This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Corporal Punishment With Respect To The Private And Public Sphere.

1520 words - 7 pages

1 Introduction
Corporal punishment is the unlawful intentional act of causing harm by physically inflicting punishment on the body of an offender or severely criticising the offender. There is a distinction in common-law between corporal punishment in the public sphere and in the private sphere.
Corporal punishment on children in the private sphere is administered by parents. It is legally accepted in South Africa, provided that the requirements are met.
The public sphere’s position is much different in the sense that the government along with all schools have no authority to physically discipline school children anymore. Authority to exercise corporal punishment often leads to abuse of power, child abuse and feelings of superiority. All of the above mentioned factors will contribute to the future for a common-law defence of reasonable disciplinary chastisement in South African law

2 General implications of corporal punishment
In most cases, punishment is given to clarify the authority and status over the offender. Irrespective of the harm the child or the offender caused, physically punishing the offender violates many of that person’s fundamental human rights. Punishment is given in the form of slapping, whipping, verbally reprimanding or violently acting towards the child or the offender which contributes to the current violence in South Africa. These punishments violate constitutional rights. Consequently, section 10 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (the ‘Constitution’) provides that everyone has the right to have their dignity respected and protected. Section 12 of the Constitution states that all citizens have: “The right to freedom and security of the person” and section 12(d): “The right not to be treated or punished in a cruel, inhumane or degrading way”. Violence is never the solution, it only does good temporarily, yet the scars it leaves behind, are permanent.

3 Corporal punishment in the private sphere
Parents have the authority to physically punish their children as South Africa’s common-law consists of a ground of justification for unlawfulness, known as corporal punishment. Rex v Janke & Janke (‘Janke’) clarifies the rights parents have when corporally punishing their children with the intention of teaching them a valuable lesson. The requirements for this defence are for it to be moderate and reasonable. The reasonable requirement refers to the child having to wrongfully do something or threaten to do so. The moderate requirement states that the punishment must be in proportion to the age, build, health and gender of the child. Corporal punishment by parental authority can only succeed as a defence if it meets these requirements, as well as having the intention to discipline or educate the child.

3 1 Arguments against parent’s right of chastisement
The harm inflicted on a child when punishing him/her, violates the human rights of the child, which states that every child should be protected from...

Find Another Essay On Corporal punishment with respect to the private and public sphere.

Corporal Punishment and Abuse Essay

1874 words - 8 pages parents is the absence of moral internalization. Moral internalization is defined as adopting the norms, ethics, perspective and the behaviour which is accepted by the society not only to articulate their feelings to others in public but also in private when they are alone. It is the self-control of children when nobody is there to ask them for their misconduct. But corporal punishment restricts in fact leads the children to moral externalization

Corporal Punishment and Parents Essay

1619 words - 7 pages parents as by continuous use of corporal punishment the respect of parents from their heart is eliminated and it’s the only fear which keeps them obeying their parents for that interval of time. Keeping in view all the long term negative effects of corporal punishment, this immediate compliance which is even not permanent has negligible importance. So this argument of expeditious acquiescence is not enough to support corporal punishment. Moreover

Jürgen Habermas: Public Sphere and Media Sphere

1297 words - 5 pages how to apply his theory to social media. Internet changed citizen’s relationship with the media and created a new way of doing what the author thought of as a principle of democracy: rational-critical debate. How relevant is the public sphere concept in today societies? We will expose Habermas’ concept and critic it, and then see how we talk about public sphere in a hyper connected world. In feudal world, debate was a private affair for

Public Sphere and The Ideals of a Democratic Society

1235 words - 5 pages area where people could meet and freely discuss issues within society (Ironstone March 21, 2014). On the other hand, the emergence of communicative technologies ties in with the idea of communicative capitalism, which emphasizes that the market is the “site of democratic aspirations” (Dean 2005, p. 54). Using Nancy Fraser, Jürgen Habermas, and Jodi Dean’s ideas, this essay will argue that nor the public sphere or societies endless access to

The Controversy Around Corporal Punishment

1443 words - 6 pages corporal punishment and believes that it should not be illegal, uses scriptures from the bible as justification. Supporters of corporal punishment feels as if spanking is an effective way to manage behavior. Those who are against spanking points out the negative, psychological issues, and mental disorders associated with whipping a child. This issue matters and is important to comprehend because spanking can lead to physical abuse, affect self

A Comparative Technical Analysis of Banking Sector with Special to Public and Private Sector Bank

1323 words - 6 pages year value, Sales, Operating profit margin, Net profit, Equity, Earning per share, Book value, Factor value, Dividend and Price Earnings for the public sector bank of SBI, and for the private sector banks of HDFC. 1 Weekly movement of Current market price The performances of Current market price of the public sector and private sector banks are analyzed in this section. The Weekly movement of Current market price of the public sector and private

With attention to women’s and gender history’s appropriation of an androcentric framework, discuss the significance of the ‘public and private sph

1662 words - 7 pages by women and a set of boundaries expected to be observed by women. The ‘public sphere’ was tied to men, politics, economy and law, whilst the ‘private sphere’ was linked with women, family, domesticity and emotional intimacy – notions which women’s and gender history appeared to accept and challenge simultaneously. Their respective appropriations of the model were problematic, for as we will see, the separate spheres model itself can be viewed

Russia and the Problematic Relationship with the Soviet Sphere

941 words - 4 pages Crisis poses Russian - Ukrainian explosive Currently, Bchabadtha Euro - U.S. , the problematic relationship between Russia on the one hand , and « the Soviet sphere » the former on the other hand . After the disintegration of the Soviet Union in the early nineties of the last century , Moscow was keen in the midst of transitions and political and economic chaos , to ensure a minimum level of influence , through maintaining the political and

Redefining Public and Private

3836 words - 15 pages together, of their normative significance." The mantra of second wave feminism, "the personal is political," signifies the first attempt to break down the gendered division between the private sphere attributed to women and the public sphere of men. There is no clear origin of this public/private division; it could have been, as Germaine Greer humorously suggests, "while the male-hunter-gatherer strolled along burdened with no more that his spear

The Public Sphere of Athenian Women

1970 words - 8 pages Women are often excluded from discussion when looking at all periods of history from ancient Greece to our own Canadian history. The lack of sources pertaining to women was likely caused by the traditional view that women are, in some ways, inferior to men. Athenian women are usually studied in two domains: the private sphere and the public sphere. Many studies acknowledge that women are consumed by the family and remain in the home. However

Jürgen Habermas’ Idea of the Public Sphere

2247 words - 9 pages Jürgen Habermas’ idea of the “public sphere” is considered a communications revolution because it allowed for the transfer of information and ideas. This free flow of communication that grew out of the public opinion would allow democracy to prevail as it provided checks on powerful groups in society and allowed for critical discussions. Although Habermas’ notion of this democratic mechanism allowed for citizens to play a larger role in society

Similar Essays

Corporal Punishment In Public Schools Essay

784 words - 3 pages share of skeletons in the closet, but in the United States, many states that allowed corporal punishment in their schools are now outlawing its use. In conclusion, with these factors in mind, this is why I believe that corporal punishment should not be permitted in public schools. Besides, there are other civilized ways that have been proven to discipline students such as a Social Skills Instruction Character Education Programs, Student

Ct Os And The Public Sphere Essay

2086 words - 8 pages We as a team do not agree that Community Treatment Orders (CTO) is a way to maximize the liberty of persons diagnosed with psychiatric illnesses by ensuring the continued participation in community living First of all, the effectiveness of CTO's has only not been proven it also undermines people's basic human rights. This debate will indicate that we are firmly against CTO's as a way of community involvement, and

Privatizing The Public Sphere Essay

1603 words - 6 pages without public spaces such as parks, streets, and buildings, the mixing of classes will become increasingly uncommon. Society is made up of two sectors: the private and public, and it is essential that both remain separate entities. However, through the use of fear tactics especially the threat of violent crimes, privatized settings are spreading throughout the public sphere. In this analysis, it is my intent to explore the various tactics being

The Public Sphere Essay

1161 words - 5 pages amount of people who were taking interest in political issues was growing as well. Now, politics was not an issue to be delt with solely by the upper-class. David Waldstreicher in writing about the effect that print had on public celebrations, such as parades, states Through the new media of journalism, urban festival reached an expanding audience. . . Even the new, bourgeois public sphere can be seen as a locus for relating and