Court Case Number 202: First Degree Murder

1330 words - 6 pages

No. 202. Argued March 9, 1965. Decided April 28, 1965.
In 1964 Edward Dean Griffin was brought before a court, convicted and tried for the crime of first degree murder. Griffin had been invited to the apartment of Essie Hodson and her boyfriend Eddie Seay. After all three had went to bed Seay woke up to find Griffin and Hodson struggling. Hodson claimed that Griffin had tried to force her into unwanted sex. Seay locked Griffin out of the apartment. However, Griffin broke back in and hit Seay in the head. Seay went to a nearby bar to get help and when he returned neither Hodson nor Griffin were there. The next morning, a witness saw Griffin coming out of a large trash bin in a nearby alley and noted that Griffin was adjusting his pants. The witness found Essie Hodson in the trash bin. She was bleeding and in shock. Hodson passed away the next day at a local hospital from the injuries sustained from the violent attack.
Griffin was tried for the first degree murder of Essie Hodson. During trial, Griffin refused to take the stand and testify. Both the judge and the district attorney commented about Griffins silence to the jury stating:
“As to any evidence or facts against him which the defendant can reasonably be expected to deny or explain because of facts within his knowledge, if he does not testify or if, though he does testify, he fails to deny or explain such evidence, the jury may take that failure into consideration as tending to indicate the truth of such evidence and as indicating that among the inferences that may be reasonably drawn therefrom those unfavorable to the defendant are the more probable."
The Prosecutor also added, "These things he has not seen fit to take the stand and deny or explain and in the whole world, if anybody would know, this defendant would know. Essie Mae is dead, she can't tell you her side of the story. The defendant won't." The death penalty was imposed and Griffin felt as though the comments made during his trial were an obstruction of justice and caused an unfair trial. He then appealed to the California State Supreme Court. The court upheld the previous ruling and claimed the comments made during trial had no effect on the ruling in Griffin’s case. Griffin was still unsatisfied and, therefore, appealed his case to the United States Supreme Court in 1965.
Legal Proceedings:
The first ten amendments in the United States Constitution are known as the Bill of Rights. Of these amendments, the fifth calls for due process during trial, outlaws double jeopardy and states that a person cannot be forced to testify as a witness against him or herself. A defendant is allowed to “plea the fifth” and stay silent during trial. Because of these provisions should a jury instruction on the accused’s silence be reversible error?
The case was argued on March 9, 1965 and then decided on April 28, 1965. In a 6-2 vote the court sided with Griffin. The Supreme Court ruled that the Fifth Amendment protect...

Find Another Essay On Court Case Number 202: First Degree Murder

In depth analysis of US's Model Penal Code, especially the state of New York - Washington State University; Crim J 320 - Essay

1676 words - 7 pages . Another condition, is if the action was committed along with arson in the first degree (N.Y. Penal Law § 1044). Lastly, the N.Y. Penal Law § 1044 defines “A person who willfully, by cause the death of a human being, is guilty of murder in the first degree, and punishable accordingly”. These four conditions help the state of New York distinguish either a case has felony murder in the first or second degree. In addition to these four conditions

Business Ethics Working Conditions When does a worker's death become murder?

2092 words - 8 pages DEGREE - In order for someone to be found guilty of first degree murder the government must prove that the person killed another person; the person killed the other person with malice aforethought; and the killing was premeditated. To kill with malice aforethought means to kill either deliberately and intentionally or recklessly with extreme disregard for human life. Premeditation means with planning or deliberation. The amount of time needed for

Capital Punishment: Right or Wrong?

2309 words - 9 pages best, face the same prospect that the jury would deliberate his case at first degree murder. At worst, the black defendant would be fifty-six times as likely to face a first degree murder deliberation than a white defendant” (Nakell and Hardy 139). However, later in Nakell and Hardy’s study on the sentencing process, their findings were quite the opposite. He stated: “At sentencing, the key factor was again the race of the defendant

Violent Crimes Article

1365 words - 6 pages primary intentions of Mr.Milard were to inflict harm upon Mr.Bosma, this was a deliberate act; otherwise classified as a culpable homicide. Secondly, murder is considered as intentional homicide; meaning the act was intentional. Murder is further divided into two categories, which are first-degree and second-degree murder. This case is an incident of first-degree murder because the Mr. Millard’s actions were planned, intentional, and deliberate

Pretrial Publicity: Media Coverage and Guilt Attribution Abstract: This study

1167 words - 5 pages information during deliberations.Procedure The first case involved a head librarian who was shot at a local state college. The shooting occurred on the campus' parking lot, the librarian died two days later. A father and son were arrested and charged with first-degree murder. 286 potential jurors were interviewed by phone. Change of venue motion was not met due to the confession of the defendant. The second case involved multiple crimes and multiple

Casey Anthony

366 words - 2 pages Casey Anthony did not commit first degree murder. The evidence does not prove that she committed first degree murder, rather it proved that she committed negligent homicide. The prosecution was able to provide a means and opportunity to Casey Anthony, but the prosecution was not able to give a motive as to why Casey Anthony would purposely murder her own child. Means, opportunity, and motive are all required in order to find someone guilty of

Criminal Justice System

1183 words - 5 pages United States and Finland have a three-level system: the court of first instance in both countries is the district court, followed by the court of appeals and the Supreme Court, the highest court in the systems. The district court and the courts of appeal have similar status and similar functions. It is the functions of the Supreme Court which are different. The Supreme Court hears a limited number of the cases which are appealed. Typically, the

Fifth Amendment and Double Jeopardy

1651 words - 7 pages and a jury tried the case. The trial judge told the jury that they could find Green guilty of arson under the first count and either first degree murder or second degree murder under the second count. Second degree murder, as defined in District Code, is killing of another with predetermined malice and is punishable by imprisonment for a term of years or for life. The jury found Green guilty of arson and of second degree murder. Green was

Double Jeopardy2

1632 words - 7 pages plea of not guilty to both counts and a jury tried the case. The trial judge told the jury that they could find Green guilty of arson under the first count and either first degree murder or second degree murder under the second count. Second degree murder, as defined in District Code, is killing of another with predetermined malice and is punishable by imprisonment for a term of years or for life. The jury found Green guilty of arson and of second

Definition Essay: Murder

1282 words - 5 pages peoples lives are classified as homicides which include manslaughter and first and second degree murder. More important, the justice system has put different labels on such crimes, but it also allows room for criminals to get away with murder. A person who's accused of unlawful killing in a court of law may be faced with a manslaughter charge by the prosecutor. Since there are different scenario's in which a unlawful killing can occur, there are


1230 words - 5 pages poison, lying in wait, imprisonment, starvation, willfull, deliberate, and premeditation killing. A homicide occurring during arson, rape, robbery, or kidnapping is also included under murder. First degree murder is defined as specific intent to kill, second degree is general intent to kill. Punishments for murder were life in prison without parole, and the death penalty; only if convicted of first degree murder. Second degree murder is loosely

Similar Essays

First Degree Murder Conviction Essay

895 words - 4 pages perpetration, or the attempt to perpetrate, certain felonies, which includes burglary, excluding petty offense of shoplifting (Cal. Penal Code S 189) (Lectlaw, 2010). The “mens rea” of first degree murder is that the person, with time and intent, planned out or premeditated the murder. The “actus reas” of first degree murder is the actual act of committing the murder after planning it (Lippman, 2006). The Laci Peterson case is good

Abortion A Woman's Right Or First Degree Murder

1113 words - 5 pages Abortions a Woman’s Right to Choose or First Degree Murder? In the book, The Abortionist A Woman Against the Law by Ricki Solinger, it was stated that there has never been a society where women did not get ride of unwanted pregnancies. In the early years women used herbal remedies, trusted strangers in dirty back rooms, or sometimes trusted strangers in well organized abortion rooms with experience, who on a daily basis performed thousands of

Court Case Number 15: Bowers V. Hardwick (June 30, 1986)

561 words - 2 pages Court Case Number 15: Bowers v. Hardwick (June 30, 1986)In August of 1982, Michael Hardwick was charged with violating the Georgia statute criminalizing sodomy by committing that act with another adult male in the bedroom of Hardwick's home. Hardwick then brought suit in the Federal District Court, therefore challenging the constitutionality of the statute as it criminalized sodomy. Hardwick asserted that he was a practicing homosexual, that the

Felony Murder Law Essay

1872 words - 7 pages The Felony Murder Law of Colorado states that a person is guilty of first degree murder if he or she participates in, or is fleeing from, some other crime and a death results, intended or not2. This statute is the reason a 21 year old Colorado resident, Lisl Auman, was sentenced to life in prison without parole at the Colorado Women's Correctional Facility3. This case has drawn national attention and while appealing her conviction, has gained