Traditional And Utilitarian Approaches To The Euthyphro Dilemma

1842 words - 7 pages

Traditional And Utilitarian Approaches To The Euthyphro Dilemma

In the Euthyphro, Plato describes the proceedings of a largely circular argument between Socrates and Euthyphro, a self-declared prophet and pious man, over the nature of piety and even of the gods themselves. The issues raised in this dialogue have been reinterpreted and extended to remain relevant even with a modern theological framework, so much so that the central issue is now known simply as ?the Euthyphro dilemma.? This is based on Socrates? two-way choice which he offers in the dialogue:

"Consider this: Is the pious being loved by the gods because it is pious, or is it pious because it is being loved by the gods?" (10a)

In the context of the dialogue, this simply segues to a logical argument about the definition of piety, and the question is more or less rhetorical as Socrates asks it. When Euthyphro chooses the first option, the discussion moves on to his next point without further ado, and the implication that this limits the omnipotence of the gods is ignored, probably because the omnipotence of the pantheon of gods wasn?t an assumption of Greek theology (after all, as we read in the dialogue, the father and grandfather of Zeus were castrated; what kind of omnipotent being would allow that to happen to himself?). However, when read with a Judeo-Christian concept of God in mind, the dilemma becomes this:

"Did God decide what goodness is? If so, then "good" is more or less the arbitrary decision of a frightening being to which we cannot relate, and that being could just as easily have made murder and stealing the ultimate moral actions without any contradictions. On the other hand, if God did not decide what goodness is, he cannot truly be omnipotent."

This has become the main issue of the Euthyphro in modern times; other questions the dialogue raises, like what the purpose of prayer is, and of course what the definition of piety is, are more or less ignored for the "big issue" here.

There is no big agreement in the modern monotheist camp as to which half of the dilemma to choose; for example, Descartes chose the big-scary-unknowable-god option (I'll refer to that as Option 1) and Saadia Gaon fell firmly into the good-came-before-god camp (Option 2) (Rich 1, Solomon 36). However, there are clearly problems with choosing either side if you want a traditional God; it is a dilemma, after all.

The assumptions that cause the dilemma to be so problematic are more or less: a) God is omnipotent, b) God is good, and c) God is like the Biblical God; God is knowable in some sense, and we can form meaningful relationships with Him (or Her, to be PC). For simplicity's sake we will just deal with the Old Testament, since both Jews and Christians accept it and it prevents us having to delve into the finer points of Trinitarian theology.

Assumption a is pretty much a fair assumption in modern discussions of God. If God were not omnipotent then we have no real use...

Find Another Essay On Traditional And Utilitarian Approaches To The Euthyphro Dilemma

The Behaviorist and Cognitive Approaches to Psychology

1422 words - 6 pages The Behaviorist and Cognitive Approaches to Psychology In this essay I am going to explore two of the major approaches to Psychology, Cognitive theories and Behaviorist theories. I will discuss in some detail the two approaches, state how they compare and illustrate the similarities and the differences between them. John Watson, one of the founders of Behaviorism, based his theories on the principles of learning


2188 words - 9 pages according those studies. Consideration of several options such as job enlargement, job enrichment, promotions, internal and external stipends, monetary, and non-monetary compensation should also be discussed. As a matter of facts, the approaches used to motivating employees are to know what motivates them and designing appropriate motivation program based on those needs. Lastly, this term paper recommends that employers should make an effort to

The Utilitarian and Kantian Perspective: Prompt #2

1068 words - 5 pages “could have intrinsic value caring about whether or not it is useful to others”(Gray). So to bring it back into to the utilitarian perspective, human life in war is only valuable as a means to happiness. And also the purpose of war according to the hedonistic utilitarian is to maximize “pleasure, satisfaction and lack of pain” (Wetzell PP/Mills 247). General Marshall’s decision to save Ryan was the morally right decision despite the following

The Puritan Dilemma Responds to questions: According to Edmund Morgan, what was the "Puritan dilemma?" How did the Puritans and/or Winthrop address this dilemma?

1306 words - 5 pages The Puritan Dilemma by Edmund MorganJohn Winthrop's "Puritan dilemma" arose out of his life long effort to accomplish two goals: to secure a community dedicated to upholding every aspect of God's will and to do this within the context of everyday life. His first challenge dealt with the depravity of the Church of England in the early seventeenth century and how to escape its wickedness without withdrawing from the world. Then, with the founding

The Distinction Between Deep, Surface and Strategic Approaches to Learning

2647 words - 11 pages In this research of the topic, I will firstly examine the ‘characteristics’ of students who take deep, surface or strategic approaches to learning in higher education, and explore how these approaches are distinct from each other using literature from notable authors researching the topic of ‘approaches to learning’ mainly in higher education. Secondly, I will consider the ‘usefulness’ of these concepts in understanding how students learn and

Understandings and Approaches to Human Trafficking in the Middle East

1719 words - 7 pages In 2013, the ILO (International Labour Organization) reported the Middle East to be the primary destination for trafficking victims, as they calculated that there are around 600,000 forced labour victims within the region to date (13). This seemingly widespread issue of human trafficking within the Middle East has been subject to significant media coverage and global debate. There are three major elements at the centre of this debate: issues

The utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill.

2070 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast the utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Which do you think is the more convincing moral theory, and why?In terms of Utilitarianism, this assignment shall outline the philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. It shall firstly illustrate the ideas of Bentham and then follow on to compare and contrast those of Mill. To continue, the assignment will view the failing qualities in both the

Bush and the Medicare Dilemma.

765 words - 3 pages (Facts...2003). Those seniors that are happy with their Medicare coverage will be able to keep the traditional coverage while still receiving help with prescription drug costs. However, seniors that want more choices including full coverage for preventive health care and limits on high out-of-pocket costs will be able to select options providing these benefits. This new plan gives seniors the right to choose the plan that best fits their needs

Spenser and Shakespeare: Contrasting Approaches to Sonnets

1199 words - 5 pages immortalized love; yet after analysing the two sonnets, it is evident that both took different approaches of comparison to achieve their goal. Furthermore, both Sonnet LXXV and Sonnet 55 also differ in their given form and structure. In this case, Spenser’s sonnets were known to have their own specific format, which led to the emergence of the Spenserian sonnet. Spenserian sonnets were a variant on the traditional English format, but still

Approaches to Madness and Mental Disorders

1592 words - 6 pages Madness and aspects of the mental illness had various approaches throughout modern history. In general, there had been 3 common views from the beginning of the 17 century, with different approaches to madness. These were the most popular among the many are as follows:The madness as of supernatural origin; where religion was used to explain unacceptable or outrageous behavior. This was very common in small communities that had a strong belief in

Theoretical Change and Approaches to Therapy

1908 words - 8 pages ). Outcome studies of humanistic therapies in general, person-centered therapy in particular, indicate that people who have been treated with these approaches maintain stable changes over extended periods of time, that they change substantially compared to untreated persons, and that the changes are roughly comparable to the changes in clients who have been treated by other types of therapy (Cain,2001). Person-centered therapy, however

Similar Essays

The Euthyphro And The Republic Essay

1817 words - 7 pages The Euthyphro and The Republic I. In the Euthyphro, Euthyphro himself gives three proposals of piety. First, the pious is to prosecute the wrongdoer and the impious is not to prosecute the wrongdoer. Socrates disputes this example as lacking generality. He believed that in order to define piety, one had to find the form that made all pious acts pious. An example of a pious act does not in turn define piety. Euthyphro’s second attempt

The Euthyphro Dilemma Vs. The Divine Command Theory Two Theories Explaining Moral Behavior Explored.

1104 words - 4 pages returning to the original statement that what is pious is what the gods love, which makes no point at all.Why is The Euthyphro Dilemma important? Many theists consider God to be the basis of all morality. What does this mean? Is it that God is the source of morality and that what God wills is good and always trustworthy? If so, then God's commands are arbitrary, making it perfectly reasonable to say that one day God may decree that committing murder

Magistrates Of Morality: How The Euthyphro Dilemma Cripples Divine Command Theory

2020 words - 8 pages who accept this theory believe that moral action coincides with what has been ordered by the deities, and immoral action would occur when one deviates from these orders. Despite this theory remaining relevant into the twenty-first century, it has still yet to solve one age-old dilemma. The Euthyphro Argument has stumped philosophers for years, but some Divine Command theorists believe they can overcome the massive obstacles it presents. In this

The New Managerial Thoughts And Organisational Approaches Like Empowerment, Delegation Decentralisation And Self Managed Teams Has Ensued The Changes As Compared To The Traditional Approach.

1683 words - 7 pages 1. Introduction The role of a manager is rapidly changing and demands a fresh perspective at present situation. The new managerial thoughts and organisational approaches like empowerment, delegation decentralisation and self-managed teams has ensued the changes as compared to the traditional approach. 2. Classical approach of the manager Traditional or classical management focuses on efficiency and includes bureaucratic, scientific and