This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Courts And Power Relations Essay

1495 words - 6 pages

The courtroom is a ritualised space, involving costume, language, spatial organisation and so on, and courts, therefore, constitute performative exercises of power. Discuss some of the ways in which courts demonstrate power and/or power relations.

The courtroom is a ritualised space in which many features are effectively manipulated to demonstrate the states power over the individual. It is because of such displays of power that the courtroom is commonly identified as a place of justice where social order is upheld. Upon observing civil courtrooms 5.1 and 5.6 it was clear that the architecture and spatial organisation of the room plays a significant role in displaying the various power relations between the courtroom actors. Interior features such as structural elevation, spatial organisation, lighting, entrances and design effectively highlight power disparities. Furthermore language was a vital factor in the determination of one’s status within the courtroom. Differentiations of power were evident through the use of legal terminology, the contrast of formal language and colloquialism, and the manipulation of rhetoric in cross-examinations.

The architecture of the courtroom establishes clear power disparities within the courtroom setting. The physical dimensions of Courtroom 5.1 were organised in such a way that the hierarchal nature of the court is visually clear from the moment you step into the room. The stratification of power amongst the courtroom actors is displayed through the ‘structural elevation’ of the seating (Carlen, 1976, pp. 50). The magistrate is seated at the uppermost level at the bench facing the defendant, solicitors and public gallery. This particular positioning demonstrates pre-eminence which allows complete control and power over the courtroom to reside with the magistrate. Moreover the Royal Coat of Arms is symbolically situated above the bench to enforce the notion that the magistrate is representative of the Crown (, 2014). It was also observed that carved into the wood of the bench were intricate designs which portrayed a sense of importance and significance. This was in stark contrast to the plan wooden table at which the defendant and lawyers sat.

On the contrary to the magistrate, the defendant, solicitors and police prosecution were not seated on a platform .Their positioning was significantly lower than the magisterial bench which is parallel to their inferiority to the magistrate. The juxtaposition between these levels projects a sense of intimidation which facilitates the submissive behaviour of those in the lower seating thus allowing the magistrate to exercise complete power. This behaviour was observed in both courtrooms where the defendant was completely acquiescent to the judge.

The power and significance of the magistrate was also clear through the ‘staged and heralded’ entrance (Carlen, 1976, pp. 50). Whilst the public gallery and the other courtroom actors entered the room...

Find Another Essay On Courts and Power Relations

Marginalised groups in society are often forced to collude with the dominant culture's practices and beliefs in order to survive in a world of unequal power relations. Discuss with NO SUGAR

922 words - 4 pages Marginalised groups in society are often forced to collude with the dominant cultures practices and beliefs in order to survive in a world of unequal power relations. Discuss. - TEE Q1 1998When certain racial groups are marginalised, such as in a postcolonial society, they are forced to collude with the dominant culture's practices in order to survive. In Australian history, Aborigines were marginalised by paternalistic, oppressive policies

Courts Essay

1043 words - 4 pages by state courts. All lower federal courts operate under uniform rules of procedure promulgated by the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court is the highest appellate tribunal in the country and is a court of original jurisdiction according to the Constitution “in all cases affecting Ambassadors, other public ministers and Consuls, and those in which a State shall be a Party.” By virtue of its power of review, the Supreme Court is also the final judicial

Punishment and sentencing guidelines and issues

2415 words - 10 pages Untitled Running head: FINAL ESSAY Essay Punishment and Sentencing� After researching the National Center for State Courts of Texas the system structures are as follows. Municipal court consists of 917 cities 1,414 judges. In this court you have local trial courts of limited jurisdiction. The Municipal Courts consists of Criminal misdemeanors punishable by fine

Jackson County Judges

1109 words - 5 pages Jackson County Judges The judges from the Common Pleas, Domestic Relations, and the Municipal Courts for Jackson County oversee thousands of cases each year. A small percentage of these cases are appealed each year and the probability of winning a reversal of the original verdict varies from court to court and from judge to judge. Those individuals who have cases pending in these courts would be interested to know the probability of winning a

Term Paper: Judicial Review

639 words - 3 pages Constitution are invalid. During conflict, the courts have to determine the law and under that power, must interpret and administer the Constitution and decide if a certain law is in line with the constitution. The Supreme Court has final jurisdiction on all cases involving the Constitution. Prior to Marbury v. Madison, the Judiciary Act of 1789 incorporated the concept of judicial review by giving the Supreme Court the power to evaluate court

Understanding the Complexity of Canada's Courts

924 words - 4 pages guilty or not. The constitution calls for the creation of the Supreme Court and leaves the responsibility of creating the inferior courts to Congress. The Canadian provinces of Quebec, Ontario, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick signed the Constitution Act of 1867, which made Canada its own country. The act also assigns power go both the provincial and federal governments. The constitution is Canada's supreme law, and any government, whether it be

Was Australia's participation in Iraq illegal?

902 words - 4 pages , and as a result the legislation has little power over the 'municipal laws' of Australia. Therefore, although military operations in Iraq would indeed be contravening international law, they would not be in violation of any existing law in Australia.Upon establishing that Australia is not legally constrained by the Charter, we can now investigate whether the courts' jurisdiction extends as far as reviewing the decision of a commitment military

court system

1463 words - 6 pages The basic role of the Canadian court system is to deliver justice between two individuals or two individuals and the state. There are four levels of court in Canada. Provincial courts are the lowest in terms of power. They handle most of the day to day cases. The next court in terms of power is the provincial and territorial superior courts. These courts take care of the more serious crimes that are admitted into the system, and can also take

Texas Court System

1957 words - 8 pages The Texas Court System "Our legal system based on the principle that an independent, fair, and competent judiciary will interpret and apply the laws that govern us. The role of the judiciary is central to American concepts of justice and the rule of law." -Preamble, Texas Code of Judicial Conduct The Texas Court System consists of many trial courts and appellate courts. The trial courts consisting of the municipal court, justice of the peace

common law and equity

1677 words - 7 pages approach the appropriate individual directly. Out of the councilors’ arrangements for dealing with these cases, along with their added significance, developed several distinct courts. The most important of these was that of the chancellor as it developed its own jurisprudence. The Chancery began as the royal secretariat. Originally it was a department where royal writs and charters were drawn and sealed. Much of the chancellor’s later power

The importance of the constitution

990 words - 4 pages constitutional values are violated by the legislature and executive powers itself. To minimize the violations, constitutional jurisdiction was established which secures democratic constitutional stability and eliminates suppression of democratic values. Certainly one may think that the constitution and constitutional courts are the “weapons” in hands of power to set down mutual interests and relations. However, constitutional law, establishing a

Similar Essays

Power Relations And The London Riots

2734 words - 11 pages The 2011 London Riots was one of those spontaneous events that sparked intense media coverage and called upon the government leaders to adopt new policies amidst the changing political climate. For this reason, I will be using the London riots as a case study to discuss the effects of social media networks on the power relations between the mainstream media and the acting government during a spontaneous event. I argue that a spontaneous event

The Lust For Power: How Politics And Personal Relations Become One

2583 words - 10 pages THE LUST FOR POWER: HOW POLITICS AND PERSONAL RELATIONS BECOME ONEThe stories of the Bible reveal a pattern of "ups and downs" for the nation of Israel. A period of prosperity, faithfulness and fearing God would almost always be followed by a period of destitution, lawlessness and idolatry. This recurring cycle can be linked to political authority, and the level of separation of political authority from other influences. The successful struggle

An Analysis Of Joseph Nye’s Use Of “Soft Power” And Its Relationship With Morality In International Relations

3025 words - 12 pages An Analysis of Joseph Nye’s Use of “Soft Power” and its Relationship with Morality in International Relations Recently, the United States has lost a great deal of power in the international arena because of its invasion of Iraq and torture of prisoners of war. The United States holds an incredible edge in military capabilities over any other nation and the US benefits from the largest economy in the world. In a world where there is one

Internalisation Of Power An Essay On Cultural Ideals Of Femininity, Internalisation Of Gender Power Relations And The Effect This Has On Woman's Sense Of Self

1949 words - 8 pages INTERNALISATION OF POWERHow have women (and/or) men internalised the power relations established in the gender order (the male as the one, the female as the other) and cultural ideals of femininity?The structure of power relations of the gender order is based on assumptions of what is is to be male and female. This arrangement divides humanity in to separate classes according to gender by attributing certain physical and psychological