Cons Of Genetic Engineering: The Case Against Perfection By Michael J. Sandal

1865 words - 7 pages

Genetic engineering includes altering heredity structures of living organisms and food products to provide the substance with certain traits which may appeal more to one. Other desired characteristics with regards to the Human genome project scientists have had a breakthrough in science. Now scientists are able to create synthetic organs for transplants and prevent disease by manipulating genes. According to Grocery manufacturers of America 70% to 75% of processed foods contain genetically modified ingredients from plants. Curing disease and a longer lifespan are now in the distance. Also, benefits include using a smaller amount of resources to feed a growing nation. Citizens who do not support biogenetics have concerns with ethics, safety, and disease which are why GMO should be limited to non-existent.

Genetic engineering challenges ethics itself. In the “Case Against Perfection” by Michael J. Sandal the author includes multiple statements such as “manipulating our own nature” and “to make ourselves better” to argue what any type of person may do for self-improvement. With genetic engineering becoming more involved it is implausible to avoid, but as a race, humans have the ability to see what is right and what is wrong. For example, a competitor may find the need to increase physical aspects that enhance the athlete’s ability to perform at the next level. This is clearly wrong and can appear unfair to a natural contender and “degrades the game and player’s dignity “as “Tinkering with Humans “ by William Saletan describes modifying deoxyribonucleic acid. Additionally, reshaping born-give traits can become the next immense skill enhancer such as creatine.
Another controversial topic is cloning and the message derived from the issue. The message is self-improvement which is corrupt since it brings self-reformation to a whole other level. Beside the point just made some may say it violates the right of independence of freedom since parents deny a child to a future in which they can create their own life. Cloning centralizes around the advancement of a human being who may seek duplication to be above a certain standard. The problem with this is imitating DNA goes against the principles of the human species itself. "The mystery of cloning is why that 1 or 2 percent make it through" which is why the case with Dolly is such a breakthrough on science (Faye Flam, “Cloning in the Decade after Dolly). In 1997, Scottish scientists were the first scientists to have a successful cloning attempt. Though they were triumphant in reproducing exact genetic material of a cow, the abnormalities and dangers were present. This enough fears inhabitants around the world of the peril of cloning. The line is crossed into unethical behavior and the danger is certain of what cloning has the capability of doing.
An unaware consequence of genetically modified organisms is a human disease. In “Genetically Engineered Crops May...

Find Another Essay On Cons of Genetic Engineering: The Case Against Perfection by Michael J. Sandal

Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering

2383 words - 10 pages Genetic Engineering is highly controversial since some people believe that genetic engineering is playing God. As this fact there is opposition to the progression of the field by people who do not see the value in genetic engineering, or they fear what genetic engineering may lead to for us as people. There is a history of discover that belongs to genetic engineering, which has led to numerous products that have emerged which have brought

Arguments Against Genetic Engineering Essay

1114 words - 4 pages individual? Today we already have methods of "looking into the future". To determine an unborn child's characteristics we can do something called amniocentesis. This isn't really a valid example of genetic engineering, as this only tells us about the child, not how to fix it. The only thing to do in the case of possible down syndrome or Tay-sachs victim is have an abortion. That doesn't necessarily work for everyone. On the other hand, how can we

Genetic Engineering: Pros and Cons

1274 words - 5 pages the problems of genetic engineering. Works Cited "Genetic engineering." The Gale Encyclopedia of Science. Ed. K. Lee Lerner and Brenda Wilmoth Lerner. 4th ed. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Gale Student Resources in Context. Web. 20 Jan. 2012. Ren, Yin. "Designer Babies: The Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering." MIT Undergraduate Journal 12 (2009). Print. Rollin, B.E. "Bad Ethics, Good Ethics and the Genetic Engineering of Animals in

To Clone or Not To Clone... This is a essay against cloning and includes some references to genetic engineering.. It's loosely based on the persona of a political leader

1476 words - 6 pages Cloning and genetic engineering is a topic of much controversy in today's society. There are many religions that believe that cloning and/or genetic engineering should simply not be done because of the fact that it's not "God's (or whomever else they believe in) way". However, this is not the only cause of the controversy in regards to cloning and genetic engineering. Many others believe it is against human ethics and could be dangerous to

The Ethics of Genetic Engineering

2994 words - 12 pages about eugenics under Hitler’s regime and today they have some of the toughest legislative controls of any nation. In Germany Hitler's mistakes have left marks on the German psyche, by this I mean Germans are still afraid of genetic engineering because of Hitler’s ruthless Eugenics project that tried to create a master race. An example of this is biochemist Carl-Wihelm Vogel. Vogel had set up a Class 1 Lab (the category denoting the least risk) at

The Benefits of Genetic Engineering

1018 words - 4 pages insulin. By cloning the human gene for insulin and inserting it into bacteria known as E. coli, the scientists created bacteria that produced insulin and when the bacteria reproduced, they reproduced the human gene as well. Next, genetic engineering will make it possible to create vital organs for transplants. A major medical difficulty today is the lack of organ donors. Waiting lists are always getting longer, and people are losing their lives

The Benefits of Genetic Engineering

3305 words - 13 pages quite volatile topic these days. On the one side, people are screaming about how people are "playing God" and the potential for disaster, and on the other side people are screaming about the vast potential for good that it has. But how can anyone make a decision if most of those people do not even know what genetic engineering is? The man who perhaps started this genetic revolution was a humble Augustininan monk by the name of Gregor Mendel. He

The Future of Genetic Engineering

653 words - 3 pages , Deborah Gridley, discusses the heated topic of genetic discrimination. Genetic discrimination is defined as “discrimination against an individual or against members of that individual’s family because of real or perceived differences from the ‘normal genome” (Gridley 973). The benefits of genetic advances are quite clear. “As the genetic causes of many diseases are found, effective treatments and cures may be developed” (Gridley). However, with genetic

The effects of genetic engineering

1127 words - 5 pages because I did not have to do this paper but because you offered the opportunity to do the genetic engineering of animals. Which is a topic that, I actually find to be an interest to myself. I have strong feelings for the use of animals to provided science with further research and development of all areas. Especially, if animals can lead to the saving of human lives.I would like to start by defining the word "genetic engineering". It is the

The Dangers of Genetic Engineering

1076 words - 4 pages help their children have the best possible life, free of diseases and pain.  This hope for a good life gives rise to the use of genetics as an eliminator of diseases that are a result of imperfect DNA.  After this pragmatic use, however,  is the expectation that genetic engineering will bring about a systematized choice about better or exceptional babies.  With the ability to alter a gene pattern comes the prospect that children face today - that

Morality of the Genetic Engineering of Animals

1289 words - 6 pages regulation by the government to secure extended rights for animals and proper safety for humans. Genetic modifying of animals found its beginning and the beginning of controversy in America nearly forty years ago. “Genetic engineering is a process in which scientists use recombinant DNA (rDNA) technology to introduce desirable traits into an organism” (Animal & Veterinary). During 1972, a Stanford University professor documented the first

Similar Essays

The Case For And Against Genetic Engineering

962 words - 4 pages The case for and against genetic engineering I will look at the case for and against the use of genetic engineering and make a conclusion on whether or not I believe that it is right. As I believe in genetic engineering, I will start buy looking at the reasons that support it. The main reason that I support genetic engineering is that this technology has dramatically improved our ability to treat and even cure

The Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering

820 words - 3 pages with their bolls falling off. Something like ¼ of the acreage used for cotton farming in the USA is ruined by biotechnology and its creation of deformed plants. Genetic engineering also promises to splice a herbicide tolerant gene with a common crop gene, which will create a herbicide tolerant crop. This means that the chemical’s poisonousness doesn’t affect the crop any more, in which case will allow us to be rid of weeds in areas where crops

The Pros And Cons Of Genetic Engineering

1043 words - 4 pages . It is used for producing proteins which can be used by humans, such as insulin for diabetics and is also used to make organisms better at surviving, for example genetically modifying a plant so that it can survive in acidic soil.      There is debate about whether genetic engineering should be used or not, and to what degree. There are many problems that can occur from the process and many of these cannot be avoided

Pros And Cons Of Improving Humans By Genetic Engineering.

832 words - 3 pages ; therefore, enabling humans to profit from the unused health care money. Also dealing with germline engineering is basically designing your own baby (Bankston, 1999). This is very beneficial to your child because, your child wouldn't have to deal with genetic obstacles such as their physical appearance or their mental issues (Bankston, 1999). By changing your germline we could make humans be able to adapt to what is now thought of as unbearable