This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparison On The Polybius, From Punic Wars And Ssu Ma Chi’en, Records Of The Historian.

1175 words - 5 pages

At the end of the third century B.C., there were two independent and strong powers existing separately at the southeast of China in Asia and at the core area of Mediterranean in Europe, the Han dynasty and Rome. They have both reached the high point of the contemporary civilizations. Also, they formed their empires by defeating their own hostile forces. There are significant differences between the two great empires in their process of birth, growth and perfection, ruling ideologies and institutions and so on.
Before discovering and comparing these two civilizations, we have to enhance our understanding on the authors of these two excerpts that lead people to reveal the unknown yet attractive history of Rome and Han dynasty. Polybius described and portrayed Rome at the End of the Punic Wars in his history sourcebook. “Polybius’ importance rests no small extent on the importance of his theme—the rise of Rome,” said by Frank William Walbank who wrote the book “Polybius”. Polybius lived in the critical period of the three Punic wars between Carthage and Rome and was present at the destruction of Carthage and Corinth. Also he is one of the officers in the Achaean League that works on the independence of Peloponnesus against the Romans. The experience of Polybius made him the most reliable ancient historians during this period.
On the other hand, Ssu-ma Ch’ien was another major figure in the Chinese historians. He carried on the work that his father Ssu-ma Tan left to record the contemporary history and developed it into a history masterpiece called “Records of The Historian” that encompassed the history of China and the world seen from China from the founding of the state down to his own time. He sets a standard for objective history and makes his book one of the most authoritative materials for us to get a glimpse on the Han dynasty.
One of the most obvious differences between the Rome and Han dynasty is the way they build their supremacy. Rome has existed for nearly three hundreds as a republic country when it started three Punic Wars against Carthage. But only by defeating the Carthaginians did they control the west area of Europe. D. W. Baronowski pointed out that “Romans attacked the Carthaginians after resolving initially to displace, and later to destroy them utterly.”(1995) Roma has conquered the last of the civilized world by the end of the third Punic War. Polybius analyzed the reasons that Carthage is conquered by Rome from the differences in armies and beliefs. With respect to the military science like fighting skills, Carthaginians are better than Romans because they have derived such skills from their ancestors. However, in the aspects of army disciplines and compositions, Romans have a more advanced and mature system. Roman soldiers are divided into different companies by their ages and physical condition. The youngest and of the lowest condition are set apart into light-armed troops. These people who are in the age are selected as...

Find Another Essay On Comparison on the Polybius, From Punic Wars and Ssu-ma Chi’en, Records of the Historian.

These are great study notes on the Punic Wars

525 words - 2 pages The Punic Wars NotesThe Punic Wars was a series of three wars fought between Rome and Carthage for a period of 118 years. Rome, one of the sides of these wars, was a immense empire whose influence covered much of the known world at the time. Carthage, the other player in the Punic Wars, was a city state on the North Coast of Africa which had partial control over Sicily before wars and whose location was ideal for trading ground in the

How the Punic Wars Changed Rome and Carthage

1343 words - 6 pages How the Punic Wars Changed Rome and Carthage The Punic Wars were a series of wars that destroyed an empire. The three wars were fought between Rome and Carthage. The First Punic War started in 264 B.C. with a dispute over land in Sicily. These wars had a major effect showing that Rome was a dominant force. These wars also gave Rome land stretching from Italy down the eastern coast of Spain and through northern Africa until Carthage, Tunisia

Carthago Delenda Est: Who Caused the Punic Wars?

1848 words - 7 pages In his account of the Punic Wars, Polybius declares “it is my contention that by far the most important part of historical writing lies in the consideration of the consequences of events, their accompanying circumstances, and above all their causes.” Polybius recognized the intricate relationship between circumstances, causes, and their consequences, and in his account of the Punic Wars he seeks to explain the reasons for Rome’s victory over

A Comprehensive Comparison of the Iraq and Vietnam Wars

2699 words - 11 pages officially declared by Congress. Second, both wars involved the protection of a political belief. The Vietnam War was in essence, a war on Communism, and a war to protect the democracy of South Vietnam. The Iraq War, at its core level, was a war to replace the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein with a democratic government.These wars have also both received very similar receptions from the citizens of America and other countries. The Vietnam War was

Analytical Bibliography on Hannibal and the Second Punic War

1807 words - 7 pages with no commentary, side notes or analysis. Grant does provide some of his own opinions on Hannibal's character and possible reasons for his eventual defeat, which I will discuss after first drawing out an outline of the Second Punic War.The Second Punic War, fought between Carthage and the Roman Republic from 218-202 BC, was the final major Carthaginian military opposition to Rome's dominance in the Mediterranean. Hannibal, born in 247 as the

Effects Of The Persian Wars On Sparta And Athens

337 words - 2 pages , causing the beginning of the Persian Wars.The Athenians praised the gods, mainly Zeus and Athena, for the winnings in the war. Winning gave Athens confidence even though the war caused Athens to be left in ruins. The Athenians went on to produce their amazing civilization. One of the most important results of the wars was that Athens was established as the dominant Greek naval power. This gave Athens the opportunity to create a widespread empire

An analysis of a comparison and contrast on the characters Ferdinand from Tempest and Lady Macbeth from Macbeth

1068 words - 5 pages Shakespeare was the absolute man of his time during the medieval ages in which he lived. Actually, his plays began to be famous far after his death, which has resulted in a lasting legacy for his writings. He has composed an incredible amount of plays that have almost all continued on to be performed. Two more commonly known plays of his are The Tempest, and Macbeth. These are two very diverse plays that have a completely separate plot

The Importance of Good Leadership Expressed in The Histories of Polybius

1534 words - 6 pages . Thucydides describes Themistocles as one of the “most famous people of [his] day” and a “man . . . of unmistakable natural genius . . . [who] beyond all other [leaders] deserves admiration” (Thucydides 1.138). Herodotus commends Themistocles for his practical thought process on occasions such as the way that he persuaded the Athenians to use the money from the Laurium mines to build two hundred war ships, which turned out to be a very useful

How mexican american historians tell the history of america from a different perspective from the standard angle historian standpoint

634 words - 3 pages The contribution that Mexican Americans have made to the history of the United States of America have been omitted from our school books, and for that matter from all other media. As far as the American society at large knows, Mexican Americans had little or nothing to do with the development of our beloved country. Being that most, if not all of what we 'know' of history are words, and descriptions according to an Anglo historian. Most

Analysis of Articles on The Chichimeca Wars

2462 words - 10 pages the Spanish settling in the future. This stand by the Chicimeca people is significant to the conquering of the Aztecs as it was one of the last attempts made by a native group to stand up against the invaders that were the Spanish colonizing Mexico. Overall the article on the Chichimeca Wars is reliable in providing details about the subject. All the major points do have citations from reliable and trustworthy sources, and contains some sources

The Impact of Technology on Wars

1875 words - 8 pages more important than soldiers. World War II is the junction point of the past and future. To see how the technology played a more and more important role in World War II, four critical battles are picked from different stages of the war to be analyzed. They represent the early stage, middle stage, and final stage. This chronological approach allows us to see the gradual but increasing impacts technology had on the outcome of the battles. The

Similar Essays

Carthage And The Punic Wars Essay

1194 words - 5 pages . These wars lasted off and on from 246 BC to 149 BC, with Carthage eventually being destroyed.      The First Punic War started in 264 BC and lasted to 241 BC. In the first half of the 3rd century BC Carthage held many territories that made it easy to control and dominate the western Mediterranean Sea. However, when they conquered Messana on the north eastern tip of Sicily, in 263, they faced the Romans for ware for the

The Punic Wars Essay

1186 words - 5 pages The Punic Wars were made of three major wars. The last war was kind of a punishment for Carthage from Rome. The two powers in these wars were Rome and Carthage. Rome was controlling the main peninsula of Italy while Carthage was controlling the islands and trade of the Mediterranean. Rome and Carthage were once on a friendly term until things went south well. The Punic Wars have major historical content that involve both leaders on opposite side

The Punic Wars Essay

992 words - 4 pages civilization. Essentially, the conflict arose from the clash of economic interests. The Carthaginians wished to protect commercial basis of power, while the Romans committed themselves to expansion (Marcel Le Glay 2009, 73). Carthage would lose the First Punic War, the result of this loss would cause vast amount of reprirations paid to Rome and a social revolt amongst its own people. Rome on the other hand would grow even more powerful, gaining land

Analysis Of The Three Punic Wars

816 words - 4 pages The first Punic war started like this...Tradition holds that Phoenician settlers from the Mediterranean port of Tyre founded the city-state of Carthage on the northern coast of Africa, around 814 B.C. By 265 B.C. Carthage was the wealthiest and most advanced city in the region, as well as its leading naval power. Though Carthage had clashed violently with several other powers in the region, its relations with Rome were historically friendly, and