Conscription Crisis Position Paper Social Studies Argumentative Paper

1082 words - 5 pages

Conscription Crisis Position Paper
Shai Butler
Dear Editor,
I have recently read your editorial on the conscription crisis examining the multi-faceted perspectives that Canada faced during World War 1. This letter is in response to your position outlined in the editorial as pro conscription. However, one could argue against conscription in that it has exacerbated the state of Canada in terms of its domestic relations between the French-Canadian and English-Canadian people. Those who oppose your editorial could counter that The Military Service Act of 1917 which first enforced conscription in Canada suppressed French-Canadian culture. The Conscription Act forced Canadian men into the military service, which was predominantly English-speaking, this began to create language barriers, specifically for French-Canadians. Communication barriers and the absence of French-Canadian Regimens caused French-Canadian men to feel as though they were being attacked and involuntarily assimilated. French-Canadians were also denied the opportunity to move up the ranks as they had limited English language skills. The Manitoba Schools Act also restricted the amount of French learned in French-Canadian schools and was considered an aim towards assimilation from the Anglophones. Additionally, the conscription act was not democratic and stripped the French-Canadians of their basic needs and rights. Canada used the French-Canadians as a replacement for the English soldiers. When the English- Canadian soldiers came back home, they took over the French-Canadian’s jobs, political positions and especially their voters voice. Conscientious objectors, many of whom were French-Canadians and recent immigrants from enemy countries, were denied from voting. It further violated fundamental human rights as it forced men to essentially give up their lives and make the ultimate sacrifice for a country they lacked connection to. These French-Canadians felt little Canadian nationalism as a colony, and instead were nationalistic in their own French-Canadian heritage. Conscription asked these French-Canadian men to fight for Britain as Canada remained a British colony. However, these men had little ties to Britain and hence felt a disconnect in their motivation to fight. French-Canadians had lived generations in Canada and considered themselves as their own nation, described as Canadien. Historically, they had been independent from both Britain and France and did not feel the need to protect their sovereignty as Canadians but more specifically French-Canadians. They felt as though going to war would do little in the pursuit of what was important to them, their French-Canadian culture and heritage.
Conversely, upon examining your editorial, the arguments for conscription are strongly supported. The positive aspect of conscription is seen in how the call for enlistment fortified Canada and Britain in their war efforts during World War 1. Conscription was necessary for Canadians as it was...

Find Another Essay On Conscription Crisis Position Paper - Social Studies - Argumentative Paper

Position Paper On Heroes

701 words - 3 pages Position Paper on Heroes On September 11th 2001, New York City, Washington D.C., and Somerset County, Pennsylvania all came face to face with an unthinkable tragedy. When the emergency response teams were sent out to the sites, they had no idea what they were going to experience. They helped others to safety and then turned right back around to help someone else. These are America’s real heroes. As The United States changes because of these

position paper rough draft

767 words - 4 pages Position paper rough draft Since the beginning of the colonies, gun control has been infringed upon our society. Great Britain attempted to ban all muskets which were considered the assault rifle of the time. They then placed restrictions and tried to confiscate all gun powder and prevent it from being shipped to the colonies. The colonists then switched to black powder, which was more unstable and had to be stored in special buildings that

WTO Position Paper

1357 words - 5 pages The paper will begin with a description of the World Trade Organization (WTO) and an explanation of the key principles by which the WTO operates. An opinion will be offered about the WTO followed by a brief discussion of whether the WTO is accomplishing the organization's mission. Finally a current issue facing the WTO will be briefly outlined.What is the World Trade OrganizationThe World Trade Organization (WTO) is the only global international

Response Paper 8: Crisis Communication and Social Media

1045 words - 5 pages Prompt: Think about a crisis that occurred with a specific organization in the past couple of years. In your response paper, provide a brief (half page) summary of the crisis and organization. Then, using concepts from class, analyze the organization’s response to the crisis through social media. How did they use social media to address the crisis? Lastly, in your response, share whether or not you think the organization succeeded in addressing

Position paper on GM Food

1892 words - 8 pages develop solutions to solve the world’s hunger and malnutrition problems. Farmers can now improve the quality and quantity of their crops through the development of crops that are pest and disease resistant and herbicide tolerant.A common argument against GM food is that the products may adversely affect human health. However, this argument has no basis as there have been no studies reporting that GM food could lead to health risks

Determining Your Perfect Position Paper

1266 words - 5 pages Determining Your Perfect Position Paper PAGE 1 Determining Your Perfect Position PaperIntroductionIn this week's individual assignment, I am given the opportunity to determine the position that would best suit myself in expanding and restructuring the company I am currently employed. The assignment requires me to describe and identify jobs in my current organization that would fit my leadership style, and how it would most benefit the company

James Wilson Position Paper (Constitutional Conven

1607 words - 6 pages James Wilson Position Paper James Wilson was an important figure in the Constitutional Convention. His views and ideas were incorporated into the Constitution and helped to build the foundation of this country. His emphasized view of republicanism and representation contributed to the creation of an astounding government. He and other significant figures of the Convention shared views that helped reinforce the success of the Constitution

Position Paper: Gene Therapy in Humans

1726 words - 7 pages Position Paper: Gene Therapy in Humans Advancements in science and medicine are usually accompanied with a myriad of ethical and moral implications. The fairly recent advancement in genetics called gene therapy is no exception to the baggage of polarizing views that come with new technology. Gene therapy is an extremely hot topic in both the science world and everyday life. New technology, discoveries, and breakthroughs are rapidly occurring

Tropical Rain Forest Depletion (Position Paper)

2389 words - 10 pages produce charcoal. The paper industry uses a single manufacturing plant that consumes about 2,000 tons of surrounding rain forest wood everyday to give 55 megawatts of electricity needed to run the plant. Moreover, in the mining industry even more rain forests woods are being destroyed. Due to mining operations more lands are lost to the population as the constant water runoff in the forests carry the waste oil, mercury, and other pollutants and

Preparing my Position Paper: Topic A

1893 words - 8 pages Preparing my Position Paper: Topic A Topic: Buying-Selling Weapons to Countries in Conflict: Enforcements and Regulations of Security Measures 1. Definitions important to the topic: -Arms Trade Treaty (ATT): On April 2nd, 2013 the General Assembly voted in favor of the Arms Trade Treaty, regulating the international trade of arms, from small firearms and conventional arms to tanks, military aircrafts and warships. It has the intention of

Political Science Position Paper on Education Reform

2156 words - 9 pages Policy Paper: Educational ReformBackground:"Our [educational] system is, more than anything, an artifact of our colonial past. For religious dissenters who came to the New World, literacy was essential to religious freedom, enabling them to teach their own beliefs. Religion and Schooling moved in tandem across the Colonies. Many people who didn't like what the local minister was preaching would move on and found their own church, and generally

Similar Essays

Argumentative Paper

1758 words - 8 pages for the Iranian people, especially in social aspects such as women’s rights, educational opportunities, economic wellbeing, and individual freedom. To inform the audience about the discussion involving Iran, names and terms that are used in this paper need explanation. According to Merriam-Webster, Regime in politics is the form of government, which sets the rules, for cultural and social norms that regulate the operation of government and its

Argumentative Paper: Obesity Must Be Treated As A Social Problem

3014 words - 12 pages PAGE PAGE 1 [Author's Surname] [Author's Name][Instructor's Name][Course Title][Date of Submission]Argumentative PaperIntroductionThe prevalence of both overweight and obesity in the U.S has increased considerably over the last two decades, and studies reporting nationwide trends now abound in medical journals of all types, appearing in subspecialty as well as prominent cross-specialty journals. According to Hill et al. (p. 29), 54 percent of

Plagiarism Position Paper

2040 words - 8 pages they can do the work therefore they take others. Second, students believe they can get away with the act because they know others who have plagiarized, and there were not any consequences. Lastly, students are uneducated on what plagiarism is and do not know the consequences of their actions if they commit an act. These ideas will be the focus of the position taken on plagiarism in today’s academic society. Some may say that individuals plagiarize

Perfect Position Paper

1361 words - 5 pages leadership approach to become a more effective leader.Hinc. focuses on packaging operations where it has a competitive advantage, good market positions which create value for the company and its customers. has a good position in smooth and rough molded fiber products, release films, flexible packaging, foodservice paper cups and other products based on paper forming technology. In these operations has strong know how, technology platforms and business