Convictions Of Adult Offenders In Canada

1135 words - 5 pages

Convictions of Adult Offenders in Canada On Sept. 16, 1995, after fatally stabbing her husband as he slept,
19-year-old Jamie Tanis Gladue shrieked: "I got you...bastard." In
addition to getting her husband, however, Mr. Gladue disregarded the
rule of law.

In the course of confirming Ms. Gladue's sentence of three years for
manslaughter -- only six months of which were served behind bars --
the Supreme Court of Canada scolded the trial judge for not giving due
attention to the killer's "Indianness." This ruling follows the
guidelines within section 718.2(e) of the Criminal Code, stating that
judges must pay "particular attention to the circumstances of
aboriginal offenders."

Thus Canada's top court gave its assent to legal prejudice by allowing
the same offence to be punished differently depending on the ethnicity
of the offender. The court justified this extraordinary decision, in
effect, by denouncing judges across the country for their
"over-reliance (sic) on incarceration" for aboriginal offenders.

For instance, the Court pointed out that a male treaty Indian is 25
times as likely to be incarcerated in a provincial jail as a
non-native and that aboriginals, though only 3% of the Canadian
population, make up almost 15% of federal prisoners. The extent of
native incarceration, declared the court, was "so stark and appalling
that the magnitude of the problem can be neither understood nor
interpreted away."

Alas, the court's reasoning was equally stark and appalling. After
all, the "overrepresentation" of natives in the criminal justice
system hardly proves systemic racism. Women make up less than 2% of
Canada's prison population. Yet no one argues that is because men
suffer from systemic sexism in the criminal justice system. Men commit
disproportionately more crimes.

Yet the court did not even examine whether natives were more or less
likely than non-natives to commit crimes -- surely the first step in
any serious inquiry. As it happens, if the court had tried to discover
this, it would have had great difficulty. The federal Department of
Justice has conspicuously dodged this politically explosive question
-- while spending millions of dollars on studies documenting abuses
that befall aboriginals once inside the criminal justice system.

What little data exist (which the court did not consider) show that
rates of incarceration for aboriginals may not be out of line with
their rates of crime. In 1995, the Canadian Centre for Justice
Statistics completed a three-city study on police-reported crime. It
found that natives were nearly five times as likely as non-natives to
commit a crime in Calgary; 10.5...

Find Another Essay On Convictions of Adult Offenders in Canada

Contempt of Court in Canada Essay

2368 words - 9 pages offence of contempt of court and narrow the scope of this paper. The second part will set out and explain the arguments in favour of, and against, codifying the law. Finally, the last part of the paper will set forth some proposals for reform. The Openness Principle Even before freedom of expression was enshrined in our constitution, the judiciary noted that the basic principle governing judicial proceedings in Canada was their openness

This essay discusses the origin of the Young Offenders Act and compares it with the Juvenille Delinquents act, which was the first version of the modern Young Offenders act. (Canada)

2218 words - 9 pages . The Act replaced the only other law regarding youth crime that had existed in Canada, that of the Juvenile Delinquents Act. The Juvenile Delinquents Act originated in 1908, when it was first deemed necessary for children who were believed to be guilty of a crime to be treated differently than adult offenders. Before this, children between the ages of seven and fourteen would go through the same process as an adult when they were shown to be

Juveniles in Adult Facilities: History of the Juvinile Justice System

1293 words - 6 pages created to treat delinquent youth apart from adult offenders in adult facilities. “Of these, approximately 14,500 are housed in adult facilities. The largest proportion, approximately 9,100 youth, are housed in local jails, and some 5,400 youth are housed in adult prisons” (Austin, 2000). The quagmire of placing juveniles in adult facilities is the risk factors juveniles may experience while incarcerated. Being that juveniles are young and

The rise of violent crime in Canada

2778 words - 11 pages . Yet if these statistics were to include all crime, the greater quantityof arrests and convictions for crime would be of a much higher social standing in oursociety.Cultural statistics show that it is probably not a genetic or biological factor thatcauses individuals to commit violent crimes. It is shown that the rates of violent crimediffer around the world. Bigger countries than Canada having lower robbery and raperates than our country. If these

Negative Impact of Hate Crimes in Canada

2072 words - 9 pages Policing is a primary tool in order to over time, reduce hate crime that occur within Canada. In order to reduce these crimes you need to figure out the offenders motive and be able to suppress it using different tactics. Allen and Boyce (2011) concluded that race and ethnicity are the most common motivation behind these hates crimes that occur within Canada (p.7). Fifty-two percent of hate crimes that were reported in 2011 were triggered by

Canada is in favor of Peace

1329 words - 5 pages Mission. Lieutenant-General Roméo Antonius Dallaire created Rwandan, to help stabilize Rwanda after the genocide that had occurred. They also joined NATO, which is a political, and military alliance that is committed to the peaceful resolution of disputes. During World War I, Canada got the perfect opportunity at the Battle of Vimy Ridge to establish them as a proper nation on the world platform. All four divisions were to be assembled to operate in

The Legalization of Marijuana in Canada

2252 words - 9 pages illegal in Canada in 1923 under the Opium and Drug Act, and since 1997, marijuana has been under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (Decriminalization of Marijuana in Canada, 2003). Under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, Marijuana is a Schedule 2 offense, meaning "cannabis, its preparations, derivatives and similar synthetic preparations" (Greenspan, s.3). This includes cannabis resin, cannabis (marijuana) and any other cannabis related

The Sale of Indian Textiles in Canada

6091 words - 24 pages The Sale of Indian Textiles in Canada Canada, with its economic and political stability offers a variety of business opportunities. With such a large population of immigrants, Canada is known for its acceptance of diverse cultures. English and French are Canada's official languages and there are many other languages spoken freely by diverse racial groups on Canadian soil. Many different religions are also practiced freely and peacefully in

Regulation of stricter Gun Control in Canada

2100 words - 9 pages Gun control in Canada has been a controversial issue since it was imposed in 1892 by the Criminal Code. Many parties such as anti-gun-control lobbyists challenge stricter gun control while others believe in more strict laws for firearms. Historically, Canada has always had more rigid gun laws and regulation of weapons over the United States. Canadian firearm law is regulated by the federal government. In 1991, Bill C-17 promoted stricter guns

The Legalization of Marijuana in Canada

1969 words - 8 pages 1. Introduction In the prime news on the television, there is plentiful atrocious news of deaths by excessive use of drugs. Often, many entertainment stars in Hollywood have been accidentally killed by excessive ingesting of narcotics, for example, Michel Jackson. Furthermore, in some cases in Canada, when the majority of the companies hire employees, they are usually questions or drug tests the candidates. Unfortunately, the

Impact of Canadian Medicine in Canada

1183 words - 5 pages Although Canada has always been considered a small country, its achievements in medicine are far from small. They have greatly benefited Canada and improved the country’s way of life. In fact, Canadian physician Dr. Frederick Banting discovered insulin to treat diabetes. Also, Michael smith developed site-directed mutagenesis to alter and identify genes. Lastly, doctors at Toronto Hospital For Sick Children produced Pablum to treat rickets

Similar Essays

Young Offenders Act In Canada. Speaks Of Why It Should Be Changed, And The The Reasons And Actions Taken

1424 words - 6 pages material to use as a basis for the argument thatthe government is not moving in a positive direction to address theproblems of repeat young offenders.Ottawa, Canada. (1986). Canadian Association for Children andAdults with Learning Disabilities. Learning Disabilities and the YoungOffenders: Arrest to Disposition.This publication investigates how the young offenders act inmany ways does not address adequately the special problems thatsome young

History Of Bullying In Canada Essay

1662 words - 7 pages , A, 2003). Bullying not only takes place in person but can presented in many different forms and manners. Some including online or more formally known as cyberbullying, where a person is threatened by the means of online communication or social networking. According to Statistics Canada (2009), “1 in 10 adults living in a household with children reported a child victim of cyberbullying” (StatsCan, 2009). Other types of bullying include physical

Decriminalization Of Marijuana In Canada Essay

1338 words - 5 pages Marijuana is currently a hot topic of debate throughout Canada, and has been for the past few years. Marijuana was first banned in 1923 under the Opium and Drug Act, but since 1997 the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act have controlled it. In 2000, over 30,000 Canadians were charged with possession of marijuana. Currently, the marijuana laws are not enforced equally across the country, which has prompted the interest in changing the laws or

Overview Of Divorce In Canada Essay

1706 words - 7 pages really on the rise? According to the statistics, the divorce rate of Canadian marriages has been more or less decreasing for the past twenty years. In fact, the number of divorces in Canada for every 100,000 people has decreased from a high of 362.3 in 1987 to 220.7 in 2005 (Wyman 1). Yet when we exclude the large and sudden jump of the Page 2 divorce rate in the 1980’s, we can see the overall national divorce rate is still gradually increasing