Controversial Activity About Short Selling Been Ethical

2074 words - 8 pages

Short selling in the stock markets is the sale of stocks not owned by the seller. Money is made when the stock drops in value instead of increasing in value, thus making it such a controversial activity. Many have argued that short selling have large detrimental effects to the stock market, however it does also provide benefits to the society. By applying ethical models of reasoning and determining if NRFs are acting in the conflict of interest, we will be able to determine if short selling conducted by NRFs is indeed ethical and whether it should be allowed to be conducted.

Ethical Model of Reasoning
Consequentialism is based on the principle of maximizing utility, focusing on the consequences of the action. As long as the positive consequences outweigh the negative consequences, it is considered as ethical (Brooks & Dunn, 2011). The strength of consequentialism is that it can be applied systematically. Unfortunately, it is difficult to apply because it is difficult to determine and measure all the consequences bore by others. Moreover, there is no definite guideline to who are the stakeholders that should be considered when applying the model (Hart, n.d).
Deontology is a “duty” based ethics. In order to be ethical, one must take proper actions with good intentions resulting in positive consequences (Brooks & Dunn, 2011). The appeal of Deontology is that it provides us with rules that are applicable to all situations as rules. On the other hand, it is rigid and unable to be fair in different situations (Hovland & Wolburg, 2010).
Justice Ethical Approach
Justice ethical approach is where everyone should be treated equally regardless of their social standing and background (Velasquez, Andre, Shanks, S.J, & Meyer, 1990). Justice can be defined as the administering of what the person deserves (Justice, n.d). It is unfortunately an uphill task to determine what people deserve as there are no guidelines or specific rules to adhere to (Velasquez, Andre, Shanks, S.J, & Meyer, 1990).

Conflict of Interest
Conflict of interest is a situation when a person has a duty to more than one party but cannot act fairly for both parties (Hill & Hill, 2008). It could also be a situation when a profession or corporation has a personal stake in the decision being made resulting in him being untrustworthy (Conflict of Interest, n.d.).

Short selling, stakeholders and ethics
Companies who are targeted by NRFs may lose their credibility and thus their ability to raise capital through debt or equity, and then lose its capability to function. The type of company determines if this consequence is beneficial to the society or not. If the company was initially a benefit to the society, like a pharmaceutical company which conducts medical research and produce medicine, its inability to conduct its principal business could be a negative consequence. On the other hand, if a company that harms the society, like a company that...

Find Another Essay On Controversial Activity about Short selling been Ethical


4061 words - 16 pages any clearly illegal or immoral activity, such as the selling of cocaine, but it also may rule out certain legal but questionable activities as inconsistent with its self-definition and its moral purpose.B. Responsibility to ConstituenciesA responsible organization, like a responsible individual, will be concerned about the impact of its behavior on others. Many classes of individuals are affected by how a business conducts its affairs. Typically

Ethical Hacking and Ethical Hackers Essay

1703 words - 7 pages : malicious hackers, bright computer science graduates, and individuals from a systems or administration background. Out of these three sources, the malicious hackers is the type of ethical hacker that have higher risk as this is the people who has been using his skills for malicious intent, then grows out of it and wants to earn money. It raised a controversial here while some will argue that only a "real hacker" would have the skill to actually do the

North Face Knapp Case Questions

1313 words - 5 pages 1. Materiality is one of the most controversial topics in accounting due to its subjective nature. Auditors must gather data and decide whether the adjustments in question would have a material affect on a financial statement. A large number of inaccurate transactions that are determined immaterial could easily add up and over time, create significant misstatements, so the aggregate effect must be taken into consideration. Audits should be

Current Ethical Issue

1621 words - 6 pages privacy in Internet activity, especially in creating databases out of personal information, is a serious issue facing society. As such it raises serious legal issue, but ethical issues are also raised.There are people on the Internet who use anonymous servers as a way to avoid responsibility for controversial and inappropriate behavior. Cases of harassment and abuse have become increasingly frequent, aided by a cloak of anonymity. There are also

Societal Ethical Changes Caused by Information Technology

1989 words - 8 pages Ethical issues regarding the use of information technology are changing rapidly in our advancing modern society. Historically information technology had seen limited applications and impacts on society in general. More recently, however, this has been changing as information technology has become a part of nearly every business, and personal activity (Brooks, 2010). As a result, there are more opportunities than ever to engage with

Open Source Software vs. Microsoft Empire

3381 words - 14 pages decisions among governments’ rules and regulations in terms of intellectual property laws and foreign trade policies. Thus, we have to keep in mind that acting within the laws does not necessarily acting in an ethical manner. Unethical actions can always be legal. The conflict between open source movement and commercial software model raise the ethical issues of to what extent we should view selling and patenting one’s software idea and intellectual

Consumer behaviour in marketing ethics

1889 words - 8 pages . Issues surrounding marketing ethics and social responsibility are inherently controversial. An area that causes particular dispute is the question of the effect of ethical and unethical marketing activity in regards to the purchasing behaviour of consumers. According to the contemporary theory of ethics one would like to think that being a ``good company'' would attract consumers to your products, whilst unethical behaviour would see customers

Consumer behaviour in marketing ethics

1224 words - 5 pages leads to a higher return on investment Page 4 of 7 D. Suppose the company has always been coming out with new variants. New product development can be seen as a process consisting of seven steps: (L03: Assessment Criteria 3.3) 1. Idea generation 2. Screening 3. Concept testing 4. Business analysis 5. Product development 6. Testing 7. Commercialisation Match the step with the activity that goes with that step and describe how the company will

Discussing Ethical Judgments in the Production of Knowledge in Both Arts and Sciences

2542 words - 10 pages goal since they expressed intense empathy, distress, and sorrow. Even though I had presented a controversial topic, my methodology enabled me to approach acceptable ethical standards in context of the belief that “good” is whatever brings the least amount of overall unhappiness. All the same, illustrations of ethical standards facilitating the knowledge of art is generally more difficult come across since it infringes the universally held


3136 words - 13 pages PROBLEM AND ITS SETTING Background of the Study Are there really any ethical practices in finance? Are most business organizations (if not all) practice the same level of ethical finance? These are only some relevant questions that have to be proven, for the public have had a huge participation about financial misconducts. More specifically, in terms of financial scandals, about the weak financial governance and the egregious amount of money

How to Develop an Ethical Organization

2845 words - 11 pages The purpose of this paper is to describe how I would improve the ethical culture of an organization that I have recently joined. The organization has been through recent ethical scandals and the board is looking to me to improve the ethical culture. This paper will be written in a leadership journal format.Problem Statement: Recent ethical scandals require us to improve the ethical cultureI would like to relate a real challenge that I

Similar Essays

Zqler Essay

9619 words - 38 pages may be concerned about a health care organization or practitioner over- charging the provincial government for medical services. From a social responsibility perspective, we might be concerned about the impact that this overcharging will have on the ability of the health care system to provide adequate services for all citizens. The most basic ethical and social responsibility concerns have been codified as laws and regulations that encourage

Business Essay

9619 words - 38 pages may be concerned about a health care organization or practitioner over- charging the provincial government for medical services. From a social responsibility perspective, we might be concerned about the impact that this overcharging will have on the ability of the health care system to provide adequate services for all citizens. The most basic ethical and social responsibility concerns have been codified as laws and regulations that encourage

Ethical Theories On Stealing Essay

1373 words - 5 pages and dramatically changing contemporary world, ethical issues and problems are becoming ever more important and urgent. Maintaining basic ethical principles in a variety of settings and conditions requires more than accepting major moral values; it calls for courage, commitment, character, and strong and flexible reasoning and judgment. Ethical principles have been developed by different philosophical teachings and theories that analyze and

If You Don't Like It, Turn It Off.

1648 words - 7 pages nothing wrong, and therefore taking the morally right course of action. Now, consider the drug addict to be a viewer of a controversial commercial containing nudity and profanity. The drug addict sees nothing wrong with the commercial; he actually finds slight humor and pleasure when viewing the short ad. Meanwhile, parents viewing the ad with their children present become furious about the offensive commercial, and thus begin taking action