Compatibilism Paper

1859 words - 8 pages

In Elliot Sober’s, Core Questions in Philosophy, he suggests a compatibilist theory known as the weather-vane theory... The weather-vane theory argues that an agent is has free will when their thought process is functioning correctly. The objection to the weather-vane theory argues that the theory is flawed by using a case of rational, self-sacrifice. I think that the objection to the weather-vane theory is lacking because it does not account for differences between a soldier’s actions and a kleptomaniac’s actions. To argue my point, I will first explain the weather-vane theory in detail. Second, I will explain the case of rational, self-sacrifice objection. Third, I will argue that the case of rational, self-sacrifice is lacking Fourth, I will argue an objection to my argument for the weather-vane objection. Finally, I will argue a rebuttal to the objection against my argument.
The weather-van theory states that a free weather-vane and a stuck weather-vane are different. A free weather-vane functions correctly in that it can react to changes in the wind’s direction. The stuck weather-vane is malfunctioning because it cannot react to changes in the wind’s direction. Sober says that what the two weather-vanes do both have in common is that they are caused to point in a certain direction by something.
Sober ultimately makes an analogy between the weather-vanes and a person’s ability to act freely. Before Sober’s analogy can be understood, his decision-making process must first be explained. A person’s decision-making process can be broken down into its parts. Sober thinks beliefs come from the belief-generating device that in turn, uses evidence to make a belief. Desires are harder to explain than beliefs because what the desire-generating device uses to develop desires is not explained. What can at least be said is that desires come from the desire-generating device. Desire-generating devices are supposed to function as representing what is good for the organism. With this being said, beliefs and desires are used when a person deliberates. From a deliberation, a person develops their intentions. A person’s intentions are then used to determine what action that person should take.
As a weather-vane is free if it functions properly, a person is considered to be free if their decision-making process functions properly. A person’s mind functions properly if it is able to follow the decision-making process generate an action from its beliefs and desires. Sober thinks that a person is proper functioning if the belief-generating device and desire-generating device are sensitive to specific types of causal influences. If a person is unable to generate an action based on the decision-making process, then the person’s mind is malfunctioning.
One type of malfunction that is an important aspect of Sober’s explanation is compulsive behavior. Compulsive behavior is an intense desire to perform an action of a person’s decision-making process. Kleptomania is...

Find Another Essay On Compatibilism Paper

Reality and Illusion in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Reality, Appearance and Deception

896 words - 4 pages Reality and Illusion in Hamlet   Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, begins with the appearance of a ghost, an apparition, possibly a hallucination. Thus, from the beginning, Shakespeare presents the air of uncertainty, of the unnatural, which drives the action of the play and develops in the protagonist as a struggle to clarify what only seems to be absolute and what is actually reality. Hamlet's mind, therefore, becomes the central force of the

Sub-plots in Hamlet Essay

1118 words - 4 pages Sub-plots in Hamlet   There are many things that critics say make Hamlet a "Great Work," one of which is the way that Shakespeare masterfully incorporates so many sub-plots into the story, and ties them all into the main plot of Hamlet’s revenge of his father’s murder. By the end of Act I, not only is the main plot identified, but many other sub-plots are introduced. Among the sub-plots are trust in the Ghost of King Hamlet, Fortinbras, and

Hamlet as Victim and Hero

1301 words - 5 pages Hamlet as Victim and Hero      Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, a Shakespearean tragedy, tells the story of Prince Hamlet, who gained the knowledge of a terrible incident that his kingdom had suffered. Claudius, the king of Denmark and Hamlet's uncle, had killed his own brother, the king, who was also the father of Hamlet, and married his brother's widow. Hamlet suffered these traumas to a severe degree, and his only relief was to defeat his

Essay on Light and Dark in Antigone

1188 words - 5 pages Use of Light and Dark in Antigone   The "Golden Age" of Greece is noted for its many contributions to the creative world, especially in its development of the play. These performances strived to emphasize Greek morals, and were produced principally for this purpose. Antigone, by Sophocles, is typical. The moral focused on in Antigone is the conflict between physis (nature) and nomos (law), with physis ultimately presiding over nomos

charant Creon as the Main Character of Antigone

1231 words - 5 pages Creon as the Main Character of Antigone   Throughout the Greek play Antigone by Sophocles, there exists a dispute as to who should receive the designation of main character. Antigone, the daughter of the cursed King Oedipus, as well as Creon, stately king of Thebes, both appear as the key figures in this historic play. I believe that Creon, king of Thebes, should be considered the main character in this work of Greek theater. Three

Free Macbeth Essays: Sleep and Sleeplessness

525 words - 2 pages The Sleep and Sleeplessness Motif in Macbeth We have consciences that function to tell us the difference between right and wrong. If we have clear consciences, we usually possess the ability to sleep. But when our consciences are full of guilt, we experience a state of sleeplessness. In Macbeth, Shakespeare uses the sleep and sleeplessness motif to represent Macbeth's and Lady Macbeth's consciences and the effect Macbeth's conscience has on

Life Outside of Life in Hawthorne’s Wakefield

898 words - 4 pages Life Outside of Life in Hawthorne’s Wakefield   Efficacy lies at the heart of human desires for immortality. Characters throughout literature and art are depicted as wanting to step aside and see what their world would be like without their individual contributions. The literary classic A Christmas Carol and the more recent, but ageless, film It’s Wonderful Life both use outside influences (three ghosts and Clarence the Angel

Essay on Identity in Song of Solomon

2172 words - 9 pages Searching for Identity in Song of Solomon         Abstract: Whether Africans really fly or just escape a monumental burden, perhaps only through death, is a decision Toni Morrison has apparently left to her readers. Never the less, no matter what you believe, within Song of Solomon, the suggestion is, that in order to "fly" you must go back to the beginning, back to your roots. You must learn the "art" from the old messages.   O

The Character of Oedipus in Oedipus and The Infernal Machine

904 words - 4 pages The Character of Oedipus in Oedipus and The Infernal Machine    The stories of Oedipus, as told through Seneca's Oedipus and Cocteau's The Infernal Machine, contain both similarites and differences. Both authors portray the character of Oedipus as being obstinate, ignorant, and inquisitive. Yet Seneca and Cocteau differ on their interpretation of the motives that propelled these characteristics of Oedipus. Seneca portrays Oedipus as a

Okonkwo's Tragic Flaws in Chinua Achebe's Things Fall Apart

3121 words - 12 pages        An increasing amount of contemporary literature traces its origins back to the early works of Greece. For ages, humans have fascinated themselves with the impossible notion of perfection. Unrealistic expectations placed on those who were thought to be the noblest or most honorable individuals have repeatedly led to disappointment and frustration, either on the part of those particular individuals or those they influence. Classic

Sophocles' Antigone - Antigone Must Challenge Creon

889 words - 4 pages Antigone Must Challenge Creon in Antigone   In his "Funeral Oration" Pericles, Athens's leader in their war with other city-states, rallies the patriotism of his people by reminding them of the things they value. He encourages a sense of duty to Athens even to the point of self-sacrifice. He glorifies the free and democratic Athenian way of life and extravagantly praises those willing to die for it. In Antigone, Creon, Thebes's leader in

Similar Essays

Is Compatibilism True? Essay

1522 words - 6 pages between free will and determinism are compatibilism and incompatibilism. In this essay I shall argue that compatibilism is true. Firstly, I shall explain what compatibilism is and consider possible objections and responses to the theory. I shall then examine incompatibilism and evaluate its strengths and weaknesses and argue that compatibilism is a stronger argument and, as a result, show why it is also true. Compatibilism is the thesis that all

Qumran: Identity, Spirits, Science And Dualism

2324 words - 9 pages blameworthy, non-divine agents the freedom to change the physical universe through choice. Outside the world of the Dead Sea Scrolls there is a significant debate over the existence, compatibilism, and nonexistence of natural evil and moral evil, defined here as determinism and free will. Cain and Rogers, in 2004, published separate papers concerning this debate. Each chose different avenues of approach which ended in nearly the same place

Implications Of Determinism And Free Will

2264 words - 9 pages to realise if we were to read on paper, for example that we were to die on a certain date but we decided to commit suicide before that date, then is our concept of fate just as much an illusion as those who believe the same for free will? Fate, the power of necessity and providence. The future is inevitable and unavoidable. The future can be predicted with certainty. What is certainty? Without doubt and absolute? In the Journal of

Determinism Vs. Free Will Essay

1946 words - 8 pages Many people often wonder what influences their choices, why they do the things they do, and why the world functions the way it does. Many like to argue that people make the choices they make because things are determined by nature and nurture, no other factors. Others like to argue that people have full control over the choices they make and there are no constraining factors. In this paper I will demonstrate that determinism is false and