Is The Buying And Selling Of People Morally Right?

900 words - 4 pages

Based on the substantial ideas provided by John Locke and other readings, President Schwarzenegger?s proposal to allow the buying of substitutes for the draft is wrong because it promotes the devaluation of humans based on their economic status and opposes the theory of utilitarianism as well as the concept of distribution.One Prime reason why the proposal is wrong is the concept that buying a human is a form of slavery and a portrayal of inequality. All humans are born to the same advantages of nature and thereby are equal. In an equal society there should be no subordination or subjection.(Locke chp II). Treating people with respect is an important part of a fair society. The government allowing for the buying and selling of substitutes for the draft is equivalent to declaring that richer people are superior to the poor and thus the poor deserve to suffer. On the other hand, the poor selling their selves as substitute would corrupt the meaning of being human. Locke states that ?But through this be a state of liberty, yet it is not a state of license though men in that state, have and uncontrollable liberty to dispose of his person or possessions, yet he has no liberty to destroy himself or so much as any creature in his possession.? The proposal allows for self destruction because there is no guarantee that a soldier would return from a war alive.The proposal also promotes the exploitation of the economically disenfranchised because the money incentive of selling yourself as a substitute would coerce the poor people to do what conflicts with their moral beliefs. For instance, in the case of Baby ?M? (regarding a contract dispute arising out of a surrogacy contract) the court based itsdecision on the fact that the surrogate mother was not shown to be unfit for the child. The court declared the contract void because the money incentive made her choice less voluntary and thus the best interests of the child become a secondary part to the market. Connecting this issue to the proposal, one cannot proof that he poor is unfit to live. Legally, the proposal may be lawful because it was passed by the government, however it is a strong moral issue since people are exploited based on their economic status.Furthermore, in the ?Human Body Shop? The sale in interstate commerce of organs or organ subparts was prohibited because it took advantage of poor people who would sell their organs to feed their children. This applies to the purchasing of substituted for the military draft since selling of the organs is adjacent to selling yourself, and both corrupt the sense of being human. In ?Tragic Choices?, buying a substitute became a...

Find Another Essay On Is the buying and selling of people morally right?

Is Euthanasia Morally and Philosophically Justifiable?

911 words - 4 pages . Reaching a destination by driving does not incite the immediate question of the effect the drive will have on the car, but a doctor does need to ask the question of the effect a treatment, or lack thereof, will have on the patient's life. As passive and active euthanasia have been shown to be more or less morally equivalent, the question that must then be answered is do we as individuals have the right to ask our life be ended if, because of

Abortion is Morally and Ethically Wrong

1198 words - 5 pages . “All men are created equal and endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, among theses are the right to life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness.” The above quote goes out to declare that we as human beings have the right to live and fulfill life and its course that is desire for us. Therefore it is proving that abortion should not be legal and is morally and ethically wrong. Arguments to abortion either one is for it or

The Death Penalty Is Morally Unjustified

1186 words - 5 pages , the number of executions and death sentence has decreased tremendously over the years. (Dieter, 2011) With the European Union and the Human Right Watch pressing for the abolishment of death penalty, there is much disparity and debate among the citizens of the United States of America on whether the death penalty should be continued or abolished. For the advocates of the death penalty, they champion death penalty as the only way to make

America Must Ban the Selling of Firearms

1207 words - 5 pages violent crime is reduced when citizens have a law that allows them to carry concealed weapons. In 1994 a crime bill was passed that included an assault weapons ban that outlawed the manufacturing and selling of semiautomatic weapons and prohibits the manufacturing of copies.      The Johns Hopkins Center for Gun Policy and Research was established in 1995 and applies an approach to informing the public about guns. The Center attempts to educate the

The Selling of Women in America

1748 words - 7 pages The Selling of Women in America Beautiful, skin-tight clothing, thin, blonde, long hair, and big breasted women are what people normally think of when they think of television commercials. This is very stereotypical but how stereotypical is it? Look at the media anymore and this is what the audience sees. There may be a change here and there with the hair color and how tight the clothing is but in all honestly this is what the public is

Revenge, is it morally justified? Refers to The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas

1023 words - 4 pages on smaller issues. But is it morally justified? The answer to this question is largely depends on whom you ask, and it may vary according to the concepts and values that he/her was raised on - it differs among different peoples, cultures and traditions. In this essay I will try to answer this question from the point of the story The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas. In order to discuss the revenge issue of this book let us begin by a

The Morally Good and Bad in Othello

1765 words - 7 pages The Morally Good and Bad in Othello        William Shakespeare’s drama Othello is one concentrated contest between the forces of the morally good and the morally bad. Let us analyze this contest in detail in this essay.   Standing out like a dark silhouette on a white background is the sinister character and master of deception in the drama – the general’s ancient. Morton W. Bloomfield and Robert C. Elliott  in Great Plays

The right to disagree is projected in modern democracies and yet people still suffer because they have different values from the majority. Give your views.

725 words - 3 pages politicians were forced to leave Athens or killed based on very doubtful evidences prepared in politically-dependent courts. Meeting of all citizens (Ecclesia) was no more than a crowd; the number of people was to great for conducting typical responsibilities of parliament, legislation, and controlling the government or state administration. In real democratic country there is no need for institution like "ostracism". Democratic system is too

Buying the War and Bush’s War

823 words - 4 pages The videos about “Buying the War and Bush’s War,” show the American people the cruel reality about the war in Iraq. They display many of the atrocities committed within the war, were many Americans and Iraqis died. This was the time when the country of the United States was under George Bush’s administration (2001-2008). All was initiated after the attack to the World Trade Center, on 9/11, which was one of the biggest terrorist attacks that

Complexities of the organisational buying process

1390 words - 6 pages initiator who notices a problem and initiates the buying process. The decisions of the buyer in the buying center might not agree with the people in the organisation who are actually using the products bought. That is why it is vital to have a carefully selected buying center that takes into account all the personnel involved in the organisation. This also adds complexity to the buying process as going through the entire organisation trying to make

Euthanasia: A controversial issue paper dealing with whether or not people have the right to choose to die. This paper is in support of euthanasia/assisted suicide.

1257 words - 5 pages includes the ban on assistedsuicide and euthanasia. (Lund, 41)Although at the present time many people believe that terminally illpatients have the right to choose, many also believe that it is unethical.The active termination of a person's life is against the law and violatesmedical ethics. (Outerbridge, 95) "If the Federal courts strike down lawsagainst assisted suicide, they will unleash legions of Jack Kevorkians."(Lund, 42) To start, some doctors

Similar Essays

Send In The Clones Is Clonig Morally Right? My Opinion On Cloning. Consequences And Trouble Involved In Clonig

690 words - 3 pages stereotype. The main opposing argument is that clones will not have any uniqueness or personality of their own. This is where many people are wrong. Nature has been making its own clones for millions of years in the form of identical twins. Studies show that identical twins, humans with the same genetic makeup, have many similarities, but that they also have different personalities and their own uniqueness. Our individuality comes from our environment

A Proposed Method To Boost Sales By Designing A Website That Would Allow Buying And Selling Of Products

525 words - 2 pages looked at other websites of similar companies and I concluded that they all offer customers the ability to buy products. To give ICOMS an edge, I propose that the website be designed to integrate buying, selling, modification and customization of existing products by customers and the ability to make requests for special orders. Although it may be expensive, I think it can be considered a worthwhile business expense that is necessary to ensure

What Is A Buying Center. Explain How The Prcoess Of Buying Center

1140 words - 5 pages selecting suppliers.Webster and Wind call the decision making unit of a buying organization the buying center. The buying center is composed of "all those individuals and groups who participate in the purchasing from the decision". The buying center includes all members of the organization who play any of seven roles in the purchase decision process.Several roles of organization buying:Initiators: Those who request that something be purchased. They

Making The Production And Selling Of Cigarettes Illegal

1400 words - 6 pages and 22% would support a ban to make cigarettes illegal in all parts of the country. The production and selling of cigarettes should be permanently illegal as they have harmful effects on the environment, people, and invades freedom of choice. Cigarettes inability to biodegrade and manufacturing effects on environment are harmful and accounts for about 25% of garbage nationwide. This is cause for concern considering more and more young people 17