Compatibility Of Modernism And Traditionalism Essay

1436 words - 6 pages

The Bible is one of the most influential books in human history. It has survived through numerous attempts to destroy it and all it represents. It has been interpreted different ways throughout the years but two of the most important modes of interpretation are the Traditionalist and Modernist views. The Traditionalist perspective has existed for centuries and originated almost as soon as the Bible itself. Modern biblical scholarship’s rise has been more recent, being led by Charles Briggs in the past few centuries. Along with this rise has come much debate about which perspective is right and whether they can coexist. In order to determine if the views are compatible one can examine the purpose of the way of interpretation, the assumptions made by each, the levels of interpretation of each, and the purpose of the Bible in both modes of interpretation.
Determining the purpose of a way of Biblical interpretation is vital because it sets the course. The purpose is the guiding compass for all interpretations that comes. Ancient interpreters have always viewed the Bible as a book whose main purpose was spiritual nourishment and enlightenment. In fact, what the Bible explicitly says is not the most important aspect of it in Traditionalism. Kugel captures this excellently when he says, “that there was something considered even more important, more powerful than the words of the text themselves.” This leaves the question of what exactly is this something that is more important? For the ancient interpreters it was the meaning that was underlying the words, the mission of serving and worshipping God. Knowing this is vital in understanding that the purpose of Traditionalist views is to expound on this mission of service in every part of Scripture, using both the text and the meanings beyond.
The purpose of Modern biblical scholarship was said best by Charles Briggs himself. Biggs stated that Holy Scripture is, “covered over with the debris of the traditional interpretations of the multitudinous schools and sects” and that, “Historical criticism is searching for the rock-bed of the Divine word, in order to recover the real Bible.” These statements show that Modernism is based on refuting Tradition, but even so still sought to find truth. However throughout the years the focus has shifted from looking for the real Bible to only degrading the idea of, “Holy Scripture as given by divine inspiration to holy prophets.” This evolution brings to mind 2 Timothy 3:7 which speaks of people in the last days, “always learning and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth.” With this change in focus, it begins to be obvious that one cannot mix what Modernism has become and Traditionalism.
The assumptions of a view of interpretation are important because they are directly responsible for the worldview that results from following this way of. Facts remain constant but can be interpreted different ways based on what assumptions are being applied to them. ...

Find Another Essay On Compatibility of Modernism and Traditionalism

Humanity of the Primitive in Heart of Darkness, Dialect of Modernism and Totem and Taboo

1632 words - 7 pages Humanity of the Primitive in Heart of Darkness, Dialect of Modernism and Totem and Taboo     The ways in which a society might define itself are almost always negative ways. "We are not X." A society cannot exist in a vacuum; for it to be distinct it must be able to define itself in terms of the other groups around it. These definitions must necessarily take place at points of cultural contact, the places at which two societies come

Modernism and Existential Loneliness Demonstrated in Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness and James Joyce's The Dead

847 words - 3 pages Two authors who demonstrate modernism in its rawest form are Joseph Conrad and James Joyce. Both Conrad and Joyce incorporate one of the key characteristics of modernism throughout their works, Conrad in Heart of Darkness and Joyce in The Dead. The key characteristic that each writer targets in on is existential loneliness. It is a predominant theme throughout both of their works. A working definition of existential loneliness as illustrated

Characteristics of Modernism in Jewel in the Crown and Heart of Darkness

1835 words - 7 pages Characteristics of Modernism in Jewel in the Crown and Heart of Darkness         A Modern novel, Jewel in the Crown, by Paul Scott, depicts the latter stages of imperialism's erosion and explores it through the lives of individuals and their relationships as symbolic of larger societal conflicts and political events.  Jewel was written well into the 20th Century and employs thematic concepts and literary forms characteristic of Modernism

Towards a New and Integrated Language: A Rejection of Post-Modernism

1284 words - 5 pages The term post-modernism has gradually become popular with music commentaries since the phrase was first coined in the early mid 1960's. It was adopted as a way of explaning the rise of so called 'populist' music in the era of the avant garde. The history of the term can be traced to the upsurge in parodying the past in art and architecture and was thought to be a new aesthetic which would eventually replace modernism. In music, this apparently

Modernism Defined in T.S. Eliot's The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock and James Joyce's The Dead

1522 words - 6 pages Modernism is by no means easy to define. In fact, no one is exactly sure if the movement has even ended yet. But that’s befitting of the period, as well as the pieces of literature that serve to define Modernism. Two pieces, T.S. Eliot’s “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” and James Joyce’s “The Dead”, are epitomes of this modernism. In both, the main characters are paralyzed by an inability to communicate, even while speaking. Whether through

Moral Struggle. It traces American theme of moral struggle through Modernism, citing JD Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye, and through Realism with WD Howells's Editha.

1727 words - 7 pages views of modernism authors. As a participant of the modernism period of literature, Salinger wrote his works according to this style. The term modernism refers to the shift in aesthetic and cultural sensibilities in the literature of the post-World War One period. Modernism marks a distinctive break from nineteenth-century optimism, and presents a profoundly pessimistic picture of culture. Salinger displays this view in his book. Holden, the

Arguementative Essay Regarding the Effects of Video Games and Violent Entertainmnet with refrences to the ideals of Modernism.

1017 words - 4 pages English Composition 2From Video Games to War PlanesCoinciding with the consistent and rapid modernization of technology, the entertainment industry has been at the forefront of technological advances here in the West. With every new discovery in the field of science comes a new advancement in the industry of entertainment. Many will argue that the improved varieties of entertainment only enhance and benefit the human experience. Some will even

Modernism vs Neo-Traditionalism

1052 words - 4 pages Modernism vs Neo-Traditionalism: A debate on the merits and failures of two major competing paradigms in architecture and urban planning.      Beyond the term modernism underlies one of the greatest ideas in architectural development. Modernism was meant to provide more green areas, cheaper housing and more efficient use of space. This was to be accomplished by creating vertically dense spaces with the use of the new

Comparative Essay

749 words - 3 pages Modernist literature makes the statement of non-traditionalism in its content and style. The modernist movement began in Europe and moved to the United States in the early twentieth century. The voices of modern idealism speak out against the conformity of the nineteenth century, and oppose class distinctions and lifestyles considered politically correct during this time. Religion and what it represents, no longer explicitly drive the content of

Explaining The Twenties

1260 words - 5 pages one of the darkest moments for American democracy. Today, it is clear that Sacco and Vanzetti were arrested and convicted because of who they were- Non-Protestant, Non-Fundamentalists who believed in something different from the majority of the people. The battle between modernism and traditionalism is most apparent as a battle between the city and the country. In geographical terms, this was how the multi-cultural modernism and mono-cultural

Italian Rationalism

2515 words - 10 pages conditions, the architecture of the era was inevitably affected. The idealists wanted to come up with the idealistic city, obsessed with the utopian thought of changing a materialistic city to one which is more humane and harmonious. Several styles evolved and in particular, Traditionalism stood out. Many people believed that tradition was to inspire invention and at the same time invention keeps tradition alive. However, it was only when Marc Antoine

Similar Essays

Modernism Vs. Traditionalism In The Mayor Of Casterbridge

1803 words - 7 pages An Essay on Modernism vs. Traditionalism in The Mayor of Casterbridge During the first half of the 19th century English society was making the difficult transition from a pre-industrial Britain to ‘modern' Victorian times. In agriculture, most of the transition took place around 1846 with the repeal of the corn laws. This allowed foreign grain to be imported into England for the first time. Consequently, the entire structure and methods of

The Study Of Modernism And Globalization

1988 words - 8 pages , developed and less developed countries, while blurring geographical borders. Along with the study of modernism and globalisation, some theorists have raised the question of the new forms of modern violence and its plausible relation to modernity and globalisation. In Fear of Small Numbers: An Essay on the Geography of Anger (2006), Arjun Appadurai presents a number of key explanations as to how high-scale violence has increased in a global

Budgets Fulfill A Number Of Roles In The Management Of Organizations. Identify The Principal Such Roles And Comment On The Compatibility Of These Differing Roles.

1035 words - 4 pages some conflicts. Here, we will identify the principal roles of budgets and have a briefly comment on the compatibility of these differing roles.Principal RolesAccording to Emmanuel et al. (1990), there are five main roles for budgets: a system of authorization; a means of forecasting and planning; a channel of communication and coordination; a motivational device; a means of performance evaluation and control, as well as of providing a basis for

The Compatibility Of Faith And Reason

1536 words - 6 pages In today’s modern western society, it has become increasingly popular to not identify with any religion, namely Christianity. The outlook that people have today on the existence of God and the role that He plays in our world has changed drastically since the Enlightenment Period. Many look solely to the concept of reason, or the phenomenon that allows human beings to use their senses to draw conclusions about the world around them, to try and