This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Constructive Discharge Case Essay

861 words - 3 pages

SUBJECT: Constructive Discharge Case

The recent changed in the company’s policy on shift work requiring production staff to work rotating 12-hour shifts with four days at work and then four days off to meet growing demands of customers prompted the employee to quit. The employee’s constructive discharge lawsuit claimed that the policy change is discriminatory because it requires employees to work on a religious holy day thereby creating an intolerable working condition that forced the employee to quit rather than suffer more abuse which is why constructive discharge as a legal concept is relevant to the scenario.

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects employees and job applicants of companies with 15 or more employees from the employer’s unlawful employment practice of discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, and national origin. This law also established the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), an independent federal agency that enforces laws against workplace discrimination.

Courts have developed two different tests for determining when an employee has been constructively discharged by a discriminatory employer (Finnegan, 1986):

1. The Reasonable Person Test or majority view - an employee who resigns after being subjected to unlawful discrimination is said to have been constructively discharged if a reasonable person would have found the discriminatory conditions to be intolerable.

2. The Specific Intent Test or minority view - a plaintiff must show not only that conditions were intolerable, but also that the employer created those conditions with specific intent of forcing the employee to resign.

Company Response

An employee who seeks religious accommodation must make the employer aware both of the need for accommodation and that it is being requested due to a conflict between religion and work. The employee is obligated to explain the religious nature of the belief or practice at issue, and cannot assume that the employer will already know or understand it (U.S. Equal Employment, 2008). Implementing the policy change was required for the company to increase its production to meet customer demands. The policy was implemented in good faith and was not intended to discriminate against any company employees.

The employee not only failed to communicate the need for a reasonable accommodation with the management to fulfill religious obligations but also assumed that the employer made the policy to discriminate based on the employee’s religion. The company was not aware that the problem existed and was never given the opportunity to rectify it. It was blind sided by the employee’s actions of quitting and afterwards suing for constructive discharge.

The implementation of the policy change was the result of the...

Find Another Essay On Constructive Discharge Case

reflective paper

1519 words - 7 pages from oil. Oil sand has a large economic and constructive value including road constructions. However, the toxic waste of oil sand creates more greenhouse gas emissions that would speed up global warming. In addition, the film talks about other kinds of energy uses and uses case studies to show how those energies develop in some countries. For example, the Japanese nuclear leak accident, which was caused by the earthquake, led to numerous people

Do Prisons Rehabilitate? Essay

1546 words - 6 pages offenders themselves are willing to be rehabilitated. “It is wrong therefore to say that prisons fail; it is their inmates who fail. If on discharge from prison the ex-prisoner re-offend, it confirms that a custodial sentence was right in the first place...” Norman Brennan, Director of the Victims of Crime Trust, and a 23-year serving policeman Often now, it is believed that a prison sentence is not always the most effective way of punishing an

Gender and Human Sexuality

1560 words - 7 pages development emphasizes the power of the immediate case and behaviors seen on gender-role. It determines that girls learn to be feminine and boys learn how to be masculine. A boy who puts on his father’s tie or baseball cap wins big smiles from his parents. But what if that boy started putting on lipstick or a dress? Parents, instructors, and friends usually reward or punish behaviors according to the expectations of the boy/girl. (Huffman, 2012

Human Resource and Employee Relations

1729 words - 7 pages managers and employees. By indicating that there are rewards for good performance and consequences for poor performance, progressive discipline helps to improve employee morale. Lastly, replacement costs are avoided and legal groundwork is laid for fair termination in the case that the employees performance or behavioral problems do not improve. Progressive discipline is a five step process and each employee misconduct or problem should be handled

Performance Appraisals         We have researched performance appraisals by reviewing literature

2501 words - 10 pages used as case studies today. To perform a legally sound performance appraisal, managers should follow these guidelines (Smither 83): • Should be standardized and uniform for all employees within a job group • Should be formally communicated to employees • Should provide notice of performance deficiencies and of opportunities to correct them • Should provide access for employees to review appraisal results • Should provide

Binding of contract - Prudent Bank Ltd v Freehills Antiques Pty Ltd

1915 words - 8 pages 129 assumptions is to protect outsiders who deal in good faith with persons who can reasonably be expected to have authority to act for the company. The company is not entitled to assert in proceedings in relation to the dealings that any of the assumptions are incorrect.Prudent Bank Ltd could refer their situation with the rule in Turquand's case which states that even though persons dealing with a company are taken to have constructive notice of

Maritime law,safe ports

4083 words - 16 pages trapped unless something is done quickly it get out of the port as quickly as possible. A relevant case is Evia No 2 (1982) the vessel was to use safe ports only under the charter party. The Evia was ordered to Basrah. She arrived on the 20th of August 1979.After discharge was completed on the 22nd of September. She was prevented from leaving due to the commencement of the Iran/Iraq war. The shipowner claimed damages from the charterers. In this case

Director of the Company: As per Company Act 2001, Setion 9

2982 words - 12 pages act in good faith. Has directors acted in good faith in best interest of the corporation? Relevant legal principles and cases:- SEC181of corporation act 2001States that; -A director or other officer of a corporation must exercise their powers and discharge their duties: (a) In good faith to be in the best interests of the corporation; and (b) For a proper purpose SEC 182 of corporation 2001 states that:- (1) A director

Wrongful dismissal and summary dismissal: Law problem style question

3900 words - 16 pages contracts.The law governing the issues identified is found in common law and statute, with guidance also given by relevant codes of practice. The main statute is the Employment Rights Act 1996. Although statue has largely superseded common law, where there has not been a decided case on similar facts under the statute, the court or tribunal will look to earlier common law cases. Non-statutory materials such as Codes of Practice and handbooks issued by

"Accurate and fair performance appraisal is impossible within a working environment based on teamwork"

2516 words - 10 pages performance appraisals.This is important for any human resource manager because at one time or another, they will be forced to deal with this issue on a first hand basis. There are many court cases that discuss important topics concerning performance appraisals that have been used as case studies today. To perform a legally sound performance appraisal, managers should follow these guidelines:- Should be standardized and uniform for all employees within

Mental Illness

2259 words - 10 pages treatment. In society, illness is socially defined and considered to be any sort of interference with health (Kendall 2014, 411). The functionalist perspective views mental illness as a form of deviant behavior that can be measured and organized to improve the overall order in society. The functionalist perspective sees society as made up of parts that contribute to the overall stability of the society. In this case, developing treatment for mental

Similar Essays

Sexual Harassment Essay

1458 words - 6 pages . In which case can cause a lot of effects and consequences that can be great and serious. Some might have to take lower paying jobs, lost of promotions, constructive discharge (forced to leave), stress related injuries and or mental problems. (Wall, 76) All these things are damaging. So the bottom line is at work maintain a pleasant environment do not offend people and be considerate of their feelings just because you think is not offensive someone else may. And if you think or feel you are being sexually harassed look into it and g through the proper channels to get it handled. Don't be afraid; fight for your rights to make it a better work environment for all.

Toyota Manufacturing Company Essay

1117 words - 4 pages minimum cost, effort and can save time. Thus, it will lead to improve performance and optimum utilization of the company’s additional capacity and resources. Lean Thinking Category of Waste Health Care Examples Correction (defects) Adverse drug reactions. Readmission because of inappropriate discharge. Repeating tests because of incorrect information. Waiting Waiting for doctors to discharge patients. Waiting for test results

Children's Play Essay

1306 words - 6 pages type of play in a time (NCCA, 2014). The common types of play are heuristic play, ludic play (Hutt, 1979), symbolic play, epistemic play (Hutt, 1979), role play, structured play, imaginative play, manipulative play and rough and tumble play. To take the case of symbolic play, this play is a type of play where children take one thing as another, relying on a mental picture and reconstructing it in the mind (Moyles, 2012). Symbolic play plays an

Care Plan Essay

2210 words - 9 pages This is a case study of Sarah, a 39 year old female who presented at the emergency department with her husband, who is worried about her recent behaviour. She is showing classic signs of Hypomania, which is commonly associated with Bipolar Disorder. Hypomania has distinguishing features and can be displayed with high energy levels, positive mood, irritability, inappropriate behaviour, heightened creativity and mystical experiences (Athanasos