This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Conceptions Of Canada As A Peaceful Nation

1548 words - 6 pages

Canadians often pride themselves as being different from, and more innocent than their American neighbors, who have a well-known history of slavery and racism. Canada is built upon naïve and passive conceptions of being a kinder, gentler, and more peaceful nation in comparison to the United States. These unchallenged assumptions, or myths, allow Canada to "tell a story of national goodness," while effectively erasing sections of history that would otherwise take away from this clean image (Razack 2000:134). These general ideologies were similar to my notion of Canada as a multicultural and tolerant nation, before taking the time to develop a profound understanding as to how these beliefs are fostered throughout society in order to uphold dominant racial and gendered hierarchies. In this paper, I hope to illustrate how my attitude and awareness toward discourses of Canada as a benign nation has developed through readings, lectures, and a relative film. Through summary and analysis of this research, I intend to demonstrate how these nationally constructed ideas constitute a form of racial and gender-based discrimination that is ultimately embedded in history and reinforced through social institutions. I will begin by summarizing both articles and the film. I will then link the intricate concepts by providing a deeper personal analysis.In the first article, "From the 'Clean Snows of Petawawa': The Violence of Canadian Peacekeepers in Somalia," Razack (2000) reveals the shocking, yet generally unheard of atrocities performed by Canadian peacekeepers to Somalis in 1992. These acts included numerous instances of violence, rape, torture, and degradation to seemingly innocent Somalis (Razack 2000:127). Razack (2000:127) describes the Canadian soldiers' gratification in the abuse, where pictures and videos emerged with peacekeepers proudly "posing with bound Somalis, many of whom were children". What is most disturbing is how recorded documents of these violent stories have disappeared from Canadian national and legal consciousness, essentially so that the national image of peacekeepers and nonracists would not be shattered.Canadian civilians were informed that the violence toward Somalis was the result of "corrupt military leaders that were unable to control a few rebellious men" (Razack 2000:154). This enforces the idea that racist ideas might only be evident in the Canadian military culture, but certainly not in Canada as a whole. This notion fails to realize that the damage done in Somalia may have, in fact, been ultimately rooted in racist ideologies that most Canadians are socialized into. For instance, Razack (2000:129) describes how in general, Canadians view white people as normal and good. Therefore, with these ideas in mind, the peacekeepers felt compelled to colonize and civilize the Somali natives. Specifically, the article suggests:there is a relationship of hegemonic masculinity to the making of Canada as a white nation-state that when...

Find Another Essay On Conceptions of Canada as a Peaceful Nation

The Day Canada Became a Nation

2209 words - 9 pages Expeditionary Force (C.E.F) perfected their defense tactics and techniques to fight in the evolutionary battle that made Canada a nation. When Great Britain declared war on Germany in 1914, the Dominion of Canada was automatically motivated to mobilize. Nationalism and determination got Prime Minister Robert Borden to send the first Canadian contingent overseas, which held 33, 000 men.1 As Byng’s biographer states, “Byng admired the Canadian’s

Laurier, Canada's loved prime minister. Did he help unite Canada as a nation or not solve any problems

736 words - 3 pages During Sir Wilfred Laurier's fifteen years as Canada's liberal prime minister, he proved to the world what Canada really was. Laurier was effective because of his policies on promoting Canadian industries, expanding the railway, encouraging national unity and most importantly the creation of two new provinces because of increased immigration. Laurier acted fairly to the French and the British, being the first Canadian prime minister who was a

Peaceful protesting as a Liberty - University, Year 1 - Essay

1150 words - 5 pages Ruthven 5 Caitlin Ruthven Dr. James Sikkema Philosophy 400051826 27 March 2017 Peaceful Protesting as a Liberty For years now, there has been an on-going conflict between the objectors of the North Dakota Access Pipeline and law enforcement. By attacking the protesters, law enforcement introduced legislations banning peaceful protesting, which is in direct conflict with John Stuart Mills’ One Simple Principle (also referred to as Harm Principle

Obedience As the Means to a Peaceful Life

1648 words - 7 pages those with authority over them. Through obedience the participants were able to accept that their actions were not theirs, but that they were justified in their reactions, which enabled them to come to peaceful terms with the Stanford Prison Study in which they played a role. The human need to be obedient and please those in authority as a demand of one’s role was also seen in the study conducted by Stanley Milgram in 1964. Milgram designed a

Birth Of A Nation

715 words - 3 pages "BIRTH OF A NATION" The film "Birth of a Nation," by D. W. Griffith, is a timeless and controversial silent film. Griffith attempts to use his one-sided philosophies to portray Caucasians and African Americans the way he sees them. "Birth of a Nation" was based on the anti-black play "The Clansman." The story line follows the Clansman family that is from the South and their close friendship to the Stoneman family from the

Birth of a Nation

629 words - 3 pages Gus touch her. The construction of white womanhood plays a big role as for something worth preserving and fighting.      Lastly, the KKK was viewed as the heroes and saviors of the nation in the end. They manage to arrive just in time to stop Lynch from marrying Stoneman’s daughter, to save the family in the house from the renegades and to restore social order into the community.      In

A Nation of Carnivores

613 words - 2 pages Ochoa 3A Nation of CarnivoresMost people I know eat meat almost every day. Kathy Freston is a "'conscious living counselor', talk show guest, and best-selling author of Quantum Wellness: A Practical and Spiritual Guide to Health and Happiness (2008), among other titles." This background gives her the ethos to talk or write about vegetarianism (preface 800). She tells us in her essay "Vegetarian is the New Prius" that being a vegetarian is far

A Nation of Idoits

766 words - 3 pages America's idiocy. The priorities of our politicians are unacceptable. According to Moore, our political leaders "have decided it's a bigger priority to build another bomber then to educate children" (135). As a result any schools throughout the United States have overflowing classrooms, outdated facilities, and below average teachers. Moore as well as myself feels that politicians should change their focus towards education. A focus on education would


1083 words - 4 pages spanned much of Europe and Asia, it is now a dwarf of its former self. It was once home to a great Islamic civilization whose culture flourished and spread to the ends of the earth, yet it is now an officially secular society devoid of religious inspiration. While these changes occurred many years ago, most Turks have not yet recovered. Just as the prisoner is separated from society, many modern Turks are separated from the very essence of

What challenges does As You Like It present to out conceptions of gender identity?

1365 words - 5 pages Present day conceptions of gender would appear to be different to what they were in Shakespeare's day. Clear cut divisions of male, female and neuter are apparent. One would need to look back to the time of Shakespeare to try and see the different view of gender identity. Using the play As You Like It and the characters portrayed within it one might be able to see how our concept of gender may well be challenged. Gender role in this play does

A Weight of a Nation

1189 words - 5 pages The Weight of a Nation I saw so many true facts in this video that hits close to home. From the advertising to the Lower end housing. I was never obese as a child and I was always fed, but I won’t be able to say it was necessarily healthy. I pretty much ate what I wanted and if my mother was making something I did not eat she made me a separate meal, and

Similar Essays

The Development Of Canada As A Nation

1149 words - 5 pages The Development of Canada as a NationCherrisse PorterThere are different opinions about the most important event in Canada's development as a nation. The story starts with the voyager, warrior, and forefather of the second largest nation today, Samuel de Champlain. He is the famous French explorer who helped broaden the Europeans' understanding of Canada. Few persons in his era came to recognize the potential that North America had to offer in

Growth Of Canada As A Nation During Wwi

1142 words - 5 pages stepping stone for Canada becoming a whole and uniting as one in a nation. Canada grew as people, economically and throughout the war as a powerful nation. Canada’s debt began during the war went there crops weren’t growing to their fullest length causing farmers to lose more money than expected. Between 1914 and 1914 about 50 000 Canadian living families lost their jobs because of the railway debt. However Britain along with Canadians came up

America As A Nation Of Immigrants

2394 words - 10 pages America as a Nation of Immigrants America has, is, and will always be a nation of immigrants: the great melting pot. In the years that have passed since Emma Lazarus' poem was inscribed on the Statue of Liberty "the golden door" Americans have seen times when the door was open wide and times when it was close shut to most immigrants (Sure 4). Many people look at the present immigration problems as a purely modern dilemma. The truth is

Who Helped Canada To Become A Nation?

1144 words - 5 pages the war and was the first Canadian to be promoted to the rank to General. He fought to keep Canadian Soldiers together in a true Canadian Division. Since his plan for the Battle of Vimy Ridge was successful, Canada won a seat as a separate nation at the Peace talks after the war. This displays that his achievements and his cooperation contribute Canada's reputation and coming of an age as a nation. General Arthur Currie's hard work strengthen