Comparison Of Three First World War Poems

1897 words - 8 pages

Comparison of Three First World War Poems

The three poems that I will be studying in this essay are “Dulce Et
Decorum Est” by Wilfred Owen, “Comrades: An Episode” by Robert Nichols
and “Who’s For The Game?” by Jessie Pope. These poems are about the
First World War and two of them seem to have a negative attitude
criticising and downgrading the so-called spectacular experience of
the First World War. In “Dulce Et Decorum Est” Wilfred Owen seems to
mention good aspects of the War but compares them to low-class tragic
events. In “Comrades: An Episode” Robert Nichols describes the event
of a soldier being badly injured and eventually dying. It describes
what the corporals and soldiers did and how they reacted to the
situation. However, Jessie Pope’s poem “Who’s For the Game?” talks
about war as if it is a joke and the scary aspect of the war is taken
away.

In each poem a different picture emerges in one’s head. In “Dulce Et
Decorum Est” similes are used quite regularly to create dreamlike
settings and haunting images that provide a vivid picture of the
realities of warfare. To the general public soldiers were seen as
heroes but the first line of this poem ruins that image by describing
the soldiers as

“Bent double, like old beggars under sacks”.

This line creates a grim image of the soldiers portraying them to be
weak and helpless. Other similes are used to create a similar effect
in this poem. Another line, which relates to a soldier, is

“His hanging face, like a devil’s sick of sin”
==============================================

Which shows how fed up and emotionally tired this particular soldier
must have been to be compared to the extent of a devil being sick of
sin. It is a powerful comparison as the devil lives for sin – this
creates an image of how extreme the situation would have been. In the
second poem, “Comrades: An Episode” the same picture comes to mind by
using different techniques. The poem is written in the style of a
story, which gives the writer more opportunity to include descriptions
and details. In this poem the narrator is the leader of a group of
men and he mentions names and, as he knows his men so well, he can
create and describe vivid pictures of them, such as “Not to see them:
Wilkinson, Stubby, Grim.” Other ways he describes his men is by the
speech they use regularly. “Who’s For the Game?” shows the thoughts
that Jessie Pope has towards the war; she views the war as very
straight forward and simple; join the army, fight, win, then go home.
There is some reality points in the text even though they are
understated, such as;

'It won't be a picnic - not much',

and

'Come back with a crutch'.

This second quote is very misleading, Pope is saying that a crutch is
the about the worst thing that could happen when...

Find Another Essay On Comparison of Three First World War Poems

World War 1 poems by Wilfred Owen - a comparison

1284 words - 5 pages World War 1 poems by Wilfred OwenThe pity of war, the pity war distilled.Wilfred Owen, 1918Wilfred Owen wrote a draft for a war poem shortly after war broke out entitled 'the Ballad of Peace and War'. It is ironic because it greatly contrasts with his later work. It can explain the naivety of him about war before joining up. The aim and effect of the poem is very patriotic and shows he is very proud and loves his country. "...their bodies of men

Origins of First World War Essay

719 words - 3 pages There are many origins of the First World War. For this essay I will cover just two or three of them. An important factor leading up to the First World War was the assassination of the Archduke Franz Ferdinand. The archduke and his wife Sophie were assassinated by Gavrilo Princip, a Serbian, on the 28th June 1914. This appeared to be a catalyst to the war.Archduke Franz Ferdinand was the heir to the Austrian throne. The Austrian - Hungarians

To what extent is Laurence Binyon’s ‘For the Fallen’ typical of the way the anthology’s poems present those who died in the first world war war?

596 words - 2 pages Sadie Callison To what extent is Laurence Binyon's 'For the Fallen' typical of the way the anthology's poems present those who died in the war? The way Stallworthy's Oxford Book of War Poetry presents those who have died in the war is typical to the poem 'For the Fallen' by Laurence Binyon. Compared to other poems regarding death in the anthology, 'For the Fallen' presents the deaths of those who fought in the war in a prestigious way

Three Causes of World War I

2478 words - 10 pages ). Imperialism, which began to emerge around the turn of the 20th century also played a decisive role. Fights over the colonies contributed to the establishment of complex set of international alliances, which helped to destabilize the European balance of power and when combined with the third factor - instability in the Balkan region - inevitably sparked off the First World War. Besides the three main causes, they were also

Choose three contrasting poems that you feel show the difference in the attitudes and experiences of those people who were part of World War One.

1938 words - 8 pages Choose three contrasting poems that you feel show the difference in the attitudes and experiences of those people who were part of World War One. Analyse them in relation to how they demonstrate the experiences and feelings towards war at the time.The three poets that I am choosing to write about are, Wilfred Owen, Thomas Hardy, and Rupert Brooke. The reason that the three poems contrast is the tone and content of the poem. Rupert Brooke had

Causes of the First World War

1399 words - 6 pages militaristic alliances. These changes in Europe lead to a war which the world will never forget.Many alliances were formed during the years leading up to World War I. The first was in 1872, when Otto van Bismarck, prime minister of Germany, formed the Three Emperor's League. This brought together Germany, Russia, and Austria-Hungary. Ten years later, Bismarck found another country to add to his list of alliances. Bismarck took advantage of Italy's

The Origins of the First World War

2048 words - 8 pages The Origins of the First World War The study of diplomatic history has led to many different theories on the origins of the First World War. Each historian focuses on different aspects of the events preceding the war. In viewing them from a different time periods, many come to radically different conclusions. For example, the theory of German responsibility proposed directly after the war was soon revised with the

Origins of the First World War

1600 words - 7 pages The First World War was an international conflict which erupted in July 1914 involving various nations across the world. Many historians and those who have studied the Great War tend to give varied opinions as to what initially sparked the outbreak. However, although these opinions between researchers differ, they do all tend to revolve around the hostility between the great powers of Europe, the violent assassination of the Austro-Hungarian

Origins of the First World War

1971 words - 8 pages plan for power sharing has been shaped by various historical and economical events, many of which are still very important in current politics. One of the first events that influenced Scotland to want a devolved parliament was when a Scotland bill was introduced into the House of Commons just before the 1979 referendum. The Scotland bill was established because Scotland had a particularly poor network of MP’s in place within the parliament, and

World War Three

2380 words - 10 pages first glimmer of peril because the United States abandoned its isolationist views. Following World War II, the United States was determined at the Yalta Conference to make effective decisions that would make the prospect of a World War III impossible. However, the United States had a waning leader at the Yalta Conference, as President Roosevelt’s polio was becoming progressively worse. Weakened in health but trying to come to a decent decision

A Comparison of World War I and World War II

980 words - 4 pages A Comparison of World War I and World War II World War I and World War II, while started by much of the same worldwide tensions, had drastically different results because of the much more destructive nature of World War II

Similar Essays

Compare The Descriptions Of The Society Of '1984' And 'brave New World' In The First Three Chapters Of Each Book. Huxley And Orwell Comparison.

1625 words - 7 pages follow religiously its prominent and tyrannical leaders. In '1984' social control is carried out from an early age, training children to follow commands, which is evidently similar to the Hitler Youth association set up during the Second World War. By controlling all children they have yet to develop prominent memories, a close link between parent and child can be severed and are easily taught to believe what is right."Both of them were dressed

Exploring Different Types Of Love In Three Poems: A Woman To Her Lover, When We Two Parted And First Love

2798 words - 11 pages Exploring Different Types of Love in Three Poems: A Woman to Her Lover, When We Two Parted and First Love There is a wide variety of the types of love with different aspects to the effects and meaning of love. This makes it harder to define them. There is your first love, which is the first person who have fell in love with properly, you can be any age, young or old, you r past relationships have been flings or you may just

I Am Going To Study Three Love Poems. The First One Is Called First Love

1129 words - 5 pages I am going to study three love poems. The first one is called First Love by John Clare How does poet’s writing before 1900 use language to write about different types of love? Consider three love poems, two of which must be by the same poet. In this piece of coursework I am going to study three love poems. The first one is called “First Love” by John Clare; this poem is a very simple, sweet poem about a mans first love of his life

Critically Asses Three Major Causes Of The First World War

2378 words - 10 pages strong sense of nationalism: all wanted superiority over the others, all wanted to expand their territory, acquire new colonies, and have superior armies... Inevitably, this led to conflicts, which in turn led to the Great War.There were many influences and factors leading to the First World War, but from the above analysis we can see that three causes can be isolated as having been determining causes: political alliances, militarism and