Convicts And The Writing Of History: Reality Or Myth?

2580 words - 10 pages

Historiography, or the methodology used for historical study and writing, helps demonstrate that the present is not divorced from the past; rather that history is a continuous dialogue with it. There are many contentious issues in writing history, depending on the agenda behind the accounts. This is shown clearly through attitudes to the Australian convicts. This essay will examine the historiography of writing Australian history, through authors such as MacIntyre, Pascoe, Windschuttle and Clark, then will focus on some of the debates concerning the convicts to demonstrate the arguments historians like Smith, Shlomowitz, Damousi and Hancock face.One of the most problematic areas in the writing of Australian history is that, on the whole, it has been uneventful in the traditional sense, meaning that there were no large-scale revolutions, civil wars or struggles for independence. Therefore, a successful historian must, through necessity, be able to dramatise what would otherwise be no longer than a few paragraphs. "Historians of this dramatic bent have enlivened every period of the Australian past with struggles between contesting social classes: in the convict era, it was emancipists versus exclusives; in the gold rushes, diggers versus troopers; in the pastoral economy, squatters versus selectors; in the industrial economy, labour versus capital." Empirical historiography, on the other hand, relies upon careful comparison of documented resources; leading to objective, impartial and detailed facts, which fail to draw conclusions, rather, merely define past events. For this essay, empirical research will be sidelined, as Australian history appears to lend itself to a less methodical telling. The sources of documentation used to provide the conclusions inherent in the more sentimental approach are newspapers, journals, memoirs, pamphlets and other forms of propaganda, including verbal accounts. The telling of this form of history ties firmly into the concepts of the present, and is therefore, open to changes as politics and social attitudes evolve. This, as the empiricists believe, is the inherent danger in this form of history.Documentation for Australia; its people, environment and events; was recorded for posterity from the beginning of white occupation. MacIntyre states that the aboriginals, who had no written history, were considered to have had no past, and this attitude helped white Australia to become one of the most heavily documented societies ever to have existed. Much of this documentation was propaganda, which was supplemented with memoirs, journals of exploration and travel, emigrant manuals, land promotion and scientific data. All these documents were written into novels, which were the most influential historical literatures of the time. Clark states that this was the sort of history he wanted to write, history as a story and an art form.The study of history has remained "wedded to the notion of continuous progress." "Most people in...

Find Another Essay On Convicts and The writing of History: Reality or Myth?

ARE unicorns a MYTH or REALITY

1377 words - 6 pages on her journey and his unhappy wife, or the unicorn and her party seeing a princess calling for her in a forest, each enrich the story with their own individual comment on the theme, and slow the pace down so it feels a little bit more like life - a lot of amusing nothings with the odd profound occurrence spattered amongst it all.Throughout the novel, the mortal characters struggle to find their own fairy tale within the sometimes cruel reality

Ozzy Osbourne: The history of a Myth

3972 words - 16 pages the "Godfather of Heavy Metal"[2] and because of some of his material, the "Prince of Darkness." In the early 2000s, his career expanded to a new medium when he became a star in his own reality show, The Osbournes, alongside wife/manager Sharon and two of their three children, Kelly and Jack. In August 2008, Osbourne stated in USA Today that he intends to retire from his music career after two more albums. Osbourne was born

Finding a Balance Between Reality and Myth

961 words - 4 pages . It’s like an onion, once you peel off each layer symbolizing a mythical idea, what’s left in the core is the truth, what one can take with them to create their own mythical reality. Something that started out as a myth takes flight and people really live with the ideas that come from these mythical stories to create a stronger reality for themselves. For instance, in The Company of Wolves, Angela Carter was dissatisfied with the traditional

The role and impact former convicts had on Australian society

1945 words - 8 pages history, culture, and identity? Should we be proud of Australia's convict past, should we reject and be ashamed of our convict origins, or should we look at the complexity of convictism in the early days and not fall into either of these categories? It is true that the assumptions and values about convicts have gone through some drastic changes. But how do we view convicts and convictism today? It is without a doubt that convicts had a large

G.I. Jane - A Hollywood Myth or Contemporary Reality?

1475 words - 6 pages error that she had made twice before in training.But what about the psychological reasons. In war some soldiers will become POWs, it is an accepted fact. However, the dangers to female soldiers are far greater than male soldiers with the possibility of rape and other indignities. In the book "Women in Combat, Civic Duty or Military Liability," Marie E. DeYoung cites "an expose of the Air Force Academy prisoner of war training which revealed that

The American Cowboy: Myth vs. Reality

1316 words - 5 pages Historian Frederick Jackson Turner's famous essay "The Significance of the Frontier in American History" defines the "frontier" as a place of westward expansion with new opportunities, heroism, triumph and progress mainly by brave white men. While he writes that the "closing of the frontier" occurred with the extinction of the Western frontier and cowboy's character, Americans have found a way to glamorize the image of the cowboy in the west

The Stranger and The Myth of Sisyaphus

1023 words - 4 pages Many wise men have posed the question, "Why is it that people do not like to be alone?" Well, the answer to that question lies in the words of two exceptional writers: Albert Camus, and Ernest Hemingway. In Hemingway's, The Sun also Rises, and in Camus', The Stranger and The Myth of Sisyphus, these authors explore solitude, and the impact it has on people's lives and on happiness in general. It is suggested in all three of these works

Writing the History of the World

1099 words - 4 pages Writing the History of the World To write a history of the world, one must begin at a point when the world is shifting from the remnants of old empires into the modern or at least the pre modern world as we know it. During the 15th century, we begin to see a change; Europe climbs out of the Middle Ages, tosses off its religious shackles and starts evolving. The Europeans set sail and we start to see well-documented

History of Writing

835 words - 4 pages people, both children and adults, to read and learn from. People throughout history and today even use writing for religious reasons such as writing out a prayer to God or even taking note on what has happened or talked of in the sermon. Not only has writing revolutionized, nevertheless writing utensils have as well. Writing utensils have gone from bone, to clay, to pen and pencil in thousands of years. With bone, you would scratch the bone

Magnetic Water and Treatment: Myth or Magic?

1144 words - 5 pages It is important that everyone know of the need to improve our energy and water savings and assist in reducing the use of electricity, water, and non-renewable fuel sources. There are a number of non-chemical, non-mechanical water treatment technologies. Many of these are known by names such as electronic, magnetic, electrostatic, electromagnetic, and AC induction. The history of these devices goes back to at least 1952. Claims for and

The Power of Myth

4019 words - 16 pages stereotypical submission. I started to question why mythical women were relegated to one word (as in Hamilton's presentation) or stereotyped. I decided to pursue a line of inquiry that explored the nature of women and mythologyódo myths perpetuate certain gender stereotypes? Do they serve as models of inequality? In what ways are we (as students of mythology) conditioned to view the women in myth as relegated to certain roles and voices, stripped of power

Similar Essays

Anonymity And Internet Privacy, Reality Or Myth?

1615 words - 6 pages With the introduction of internet-chat, hacking and e-commerce into our modern lifestyle, drastic measures to the protection of users' online personal information had to be implemented. But first what is Internet privacy and what are the ethical issues that we face when trying to face problems related to this subject?Nowadays, privacy on the web has become a necessity to everyone. No matter where you go or what you do, someone could be watching

Teenagers Myth And Reality Essay

1019 words - 4 pages When you hear the words "teenagers" or "adolescents", what other terms come to your mind? "Rebellious," "secretive," "moody" or "self-centred"? Almost anything written about adolescents is likely to include these words.But are these really fair descriptions of the typical teenager? Do they spell trouble for teens and their families? Not necessarily. There have been many studies done on teens and their families. To a very large extent the

Genesis: Myth Or H Istory? Essay

1233 words - 5 pages Genesis: Myth or History? Followers of the Judeo-Christian belief are often referred to as "the people of the Book." This then implies that the structural foundation of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam is centered around the text in which they follow. Of these three religions, Judaism and Christianity both follow the first five books of the Old Testament known to the Jews as the Pentateuch. In addition to these five books

Are Unicorns A Myth Or Reality?

526 words - 2 pages Are Unicorns a Myth or Reality?The Unicorn is a particularly beautiful creature once widespread throughout the northern hemisphere. Known under different names in different countries, it is now popularly known by its Latin appellation deriving from unus=one and cornus=horn. The Unicornus sinoensis roams the forests of China, Japan and Indonesia; The Unicornus runiferous however, is found throughout Arabia, India, North Africa and much of the