Control Of Internet Pornography Essay

3504 words - 14 pages

The most critical concerns regarding the regulatory strategies revolve around the fundamental freedoms of expression and the right to personal autonomy which includes interference with a user’s right to the Internet. There is also the generic fear of the Internet being covered by political censorship. The creation of regulatory bodies and their mechanisms slowly encroached upon several Member States in the EU (France, Italy, UK, etc.) and sporadically across the world (Middle East, Australia, China, etc) and inevitably led blocking of different types of content (also known as ‘mission creep’). This invoked a fear amongst members of society especially those concerned with safeguarding their fundamental rights, and this led to the creation of several anti-censorship organisations. Having researched these organisations, there are a number of important issues that have been proposed.
Firstly, there is the argument of overblocking and underblocking caused by blocking and filtering mechanisms.
The reason the blocking strategy is so controversial in its application is because, on the Internet, there may be more than 50 websites that share the same IP address and it is technically impossible for an ISP to determine what content is held on domain names assigned to a specific IP address. Therefore, when the ISPs had to comply with the law, it resulted in a rather large number of blocking of innocent content on websites. BT’s Cleanfeed system apparently uses URL/IP blocking to prevent access to the list of sites identified on the IWF’s block list.
An analogy can be drawn in the incident of Steve Marshall (an English travel agent living in Spain) and his commercial websites aimed at Italian and French tourists. His domain names had been put on the US Treasury Department blacklist and were registered on an American DNS host, who therefore shutdown the sites. He was not notified of the shutdown and neither could he retrieve the domain names. The incident illustrates one of the many cases of overblocking and also begs the question as to the accountability of ISPs/DNS hosts that act on impulse.
On the other hand, filtering tools find great difficulty in trying to distinguish innocent content from harmful/illegal content especially in user-generated web content (Web 2.0). This results in underblocking where regulators try to play it safe or overblocking where too much ‘good’ content is blocked. In a research conducted by the Safer Internet Plus programme (SIP-BENCH) dealing with filtering software, the trend lines showed a drastic change from 80% underblocking in 2006 to 90% overblocking in 2008. This is largely due to the filtering tools not being able to keep up with the evolution of the Internet.
The SmartFilter software (now owned by McAfee) is widely used by corporations and governments. It claims to provide the industry’s most comprehensive and proven database of forbidden URLs . In a study conducted by Seth Finkelstein , who wrote a software to...

Find Another Essay On Control of Internet Pornography

Are the Dangers of Internet Child Pornography Exaggerated?

734 words - 3 pages The idea of child Pornography on the internet is very well alive and well. There are people who rummage around the black holes of the internet looking for Child Pornography or some call “Kiddy Porn”. Child Molesters are everywhere; the internet is a virtual playground for them to pry and hunt out children for their satisfaction. These reviews are both very opinionated views.The first thing that stood out to me was that Julia Wilkins

Internet & Society: Technologies and Politics of Control

1923 words - 8 pages Internet & Society: Technologies and Politics of Control From the moment Internet file-sharing became a reality, exploding into millions of homes and dorms, something changed. Internet file sharing brought with it the opportunity to access for free what had previously cost money. Beyond that, file sharing created a social norm that music and digital media ought to be free. How did this happen? How did file sharers warp reality and forever

Growth of, Control of, and Access to the Internet

4299 words - 17 pages communication in the form of email. Information can be sent to anyone who has access to a computer and the Internet. The Internet allows people to express their feelings and emotions anonymously. However, governments have looked to control information from the Internet. This presents a battle between freedom of speech and censorship by the government. With the terror attacks of September 11, 2001, governments have increased the security in order to

The Pros and Cons of Pornography

945 words - 4 pages come to life (King 418). According to King, “One third of all use of the internet is connected to porn sites,” (419). With explicit sexual material nearly impossible to avoid, it may be difficult to decipher between what is normal sexual behavior and what is merely fantasy. There is belief that the sexual activities of women presented in pornography effect both genders’ perceptions of what is normal female sexual behavior. Many argue that

The Wrongs Of Child Pornography From A Christian Perspective

3183 words - 13 pages /child pornography on the Internet and in everyday life. I chose this topic because in the past few years this issue has become more and more prominent in the world of today. Pornography is truly a scary thing. Even though some people may not realize it, pornography is growing more and more and it is changing societies beliefs and the way it acts. In this paper I will show you what pornography is, the many different problems that have come up due

Internet Pornography and the Need for Increased Censorship

1248 words - 5 pages organization in Washington. "It's an attractive nuisance (Voedisch). With more than 43 million households using the internet in 1999, 22 million of those being children and teenagers (Cline), there needs to be some limit on what is allowed. Censoring the Internet could not stop the problem, but certainly could help reduce the amount being allowed. The first attempt to control pornography was in an International Treaty called "Agreement for

Got Internet Pornography?

1296 words - 5 pages Got Internet Pornography? Pornography is viewed differently by everyone. Is pornography as bad as it is made out to be? What if it is that persons outlet from reality, just like smoking, drinking, snowboarding, skiing. Is it hurting anyone. Some say it is degrading to women. Do those women that do it think it is degrading. If they did they wouldn’t do it. There are several different types of pornography in the world. It started in art where we

Pornography in the 20th Century

2262 words - 9 pages Laura Kipnis has described pornography as “an archive of data about...our history as a culture”. Therefore if, she described it as such, what can it tell us about the sexual history of the 20th century? Examining the history of the forms of archive from pornographic playing cards to blu-ray discs and the internet, this shows the ever changing form of how as a society we view pornography. From the forms of archive come the social implications

Pornography and the Internet

2869 words - 11 pages Considering the availability of pornography online, and the negative representation of women in porn and the detrimental effect this has, the time has arrived for the Internet to experience tighter regulations and statutory controlYou used to have to go looking for pornography. Now it comes looking for you. Porn has gone public - it seems to have pervaded our whole society, wrapped its legs around the neck of our culture, jumping literally out

Behind Closed Doors

986 words - 4 pages life. When Jacob gained access to the internet in his room, he was able to enter a portal of adult content without supervision. Now he is paying the consequences, having to pay for therapy and make a slow recovery. Compulsive and sexually risky behavior can occur due to too much viewing of pornography and have a negative impact on the brain. Undeniably, an increase in the availability of technology has increased the usage of pornography in children

Internet Pornography

778 words - 3 pages . Children should be properly informed about sex from their parents who practices caution and care when regarding the material their children are exposed to. The reality of the matter is that children have been able to readily access pornography since the onset of the internet. Words and phrases that have little or no sexual connotation turn up uncensored pornographic materials on websites as public as Google and MSN. As the highly recognized

Similar Essays

Effects Of Internet Pornography Essay

1032 words - 4 pages Effects of Internet Pornography It used to be almost impossible for children to get pornography. Comer stores would place adult magazines such as playboy on the top rack behind all the other magazines so that only the title was visible and it was out of reach of children. Movie stores would have separate rooms at the front of the store for their porn videos; this way they could monitor who went into the room. In today's technologically

The Benefits Of Internet Pornography Essay

2224 words - 9 pages . Pornographic and erotic works have closely been related to technological development of the modern age. In fact, according to the Federal Communications Law Journal’s article on pornography, “throughout the history of new media…pornography has shown technology the way” (Johnson 217). Pornography has pioneered many services that are now commonly used on the Internet. For example, it has popularized the online payment system, which allowed people to

Children And The Censorship Of Internet Pornography

4232 words - 17 pages network resembling a connection of one body in unity. Sadly, issues arise creating concern for users, focusing particularly on minors. Pornography is one of the inappropriate materials on the Internet for minors. This material is harmful to young impressionable minds. Pornography is tearing and disintegrating the foundations of our society can be described as follows, "what was available to a small number of people willing to drive to the bad

Pornography On The Internet, Freedom Of Press Or Dangerous Influence?

2084 words - 8 pages definition of this type can be applicable to all views on the subject. Pornography on the Internet has brought about difficulties pertaining to censorship. All of the arguments in this paper can be divided into one of two categories: those whose aim is to allow for an uncensored Internet, and those who wish to completely eliminate pornography from the Internet all together.All arguments for an uncensored Internet all cite the basic rights of free speech