Contrasting Individualism And Collectivism Essay

621 words - 2 pages

Individualism-collectivism
Lukes (1973) first introduced the constructs of collectivism and individualism. Collectivism centers on the collective group and values interdependence, whilst individualism centers on the
individual and values independence (Luke,1973). In a literature review, Triandis (1993) introduced the idea of collectivism and individualism as `cultural syndromes´. He identifies a cultural
syndrome as the tendency of little within-group variance for cultural elements such as values, norms and beliefs within a group which also shares language and geographical location, when these
elements centre on a particular theme.
There is considerable evidence for the links between Western societies and individualism and between Eastern cultures and collectivism (Heinrich, Heine & Norenzayan, 2010). Triandis, McCusker & Hui (1990) found that members of Eastern cultures perceive their in-group as more homogenous than the out-group, compared to members of Western cultures. Furthermore, they found that members of Eastern cultures value the well being of the in-group over their personal goals, whilst members of Western cultures typically value the individuals welfare and goals over the well being of their in-group. Examples of Western cultures that have been found to have high levels of individualism are Germany (Darwish & Huber, 2003), the US (Kim & Markus, 1999), Norway (Birkelund, 2000; Syverstad, 2009), Australia, Great Britain and France (Hosfstede, 1980).
Smith and Bond (1993) suggest acculturation is constantly proceeding in the direction of individualism, consequently moving away from collectivistic values. In support of this, a
longitudinal study by Hofstede (1980) found that individualism significantly increased over four years, across forty countries. Furthermore, individualism is commonly referred to as a product of the modernized society (Heinrich et al., 2010), which, is supported by statistical tendencies of
individualistic themes in Western cultures and collectivistic themes in Eastern cultures (Triandis, 1993), as well as the rapid increase in individualistic attitudes across cultures (Hofstede, 1980). In support of this, Hofstede (1980) found evidence that modernity of a...

Find Another Essay On Contrasting Individualism and Collectivism

TV Commercial's Impact on Global Cultural Values in Malaysia

2076 words - 8 pages TV Commercials Influence on Global and Local Cultural Values based on New Paradigms in Research Methodology INTRODUCTION This is a study about TV commercials and how it plays a role in influencing the global and local cultural values of a society. The purpose of this study is to identify the type of values that TV commercials in Malaysia portrayed, whether it is individualism, which usually associated to Western cultural values, or collectivism

Pros and Cons of American Individualism: What Is the Ideal American Citizen?

1130 words - 5 pages What is American Individualism? Do we really know? Explaining individualism may seem impossible considering it relies solely on your opinion of the topic itself. Individualism and collectivism are two key points in our society. Are we individuals by having our own body, own mind and own life, or are we simply individuals that surround ourselves around individuals as a group? To everyone there are pros and cons to both and everyone has their own

Individualism, The Only Way. Persuasive Essay with Background on the Book: "The Giver"

1109 words - 4 pages would like to say that from any point of view individualism is the way for nations to develop, and that it surpasses the old-fashioned form of ruling (collectivism), that was almost totally eradicated from the governments of the whole world, thanks to the arguments that never fail: facts; in this case, the economical, social and political depression that nations suffered because of it. In addition, I would like to make a call to nations, voting

Embracing Collectivism

709 words - 3 pages Is an individual’s opinion more important than the consensus of the whole? I everyone agreed on one matter in society, it would benefit the majority of the people. Above all, collectivism drives society to contribute to the common good. People could be further altruistic and subsidiary towards others. On the contrary, individualism encourages only self-encouragement and turns society apart. Collectivism conveys the value of the whole and binds

Individualism Our Future?

785 words - 4 pages property. In Canada, Aboriginal peoples believe their traditional cultures as collective one. In matters such as land holding, decision making, and educating and raising children, many Aboriginal cultures emphasize thinking and acting collectively to achieve what is best for the common good. At some degree Canada was based and developed on a mix of collectivism and individualism. In the late 1960’s it transitioned into more of individualism type

Individualism or Collectivism in Society

1152 words - 5 pages Debate Question: Which ideological group has had the greatest impact on modern society? Individualism or Collectivism. Terms: Individualism-> when you value the freedom and worth of the individual, sometimes over the security and harmony of the group or a belief in the importance of the individual and the virtue of self-reliance and personal independence Collectivism-> is basically when you think that values and the goals of

China: A Cultural Examination

1792 words - 8 pages the United States of America. This comparison will be accomplished by examining four cultural dimensions or aspects of communication. For convenience and clarity, the presentation of these dimensions will be broken down into four subsections: power distance, individualism/collectivism, high-context/low-context communication, and proxemics. It should be noted upfront that the cultural dimensions discussed in this paper represent general tendencies

What is culture? What effect does culture have on the conduct of business? Explain, giving examples

1388 words - 6 pages Table of Contents1.0 Introduction p. 22.0 How can culture be defined p. 22.1 Breaking down definition of culture p. 22.1.1 The outer layer p. 32.1.2 The middle layer p. 32.1.3 The core p. 33.0 Individualism and Collectivism p. 43.1 Individualism p. 43.1 Collectivism p. 54.0 The effect on the core layer of culture - Individualism and Collectivism- on the conduct of business p. 54.1 The effect on strategy for interpersonal relationships p. 64.2

Federalism - The Perfect Balance of Individual and Collective Interest

1031 words - 4 pages peers, serving their own interests, influence such a moral foundation -- is characterized by an awareness of one's role individually and as part of the collective. In other words, a morally sound individualist can never be a "greedy, back-stabbing capitalist" unless unfairly coerced. Collective Political Philosophy (or social political philosophy). Just as individualism is the political philosophy that best serves the individual, collectivism

Cultural Issues and the Psychological Framework

645 words - 3 pages based on five dimensions of psychology to offer some understanding of different cultural issues (Ahlstrom & Bruton, 2010, p. 47). Applying the Cultural Framework Hofstede based his framework on five basic dimensions – power distance, individualism collectivism, uncertainty avoidance, production orientation, and Confucian dynamism (Ahlstrom & Bruton, 2010, p. 47). Some of these dimensions can be used to analyze some of the different cultural issues

What is Individualism? Is it Good Or Bad?

1473 words - 6 pages Individualism, Good or bad? America is filled with two types of people, people who tell you to be yourself and do whatever you want in life, and then there are also those people who try and tell you what you should be and what you should do in life. Individualism and collectivism are conflicting views of the nature of humans. By comparing the pros and cons of individualism, we will have a clear view of the American citizen. There are many

Similar Essays

A Paper Which Analyzes The Elements Of Individualism And Collectivism That Exist In The Controversial Topic Of Cloning

1477 words - 6 pages are worried that any"government restrictions on human cloning might hurt their chances someday for bearing children through new medical technology" ( Newsday, ThomasMaier, 03/14/1997). In a form of expressive individualism, Tom Buckowski,from Studio City, California said, "It's my body, my choice, right? Butwhat if I want my body cloned and warehoused for spare parts? Upon whatbasis can government decide what I can or cannot do with my body

American Individualism In Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper And The Raven, By Edgar Allan Poe

1018 words - 5 pages Do you know what American Individualism means? Are you an individualist? Discussing these issues and topics are very important because individualism or collectivism is a lifestyle and depends directly how you look at it. American Individualism is a key term used today in our society. Today, people are turning individualism into collectivism, yet trying to hold on to both at the same time. Depending on who you are and what you believe, you will

Collectivism And Children In Ayn Rand’s Anthem

675 words - 3 pages interdependence of every human. Collectivism is a basic cultural element that exists as the reverse of individualism in human nature (in the same way high context culture exists as the reverse of low context culture). Collectivist orientations stress the importance of cohesion within social groups (such as an "in-group", in what specific context it is defined) and in some cases, the priority of group goals over individual goals. Collectivists often

American Individualism In The Yellow Wallpaper, By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

703 words - 3 pages What is individualism? Individualism is to be self-reliant, and a better principle of being independent. The typical American, most of the time, consider themselves as a independent “individual”. Arguably, most Americans are in the middle of individualism, and collectivism. In today’s society our generation is in the middle of individualism and collectivism. Which is a paradox, because how can we be one thing but then turn around and be