This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Constitutionality Of Drug Tests Essay

1057 words - 5 pages

Should citizens receiving welfare be tested for drugs before being able to receive the aid they “need”? One major problem with drug testing people who collect welfare is if it is worth the effort. Large amounts of money are needed to put people through these tests, and they may not be worth it. Some people argue that the money used to drug test recipients is higher than the amount saved by not giving out the money for welfare. One final argument is the fact of drug tests being legal and constitutional. It is arguable that it infringes on the people’s rights to force them to undergo drug tests. Drug testing welfare recipients has its positives and negatives. Some argue that it is unconstitutional, and others argue that they use the money to buy more drugs. Drug testing welfare recipients is a major point of controversy with problems such as being worth the effort, saving money, and the legality of the tests in general.
A major issue in drug testing welfare beneficiaries is whether it is worth all the effort that is used. Drug tests take time to develop and some citizens may need the money quickly. If a facility does not have the proper technology, results for a drug test could take days to come in. Many states put forth these laws but did not execute them correctly, which resulted in them not doing well (Greenblatt 11). Much time would be needed when “....require drug testing of each and every individual…” (Aversa 16). If one was to drug test every individual, it could take decades to do all of the tests. Many people are required for drug tests with varying degrees and workplaces needed, which would cost even more money. Many different occupations would be needed to be able to apply the drug tests for citizens that apply for welfare. If a citizen fails a drug test, “When somebody tests positive, they lose their benefits immediately. They must also pay for the cost of the drug test” (Aversa 36-37). If someone has enough money to purchase drugs, then they should not need to be on welfare, and learn to use their money to support themselves or their family.
Money is another big issue in drug testing welfare recipients. If the money spent on the drug testing is more than what is given as welfare, then the idea should be vetoed. In many cases, the supplies and shelter needed to perform the drug tests costs more than the welfare delivers. Alan Greenblatt writes “...it will cost a lot of money to test everybody in order to find a small number of users” (16-18). If the amount of money given out as welfare were to increase, this would make the drug tests logical. This would also give people who managed to pass the drug tests more money to buy more drugs. This would eventually lead to them not passing the drug tests, and not receiving welfare. Some citizens argue that they do not want their taxpayer money to advocate people purchasing narcotics. Most people are skeptical about the laws, but are firm in saying they do not want raised taxes. Many members of...

Find Another Essay On Constitutionality of Drug Tests

This paper is a detailed example of the 4th amendment

651 words - 3 pages was impermissible); Ferguson v. City of Charleston, 532 U.S. 67 (2001) (hospital's warrantless drug tests of pregnant women were impermissible), while two others did not, see Atwater v. City of Lago Vista, 532 U.S. 318 (2001) (arrest for fine-only traffic offense is permissible); Illinois v. McArthur, 531 U.S. 326 (2001) (preventing occupant from entering home during execution of a search warrant is permissible).The most portentous case is

Drug Testing for Welfare Applicants Essay

2597 words - 11 pages Team TUFIA Rex Facer PMGT 684 25 October 2011 Florida Law: Drug Testing for Welfare Applicants Introduction The state of Florida recently passed a law, effective July 1, 2011, requiring the Florida Department of Children and Family Services to administer drug tests to all new applicants to the federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program. According to the law, applicants are responsible for the cost of the drug screening. This

Employee Drug Testing (A violation of Constitutional Rights)

2313 words - 9 pages the privacy of their home and employers do not have the right to punish employees for their private un-work related behavior. 3. Chandler V. Miller Chandler et al. v. Miller, 520 U.S. 305 was a case held before the United States Supreme Court concerning the Constitutionality under the Fourth Amendment of a State statute requiring drug tests of all candidates for certain state offices. In 1990 Georgia created a statute that required candidates

Employee Drug Testing (violation of constitutional rights.)

2313 words - 9 pages the privacy of their home and employers do not have the right to punish employees for their private un-work related behavior. 3. Chandler V. Miller Chandler et al. v. Miller, 520 U.S. 305 was a case held before the United States Supreme Court concerning the Constitutionality under the Fourth Amendment of a State statute requiring drug tests of all candidates for certain state offices. In 1990 Georgia created a statute that required candidates

Making Drug Testing Mandatory for Welfare

1843 words - 8 pages use comes into play. On the flip side of the constitutionality of searches, many claim that it is unconstitutional to redistribute the money without monitoring whether or not it every makes its way back into the circulation without being part of a drug deal. One possible solution would be if we were able to create some sort of system to decipher a way to suspect drug testers, or look through past records for drug and alcohol abuse. If this

Drug Testing is a Violation of the Fourth Amendment

3079 words - 12 pages drug tests were extended to the outermost sectors of society causing drugs to become a significant issue during election times, although politicians are never tested themselves. The Fourth Amendment of the Constitution was created because of the rough treatment of colonists by the British. The British restricted trade and travel and this gave way to smuggling. "British soldiers frequently conducted unrestricted house-to-house searches. People

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients

1112 words - 4 pages of Substance Abuse and Welfare Reform. Contemporary Drug Problems, 32(3) 429-455. Jayakody, R., Danziger, S., Seefeldt, K. & Pollack, H. (2004, April). Policy Brief. NPC (National Poverty Center), (2), 1-4. Newell, W. (2011). Tax Dollars Earmarked for Drugs? The Policy and Constitutionality of Drug Testing Welfare Recipients. Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 43(1), 215-254 Radel, L., Joyce, K., & Wulff, C. (2011, October). Drug Testing

High School Drug Testing

945 words - 4 pages . These drug addicts soon influence other students into doing the drugs because there isn’t a rule preventing drug use. In order to protect these student’s future, drug tests must be enforced among all students ensuring a safe environment for students to learn successfully. Allowing random drug testing in high schools will shy away students from trying these harmful drugs. The stop of drug use among high school students is crucial because drugs

Drug Testing         My first topic paper is drug testing. Drug

1007 words - 4 pages Drug Testing My first topic paper is drug testing. Drug testing is used in all fields of work, from a fast food employee to a professional athlete. Is it morally right for companies to give their employees random drug tests? I think so.This could be considered an invasion of privacy, but it is necessary for companies to be sure that everyone in the company is clean and in a safe working environment.In the profession of sports athletes get

Animal Experimentation for Medical Advancement Must be Abolished

1647 words - 7 pages procedures, genetic manipulation, or other experimental tests on humans prior to being tested on animals - would to opponents, be considered unorthodox. ("ProCon Animal Testing" 47) On a whole, the animals being subjected to such iniquities have not inflicted harm, malice, or any type of evil upon society in any way. Yet, opponents consider it ethical to perform such atrocities on them as opposed to incarcerated murderers. However, when examining

Forced Drug Testing

1277 words - 5 pages Neubauer, 2006), "requiring defendants to participate in drug testing does not reduce failure-to-appear rates" (p 241).ExpensiveTesting Options and Their ExpensesBesides being ineffective, another reason defendants should not be forced to take drug tests is that it is too expensive. Because the programs are ineffective, the drug tests are a waste of money and resources that could be used for something else. Several options are available for drug testing

Similar Essays

Constitutionality Of Drug Testing Essay

1104 words - 4 pages The drug testing policy is a broken system that should be eliminated, it is siphoning off funds, is fundamentally ineffective and a blatant violation of constitutional rights Chris Hardy English III CP T.Wecht September 18, 2009 Constitutionality of Drug testing Free Speech. Fair trials. Due process. Protection from unreasonable search and seizure. The common factor? All the latter are God-given rights, rights that Americans

Drug And Alcohol Testing: Do Employers Have The Right To Submit Employees To Drug And Alcohol Testing? Do These Tests Enfringe On The Rights Of Employees?

1137 words - 5 pages upon the facts and circumstances surrounding the search, it may be unconstitutional for an employer to require an employee to provide such a sample. The constitutionality of a drug or alcohol test depends upon the "reasonableness" of the test. What is reasonable under the Fourth Amendment depends upon the specific facts and circumstances of each case. The definition of ""reasonableness" has evolved over the years and continues to evolve. Certainly

Drug Testing In The Workplace Essay

3716 words - 15 pages percent of the employed drug users, while medium size companies, employing only twenty-five to five hundred employees, have 43 percent of the employed drug users on their payroll, and smaller companies, with fewer than twenty-five employees, provide jobs for the remaining 44 percent.      Now, why is it important for companies to perform drug tests? First, drug users are a third less productive than the average employee, and tend to take more sick

Should People On Welfare Have To Have Drug Testing?

1389 words - 6 pages and the federal government. While the federal government has no current mandatory drug testing for welfare recipients, the states have begun to implement their own. Most of these mandatory tests resulting from the cause of budget cuts (Vance). States feel that they can cut back on welfare spending by identifying those who test positive and deny them assistance. Since 2007, over half of the states have considered bills requiring aid recipients to