Cosmogenic Myths: Timaeus And Genesis I

1269 words - 5 pages

Although, they are different in every region, cosmogenic myths have many universal elements that are seemingly essential to the genre. The archetypal creation or origin myth contains four ideas that create a foundation for subsequent cultural dogma: primeval chaos, dualism, creation through sacrifice, and conjecture. They can start out very simply, and grow more complex as they are affected by time. They may be distorted, as they are passed down by oral tradition. And then later, when they are written down the meaning may change. But none of that will matter because, without the proper context one cannot understand the true implications of cosmogenic myths.
The Greek philosopher and student of Socrates, Plato lived in Athens c. 429–347 BCE. His work explores political, ethical, and metaphysical themes and has influenced the development of western society. Plato's works endure not just because of the concepts they explore, but for their dialectical style. All but one of his works are in the from of dialogue, in which characters hold philosophical debates. His dialogues have incurred much controversy among academics, since it is not clear what parts were Plato's beliefs and which were the character's. Since this is true, it is thought that Plato's intention was for the reader to view the works as a whole. Any interpretation of Plato's reflects one's personal philosophy, which may have been his intention; why should the author's thoughts seem better than our own interpretations his philosophical principles? Plato's Timaeus discusses the creation of the universe (or kosmos), and is widely accepted to be among his later works. In Timaeus, Plato describes how the divine craftsman, or Demiurge, created order from chaos by imposing mathematical constants like phi: the golden ratio.
Unlike Plato, the author of the biblical creation story in Genesis I is a bit more elusive. Scholars have identified three distinct literary styles in Genesis. The Yahwist, Elohist, and Priestly strains were all written at different times and later combined. The strains reflect literary techniques derived from the oral–written traditions of different regions, times, and points of view. The Yahwist or Jahwist (J) strain is the oldest of the three; thought to be written as early as 950 BCE, J was traced to Judah, and used the name Yahweh for God. The Elohist (E) strain, written c. 900-700 BCE, was believed composed in northern Israel because of it's noticeable predilection for Israeli priests and traditions. While J anthropomorphizes Yahweh by showing him form man with his hands, taking walks through Eden, and eating food that Abraham offers him, E's God, Elohim, is much more less physical but shows human emotions like regret. Around 750 BCE J and E were combined and some stories remained in their original form and other were melded together. The Priestly strain (P) was written much later around 400 BCE and contains the roles, rules, and rituals of priesthood. It...

Find Another Essay On Cosmogenic Myths: Timaeus and Genesis I

Creation Myths Essay

1020 words - 5 pages Throughout history man has searched for an explanation of our origins and why we are here. Many creation myths are attempts of our ancestors to do just that. I have found in reading many of these creation myths, that there is also an attempt to explain why human existence is imperfect. The following essay will compare and contrast four creation myths and their explanation of how mans imperfection came to be. The first creation myth I will begin

Creation Myth Essay

520 words - 2 pages Jordan VitelliEnglish 230: MythologyProf. Otero-PiersanteCreation Mythology: Exam 1, Part 2-Essay 118, March, 2010 What Is the Purpose of Cosmogony?The purpose of Cosmogony is to study the origin and evolution of the universe.Attempting to grasp and retain all of the creation myths can be a hefty task, therefore, I do not claim to know much of these creation myths yet. From what I have learned, there seems to be a strong correlation of sexuality

Comparison of the Bibles and Tablet XI flood story

1661 words - 7 pages the book of Genesis is remarkably similar to the Tablet XI of the Epic of Gilgamesh. Some people make the claim; the Bible plagiarizes The Epic of Gilgamesh, though no conclusive evidence has been found. Their storylines are quite analogous; however they have some significant differences. People wonder if the two myths are based off of each other or even based off a currently unknown, older, similar, source. Although I acknowledge it is a

Compare and Contrast ?Genesis? and ?Penetrating to the Heart of the Forest?,

1257 words - 5 pages mythic story (Adam and Eve) in the form of a short story. When comparing and contrasting these two stories we see similarities in storyline, themes, symbols, differences in detail, and the extent and significance of the stories themselves.      When deciding whether these narratives are myths or short stories, one must look at the contents of each piece of work. “Genesis” can clearly be defined as a myth because it contains

Creation Or Evolution

474 words - 2 pages , this concept has some serious flaws. some plants which depend upon birds, ants, etc. for pollination could not survive the hundreds of millions of years between the creation of plants and the creation of birds and animals. A final approach is to accept the established findings of science. This requires that the first few chapters in Genesis be seen as creation myths - similar to myths of many other religions worldwide. This approach obviously

Four Functions of Myths in Genesis

2160 words - 9 pages Four Functions of Myths in Genesis The sin stories in the Book of Genesis address theological, cosmic, social, and ethical questions. These sin stories, The Fall of Man, Cain and Abel, and Noah and the Flood, and The Tower of Babel show the functions of myths and demonstrate man's likeliness to sin. These myths let the readers learn of the culture, beliefs, and foundation of the time. A myth is a symbolic way of expressing truths and

The Biblical Flood of Genesis Based Upon the Flood of the Epic of Gilgamesh

1690 words - 7 pages .” Genesis 6:13-14 And God said to Noah “I have determined to make an end of all flesh; for the earth is filled with violence through them...Make yourself an ark...” Genesis 6: 17-19 “For behold, I will bring a flood of waters upon the earth, to destroy all flesh...but...you shall come into the ark, you, your sons, your wife, and you sons’ wives with you. And of every living thing of all flesh, you shall bring two of each sort into the ark to keep

The World on the Turtle's Back

741 words - 3 pages Native American myths are passed down from generation to generation. They change slightly as they are retold so there are different versions; however, they still have the same story line and outcome. Native American myths have many similarities; for example, there are almost always animals in Native American myths. Native American myths also involve nature and many earthly things, such as trees, plants, crops, sky, wind, etc. They also believe

Atlantis - Myth or Fact

2020 words - 8 pages When people think of myths, the images, concepts, and beliefs that emerge are usually that of old wives tales, mystical stories of gods and heroes, fables, fairy tales, and superstitions. We normally see them as colorful works of literature by people with vivid imaginations. However, to get answers to our questions like; are these myths just stories or are they based on facts? Is there any truth in them? We must look deeper into who, what, and

The Problem With Teaching Creationism in the Science Classroom

1363 words - 5 pages the Near East. The flood account in The Epic of Gilgamesh, when compared with the flood narrative in Genesis, is often cited as an example of such a similarity between Genesis and other Near Eastern texts. However, the creation stories of the first two chapters of Genesis find links with other Near Eastern creation myths. The Enuma elish is a Near Eastern creation myth that contains a god who creates the universe by separating aspects of it

The Flood of Noah and the Flood of Gilgamesh

2425 words - 10 pages doing. This indicates possible corruption that might have been common. However, the religions were clearly different. While Noah worshipped one God, Utnapishtam worshipped many gods. It is possible that religion may have changed over the course of history, but at the moment, it is unsure whether they were of same culture. Because of the special feature of extraordinary similarity in the flood myths in Genesis and Gilgamesh, there have been many

Similar Essays

Comparison Of Genesis I And Exodus 20

660 words - 3 pages The purpose of the creation story is not central to the Bible but serves as a prologue to the historical drama, which are the central concerns of the Bible. The narrative focus in the Bible is on the story that begins with Noah and is centered on the exodus from Egypt. The central event in the Bible is the creation of the covenant and the giving of laws and commandments. Although the creation of the world in Genesis I and the pronouncement of

On Plato’s Critique Of The Arts

912 words - 4 pages is problematic. I will argue the opposite: that Plato's use of myths and images in his dialogues are acceptable because 1) his arguments function as the basis for his works and the style functions as decorations to his arguments and 2) Plato meets his own criterion to allow art because his decorations are of the right kind.Before explaining Plato's argument that imitative poetry is invalid, I must first explain the mimetic theory that Plato bases

Hi, This Is A Title Essay

1559 words - 7 pages The Hebrew book of Genesis and the Babylonian Enuma Elish both tell accounts of creation. The stories of creation in Genesis and the Enuma Elish are noticeably different; however, upon closer examination, the two myths share similarities. Each myth explains different processes of creation. In Genesis, man is formed from the Earth, but in the Enuma Elish man is created from the blood of the god Quingu. Also, the Enuma Elish is polytheistic, but

Similarities In The Mythologies Of Creation

1683 words - 7 pages Metamorphoses I. 76-88). Prometheus is the creator in this account, and his method of creation resembles that of the Book of Genesis. God creates man in his Garden of Eden in the same fashion. God forms man out of the earth, just as Prometheus does. The two myths become even more alike when the reader finds that Athena breathes life into Prometheus’ man, just as God breathes life into Adam. When comparing these myths, it is quite apparent that the