383 words - 10 pages Greek and Christian Models of the Truth In his Philosophical Fragments, Søren Kierkegaard, writing under the pseudonym of Johannes Climacus, poses the question, "How far does the Truth admit of being learned?" (154). A more direct and succinct formulation of Climacus' question is "How is the Truth learned?" since his question does not concern the extent of human knowledge, which "How far" implies, but the possible modes through which one

Comparisons And Contradictions Of The Cultures And Ideas Of The Americans And Spanish By Jessica Herford

728 words - 3 pages The following paper will be comparative of the cultures and ideas of the Americans and the Spanish. It will be primarily referring to the paper “Lived Ethnicity: Archaeology and Identity in Mexicano America, by Bonnie J. Clark”. The similarities as well as the differences will be discussed. After the comparisons and contrasts have been established, there will be a prediction of what will happen when these two cultures meet and begin to