Counter Terrorism Strategy Essay

1489 words - 6 pages

Counter-terrorism strategy has been a key issue since September 11, 2001. Daniel Byman posits, “Most elements of counter-terrorism strategy address one of two different goals: disrupting the group itself, and its operations; or changing the overall environment to defuse the group’s anger or make it harder to raise money or attract recruits” (pg. 121). However, there are some fundamental flaws concerning these simplistic, straightforward approaches. Byman analyzes seven strategic options to combat terrorism; “Unilateral, multilateral action, containment, defense, diversion, delegitimation, and transforming terrorist breeding ground” (pg. 122). Furthermore, while Byman has made some valid observations, it is necessary to educate the public on terrorists threats, how to prevent them, and understand the threat of radical Islam. Moreover, mitigating and disrupting the financial network of a terrorist organization is essential to stopping the growth of terrorism. This essay will explore key decisions on the different approaches to counter-terrorism and determine which strategies are viable for real world application.
Unilateral and Multilateral action sound idealistic on paper, but when applied in real life it leads to blow back. Unilateral action involves direct action against your enemy. Unilateral action tends to be popular with the public. Byman asserts, “The goal is to kill (or arrest) those who mean to do harm. In practice, such an approach means going well beyond current counter-terrorism policies and using military forces to kill terrorist members and large numbers of supporters wherever they can be found. According to proponents, killing on a mass scale will both reduce the number of terrorists and intimidate those who remain” (pg. 123). Michael Scheuer, who once led the CIA’s Osama Bin Laden task forces, calls for the United States to use World War II tactics to neutralize the terrorism threat. Scheuer states, “That unchanged U.S. policies toward the Muslim world leave America only a military option for defending itself’ and that military force cannot be applied ‘daintily’. Scheuer calls for the United States to return to a Second World War-style use of force, with fast-paced killing and ‘extremely large’ body counts. 6 US allies, Scheuer contends, will not do this dirty work on America’s behalf” (pg. 123).
Even though there have been successful campaigns using multilateral force, such as, Turkey suppressing the PKK’s rebellion, the costs still outweigh the benefits. Byman points to the United States conflict with Al Qaeda as an example:
“First and foremost, the required intelligence capabilities are daunting. Because of al-Qaeda’s global presence (to say nothing of the far-flung presence of its sympathizers), the United States would need a massive intelligence presence in every country with a significant jihadist presence, including Pakistan, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Yemen and Indonesia. The US government...

Find Another Essay On Counter-Terrorism Strategy

Challenges for US Counter-terrorism Efforts Essay

1269 words - 5 pages Challenges for US Counter-terrorism Efforts   As a direct consequence of September 11, a number of substantial challenges lie ahead in the area of counter-terrorism..   The most prominent of these is the changing nature of the terrorism phenomenon.  In past years, when terrorism was largely the product of direct state sponsorship, policymakers were able to diminish prospects for the United States becoming a target using a combination of

The tool of Terrorism Essay

861 words - 4 pages conceptions of terrorism. Three movie, the 2 versions of The Quiet American and the Baader-Meinhof Complex, illustrates some of the arguments these writers make. Crenshaw argues that terrorism is a strategy based on a collective rationality and strategic choice. When an organization decides to resort to violence, they did it based on for political and strategic reasons rather that of psychological or social factors. She describes terrorist as

Effects of UK Anti-Terrorism Laws on Human Rights

2836 words - 11 pages , however this was then changed to 28 days. The Act also prohibited the “glorification” of terrorism. The Counter-terrorism Act, 2008 allowed for fingerprints and DNA samples to be taken from individuals subject to control orders (Loughnane, 2012). The July 7 attacks saw the creation on new laws which fixated on strengthening police detention powers rather than privacy which displayed a belief that a need to hold and share information was

Counter-Terrorism

1199 words - 5 pages possibly be dealt with outside military actions. There has to be a change of countering terrorism on our part to counter the ongoing change of strategy by the terrorist. As you can see that using military action is a quick fix to try and prevent terrorism instead of analyzing the cause and possible alternatives. But one con of trying to win the hearts and minds of the people is that it could take a lot longer and possibly require a lot more money and

Political Violence

2071 words - 8 pages property targets. These groups or agents engage in this behavior intending the purposeful intimidation of governments or people to affect policy of behaviors with an underlying political objective,” (Martin, 2009). The decision to engage in terrorism can occur for many reasons: logical choice, political strategy, ennui with the elite, and lack of opportunity for political participation. Air India flight 182 was a flight operating on from

Military Science: Irregular Warfare

1306 words - 6 pages the key issues that governments face in creating effective strategies for irregular warfare with a particular emphasis on counter-insurgency (COIN) and terrorism. Resources such as time, space, legitimacy and support present themselves as key issues in dealing with insurgency and terrorism and are leveraged by an insurgent or terrorist group to gain an advantage over conventional military forces. Modern day understanding of insurgency and

Counterterrorism and American Presence Overseas

1462 words - 6 pages adversary has internal contradictions that, given time, will discredit and divide it. In al-Qaeda’s case, the adversary is divided on what target should receive priority, who is a true Muslim, whether it is against Western values or just US policies, and other core issues. Diversion A particularly nasty approach to counter-terrorism is to divert the jihadist onto someone else the so-called ‘campfire strategy’. This is the strategy of diversion. Though

Terroism In The U.S

2490 words - 10 pages many individuals are victimized by terrorist attacks is in the creation of fear that leads to changes in lifestyles. (Reid) Some may ask, what do people do to stop terrorism. The most recognized form of counter-terrorism is The Naval Special Warfare Development Group, formerly known as SEAL Team SIX and based in Dam Neck, Virginia. They are responsible for US counter-terrorist operations in the maritime environment. The NSWDG trains in both military

Terrorism and American Society

3338 words - 13 pages Terrorism against the United States has been a security issue that forced the government to establish the Department of Homeland Security in 2002, which is tasked with spearheading counter terrorism measures. American has experienced terror attacks on its home soil and against its foreign interests, making terrorism the biggest threat that is facing the country in the twenty first century. It is evident that even small terror groups can access

You can fight terrorism without infringing upon human rights

1079 words - 5 pages terrorists. In conclusion, I would label this assumption as true or partly true. If counterterrorists use holistic approach that provides that “counter-terrorism measures and the protection of human rights [are] not conflicting goals, but rather complementary and mutually reinforcing ones”[10], and apply UN Global Counter-terrorism strategy, then the assumption is theoretically true. In practice, Global CT strategy is not verified by all UN

The U.S. Patriot Act and the Risk of Losing Our Civil Liberties

1841 words - 8 pages cut down the work load of the agencies and by helping to reduce the redundant information which is gathered and last but not least help save the agency’s budget. This strategy of all agencies coming together to share is the short and long term strategy of fighting terror. Also GAO made reports that terrorism is a part of a larger insurrection, counter-terrorism may also form a part of a counter-insurgency policy, but political, economic, and

Similar Essays

Canada's Fight Against Terrorism Essay

1131 words - 5 pages borders of Canada and they support terrorism in other countries (“Building Resilience Against Terrorism: Canada’s Counter-terrorism Strategy”). Terrorism has been a concern for a while. Canada is not only concerned with the domestic threats against them, but they are also concerned with the attacks on the United States, Madrid, London, Bali, and Amsterdam (“Permanent Mission of Canada to the United Nations”). Furthermore, Canada has taken a counter

Terrorism 4 Essay

625 words - 3 pages counter-terrorism operations and programs (Best, 2009). Lastly predictions on future terror related problems associated with vulnerable threat areas can be made. International cooperation in areas such as counter-terrorism has significant reduced the threat of terrorism since September 11 (Walters, 2008). Through a multi- stage strategy terrorism as a central force especially al-Qaeda has significantly been damaged. Prior to 9/11 the International

Terroisims Threat To Australia A Federal Issue

305 words - 2 pages United States is an important factor in the counter-terrorism strategy. The United States is the global leader in the fight against international terrorism. No other country has the global reach required, or the resources, to help other countries improve their own capabilities to deal with terrorism.To stop terrorism is impossible in my own opinion but there is a way to limit terrorist casualties. Australia should improve its defense program of

Impact Of International Terrorism On Indonesia

1455 words - 6 pages and radicalism. Also, the implementation of the United Nations Global Counter-Terrorism Strategy (UN GCTS) in countries in the Southeastern Asia region is essential, as the UN GCTS is the most comprehensive and universally accepted strategy to combat international terrorism. All laws regarding counter-terrorism should be in compliance with the rule-of-law safeguarding human rights. Local law enforcement also play a key role in the prevention of