Complete Abolition Of Corporal Punishment Essay

1724 words - 7 pages

1. Introduction:
The administration of corporal punishment to children is an archaic practice that has become obsolete, not only in the post-modern era, but within the current constitutional dispensation of South Africa. The Constitution seeks to protect the right to human dignity, bodily integrity, equality, freedom and security of all South African citizens. The administration of corporal punishment on any person clearly would amount to a violation of these fundamental constitutional values, which begs the question as to why corporal punishment to children is permitted. Corporal punishment in South African public life was officially abolished in 1997 by the commencement of the South African Schools Act 84 of 1996 (SA Schools Act), the Correctional Services Second Amendment Act 79 of 1996 and the Abolition of Corporal Punishment Act 33 of 1997. The catalyst for this change in position through legislation was the case of S v Williams in 1995, where the court was called upon to judge on the administration of corporal punishment as a punishment for a crime. The Constitutional Court declared it unconstitutional to administer corporal punishment as the human rights to bodily integrity, human dignity and equality were infringed. This essay will strive to evaluate the future of the common-law defence of reasonable chastisement in light of the influence the Constitution may have for further development
2. Nature of the defence
Section 10 of the SA Schools Act was the provision under review in the case of Christian Education South Africa (SA) v Minister of Education. This provision stipulated that no person may administer corporal punishment at a school to a learner, applicable to both State funded and private schools. The court rejected the appellants claim, stating that even if it were assumed that the provision in the Act limited parents’ religious rights, it was a reasonable and justifiable limit in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, freedom and equality. With regard to corporal punishment in private homes, the court held that even if teachers were unable to administer corporal punishment in the parents name the Act did not deprive parents of their general right and capacity to bring up their children according to their Christian beliefs.
3. The future of the common-law defence
The courts ensure to take into consideration all the relevant factors in context when making a decision. In S v JB , reliance on this defence was not successful. On the evidence provided by the complainant and others, the court found that there was no reason for the accused to chastise the complainant as she did not deserve it. The future of this defence currently seems to hang in the balance between the traditional ideals of parental authority – represented by the common law defence – and the human rights of children as defined and protected by the Constitution. In S v Kunene and Another court was tempted to speak on the constitutionality of...

Find Another Essay On Complete Abolition of Corporal Punishment

Effects of Corporal Punishment on Children

2168 words - 9 pages When a man is unpleased with something his spouse says or does and he hits her, our society labels it as abuse. If a mother hits her child our society labels it as spanking. Whichever terminology is used to help define corporal punishment, it all means the same. The very idea of physical discipline is based on an adult using his or her larger physique and power to intimidate and force someone much smaller and weaker into a state of compliance

How the Use of Corporal Punishment can Affect a Child

1748 words - 7 pages school performance can also be effected because homework may not be completed at home. Because children do not complete their homework at home, they have to finish it outside of their home environment where parents may not be able to protect their child from negative repercussions (Fletcher, Walls, Cook, Madison, Bridges, 2008) Parents that discipline their child using corporal punishment can not only harm the parent- child relationship

Effectiveness of Corporal Punishment and Learning Theory Alternatives

1202 words - 5 pages Corporal punishment is effective in the short-term, but other alternatives, based more on learning theory, are more effective in long-term behavioural modification. The media, such as Time magazine, discusses the issue of corporal punishment using emotive language and vague claims, as opposed to empirical evidence and references to surveys. Therefore, this essay seeks to discuss the effectiveness of corporal punishment, and learning theory

The Children May Suffer: The Negative Impacts of Corporal Punishment

2061 words - 8 pages The Children May Suffer: The Negative Impacts of Corporal Punishment A young boy slowly makes his way to his mom, her scream urging him forward. He is almost to her side when he sees the shadow of her belt, he slowly backs away, he does not go far, as she quickly grabs him by his shirt. She then start to beat his hands with the belt, and then turns him around and starts spanking him on the behind. Throughout the whole time, the young boy’s

Corporal Punishment Is Not An Effective Means Of C

1149 words - 5 pages Corporal Punishment Is Not An Effective Means Of Controlling Behavior Don Marquis is definitely correct when he stated, "Many a man spanks his children for the things his own father should have spanked out of him"(Spanoudis). Today, spanking as a form of punishment is a very controversial issue that does not need to be examined lightly. On one side of the argument, there are parents who believe that spanking is an acceptable means of

The Effectiveness of Corporal Punishment on Correcting Behavior of Middle School Children

897 words - 4 pages Corporal Punishment and its Effectiveness on Correcting a Child’s Behavior in the Middle School Setting: Sixth Grade through Eighth Grade A Research Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of Requirements for the EDU 501 Research Method Freed-Hardeman University March 24, 2014 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction to the Study…………………………………………………3 Statement of the Problem……………………………………………………..3 Description of Corporal

Critically Analyse the evidence about the effectiveness and limits of corporal punishment

768 words - 4 pages Corporal punishment to modify a child's undesired behaviour is an emotive issue within the general population and for Psychologists it is an extremely complex and challenging research topic. Within my body of work I will endevour to critically analyse and summarise the effective use of corporal punishment; it's effects and limitations; whilst presenting a summary of the phychological evidence both short and long term on childrens behaviour

Capital Punishment, specifically, the practice of State administered death as a penalty for any crime requires abolition

1108 words - 4 pages absent execution. Abolition of capital punishment is the only praiseworthy option.[D] capital punishment• adjective 1 (of an offense or charge) liable to the death penalty.• noun the legally authorized killing of someone as punishment for a crime.Compact Oxford English Dictionary of Current EnglishThird edition revisedRevised EditionOxford Dictionaries978-0-19-953296-4 | Hardback | 19 June 2008[D1] retribution - n. a justly deserved

Is Reward or Punishment more of a Motivation to help Someone Complete a Task?

2286 words - 9 pages motivation to help someone complete a task that was asked to do so. Throughout this review the researcher will be explaining whether a reward system will be more efficient to help someone complete a task or if a punishment system can be more efficient to help someone excel at a specific task. The researcher will describe his findings in this topic by citing articles that were used in order to get further knowledge of this topic. A study that the

The future of Corporal Chastisement as a defence

1244 words - 5 pages within corrective institutions. Corporal punishment as a sentence has since been prohibited. It came through the judgement of S v Williams and Others. The ruling that was made in the former case led to the Abolition of Corporal Punishment Act 33 of 1997. The Corporal Punishment Act prohibits corporal punishment as a sentence handed down by a court of law or a traditional court. As already mentioned, the Children’s Act also prevents the use of

Corporal Punishment

1989 words - 8 pages punishment believe it is the only way a teacher has complete control over the students (Corporal Punishment in Schools 4).Although there are still people who agree with the use of corporal punishment in schools, the overall effects of physical punishment are negative. There are many organizations against corporal punishment including the National Association for the Education of Young Children, the National Center for the Study of Corporal

Similar Essays

The Abolition Of Capital Punishment In Australia

1218 words - 5 pages Since the last execution in Australia in 1967 of Ronald Ryan and the abolition of capital punishment in Australia in 1973 imprisonment has been the only option as a sanction for murder. A survey conducted in 2009 demonstrated that a clear majority of Australians (64%) believed that imprisonment should be the punishment for murder as opposed to 23% stating the death penalty should be used and 13% did not wish to comment. The death penalty is not

Corporal Punishment Of Children Should Be Banned

2447 words - 10 pages for love, security, structure and guidance. In order to break with this vicious circle of using corporal punishment on their kid and to become ourselves once again, we need to rediscover our deep need to have with others, and especially with our child. Instead of hitting, we need to rediscover a relationship with our children with complete trust, harmony and love. Works Cited "A Report from the Advocacy Committee: Policy Statement

The Use Of Corporal Punishment In Schools

1708 words - 7 pages Abstract Recently, as the value of education is increasing, corporal punishment became hot issue on the world because there is no any appropriate answer about” Should corporal punishment be for discipline?” According to a history of corporal punishment of Wikipedia, the practice was recorded as early as c 10th Century BC in Míshlê Shlomoh. Even though corporal punishment is not correct way for discipline like people usually think, how the

Effects Of Corporal Punishment On Children

1340 words - 6 pages Corporal punishment is a controversial form of physical punishment used to deter crime or unsavory behavior. It was often used in the past, but is now discouraged or even seen as immoral, at least in Western countries. Corporal punishment is a morally unjust way to get students to act in an acceptable behavior. Corporal punishment has been used in many schools back in the day. However, it had no positive effect on the children themselves or on