Free Will: Are We Free Or Is Our Life Pre Determined?

1504 words - 6 pages

When we go out into the world are our actions really a result of our free will or were they predetermined by conditions in our past? The determinist and the fatalist believe these fixed conditions in our past transcend any notion that agents have the power to act otherwise than they in fact do. Determinists follow the idea that at any given moment, there is one and only one future state of affairs that is consistent with the physical laws and the state of affairs at that moment. Fatalists believe that whatever happens is unavoidable because events that occur are inevitable by the causal conditions that precede it (Taylor 55). These two doctrines seem to stem from the same belief: our actions are not free due to some past, fixed condition. Because of this, a fatalist can be considered a type of determinist. This way of thinking poses a threat on what we call free will. If our actions are bound to past conditions, then our 'free will' is nothing more than an infant's security blanket. The determinist and fatalist beliefs about past conditions create a problem for those who think we have free will.Some philosophers agree with the ideas of determinism and have a difficult time believing that they have control over future events by way of choosing theirSardis 2volitions. But is determinism 'the way of the cosmos'? If so, what makes determinism true? Let us take a step back and examine what makes determinism valid. "Whether determinism is true depends in the characteristics of the laws of physics," (Van Inwagen 48). If these physical laws are vague or can be broken then nothing can be concluded about the current state of the world. All actions would be random and therefore indeterministic. If all actions were random then we would not have the freedom to do as we please. This is why some people believe that we live in a deterministic world. Now, continuing with determinism, we face another problem. As was stated previously, determinism says 'there is one and only one future state of affairs.' Supporters of determinism do not say that this one particular future was destined to be; they merely say that it just happened the way that it happened. Any other outcome is possible, but there is only one future state of affairs. To sum up, our futures are uncertain except that there is only one possible future. On the surface of things, this does not seem to inhibit our freedom. But, if we have only one possible future, then it must not be possible to cause any events that would produce an alternate future. Following this statement, an agent in this deterministic world would not be able to produce any actions or events that do not correspond with his single future. In other words, he is not free to do other than what he does. We say that this agent does not have free will because he is unable to change his one, determined future. Defenders ofSardis 3determinism have a hard time believing that we have freedom of action if we live in a deterministic world.Like...

Find Another Essay On Free Will: are we free or is our life pre-determined?

Free Will Essay

987 words - 4 pages consequences, or that God intervenes in some way, both unsatisfactory and contrived. Surely the simplest explanation is that cause and effect simply do exist. Is everything we will ever think or do pre-determined? Were all of the great works of creation in art music and architecture pre-determined at the point of creation? Again this argument seems both unsatisfactory and false. So how do we resolve this

Free will Essay

1124 words - 5 pages Determinism is based off this notion that all events are pre-determined, without influence by human actions. If this is true, we can imply that people do not have free will and thus are not responsible for their actions. In Oedipus the King we see that the dichotomy of fate and free will is hazed by the hyperbole of events, which can make it difficult, but possible, to determine if humans even have free will. Through Oedipus’s flaws and

free will

695 words - 3 pages inspecting the choices we personally make. Yet, supposing that one is conscious of their own decisions and then carrying out presiding actions does not prove that one has free will. It is altogether conceivable that I could have the supposed knowledge,sense or reality of freely choosing what I want to do despite the fact that I never really did. Considering what we know with our knowledge as human beings we can identify that we connect and are a

free will

695 words - 3 pages inspecting the choices we personally make. Yet, supposing that one is conscious of their own decisions and then carrying out presiding actions does not prove that one has free will. It is altogether conceivable that I could have the supposed knowledge,sense or reality of freely choosing what I want to do despite the fact that I never really did. Considering what we know with our knowledge as human beings we can identify that we connect and are a

Free Will

814 words - 3 pages Free Will “Free Will and its effect on the Greeks, Christians, and Romans” Free will is defined as: Voluntary choice or decision; freedom of humans to make choices that are not determined by prior causes or by divine intervention (Webster’s Online Collegiate Dictionary). Free will had an effect on the Greeks, Christians, and the Romans. Three stories, Oedipus the King, the Bible, and the Aenied, respectively, that we have studied and

Free Will

982 words - 4 pages within the environment of others as well as my own. We can assume that the majority of people would want to live in that situation and therefore follow what is being asked of them. Now is that there free will? I don't think so. The fact that they choose to live is based on their enjoyment of life and there lessons that they have been taught by their upbringing, this is their environment. The same would be true on an extreme end. Somebody may

Free Will

1714 words - 7 pages the value of good will when he boldly claims "To have a good will is to have something far more valuable than all earthly kingdoms and pleasures; to lack it is to lack something that only the will itself can give, something that is better that all the goods that are not in our power." (Pg. 20, Augustine) If humankind truly has a good will it can never be punished, for it values eternal things, and the will is rewarded with happiness or

Free Will - 837 words

837 words - 3 pages and just because it was pure evil. It's even harder to think that God wouldn't want us to always be happy, even though he put that tree there and put that serpent on this earth but two people couldn't hold a promise. Their free will was to say no. God is good, and all he has made is good, but it is our choice to be happy, and that is free will.The acts of terrorism have cause this nation to be challenged, and the acts of those who have killed thousands on September 11, were the acts of their own. God could not do anything because it was not Gods choice. The future decisions we will have to make, whether they make us happy or not is in our hands and in our actions.

Romeo and Juliet: Fate or Free Will?

536 words - 2 pages believe that the deaths were a result of fate. The last act will determine once and for all if it is Fate or Free Will. Romeo again challenges Fate by saying: “Will I set up my everlasting rest, or shake the yoke of inauspicious stars”. He says this line because he is lead to believe Juliet is actually dead. No one will ever know why Shakespeare wrote this play. It seemed he wanted people to determine the outcome of the play. Many people believe

Fate Versus Free Will

2406 words - 10 pages already. However, there is an opposing issue that surrounds this dilemma of pre-determines fate, and that is the issue of free will. I believe that to have free will means that we have the control and power to make choices in our lives. Therefore, if we believe that the fate of this child was pre-determined then we would have to believe that we have no control or powers in our lives. I do not believe that people have children knowing that their

Free Will vs Determinism.

1413 words - 6 pages The apparent contrast between the theories of free will and determinism has been ane incessant debate that has attracted philosophers and theorists for many years.The debate itself in regards to criminal behaviour surrounds the central question, 'is our behaviour, including criminal actions, something we freely choose to do by an act of our own will or is our behaviour largely determined by forces beyond our immediate self control. These factors

Similar Essays

Fate Or Free Will Essay

699 words - 3 pages The first script play that we’ve discussed is Oedipus Rex. Each classmates expressed their opinion about one of the three characters, Oedipus, Jocasta, and Creon, and how their action are either fated and free will. My opinion about fate and free will is solely based on Oedipus. However, his fate was in King Laius and Jocasta’s hands and they had a chance to change it. The prophecy is based on action throughout the person’s life and will affect

Are We Free? Essay

1482 words - 6 pages national defense from foreign attacks on our freedom. Local taxes in order for local protection, for example police officers and fire fighters. Throughout history, our government has passed many pieces of new legislations in order to protect our freedoms. If we as people were in fact a truly free society, with no government, we would not have order, protection, or equality in the United States. This is why we are not a “true” free society

Are We Free? Essay

1689 words - 7 pages ensures a national defense from foreign attacks on our freedom. Local taxes in order for local protection, for example police officers and fire fighters. Throughout history, our government has passed many pieces of new legislations in order to protect our freedoms. If we as people were in fact a truly free society, with no government, we would not have order, protection, or equality in the United States. This is why we are not a “true” free

Macbeth: Fate Or Free Will. Essay

578 words - 2 pages In Shakespeare's Macbeth, there is a question as to whether or not Macbeth is driven by fate or free will. The three weird sisters approach Macbeth with prophecies that will all come true in the end. It would appear that Macbeth is just following destiny at first. However, Macbeth always had a choice throughout the play to choose his own fate. Macbeth journeyed to his murderous doom through his own free choice.In Act I, the three witches visit