Counterfactual Thinking Essay

1956 words - 8 pages

Counterfactual ThinkingWhen and how do children experience regret?Major Research Essay: Psyc241Student number: 4075274School: University of WollongongWord count: 1506The experience of regret arguably relies on a multifaceted, counterfactual analysis of two previously possible outcomes. An important question to consider is at what age these counterfactual emotions develop, and what enables these responses to occur. Previous research proposes that regret emerges at around 4 years old, marginally earlier than more recent studies conducted by Guttentag and Ferrell, who suggest that the experience of regret occurs relatively late in child development. The results of these studies argue that understanding, rather than simply experiencing counterfactual emotions relies heavily on a child's ability to simultaneously conceive alternate realities, and that a recognition of differing outcomes is a necessary, rather than sufficient component of the development of regret. These findings accumulate and extend previous research, and demonstrate that the development of counterfactual thinking in children is positively correlated with a complex cognitive processing of two alternate realities.The experience of regret and relief are counterfactual emotions based on a comparison of reality with a better, alternative situation. Counterfactual emotions are considered to perform important emotional regulatory functions, and require additional complex cognitive processing than more basic emotions such as anger, fear or happiness. They require us to consider 'dual possibilities' (Byrne, 2002) in which both outcomes were possible at some point in the past. The ability to experience emotions such as regret is believed to play an important role in decision-making following the emergence into adulthood. Significant differences however, exist between when children are thought to first experience regret. It is arguable that children's understanding of regret develops relatively late due to the complex nature of not only comprehending counterfactual thinking (Guttentag and Ferrell, 2004), which requires an identification and comparison of two equally possible, alternate actions. If children are unable to generate these comparisons, they are unable to experience the emotion of regret. Little research has been done on the cognitive processes behind the emergence of regret in young children, and thus many questions still exist as to why the experience of counterfactual thinking develops relatively late in childhood. Many inconsistencies exist in the theoretical understandings of regret, and subsequently further research is required in order to overcome these age-related discrepancies.Counterfactual thinking refers to an ability to think "about what could have been had an alternative decision been made or had the outcome been different" (Roese, 1991). It is within the intriguing paradigm that the ongoing research into the experience of regret takes place. Recent findings have shed...

Find Another Essay On Counterfactual Thinking

Our social world Essay

817 words - 3 pages save lives. When having a patient lying on the ground, medical personnel automatically checks vital signs and performs C.P.R. without thinking. Counterfactual thinking comes in after the emergency is over and we will start to analyze ourselves and question if we did everything possible or if we did anything wrong. Illusory thinking also affects us when we are evaluating symptoms that a patient is exhibiting; we try to find relationships between the

How Empirical Psychology Illuminates Issues in Moral Ontology

3783 words - 15 pages terms of subjective and intersubjective facts without loss of explanatory power. Since common sense explanatory practice does not provide definitive support for moral realism, Sturgeon reinforces his argument with the claim that these explanations stand up in the face of thought experiments concerning counterfactual situations. For instance, suppose that Alfred hits his innocent baby brother with a stick, thereby harming him. Katie sees Alfred

Cognitive Restructuring as a Therapeutic Technique

1635 words - 7 pages In Dr. Judith Beck’s video on cognitive therapy, she also emphasizes the importance of identifying distortions in the thinking of the clinically depressed. It is a “garbage in, garbage out” syndrome wherein reflexive self-criticisms trigger distorted conclusions. Beck teaches how to build a self-image only after examining actual evidence about people’s talents and abilities, or lack thereof. Depression is best treated when therapist and

The Effects of Modernity and the Military

1618 words - 6 pages was their rights as individuals, their freedom as a nation, and their culture which is a large part of the nation. People had very strong feelings about these types of things, so strong that they were willing to sacrifice their lives so their children could have those same rights as they had enjoyed. This is an example of future-oriented Modern thinking, which Giddens says is 'counterfactual thoughts as a mode of connecting past and present'(104

System Theory

1493 words - 6 pages Cognitive Behavior Therapy has many different approaches to dealing with people who are experiencing Cognitive Behavior. Explained in further detail will be discussed some of the therapies and why they are effective along with curtain approaches a therapist may use when dealing with a client. Also explained in more detail will be the purpose of Cognitive Therapy and how it works.ApproachCognitive behavior occurs when a person is thinking

Analysis of An Authoritarian Personality

1326 words - 5 pages (Christman, Sontam, & Jasper, 2009) and poorer at counterfactual thinking (Jasper, Barry, & Christman, 2008); in these three studies there were few, if any, consistent left-handers in the samples and they were excluded from statistical analyses. Finally consistency, regardless of left or right direction, was positively correlated with tendency to fixate (or ruminate) on current worries (Niebauer, 2004).

Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality

3251 words - 13 pages pondered the great philosophical questions, and as befits serious philosopher, he did not adopt a "motto"; but had he done so, it would undoubtedly have been his friend Einstein's keen observation: "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we were at when we created them". Accordingly, Zubiri believes that prior to development of any epistemology, such as Hume's, it is first necessary to go one level deeper

A Philosophy of the Impersonal

5335 words - 21 pages the limited extension, the partiality, or the unfinished character of the ideology of the person that produces these counterfactual results. If the fog lifts surrounding the premise that has taken on the features of a true and proper personalist fundamentalism, what we see is that the category of person cannot somehow make up for or fill the gaping hole between rights and man -- and in turn making possible something like human rights -- because it

Arguments Given by David Chalmers for Rejecting a Materialistic Account of Consciousness in His Book

5853 words - 23 pages characterized by the claim: B-properties supervene logically on A-properties if it is logically impossible for two situations to have exactly the same B-properties without also sharing the same A-properties. Another way of thinking about this is to consider what it would be in God's power to create. It would be impossible for God to create a world in which, for example, bachelors were married. Due to the meanings of those two terms, it is logically

Reality and Illusion in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Reality, Appearance and Deception

896 words - 4 pages Reality and Illusion in Hamlet   Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, begins with the appearance of a ghost, an apparition, possibly a hallucination. Thus, from the beginning, Shakespeare presents the air of uncertainty, of the unnatural, which drives the action of the play and develops in the protagonist as a struggle to clarify what only seems to be absolute and what is actually reality. Hamlet's mind, therefore, becomes the central force of the

Sub-plots in Hamlet

1118 words - 4 pages Sub-plots in Hamlet   There are many things that critics say make Hamlet a "Great Work," one of which is the way that Shakespeare masterfully incorporates so many sub-plots into the story, and ties them all into the main plot of Hamlet’s revenge of his father’s murder. By the end of Act I, not only is the main plot identified, but many other sub-plots are introduced. Among the sub-plots are trust in the Ghost of King Hamlet, Fortinbras, and

Similar Essays

Counterfactual Thinking And Victim Compensation: A Test Of Norm Theory.

790 words - 3 pages Untitled Counterfactual Thinking and Victim Compensation: A Test of Norm Theory. Enrique J Perez ID: 1792553 Dale T. Miller and Cathy MacFarland talk about the norm theory in a very interesting way in this article. The norm theory identifies factors that determine the ease with which alternatives to reality can be imagined or constructed. There are several assumptions of the norm theory, one assumption of norm theory is that the

Susser's Three Characteristics To Argue That The Outcome And Exposure Can Only Be Inferred From Epidemiological Studies

1170 words - 5 pages relationship can be defined by the distribution of observed variables, a causal relationship cannot be.3 This paper will use the lens of Susser’s three characteristics of a cause, association, time order, and direction to argue that a causal relationship between exposure and outcome can only be inferred from experimental epidemiologic studies. The basis for this argument is an examination of the counterfactual model and an analysis of both

Counterfactualism In History Essay

2671 words - 11 pages purely "might have been" kind may be more suited to fiction than to serious historiography, its main benefit lying in its entertainment value, we should still maintain that there are forms of counterfactual thinking which are of very real value to the historian. In addition to the use of the concept as an aid to understanding the evolutionary past which we have just mentioned, other benefits include not only understanding what alternatives would have been considered by historical agents, but also the possibility of making reasonable assessments of what would have been the likely outcomes of decisions which in fact were not made.

Videogames Essay

865 words - 4 pages frequently extra thrilling and involving than real-life pastimes. From an educational outlook, these games enthuse imagination and creativity, as well as concentration, logical thinking and setback resolving, all of that are functional skills beyond the gaming context. Furthermore, it has been shown that computer simulation games can enhance users’ motor skills and aid to design them for real-world tasks, such as driving through the highway or