Confederation And Constitution Essay

1649 words - 7 pages

Confederation and Constitution

After the American Revolution, a new government had to be established. The Constitution that was written took power away from the people. It led to rebellions from poor people and farmers.

Daniel Shays, a former Revolutionary Army captain, led a rebellion with farmers, against laws which were not fair to the poor. They protested against excessive taxes on property, polling taxes which obtained the poor from voting, unfair actions by the court of common requests, the high cost of lawsuits, and the lack of a stable currency. They wanted the government to issue paper money, since it is cheaper then gold and silver coins.

Once retired George Washington heard of this, he immediately went to Massachusetts to stop it. He was completely shocked to see the people fighting against the country which fought to free those men. “What a triumph for the advocates of despotism to find that we are incapable of governing ourselves, and that systems founded on the basis of equal liberty are merely ideal and fallacious.” (George Washington Expresses Alarm 1786) He said this to the rebels who then stopped and the rebellion was crushed.
After Shays rebellion collapsed, the government realized that they need a new constitution and to strengthen the Articles of Confederation. This was a long and hard decision on whether to give the people the right to voice their opinions or not. Mixed views on the subject were given so it was very difficult to come to a conclusion. Mr.
Sherman of Connecticut “opposed the election by the people, insisting that it ought to be by the state legislatures. The people, he said, immediately should have as little to do as may be about the government. They want [lack] information and are constantly liable to be misled.” (The Debate on Representation in Congress 1787). Mr. Sherman is saying that people should not have anything to do with what the government has to do.
They only get information wrong and can be misled and misdirected into something that can be bad for the country.

Mr. Gerry of Massachusetts believes “the evils we experience flow from the excess of democracy.” While Mr. Mason of Virginia “argued strongly for an election of the larger branch by the people.” The representatives of these states viewed different ideas on democracy. Some wanted the people to have more of a say while others wanted to do the saying for the people.

Thomas Jefferson’s views changed in 1787. At first his comments about Shays rebellion was “I hold it that a little rebellion now and then is a good thing, and as necessary in the political world as storms in the physical.” (Thomas Jefferson Favors rebellion 1787) He was saying that rebellion is good every once in awhile so the government doesn’t think they are omnipotent. Later, he said “God forbid we should ever be twenty years without such a rebellion. The people cannot be all, and always well informed.”
(Jefferson is Unenthusiastic 1787) Here he is saying...

Find Another Essay On Confederation and Constitution

Comparing the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution

1402 words - 6 pages Comparing the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution The founding Fathers consists of Alexander Hamilton, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, John Hancock, John Adams, George Washington, James Madison, and James Monroe. These were the most known contributors of all the founding Fathers. Each framer has equal contribution to the development of the Constitution and the articles of Confederation. The three greatest contributors to

The Articles of Confederation and the US Constitution

1300 words - 5 pages important step in the development of the current government system. The weaknesses presented by the Articles of Confederation helped lead to reforms that made the Constitution successful. Both the Articles and the Constitution demonstrate the struggles that the colonists went through with the British and their desire to establish a new tyranny free government. The Articles of Confederation was the United States first attempt at creating a democratic

compare and contrast the articles of confederation and the constitution essay

1940 words - 8 pages AbstractThe simple difference between the Articles of Confederation and US Constitution is that the articles were not strong enough to hold our young nation together. The articles operated the US as separate states. Under the articles, it was very difficult to pass laws since the requirement of 9 out of the 13 states' approval was needed for ratification. The Articles created a loose confederation of sovereign states and a weak central

Comparison of the United States Constitution and the Articles of Confederation

967 words - 4 pages divided colonies, establishment of a self government, and the ratification of today’s U.S. Constitution. The first U.S. constitutional doctrine ever written were the Articles of Confederation, composed during a time when the thirteen British colonies were still in a Revolutionary war with Great Britain. On November 15, 1777 after a year of debate, the Second Continental Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation. It didn’t become effective

Comparison Between the Articles of Confederation and the United States Constitution

953 words - 4 pages Towards the end of the Revolutionary War, the people felt they needed a document to secure their independence from Britain. This document was the Articles of Confederation. Shortly after that, a new document was formed to what we know as the Constitution of the United States. These documents were similar but more different at the same time with each other, and each granted specific powers to the national government. By throwing off the British

The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution - Answer to a former DBQ (Document Based Question)for an AP US History class

942 words - 4 pages Question: "From 1781 to 1789 the Articles of Confederation provided the Unites States with an effective government. Use the documents and your knowledge of the period to evaluate this statement."Although the Articles of Confederation provided a working government for the United States, it was not necessarily an effectively working government; an effective government would be one that not only establishes control and authority, but one under

Confederation to the Constitution

1758 words - 7 pages Confederation to the ConstitutionDid the ideologies that inspired and explained the revolution adapt to the need of constructing a political order while retaining coherence, consistency and integrity or did the framers of the Constitution disguise their political reorientation by substituting metaphoric revenance for realistic fidelity? When the Constitution was submitted to states for ratification, there was significant uncertainty that it

Articles of Confederation versus Constitution

1197 words - 5 pages ARTICLES OF CONFEDERATION VERSUS CONSTITUTION 2 Articles of Confederation versus ConstitutionThe articles of confederation established on November 15 1977 were United States first constitution. The articles were later ratified by the entire thirteen states on March 1, 1781. It became evident that the articles occasioned loose and weak confederation of the sovereign states and central government respectively. This led to the need of a stronger

Articles of Confederation vs. Constitution 

759 words - 4 pages to give limited powers to the central government. However, to some states the current form of government was not satisfying because the Articles of Confederation will come out to be too disadvantageous. Constitution will become the saving grace for America. Written in 1787, Constitution was requesting united and more powerful government. There were many differences between Articles of Confederation and Constitution. One of the main differences

The Articles of Confederation verses the Constitution

1310 words - 6 pages supported by two major politicians and they were George Washington and Benjamin Franklin, who called themselves Federalist. In this essay we will review the major conflicts and distinctions between the Articles of Confederation and the U.S. Constitution. The first conflict between the Articles and the Constitution was in the way they set up the Legislature. Congress was established as a single Legislature under the Articles of Confederation. The

Articles of Confederation vs. the Constitution

839 words - 3 pages in the Union ha[d] obstructed every attempt to reform the government; that little member ha[d] repeatedly disobeyed and counteracted the general authority." The changes proposed by the new constitution only strengthened the initial system of government and proved essential to the survival of the nation.The Articles of Confederation did not support a strong federal government. Many antifederalists did not want the government to have so much

Similar Essays

Confederation And Constitution Essay

1451 words - 6 pages involved in the creation of the Constitution, arguing that it was a necessary enhancement on the Article of Confederation, the country's first attempt at uniting the states in a national political arrangement. Leaders among the Federalists included two men who helped develop the Constitution, James Madison and Alexander Hamilton, and two national heroes whose support would greatly improve the Federalists' prospects for winning, Georg Washington and

The Articles Of Confederation And The Constitution

762 words - 4 pages Everyone believes that our Founding Fathers were perfect. They always had the right answer and never made any mistakes. What people don’t know is that our Founding Fathers never would have written our Constitution if they did not make a mistake. The Constitution was actually the second document written that was meant to be the “supreme law of the land”. The first document our Founding Fathers created was called the Articles of Confederation. The

Constitution And The Article Of Confederation

998 words - 4 pages “The Constitution devotes the national domain to union, to justice, to defense, to welfare and to liberty” (Maier 154). This quote, stated by William Henry Seward, displays the strength and stability that the Constitution had over the nation, and the liberty and justice it supplied for all of its citizens. Although the Constitution and the Articles of Confederation have similarities, they have many differences, which proved that the Articles

The Constitution And The Articles Of Confederation

950 words - 4 pages Bankrupt, and on her knees for solutions, America was in a state of distress. Politicians alike recognized that The Articles of Confederation, adopted in 1777, desperately needed revision as well as modification. Under the Articles, a Continental Congress had been shaped, which was allocated virtually no authority to collect revenue, handle domestic affairs, or control commercial trade. Shortly after the Revolutionary War, America