Confucius Was A Mere Preserver And Transmitter Of Tradition, While Muhammad Was An Innovator. Discuss The Validity Or Otherwise Of This Statement.

3140 words - 13 pages

Confucius was a Chinese philosopher, one of the most influential figures in Chinese history. (Ching p52) According to tradition, Confucius was born in the state of Lu of the noble K'ung clan in 551 BCE. (Bishop p14) His father, commander of a district in Lu, died three years after Confucius was born; leaving the family in poverty. Confucius nevertheless received a fine education. During the four years immediately after his marriage, poverty compelled him to perform menial labours for the chief of the district in which he lived. His mother died in 527 BCE, and after a period of mourning he began his career as a teacher, usually travelling about and instructing the small body of disciples that had gathered around him. His fame as a man of learning and character and his reverence for Chinese ideals and customs soon spread. Confucius described himself merely as a ‘transmitter of culture’, and for the majority of his teachings this is true, but claims can also be supported that he was a ‘conservative innovator’ in some of the ideas he presented. Unfortunately for Confucius, the fruits of his labours occurred long after his death.China’s traditional religion was ancient, diverse and as complex as the people themselves. It consisted of two indigenous traditions, Confucianism and Taoism, and later in the 1st century CE, Buddhism crept in from India. All three sat comfortably with the Chinese, often complimenting one another. Yet, religion was not restricted to the practices of these three. Ancient practices such as ancestor veneration and several other folk religions focussing on divination were commonly integrated. Amazingly, each of these aspects blended together to form a coherent whole, a concept that is extremely foreign to western understandings of religion. (Ching p31) Even today, such practices and beliefs are still an important aspect in Chinese religion. The principle hasn’t changed. The cosmic order or the forces behind the cosmic order can be consulted through such methods as divination, prophecy, exorcism and astrology. The ancient Chinese polytheistic gods were based on the forces of nature. The Chinese sacrificed to their gods in the hope of obtaining rewards and favours. The gods were subject to a strict hierarchy that was mirrored in Chinese society. Over several generations and under the rule of alternating dynasties, it came to consist of a Parthenon of gods with the god, Ti’en, also meaning heaven, as the supreme ruler of all. It was from this ancient tradition, Confucius based his teachings. (Ching pp62-63)Confucius lived in the second half of the Chou dynasty (c. 1027-256 BCE), a time when the feudal system was beginning to disintegrate and deception and depravity went unchecked; he deplored the disorder and lack of moral standards, and believed that the only solution was to convert people once more to the principles and precepts of the ancients. He therefore lectured his pupils on the ancient...

Find Another Essay On Confucius was a mere preserver and transmitter of tradition, while Muhammad was an innovator. Discuss the validity or otherwise of this statement.

The assassination of JFK was a conspiracy of powerful forces. Do you agree or disagree with this statement?

916 words - 4 pages commission introduced the "magic bullet theory" which is almost impossible. Many witnesses heard shots coming from the grassy knoll yet they were ignored or convinced that what they had heard were echoes. The autopsy performed on JFK was incomplete and many files were destroyed or missing. This, with the addition of other evidence proves that there was a conspiracy in JFK's death and the assassination much have been carried out by someone with the

"The First World War was the first modern war" discuss and evaluate this statement

1304 words - 5 pages " tactics were used in every day combat tactics. Trench warfare and massive offensives designed by old world general sipping cognac in their comfortable leather armchairs, sending foot soldiers to be butchered to an almost certain death as if they were young boys simulating a battle with lead soldiers, are there to remind us that this war was not "franche et joyeuse" (clearcut: "brave and joyous" is the best translation I could think of).World War

'The Weimar Republic was a failure.' Evaluate the accuracy of this statement with reference to events and individuals

1245 words - 5 pages relations with France. Another major advance for German international relations was its admission to the League of Nations in 1926 as this gave Germany an added voice in world affairs and a forum from which Germany could seek to settle other German grievances.German culture was thriving in these years and things were looking up for Germany. Literature, architecture and modern art prospered during this period with its new innovative and experimental

Was Romeo and Juliets' love a mere infatuation?

1857 words - 7 pages infatuation or crush. Their deaths were merely caused by the unreasonable and ongoing feud between the two Houses (Capulet & Montague) and sheer bad luck, it was never in any way, their fault or mistakes which (directly) took their young lives.Shakespeare opens the play (before the Prologue [to Act 1]) with a stupid fight which involves the servants of the two households. Sampson and Gregory, who are Capulets, are talking of their hatred for all

Mark Lathem and his policy on the run for pulling Australian troops out of Iraq by Christmas. This issues peice was done a while ago and was a speech

599 words - 2 pages I chose the political storm which has erupted after Mark Latham announced "Australian troops would be pulled out of Iraq by Christmas". The Government, and John Howard in particular, are using this announcement by Latham to demonstrate that he does not have a grasp of the situation in Iraq, is weak in foreign policy and therefore not a suitable candidate for prime minister. Mark Latham was recently chosen as the leader of the federal

Lord of the Flies This tale was an absolute sea

1248 words - 5 pages Lord of the Flies This tale was an absolute sea of conflict and scandal from the very start. Many relationships we saw in the beginning changed and warped into very new things. Each chapter was littered with confrontation and discord, but many of these seemed rather insignificant in consideration of the plot as a whole. However, there was one ongoing trouble: principal, and symbolic, the prominent theme in this novel. It was Ralph versus Jack

Discuss the negative and positive aspects of the development of agriculture. Was it, or was it not the worst mistake in the history of the human race?

1710 words - 7 pages Discuss the negative and positive aspects of the development of agriculture. Was it, or was it not the worst mistake in the history of the human race?Agriculture is not just a way of growing food; it involves in whole spectrum of cultural changes and adaptations by early human communities. The demands and effects of practicing agriculture as a means of survival created a new kind of community life, with new opportunities and new problems for

"My father worked at ford. He hated it – it was just like school or prison." Discuss the above statement focusing on the ideas of Michel Foucault

1208 words - 5 pages protection of the factory worker was not a priority and many workers were injuring themselves on a regular basis. This is an example of their worthlessness to the company. Consistent supervision of the factory worker played a major part of the entire Taylor system. The human rights of the factory workers were so limited that people started comparing working at the Ford motor company to being in prison. The control over the pace that the employee worked

This essay discusses why Handel was a baroque musician as opposed to an Enlightened or Classical musician in the form of a letter

1270 words - 5 pages concerto grosso, it kept the operas and some sonatas, which Handel was very into. This might also contribute to his acceptance in the International Enlightenment Society, though truly he does not belong. The fact that he was able to find his talents as Benjamin Franklin did is somewhat of an Enlightenment characteristic. While Handel's father, a barber-surgeon, intended his son for the law, Handel realized that what he really wanted was music. He

"Russia in 1894 was a country with many problems" - Discuss this view of Russia

1048 words - 4 pages Tsarist government. This meant that there was one absolute ruler, who inherited his position as a member of the Romanov family. He chose all of his advisors and had the power to choose not to take their advice. From 1881, people were not allowed to express their political views or oppose the Tsar. Autocracy had several strengths, such as things could get done very quickly, and there was an awareness of roles and position in society. However, it

"As long as Stalin was running the Soviet Union a Cold war was unavoidable." (J.L Gaddis, We Now Know). Discuss this interpretation of the origins and character of the Cold War

2078 words - 8 pages The cold war, or as John Lewis Gaddis would call it the "Long Peace" is a point in history full of intrigue. The very fact that one historian chooses to call a 'war' a period of peace, whilst for many decades previous is had been referred to as an enigma of conflicts the world hadn't seen before, and probably will never see again. The biggest problem with identifying whether or not the cold war really was instigated or inevitable because of

Similar Essays

The Traditional (Pre 1788) Australian Aborigines Had A Positive View Of The World, While The Buddha Had A Negative View Of The World. Discuss The Validity Or Otherwise Of This Statement

2108 words - 8 pages people and the environment. To place the Dreaming in time is difficult because, while it tells of origins, it links directly to the here and now. Stockton described it as “ was, and is, everywhen...”. ( E. Stockton. p52) The Aboriginal sacred stories tell of events of the Dreaming and how Ancestral Beings formed the land and life. “The tales are a kind of commentary, or statement, on what is thought to be permanent and ordained

"Picasso Was A Genius" Discuss This Statement

953 words - 4 pages , inviting upon himself a charge of heresy decreed by a public recoiling in horror from the brutal violation of the artist's traditional role - Les Demoiselles D'avignon. Shockingly unique, this artwork was a powerful driving force of the modern art movement and inspired many other artists to produce works in a similar style which would later be known as cubism. Evidently, after creating his own unique artistic style, Picasso was an innovator of thought

Were 1920's America An Era Of Social And Cultural Rebellion Or Was It The Result Of Mere Exaggeration Of The Press?

2027 words - 8 pages of the 1920's. Forexample, Shannon discuss the finances and the economical situation of theUnited States during a time that had proceeded World War I. At this time theUnited States had become a world power after its victory as an Allie against theAustro-Hungarian regime, where not only was it the pop culture and the fashioncreator for the rest of the world, but it was also very prosperous and well-to-dofinancially and economically. During the

Australia Was A Better Place In Which To Live For Women In 1945 Than It Was In 1900.' Discuss This Statement With Reference To The Status Of Women

1752 words - 7 pages career, at least until the war was over. When World War Two broke out a similar situation occurred. "World War Two was one of the most important events, this century in giving Australian women the opportunity to prove their abilities in numerous fields of work beyond the home." Women played a very active role in society during World War Two and significantly contributed to the war effort. Women did a lot during the wars to keep the country going while