Constitutionality Of Drug Testing Essay

1104 words - 4 pages

The drug testing policy is a broken system that should be eliminated, it is siphoning off funds, is fundamentally ineffective and a blatant violation of constitutional rights

Chris Hardy

English III CP


September 18, 2009

Constitutionality of Drug testing

Free Speech. Fair trials. Due process. Protection from unreasonable search and seizure. The common factor? All the latter are God-given rights, rights that Americans believe that all human are born with, rights that have been boorishly violated by the administration of our schooling system. Indeed, the youth of America are daily exposed to "an invasive policy" (Rosenbaum), a policy that fails to fulfill its sole purpose, to prevent the use of drugs. The drug testing policy is violation of American rights to privacy. The drug testing policy is a broken system that should be eliminated; it is siphoning off funds, is fundamentally ineffective and is a blatant violation of Constitutional rights.

In this climate of economic recession monetary concerns are especially prevalent ,this is why squandering school funds on drug testing is unsound. Schools "spend between 10,000-$40,000 dollars a year [on drug testing]" (Rosenbaum). Those funds, could have been allocated differently to yield much more benefit. Many school programs are suffering under the current, drug test, heavy budget. Programs such as the student senate, a program were funds are being stretched so thin, that three bake sales are not enough to pay for a field trip. That "money could be spent in a much more beneficial way" providing ailing school programs with much needed capitol to bolster programs that keep children off the street and (Rosenbaum). Indeed, 50,000 dollars could be used to raise teachers' salaries in addition to a medley of other things. Teachers over worked as it is and asking them to take on responsibility for drug testing is too much. It is a commonly held economic fact that overworking an employ is not cost effective, they will soon quit and leave a gap in bunisses structure. In addition to the internal problems schools must look at the outward effects of the testing expense. Being that the money is coming wholly from tax payers it is only a matter of time before the public notices the failure of testing and demands that tax dollars be allocated differently. Looking from an economic stand point, this is a broken investment. It is not surprising then that schools would begin consider tempting the program especially with returns on investment, the effectiveness of the tests, so low.

Testing has been extremely inadequate in its most vital department: success rate. Through the course of a year "Only one (out of an entire school) tested positive", while in the next year when more students were screened none tested positive (Leinwand). This attitude towards testing is simply not the American way; Americans strive for the highest success rates and highest...

Find Another Essay On Constitutionality of Drug testing

Employee Drug Testing (A violation of Constitutional Rights)

2313 words - 9 pages employers who use the power of the paycheck to tell their employees what they can and cannot do in the privacy of their own homes. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) along with the opponents of Employee Drug Testing believe that what a person does during non-working hours away from the workplace should not be used as a basis for discrimination. Employee drug testing is an invasion of privacy and it violates an employee's constitutional

Drug Testing is a Violation of the Fourth Amendment

3079 words - 12 pages ):18-22. 5. James, Jeannette C. "The constitutionality of federal employee drug testing." The American University Law Review, Fall 1999. 6. Kean, Leslie. "More than a hair off." The Progressive. 63 no.5, 32-34. May 1999. 7. McBay, AJ. Drug-analysis technology-pitfalls and problems of drug testing. Clin Chem. 1987;33:33B-40B. 8. Stencel, Sandra L. Issues for Debate in American Public Policy. Washington D.C.: Congressional Quarterly, 1999. 9. York, Byron. "Fast times at white house high" The American Spectator. V29, pp.20-26. 1999.

The Unfairness of Drug Testing in Low-Wage Jobs

1313 words - 5 pages cheapest drug testing there is. Twelve percent of other companies use the blood test for a more accurate reading, and hair testing is used for an even more accurate reading by about one percent of companies. Many companies believe that if they continuously drug test its employees the rate of drug use within their employees will reduce. This idea is completely incorrect considering that there are other substances workers can take "In addition

Random Drug Testing is a Waste of Time

1601 words - 6 pages “caught” with such a fickle and illusive process. Random student drug testing is not a plausible solution for the drug problem in public schools; it is unreliable and it infringes on the lives of those students involved.      Those who support random drug testing argue that the growing trend of drug testing a small population of students in a school is effective at attacking the drug abuse problem, because fewer students

Drug Testing is Not a Violation of Individual Rights

2882 words - 12 pages Every day companies lose millions of dollars due to employee drug use. Athletes break world records with gargantuan strength, but not on a fair scale. Drugs ruin the lives of users and cause injury to those who must work with users. Detection by officials is necessary to curb this problem. When does the safety for others violate the rights of drug users? Drug testing, whether in the workplace or on the athletic field, is not a violation of

The Role of Drug Testing Within Welfare Reform

2121 words - 9 pages includes a summary of the types of sources that will inform the research. This section focuses on the 3 main sources that all agree that drug testing is an important component of welfare reform. The National Household Survey for Drug Abuse is mentioned as a main source for the studies that were chosen for the research paper. A working thesis that implicates the most relevant argument based off of the initial research accompanied by the mood of the

Drug and Alcohol Testing: Do employers have the right to submit employees to drug and alcohol testing? Do these tests enfringe on the rights of employees?

1137 words - 5 pages include government employees, military personnel, those involved in the transportation industry, student athletes, and countless other employees. Both state and federal courts have been willing to extend the use of drug testing for purposes of safety, improved workplace efficiency, national security and to deter drug use.The Fourth Amendment was intended to protect the personal privacy and dignity of every citizen against unwarranted intrusions

Should people on welfare have to have drug testing?

1389 words - 6 pages federal government money, and force the welfare class to stay clean or get off of welfare which is a win-win scenario for everyone.Works CitedBudd, Jordan C. "Pledge Your Body for Your Bread: Welfare, Drug Testing, and the Inferior Fourth Amendment." William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal. William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal, 2011. Web.Newell, Walker. TAX DOLLARS EARMARKED FOR DRUGS? THE POLICY AND CONSTITUTIONALITY OF DRUG TESTING WELFARE

Should Welfare Recipients Be Drug Tested?

1286 words - 5 pages benefits. However, the question of constitutionality of the legislation, as well as the excessive cost of the testing on an already overburdened system, nullify any benefits that the law provides. Works Cited Finzel, R. (2014, March 6). Drug Testing and Public Assistance. National Conference of State Legislators. Retrieved from Goetzl, C. (2013, May 1

Drug Testing in the Workplace

3716 words - 15 pages drug testing is post accident screening. This is self explanatory and is most common in the transportation industry and is required in most cases by the federal government.      In dealing with the legality of drug testing, several questions arise. A major question surrounding employee drug testing is the constitutionality of the practice. One of the biggest constitutional questions relating to this topic deals with the issue of unreasonable

Making Drug Testing Mandatory for Welfare

1843 words - 8 pages were an option, drug testing for welfare would benefit society and the economy greatly. Another issue many Americans have with Lewis’s question of constitutionality of the search is that Americans all over the country are required to pass a drug test to be employed. This is the business’s way of saying that they do not want someone who will use the money to feed the habit of drug use. Therefore, I think it is totally reasonable that the

Similar Essays

Constitutionality Of Drug Tests Essay

1057 words - 5 pages Should citizens receiving welfare be tested for drugs before being able to receive the aid they “need”? One major problem with drug testing people who collect welfare is if it is worth the effort. Large amounts of money are needed to put people through these tests, and they may not be worth it. Some people argue that the money used to drug test recipients is higher than the amount saved by not giving out the money for welfare. One final

Drug Testing Of Student Athletes Essay

1049 words - 4 pages Drug abuse is a major problem in our society as a whole and increasingly within our youth. In recent years, many school districts have implemented student athlete drug testing programs within their schools. Athletes were targeted because student athletics are voluntary and the "athletes are often held to higher standards than other students, keeping their grades up for example" (Tantillo, Wen & Morgo, 1995, p. A22)."The issue of drug testing

Employee Drug Testing (Violation Of Constitutional Rights.)

2313 words - 9 pages employers who use the power of the paycheck to tell their employees what they can and cannot do in the privacy of their own homes. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) along with the opponents of Employee Drug Testing believe that what a person does during non-working hours away from the workplace should not be used as a basis for discrimination. Employee drug testing is an invasion of privacy and it violates an employee's constitutional

Drug Testing In Schools. The Issue Of Drug Testing In Public Schools. The Postion Is For Drug Testing And Gives Reasons And Quotas From Laws.

1354 words - 5 pages DRUG TESTING IN SCHOOLSThe issue of drug testing in public schools has become the most debated issue in the United States. This issue raises questions regarding the protection of the students' civil liberties and the moral obligations the schools have to parents, students and society. Schools are under pressure to do something about the drug use in the schools by the students. The school administrators are being forced to deal with both alcohol