Converging Menger's And Searle's Money Tale

1997 words - 8 pages

1. Introduction

The present paper aims at scrutinising whether a collective factor whatsoever has been needed
to explain the emergence or persistence of money. To choose Menger (1892) and Searle (1995) for
this discussion has some exemplary value as both are considered to defend opposing positions. As
we shall see Searle considers the presence of collective intentionality as a necessary precondition
for institutions like money to occur, whereas Menger bases his account on the sole pursuit of selfinterest
of the agents. However, we are justified in comparing them because, as Tieffenbach (2010,
191 – 193) points out, both see their task in giving a logical and conceptual account of how
institutions emerge and take for that purpose money as their “favourite example”.

The intention of this paper resides in a direct comparison of both primary texts, evaluate the
comparability and seek actively for shared grounds in their concepts with the following objective:
in the best case reveal aspects of compatibility or coincidence, but at least soften their seeming
opposition. It was though a critical stance toward Menger's postulation that uniquely the selfinterest
of agents made money emerge which motivated this paper. I was convinced that there must
be a collective factor à la Searle in the emergence of money. In this sense, it is moreover a pursuit
of proving my impressions and a defence of Searle rather than a neutral comparison. However, on
my way through dealing with both authors I realised that I was pushing Searle's position quite far –
but still in way he would not disapprove – in order to make it compatible with Menger's account. In
this sense, the loss of strength of Searle's account through my reading allows me to talk about a fair
comparison with a tendentious starting point. In any case, the reader will find several struggling
moments throughout my quest for shared grounds (most of all in section 3.1).

Current Themes in Institutional & Evolutionary Economics 06/11/2011 Darian Heim
Vromen (2003, 257)2 made an suggestion to differentiate between the emergence and
persistence of money. Eventually, this differentiation appeared to be a good tool for my project.
Although Searle and Menger focus mainly on the emergence of money, considerations of its
persistence – which are nonetheless found in their writings – will help us to reveal their
commonalities. Any the less, the main aim of this paper is to find parallels with regard to the
emergence of money. Still, revealing their commonalities will turn out easier by focusing on
considerations about the persistence of money (section 3.2).

The following section is dedicated to a reconstruction of the relevant positions of the two
authors with regard to our task of comparing them. It will be represented in such a manner to make
their opposition understandable, i.e. by insisting on their differences. Section 3 will urn the issue
and present the proper comparison along...

Find Another Essay On Converging Menger's and Searle's Money Tale

Silas Marner as a Fairy Tale

1851 words - 7 pages character. Although he is not a fairy tale villain like his brother, he still has his bad sides as well as his good sides. Godfrey is egoistic and cares largely about himself, in contrast to Silas who becomes humble. Godfrey is a good person really on the inside, as he does help Silas to look after his daughter Eppie by providing Silas with some money. He also does bad things such as not look after his wife Molly, whom he

The Wife of Bath’s Tale and The Clerk’s Tale

1858 words - 7 pages in her past marriages. The Wife of Bath had five husbands in her life, with the goal to be dominant, exploit their money, and use them for pleasure. It is not a coincidence that the queen in her tale would have control of the knight’s life and in a sense the Wife of Bath most likely imagined herself to be this queen (“The Wife of Bath’s Tale” 156-59). The structures of the two tales help widen the difference between the narratives. Both

The Miller's Tale- Chaucer's Response to Society's Flaws

977 words - 4 pages to the Wife of Bath, as the main character carries her name (Alison) and also married for money. Absalon is a parish clerk, materialistic, and also seeks the affection of the young wife (even though he is studying to become a priest and she is married). The tale continues as Nicholas concocts this crazy story simply for one night with Alison, whom also wants to have Nicholas- since she's bored and unhappy with her older and unattractive husband

Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales

589 words - 2 pages Prologue to the Pardoner's tale, the character of the Pardoner is revealed. Although the Pardoner displays many important traits, the most prevalent is his greed. Throughout the prologue, the Pardoner displays his greed and even admits that the only thing he cares about is money: "I preach nothing except for gain" ("Pardoner's Tale", Line 105). This avarice is seen strongly in the Pardoner's tale as well. In the Pardoner's tale

"The Prioress' Tale" is a miracle tale in which she discusses the beauty of God.

649 words - 3 pages Jamie MilliserEnglish 1-4Oct. 8, 2002"The Prioress' Tale" is a miracle tale in which she discusses the beauty of God."The Prioress' Tale" is a miracle tale in which she discusses the beauty of God through the eyes of a seven-year old boy who is martyred for singing a prayer to the Virgin Mary. In the Prioress' prologue, she talks about the power of God and calls on the Virgin Mary to help her tell the story. She begins the tale by describing the

Contradictions in Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales

3969 words - 16 pages make up the Prioress?s character. Her tale involves a bigotry that is unmatched in all of The Canterbury Tales as shown in the following passage: ?And as the boy passed at his happy pace This cursed Jew grabbed him and held him, slit His little throat and cast him in a pit?I say, into a privy-drain (Chaucer 190).? While most would agree that this tale represents a love vs. hate contrast, contemporary scholars and writers conflict over the

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales - Comparing Dishonesty in The Physician's and Pardoner's Tales

2185 words - 9 pages show this hypocrisy in different ways.   One way of seeing this hypocrisy, in the case of the physician's tale, is to examine the way the similarities and differences between the knight Virginius and the physician himself in terms of what he sees as moral actions. It seems fairly clear that the physician identifies himself with Virginius during the telling of the tale. One of the main ways in which the physician identifies with Virginius

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales - Comparing The Pardoners Tale and The Nun's Priest's Tale

837 words - 3 pages should have been silent.  Also ironic about this whole situation, was the fact that in the fox flattering Chanticleer he mocked his wisdom and reason and in defense Chanticleer acts by displaying neither of these qualities.         Both "The Pardoner's Tale" and "The Nun's Priest's Tale" utilize the tool of irony to teach two similar lessons.  The moral of "The Pardoner's Tale" is "Money is the root of all evil

Irony in the Canterbury Tales by

638 words - 3 pages Irony is the general name given to literary techniques that involvesurprising, interesting,or amusing contradictions. 1 Two stories thatserve as excellent demonstrations of irony are "The Pardoners Tale" and"The Nun's Priest's Tale," both from Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales.Although these two stories are very different, they both use irony to teacha lesson.Of the stories, "The Pardoners Tale" displays the most irony. Firstand foremost, the

Essay on Chaucer's Canterbury Tales - Evil Exposed in The Pardoner's Tale

1211 words - 5 pages successful for the Pardoner, as he later states, proclaiming, "That trick's been worth a hundred marks a year".  By extolling his ability to profit from deception and fear, the Pardoner offers himself as a clear example of the phrase he himself was fond of quoting, Radix malorum est cupiditas, or "The root of evil is money".  He then proceeds to prove his point with his tale of three rioters and their search for Death

The Characters in The Canterbury Tales

4126 words - 17 pages bothered with problems that arise in his marriage. These characteristics are very different from the Wife of Bath who, while in love with Jankyn, gave up all of the money that she had amassed from her four former husbands. The Merchant's physical description seems simple, just as his mind seems simple and as is demonstrated by his tale, his message is very brutal and he makes his point very clearly.   "The Merchants Tale," is very sexual

Similar Essays

America's Great Depression. Essay

1627 words - 7 pages there are many macroeconomics schools of thought, this paper will be concentrating on two initially, Keynesian economics and Austrian School economics. Keynesian economics got its start during the Great Depression with the publication in 1936 of The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money, by John Maynard Keynes. Austrian School economics began much Earlier, most notably with the publication in 1871 of Carl Menger's Principles of Economics

Crude And The Wise Biblical Story

994 words - 4 pages the day Anima left his village, at last he arrived at Searle. Searle consisted of large magnificent palaces and advanced structures, without any sign of bright decorations. The prosperous town consisted of many cheerful faces in high spirits. Fresh fruits and vegetables that was rarely hard to be seen in Anima's village were in sell of considerable amounts. Focusing on his mission Anima galloped with his servants into the King of Searle's palace

Summary And Analysis Of The Friar's Tale

990 words - 4 pages Summary and Analysis of The Friar's Tale (The Canterbury Tales) Prologue to the Friar's Tale: The Friar commends the Wife of Bath for her tale, and then says that he will tell a tale about a summoner. He does not wish to offend the Summoner who travels with them, but insists that summoners are known for lewd behavior. The Summoner does not take offense, but does indicate that he will repay the Friar in turn. The job of the Summoner to

Literary Genres Of Canterbury Tales Essay

946 words - 4 pages out the nobility of love. All three of these tales bring comedy and structure to a somewhat corrupt and violent clash of characters in William Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales. "The Miller's Tale" is characterized as a fabliau because it follows certain requisites. Just like any other true fabliau, "The Miller's Tale" focuses on the vulgar or lower class. The main character, a carpenter, and his new wife are simple individuals and are