This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Contrasting Public Administration With New Public Management

1482 words - 6 pages

There is a grey distinction between the public and private sector in OECD countries with private sector organisations moving further toward delivering public goods and services as well as an increasing social responsibility often reported as triple bottom line. The aim of this paper is to contrast the traditional model of public administration with the developing New Public Management (NPM) phenomena. Briefly defining the concepts, the focus will be on the reasoning behind the shift to NPM coupled with the critical issues and successes of its evolution and implementation from an Australian Federal context.There is a plethora of evidence demonstrating a wave of reform in public administration commencing in the early 1980's. (Davis & Rhodes, 2000; Hughes, 2003) To critically review and contrast the reasons behind this reform, it is important to first of all understand the traditional bureaucracy of public administration.According to Hughes (2003), traditional public administration is based on bureaucracy while NPM, or managerialism, is based on markets. Public administration was referred to as the services that are government funded with its purpose to serve the democratically elected government of the day under the Westminster model. (Davis & Rhodes, 2003) Public administration grew slowly from British origins and American influence. Early 20th century saw the public service boards and commissioners identifying problems within the Commonwealth public service. The key components of this model were evident until the 1970's and included: a) independent control of the public service; b) open competition for entry and independent control of employment conditions; c) defined rights and obligations by employees; d) merit based promotion usually through seniority; e) remuneration based on work value, graded and classified; f) job security providing the ability to give frank and fearless advice. (Olsen, 2005; Peters, 1996) Critics ensue that traditional public administration is overly bureaucratic, costly, cumbersome; process driven, rule based and detached from civil society's requirements and sensitivities. (Jones & Kettle, 2003)Nevertheless, the Australian public expect the Federal Government to manage the economy, minimise debt and unemployment. To do this, government still focus on good economic policy, however, seek new interventions through entrepreneurialism, contestability and information technology as interventions in service delivery. This is because the constituents within the electorate are more focused on individualism and aspiration rather than collective funding through tax. (Hughes, 2003; Lynn, 2003; Pollitt, 2001)In contrast to traditional public administration, NPM is concerned with the implementation of policy rather than just policy creation itself. Flynn (cited in Hughes, 2003) identifies thirteen characteristics on NPM with five recent additions that further define the greying distinction between the public and private...

Find Another Essay On Contrasting Public Administration with New Public Management

Technology in Public Administration Essay

1977 words - 8 pages management” which is more professional. In 1993 civil service had a radical reform as to the minimum requirements needed for a supervisor position. This meant that with the advancement of technology, the minimum requirement for personnel will increase as well. Because employees will need to be more literate, productive and motivated to progress and when they progress the business improves. The negative thing of technology in Public Administration

Public Administration: Intervention Essay

945 words - 4 pages . Congress would probably not be receptive to the analysis and support financially and or emotionally from the participants. Works Cited Day, G. S. (2011). Closing the marketing capabilities gap. Journal of Marketing, 75(4. Pai, M. M. (2013). Optimal auctions with financially constrained buyers. Journal of Economic Theory. Shayfritz, J. M., & Hyde, A. C. (2007). Classic of Public Administration. CENGAGE.

Public Administration Ethics

889 words - 4 pages Public administrator is entangled with several responsibilities: to superiors –principals- as they represent the rules and policies, for the conduct of subordinates –agent-, and to the citizenry in serving the public interest. This what is called the objective responsibility: “responsibility involves accountability to someone else and obligation for a particular standard or category of performance.” (Cooper, 75) To fulfill all kind of

Public Administration and Public Interest Issues

1728 words - 7 pages administration, there was no major technological instruments like we have today. It was not easy to monitor the bureaucrats in terms accountability. There were no technological support for analyzing input and output. Constituencies were mainly uneducated. Therefore top-down management dealt with problems very well in its time. With new public management, technology changed the all perception about government operations. It became easier to monitor

New Public Management and Decision Making in UK Public Policy

1326 words - 5 pages with public and private service providers competing for resources. New Public Management does not suggest that a government should stop performing certain tasks. Although the New Public Management often is associated with such a perspective on a policy level, New Public Management is not about whether tasks should be undertaken or not. It is about getting things done better. New Public Management was devised as a means to improve

Traditional Model to New Public Management

1515 words - 6 pages changed the `old` style of public administration in to the new approach of public management. This emancipation of public administration is recognized today as the New Public Management doctrine. United Nations, (2006) p8 stresses that traditional public administration is associated with the emergence of civil service systems in countries undergoing industrialization in the second half of the ninth century. These systems exemplified a set of

Developing Countries and New Public Management

2206 words - 9 pages rising in the United States of America, when the debate on public management concept was developed (Gunn, 1987; Gow and Dufour, 2000: 578). In the United States of America, the new public management was discussed as a new disciplinary of policy-making that different with public administration and public policy. It discusses how to build effectiveness and efficiency of rational exercise of policy-making. Then, the new public management was entered by

The Future of Public Administration

1876 words - 8 pages efforts that extend democracy · New roles to be played with respect to the public i.e. "Citizen's First" concept · Less controlling and more of supporting, resolving, exploring, creating and caring · Developing and maintaining more democratic forms of organizations and management · Integration of theories and practice · Public service to make a difference for a better future for all Submitted by: Riaz Ahmad Malik MPA Department University of the Punjab Pakistan (2001-2003) Bibliography: References for Future of Public Administration: Mr. Robert B. Denhardt (University of Delaware)

Public Administration Reformation In Brunei

3657 words - 15 pages about how to manage public administration. Public administration was something very new to them. As we all know, wealthy and successful countries always have stability and good public management. Well-managed public administration is like a root of nation's success and we can't deny that good public management is partly from good civil services. Not surprisingly, improving public administration and civil servants became the very first factor of the

The Four Pillars of Public Administration

1164 words - 5 pages looking at set goals and the various subjects that culminate during execution of the goals as well as how the issues are dealt with. SOCIAL EQUITY: Social equity is the fourth pillar of the National Association of Public Administration. According to the National Academy of Public Administration it is the fair, just and equitable management of all institutions serving the public directly or by contract; the fair, just and equitable distribution of

The Classical Model Theory of Public Administration

2330 words - 10 pages organization is very dominant. While in Public Management or New Public Management, the indicator of someone is considering as successful or not is through the agreed target oriented, and to meet the target they were given little flexibility, so that it can run it is fullest in accordance with market expectation. This is an answer to the impasse goes on a classical model, as stated by Pollit and Bouckaert (2011) that New Public Management was

Similar Essays

Public Administration Essay

1045 words - 4 pages Running Head: PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONPublic Administration[Writer Name][Institute Name]Public AdministrationIntroductionThings are either changing or evolving around us day after day. From the beginning of time people learned something and when they started trusting it and use to be comfortable of it, something new came. Public administration is one of such things, because it is growing and changing with every passing day. Public administration

Public Administration Essay

1675 words - 7 pages authorities are endeavouring to unlearn the previous lessons and methodologies for improvement (Gill & Meier, 2000, pp.157-199). Open management is in demand to re-develop itself and find routes to do more with fewer assets. Movement is required at numerous levels of legislature to successfully meet the aforementioned new challenges. For instance, the part of open management in monetary administration is being redefined, and the forms of

Public Administration Essay

2115 words - 9 pages Leadership and Management POSDCORB: planning, organizing, staffing, directing, coordinating, reporting and budgeting. These tools are necessary to perform the ongoing duties of a public administration. POSDCORB emphasizes professionalism, executive control functions, and organizational theory to governmental organizations for the sake of efficient management practices (Chalekian, 2013). Planning Planning involves the preparation for an

Public Administration Essay

1623 words - 6 pages would conclude about values in public administration. Most people do not understand what an administration deals with everyday on an individual basis. They might think that an administration is supposed to make the best ethical choices, but that is not the case. People who are outside the administration might think that administrators are supposed to use everyday values when implementing policy, but that is also not the case.   &nbsp