Contrast Between Satire In The Rape Of The Lock And A Modest Proposal

1753 words - 7 pages

Contrast Between Satire in The Rape Of The Lock and A Modest Proposal

       Although Alexander Pope's, "The Rape Of The Lock" and Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" are both witty satires, they differ on their style, intention, and mood.

To begin, in "The Rape Of The Lock," Alexander Pope uses Horation satire to invoke a light, whimsical, melancholy mood to illustrate the absurdity of fighting over the cutting of one's hair. In fact, Horation satire is defined by K. Lukes as a device that is: " urban, smiling, witty" and "seeks to correct the human foibles." and is further reiterated in The Concise Oxford Dictionary Of Literary terms as: "Horation satire, often contrasted with the bitterness of Juvenalian satire, is a more indulgent, tolerant treatment of human inconsistencies and follies, ironically amused rather than outraged" (101). Thus, Alexander Pope's intentions in writing "The Rape Of The Lock" was to turn an actual incident in which: "A young man Lord Petre, had sportively cut off a lock of a Miss Arabella Fermor's hair,"(Poetry, 211) into "jest ... so that good relations (and possibly negotiations toward a marriage between principals) might be resumed" (Poetry, 211) This type of satire is conveyed through Pope's use of mock epic form.

This satire first begins with Pope's invocation to the muses, a higher power, emphasizing that the tragedy about to occur is above mere worldly issues, and a debate that belongs amongst the gods. Hence, Pope writes: "What dire offense from amorous causes springs, / What mighty contests rise from trivial things, I sing-This verse to Caryll, Muse! is due" (English,1110). It is comical that the "dire offense" is the cutting of Belinda's hair rather than a life-threatening catastrophic event, such as the fall of a kingdom.

Furthermore, the muse Pope refers to is a direct reference to John Caryll who was a relative of Lord Petre and a friend of Pope in the similar incident involving the cutting of Miss Arabella Fermor's hair (Poetry, 211). Of course, such an event is viewed by Pope as foolishness: an idiotic event which has no bearing on the movement, creation, or destruction of the universe. In fact, a calamity in which the worst consequence is that Belinda has a "sister lock" that "now sits uncouth, alone" (English, 1125).

Thus, the intent of Pope is not to be invective or bitter but rather to give insight to the comical nature of the event, to bring to light that the universe does not move to the cutting of one's hair and that to have such a mistaken belief is foolhardy. This mockery and satire of aristocratic society is revealed by Pope throughout the poem: Belinda is depicted as a heroine goddess whose beauty causes "The tortoise here and elephant unite, / Transformed to combs, the speckled and the white" (English,1113). Furthermore,her trinkets are depicted as being spoils and ornaments of war, as one would use to prepare for battle: "files of pins extend their shining...

Find Another Essay On Contrast Between Satire in The Rape Of The Lock and A Modest Proposal

The Use of Satire in A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift

832 words - 3 pages A Modest Proposal In “A Modest Proposal” several forms of satire are demonstrated throughout the story. Satire is defined as the use of humor, irony, exaggeration, or ridicule to expose or criticize people’s stupidity or vices. (Google) In "A Modest Proposal" Swift uses parody which is a form of satire. Parody is primarily making fun of something to create a humorous feel for it. In “A Modest Proposal,” Swift uses parody to make fun of the

Dunciad: Mock epic and parallels to Rape of the Lock (another satire)

667 words - 3 pages effect on men to show the social class he is in that it fails to rise to the epic standards. It shows that society is petty where the literary grandeur ought to be. The Dunciad is far more serious than that Rape of the Lock, which causes it to share more things in common with serious epic tales, but in the same way it exposes the ulterior motives and the censorship going on under a “distinguished” society order. He uses the impending courtroom to

Literary Satire in “A Modest Proposal”

895 words - 4 pages In the mid-18th century, Ireland was a country stricken by severe poverty. Governed largely by a few wealthy English landowners, the Irish masses faced high taxation, food shortage, and over population. In “A Modest Proposal,” Jonathan Swift suggests a radical solution to Ireland’s poverty problem by means of consuming Irish infants. By using heavy literary satire to demonstrate the economic and religious prejudice surrounding Ireland

Satire in Swift's A Modest Proposal

997 words - 4 pages Satire in Swift's A Modest Proposal Swift's aim of his proposal is to expose the cruelty of the rich landlords of Ireland, who were not being aware of the poverty and suffering of the Irish people. Swift's proposal is an attempt to suggest a remedy of Ireland's situation by shocking those who are powerful enough to inflict change on Ireland's appalling circumstances

Satire, Humor, and Shock Value in Swifts' A Modest Proposal

1765 words - 7 pages Satire, Humor, and Shock Value in Swifts' A Modest Proposal Swift's message to the English government in "A Modest Proposal" deals with the disgusting state of the English-Irish common people. Swift, as the narrator expresses pity for the poor and oppressed, while maintaining his social status far above them. The poor and oppressed that he refers to are Catholics, peasants, and the poor homeless men, women, and children of

A Modest Proposal to Rid Our Country of the Homeless (Satire)

1449 words - 6 pages I am sure that you agree that in our country it would be an offence to provide for someone who intrudes on the many firms that have business in our country. Therefore, tell me this: Why is it acceptable to give money to a person who destroys the public image, sleeps on the property of something that is not theirs, and is not increasing our GDP? To see these homeless people on the streets of our cities, is NOT such a

Satire in A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift

905 words - 4 pages common realities that were relatable and indisputably true, “A Modest Proposal” resonated with the Irish community of the time. In modern times, popular satire seems to be about more trivial subject matter, but is nevertheless just as effective as works of Swift’s time. We can make fun of John McCain’s age, Bill Clinton’s love for women, and Hillary’s pantsuits; such jokes have appeared on magazine covers countless times. However, when it comes to

18Th Century Satire: A Modest Proposal

1402 words - 6 pages . Writers, such a Jonathan Swift, have commonly used satire to discuss important issues about the follies of governments, persons and social issues. It has been said that “although it (satire) is usually subtle in nature, it is used to bring light to contemporary societal problems and provoke change within a culture” (Friedman). One of the world’s best known pieces of satire is Jonathan Swift’s A Modest Proposal. This piece of work aimed to expose the

Concerns Jonathon Swift's use of satire in "A Modest Proposal." Describes how in this story caustic wit becomes the means to critique society to a more receptive and entertained audience

1425 words - 6 pages gone through by the oppression of landlords, the impossibility of paying rent without money or trade, the want of common sustenance, with neither house nor clothes to cover them from the inclemencies of weather, and the most inevitable prospect of entailing the like or greater miseries upon their breed forever. (Swift 224)In conclusion, Jonathon Swift's "Modest Proposal" uses satire to force Irish society as a whole to ponder a solution for an

The differences between eighteenth-century literature and romantic poems, with respect to history seen through the influental works of 'The Rape of Lock.' by Alexander Pope and 'The Eve of St. Agnes.'...

1279 words - 5 pages The differences between eighteenth-century literature and romantic poems, with respect to history is constituted here. This is seen through the influential works of John Keats and Alexander Pope. These works are acknowledged as, 'The Rape of Lock' and 'The Eve of St. Agnes.' Alexander Pope takes his readers on a hatred filled epic. A robust piece of literature and love induced psychoses in, 'The Rape of Lock.' On the other hand, 'The Eve of St

Similarities between Martin Luther King's Letter from Birmingham Jail and Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal

1821 words - 7 pages Even the most cursory analysis of "Letter From Birmingham Jail" by Martin Luther King, Jr. and "A Modest Proposal" by Jonathan Swift reveals glaring differences between the two essays. Surprisingly, a side-by-side comparison also yields many similarities between the two works. The most obvious similarity between the two essays is the overarching theme of the subject matter. In both essays, the writers address deeply-entrenched social

Similar Essays

"Rape Of The Lock", A Satire

2656 words - 11 pages able to die and be "revived" by the frowns and smiles of a lady. Pope is thus parodying his society in calling the beau "a hero slain", for it is obvious that there is nothing heroic in the frivolous flirtations between the men and women Britain's high society.Throughout Pope's mock epic poem, The Rape of the Lock, there is a constant inversion of epic conventions such as great heroes, G-Ds and battles to trivial people, beings and actions that

Different Use Of Poetic Device To Achieve One Goal In "The Rape Of The Lock" Alexander Pope, "A Modest Proposal" Jonathan Swift, "Candide" Voltaire

788 words - 3 pages Swift and Voltaire used different styles to send the message to their readers.In "The rape of the lock" Alexander Pope uses mock epic to show human vanity and how sometimes people should be able to laugh at things instead of making it into a big deal. Every epic has a god and goddesses to interfere in human matters, in this one Pope introduces "sylphs" to protect Belinda's curl. When the guys are playing cards, pope showed and described it in a mock

Satire And The Deployment Of Irony In A Modest Proposal By Jonathan Swift

2752 words - 11 pages Satire and the Deployment of Irony in A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift Therefore let no man talk to me of other expedients: of taxing our absentees at 5s. a pound: of using neither clothes, nor household furniture, except what is of our own growth and manufacture: of utterly rejecting the materials and instruments that promote foreign luxury: of curing the expensiveness of pride, vanity, idleness, and gaming in our women: of

Satire Of A Modest Proposal Essay

1395 words - 6 pages aspersions on his intended audience. Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” employs despicably vivid satire to call for change in a world of abuse and misfortune. The entire proposal stands as a satire in itself; an analogy paralleling the tyrannical attitude of the British toward their Irish counterparts and the use of babies as an economic commodity. In short, Swift suggests that Irish parents are owned by the British, and babies are property